Full Order Text
Final Order 16 · 04 Jul 2025 · CNR DLSH010008622024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: -1/5- CS No. 82/2024 Sunita Singhal and ors. v. Mili Jain and ors. CNR No. DLSH01-000862-2024 04.07.2025 Present : Sh. Madhur Arora, Ld. counsel for Plaintiffs (through VC). None for Defendants. Clarifications heard. Ld. Counsel for Plaintiff submits that inadvertently, the details of Gift deed has been wrongly mentioned as ‘Page no. 138 to 143’ in Settlement Agreement dated 01.06.2024 (Mark A), whereas it is ‘Page no. 133 to 143’. Ld. Counsel for Plaintiff further submits that certified copy of the said Gift Deed is already on record. Application dated 22.08.2024 filed jointly by Plaintiffs no. 1 to 5 and Defendant no. 1 to 8 respectively under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC r/w Section 151 CPC is pending for disposal. In the above application, prayer has been made for the cancellation of two Sale deeds both dated 18.09.2001 and one Gift Deed dated 27.09.2022, the details of which are as follows:- 1. Sale Deeds of Rs.2,10,000/- dated 18.09.2001 executed by Sh. Vivek Jain (as SPA of Smt. Neha Jain @ Neha Aggarwal) in favour of Sh. Parag Jain (regd. as No. 4976 in Book No. 1, Volume No. R3/BBB/4976 in the office of Sub-Registrar, Mumbai). 2. Sale Deeds of Rs.1,90,000/- dated 18.09.2001 executed by Sh. Vivek Jain (as SPA of Smt. Neha Jain @ Neha Aggarwal) in favour of Sh. Parag Jain -- 1 of 5 -- -2/5- (regd. as No. 4977 in Book No. 1, Volume No. R3/BBB/4977 in the office of Sub-Registrar, Mumbai). 3. Gift Deed dated 27.09.2022 executed by Sh. Parag Jain in favour of Ms. Mili Jain. (Regd. no. 9756 in Book no. 1 Vol. No. 3414 on pages 133 to 143 on dated 27.09.2022) [hereinafter referred as ‘said two Sale Deeds’ and ‘ said Gift Deed’ respectively.] Submissions of both the sides were heard, as reflected in the Order dated 27.08.2024. Perusal of record shows that joint statement of Defendant no. 1, 2 and 3 were recorded on 27.08.2024. The statement of Defendant no. 4 was recorded on 21.10.2024. Statement of Defendant no. 5 was also recorded on 21.10.2024. Statement of Defendant no. 3 was recorded on 21.10.2024. Joint statement of Plaintiff no. 1, 2 and 5 was recorded on 25.11.2024. Statement of Sh. Madhur Arora, Advocate was also recorded on behalf of Plaintiff no.2 and 3 on 25.11.2024. Parties have settled the matter and had requested that the said Sale Deeds and said Gift Deed may be declared as null and void & appropriate Order may be passed for the cancellation of the above documents. Ld. Counsel for Plaintiff submits that the said two Sale deeds were executed by Defendant no. 5/ Ms. Neha Jain @ Neha Aggarwal (vendor) (who is wife of Sh. Abhishek Aggarwal/Defendant no. 4) through SPA holder Defendant no. 3/Sh. Vivek Jain in favour of Sh. Parag Jain /Defendant no. 3 (vendee). Ld. counsel further submits that thereafter said Gift Deed in favour of Ms. Mili Jain/Defendant -- 2 of 5 -- -3/5- no. 1 (Donee)(who is daughter of Sh. Parag Jain/Defendant no. 2) was executed by Sh. Parag jain /Defendant no. 2 (Donor). Ld. counsel further submits that another chain of registered title documents in favour of the plaintiffs are also in existence. Ld. counsel further submits that said two Sale Deeds were executed on the basis of SPA dated 13.09.2010 which was never produced on record. Ld. counsel points out that in his statement dated 21.10.2024 before this court, the Defendant no. 3/Sh. Vivek Jain stated that the SPA dated 13.09.2001 executed by Ms. Neha Jain @ Neha Aggarwal /Defendant no. 5 in his favour is not in his possession. Ld. counsel further submits that in the said statement, Defendant no. 3 also stated that he is not aware that in whose possession, the said SPA is lying. Ld. counsel submits that when the SPA itself is not in existence, the said two Sale Deeds could not have been validly executed. Ld. counsel further submits that matter has already been settled between the parties and Defendants have also given their no objection regarding the cancellation of said two Sale Deeds and the said Gift Deed. Heard. Record perused. Perusal of record shows that Ms. Neha Jain @ Neha Aggarwal/ Defendant no. 5 is the seller in both the said two sale deeds. Perusal of record further shows that Sh. Parag Jain/Defendant no. 2 is the purchaser in both the said two sale deeds. Perusal of record further shows that in said two sale deeds Ms. Neha Jain was represented through special attorney Sh. Vivek Jain/Defendant no. 3. -- 3 of 5 -- -4/5- Perusal of record further shows that said Gift Deed in respect of the suit property was executed by Sh. Parag Jain/Defendant no.2 in favour of Ms. Mili Jain/Defendant no. 1. Perusal of record shows that the statements of Defendant no.1, 2, 3 and 5 are already on record, wherein they have stated that they have no objection if the said two Sale deeds and said Gift deed be cancelled. Considering the fact that another chain of documents as mentioned in para no. 1 of the plaint i.e. Sale deeds dated 13.01.2023 and 10.02.2013 which is in favour of the Plaintiffs are in existence, I am of the view that if the said two Sale Deeds and said Gift Deed are not adjudged void, the same may cause serious injury to the Plaintiffs. The matter has already been settled between the parties before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in CS (OS) No. 37/2023 titled as ‘Gaurav Jain and anr. v. Ruchika Singhal and ors’ (DOD:23.07.2024). The settlement dated 01.06.2024 Mark A is also on record. Perusal of record shows that Hon’ble High Court of Delhi vide Order dated 23.07.2024 has already bound down the parties towards their obligation assumed by them under the said settlement Agrement Mark A. In view of forgoing discussions, the application under Order XXIII Rule 3 r/w Section 151 CPC is disposed off and the following Order is passed:- (a). A decree is passed in favour of the Plaintiffs and against the Defendants thereby declaring the said two Sale Deeds and said Gift Deed are hereby declared as null and void. -- 4 of 5 -- -5/5- Consequently, Sub-Registrar concerned at Mumbai is hereby directed to cancel the said two Sale Deeds. Further, Sub-Registrar concerned at Delhi is hereby directed to cancel the said Gift Deed. (b). No order as to costs. Let compromise decree be prepared in above terms. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed off. At this stage, Ld. counsel for plaintiff submits that since Original Two Sale deeds have been placed on record by the Plaintiff, he requests for necessary endorsement regarding cancellation on the above documents. Ld. counsel for plaintiff further submits that he will move an appropriate application for the release of above documents. Reader to make necessary endorsement regarding cancellation on the said two Sale Deeds and said Gift Deed after lapse of period of 90 days from today. File be consigned to record room. A copy of this Order be sent to the concerned Sub-Registrar at Mumbai and Delhi for compliance of Section 31(2) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. (MOHAMMAD EHTESHAM) District Judge-03 (Shahdara), KKD Courts, Delhi. 04.07.2025 -- 5 of 5 --
