Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 24 Mar 2023 · CNR DLSH010009312023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. AMITABH RAWAT, ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-03 (SHAHDARA), KARKARDOOMA COURT, DELHI Bail Appl. Registration No. 277/2023 FIR No. 551/2022 U/S. 304/34 IPC PS- Welcome State Vs. Heera Lal Kamra and others (Rajeev Kumar) 24.03.2023 ORDER 1) Vide this order, I shall dispose off the bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C moved on behalf of applicant/accused Rajeev Kumar. 2) Arguments heard. I have perused the record. 3) Ld. Counsel for the accused submits that applicant/accused is a law abiding citizen and has been falsely implicated in the present case. He has clean antecedent and no idea about the present case. It is prayed that applicant/accused may be granted anticipatory bail. 4) i) On the other hand, Ld. Addl. Public Prosecutor for the State has opposed the bail application stating that on the intervening night of 10/11.11.2020, accused Heera Lal made a PCR call that he caught a man stealing his tempo. SI Amit Kumar received the call vide DD no. 10A, at 2.49 AM and alongwith Ct. Parvinder reached at the spot. Heera Lal handed over the alleged thief namely Mesar S/o Tullan R/o Sahaswan, Afzal Pur Chhaganpur, Badaun, UP, Aged 24 years to SI Amit Kumar. Statement of Heera Lal was recorded wherein he stated that the above said person was stealing his tempo Page No.1 -- 1 of 4 -- no.DL-1MA 1717, hence, he shouted 'Chor-Chor” and 5-7 persons gathered there and beaten up the person stealing his tempo. A case vide FIR no.547/20, u/s. 379/411 IPC was registered at PS Welcome. The alleged person was taken to JPC, Hospital and got medically examined vide MLC No. 4744/20 dated 11.11.2020 and doctor opined as “A/H/O beaten by public, (i) CLW below Lt. Eye brown 1.5 x 0.5 cm approx (ii) CLW over Lt. Forehead 1 x 0.5 CM approx.” ii) After that the said person was arrested and produced before the court of Sh. Mayank Mittal, MM, Karkardooma Court, where the Ld. MM mentioned in the JC remand order that “on being inquired, both IO and accused have submitted that accused is beaten by public.” Thereafter, accused Mesar was sent to Mandoli Jail on 11.11.2020 and in the intervening night 11/12.11.2020, an information regarding death of accused Mesar was received from PS Harsh Vihar. The death of the deceased Mesar was on account of the combined effect Brain damage (consequent upon blunt force trauma to head) and shock due to Hemorrhage (consequent upon extensive bleeding occurring in the muscles due to blunt trauma to various body parts) i.e. the cause of death was unnatural. Further, the death of the deceased Mesar had occurred at Hedgewar Hospital during his treatment where he was shifted from Mandoli Jail on 11.11.2020. iii) Thereafter, accused Heera Lal was arrested and was released on bail by this court. iv) One witness Roshan Lal has stated that he had seen accused/applicant Rajeev Kumar, Sachin Kumar and other beating the deceased with the danda. Page No.2 -- 2 of 4 -- It is prayed that bail may not be granted. 5) i) In the present matter, it is the case of the prosecution itself that the accused Heera Lal had caught the deceased Mesar while stealing his tempo No. DL-1MA 1717 on the night of 10/11.11.2020 and he was caught at the spot by the accused Heera Lal and 5-7 persons gathered there and beaten the said deceased. Thus, at the instance of accused, FIR No. 547/2020 u/s. 379/411 IPC was registered at PS-Welcome against the deceased. ii) It is the case of the prosecution that the said deceased Mesar was then taken into police custody and thereafter into judicial custody and at the same night his health worsened in the jail and he was shifted to Hedgewar Hospital and he passed away. Thus, it is the case of the prosecution that 5-7 persons and accused persons had gathered at the spot and given beating to the deceased, who was then taken into police custody and thereafter judicial custody, when he passed away. iii) Main accused Heera Lal is already on bail in this case. iv) In the peculiar facts of the case, no intention, at this stage, appears on the part of applicant/accused. It appears for this reason also that police in their reply have stated that judicial custody is required for pointing out the place of incident and to link evidence. No police custody is stated to be required. The place of incident is also identified. Main charge-sheet has already been filed. iii) Considering peculiar nature of facts and circumstances of the case as stated above, I am of the opinion that a case for anticipatory bail is Page No.3 -- 3 of 4 -- made out. Hence, I allow the present anticipatory bail application under Section 438 Cr.P.C filed on behalf of applicant/accused Rajeev Kumar. Accordingly, in the event of his arrest, accused/applicant Rajeev Kumar is directed to be released on anticipatory bail on furnishing of personal bond in the sum of Rs. 15,000/- with one surety in the like amount subject to the satisfaction of concerned SHO. The accused shall cooperate in the investigation, as and when required by the I.O and will not tamper with the evidence and will not leave the city of Delhi and will provide his mobile number to the Investigating Officer and shall keep his mobile phone on. Application is accordingly disposed off. Copy of this order be given dasti, as prayed for. (Amitabh Rawat ) Addl. Sessions Judge-03 Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts Delhi/24.03.2023 Page No.4 -- 4 of 4 --
