Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 27 Jul 2024 · CNR DLSH010007722024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SHRI ARVIND BANSAL: ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE – 05 (SHAHDARA DISTRICT) KARKARDOOMA COURTS : DELHI Criminal Revision No. 32/2024 PS Nand Nagri Nisha Gupta w/o Lt. Sh. Sunil Kumar Gupta r/o Flat No. F-2/573-574, Sunder Nagri, Nand Nagri, Delhi-110093. ....... Revisionist Vs. 1. Aamir 2. Imran 3. Danish Respondent no. 1, 2 & 3, R/o H. No. not Known, F-2, Sunder Nagri, Nand Nagri, Delhi-110093. 4. Station House Officer Concerned PS Nand Nagri, Delhi-110093 5. Asst. Commissioner of Police Concerned, Sub-Div. Nand Nagri, Ist Floor, PS Nand Nagri, Delhi-110093 ...... Respondents Date of institution : 05.02.2024 Date of reserving order : 25.07.2024 Date of order : 27.07.2024 O R D E R 1. Vide this order, the Court shall decide one revision petition filed by revisionist/complainant Nisha Gupta, challenging the order dated 17.11.2023 passed by Court of Ms. Nidhi Bala, Ld. MM Mahila Court-03, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi, whereby the Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- application u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C moved by the revisionist/complainant seeking directions to SHO, PS Nand Nagri to register an FIR against accused persons (hereinafter referred as respondents) was dismissed. 2. The facts leading to the filing of an application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. are as follows:- It is the case that complainant/revisionist is a widow lady and was running a tea stall near DTC Bus stand, Nand Nagri, Sunder Nagri, Delhi. It is the case that respondents are running their scrap shop on the opposite side of the road and in order to illegally park their scraped vehicles, tried to dispossess complainant/revisionist from the place where she was running her tea stall. It is the allegation that respondents alongwith their associates usually visited the tea stall in drunken condition and abused her in filthy language and threatened her to kill. It is alleged that on 16.10.2020 at around 02:00 PM, respondent Amir and Imran hit her tea stall with a car and damaged her articles and on protest, they abused her in filthy language. It is the case that they snatched her dupatta and slapped her repeatedly. It is further the allegation that on 22.10.2020 at about 10:00 AM, respondent Danish abused her and threatened her to remove her tea stall, and on the same night all the respondents damaged the counter of the tea stall making complainant/revisionist suffer loss. A complaint in this regard was made to police and senior police officials, but no action was taken. Revisionist preferred a complaint with an application u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C before the concerned learned MM Mahila Court-03, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi. 3. Learned Trial Court called for ATR (Action Taken Report) from SHO concerned. Consequently, a detailed report was filed. It was reported by IO that complainant/revisionist keeps her Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- shop open till late night hours and opens the same early morning causing nuisance on the road. It is reported that the respondents have alleged theft of their articles due to the regular visit of customers. It is reported that on 16.10.2020, respondent Amir was parking his car which got touched with the tea stall, causing minor damage. The son of complainant/revisionist came to the spot and a quarrel took place between him and the respondents, however, the matter was later settled. It is reported that no incident either of eve teasing or disrobing as alleged took place. No PCR call was made either on 16.10.2020 or 22.10.2020. No MLC was made for the injury, if any allegedly suffered by complainant/revisionist or her son. The IO reported that considering the facts and circumstances, no cognizable offence was made out. 4. Further, vide order dated 17.11.2023, while dismissing the application U/s 156 (3) Cr.P.C, Ld. MM Mahila Court-03, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, opined that: “I am of the opinion that registration of FIR in the present case is not warranted at this stage. Therefore, the application under Section 156(3) CrPC filed on behalf of complainant is liable to be rejected , hence, dismissed. It is clarified that inquiry under Section 202 Cr.P.C. can be ordered at the later stage, if need arises.” 5. At the outset, it is observed that a revision petition challenging the order of learned Trial Court deciding an application moved under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. is maintainable. Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Simret Katyal v. The State Govt of NCT of Delhi (decided on 11.09.2015), and Nishu Wadhwa vs Siddharth Wadhwa (decided on 10.01.17) decided the issue of maintainability of revision petition challenging an order under Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C. On the basis of said authorities, it is no more res integra and Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- unambiguously clear that the present revision petition challenging the order of the Trial Court deciding the application u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C is maintainable. 6. Learned counsel for revisionist argued that learned Trial Court dismissed the application without considering the complaint of revisionist filed with SHO PS Nand Nagri and the one made with senior police officials. It is argued that the matter required thorough investigation in the form of collection of material and recording of statements of witnesses. It is submitted that allegations in the complaint disclosed commission of a cognizable offence and in terms of judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘Lalita Kumari Vs. State of UP’, the concerned SHO was bound to register the FIR. It is argued that the order of learned Trial Court is mechanical in nature without considering the allegations leveled by revisionist in her complaint and application u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C and therefore, be set aside. The petition has been opposed by Ld. Counsel for respondents arguing that Action Taken Report filed by IO on behalf of SHO PS Nand Nagri is self explanatory and no case as alleged is made out. It is argued that complainant/revisionist is unnecessarily exaggerating a minor issue which already stood resolved. It is submitted that Ld. Trial Court passed the impugned order after due consideration of the facts and circumstances and, therefore, present petition be dismissed. Ld. Counsel has relied upon judgment passed by Supreme Court titled as Sakiri Vasu Vs. State Of U.P. And Others, 07.12.2027. 7. While deciding the present revision petition, this Court stands guided by the precedent laid down by Hon’ble Delhi High Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- Court in Subhkaran Luharuka v. State, Crl.M.C. No. 6122-23/2005 dated 09.07.10, wherein it was held that: “52A. For the guidance of subordinate courts, the procedure to be followed while dealing with an application under Section 156(3) of the Code is summarized as under: (iv) Of course, it is open to the Magistrate to proceed under Chapter XII of the Code when an application under Section 156(3) of the Code is also filed along with a Complaint under Section 200 of the Code if the Magistrate decides not to take cognizance of the Complaint. However, in that case, the Magistrate, before passing any order to proceed under Chapter XII, should not only satisfy himself about the pre-requisites as aforesaid, but, additionally, he should also be satisfied that it is necessary to direct Police investigation in the matter for collection of evidence which is neither in the possession of the complainant nor can be produced by the witnesses on being summoned by the Court at the instance of complainant, and the matter is such which calls for investigation by a State agency. The Magistrate must pass an order giving cogent reasons as to why he intends to proceed under Chapter XII instead of Chapter XV of the Code.” 8. Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case and submissions of learned counsel for revisionist and respondents as also the averments made in the application u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C., and after perusal of the grounds for revision, this Court is of the view that the complainant/revisionist is certainly in control of all the material required to be produced in support of her allegations. The allegations of complainant/revisionist, even if considered true and genuine, the same may be prima facie proved by her before learned Trial Court through oral and documentary evidence at the Pre- Summoning stage. The case of complainant/revisionist is substantially Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- based on the statement of herself and her son and they may be produced before the Court as witnesses. The alleged offence does not appear to be of such a nature requiring custodial interrogation of the respondents or intervention of State in the form of police investigation. No recovery is required to be effected and thus, registration of FIR is not warranted. Furthermore, this Court while exercising its revisional jurisdiction cannot order registration of FIR merely because the contents of complaint ‘may’ disclose commission of a cognizable offence. While, Hon’ble Supreme Court in Lalita Kumari case (Supra) has made it incumbent on the part of SHO to register FIR, in case, the complaint discloses commission of a cognizable offence, learned Magistrate is empowered to exercise judicial discretion in this regard. 9. At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to the case titled Arvindbhai Ravjibhai Patel Vs. Dhirubhai Sambhubhai reported in 1998 (1) Crimes 351, wherein Hon'ble Gujarat High Court took strong exception to the growing tendency of asking the police to investigate cases under Section 156(3) of the Code and advised the Magistrates not to pass orders mechanically. It was held that:- “Magistrates should act under Section 156 (3) of the Code only in those cases where the assistance of the police is essentially required and the Magistrate is of the considered view that the complainant on his own may not be in a position to collect and produce evidence in support of the accusation”. Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- 10. In the thoughtful consideration of this Court, once an application under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. is moved before a Magistrate, there are two options. One, Magistrate can send the case for investigation to concerned Police Station; Second, the Magistrate may take cognizance of offence on the complaint and may proceed to record the testimony of complainant and her witnesses in pre-summoning evidence and thereafter, may decide whether a case for summoning of accused is made out or not. Once, the Magistrate has opted to exercise his discretion of not sending the matter for investigation, this Court, while exercising its revisional jurisdiction, cannot substitute its own opinion with the opinion of the Learned Magistrate unless a patent error or illegality is found in the impugned order. In this regard, it would be significant to rely upon judgment of Taron Mohan v. State & Anr, 2021 SCC OnLine Del 312, wherein Hon'ble Delhi High Court has observed as under:- “9. The scope of interference in a revision petition is extremely narrow. It is well settled that Section 397 CrPC gives the High Courts or the Sessions Courts jurisdiction to consider the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding inter se an order and as to the regularity of the proceedings of any inferior court. It is also well settled that while considering the legality, propriety or correctness of a finding or a conclusion, normally the revising court does not dwell at length upon the facts and evidence of the case. A court in revision considers the material only to satisfy itself about the legality and propriety of the findings, sentence and order and refrains from substituting its own conclusion on an elaborate consideration of evidence.” Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- 11. On the same issue, Hon'ble Apex Court in Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan vs. Dattatray Gulabrao Phalke and others, 2015 (3) SCC 123 observed as under : “14.....Unless the order passed by the Magistrate is perverse or the view taken by the court is wholly unreasonable or there is non-consideration of any relevant material or there is palpable misreading of records, the Revisional Court is not justified in setting aside the order, merely because another view is possible. The Revisional Court is not meant to act as an appellate court. The whole purpose of the revisional jurisdiction is to preserve the power in the court to do justice in accordance with the principles of criminal jurisprudence. The revisional power of the court under Sections 397 to 401 CrPC is not to be equated with that of an appeal. Unless the finding of the court, whose decision is sought to be revised, is shown to be perverse or untenable in law or is grossly erroneous or glaringly unreasonable or where the decision is based on no material or where the material facts are wholly ignored or where the judicial discretion is exercised arbitrarily or capriciously, the courts may not interfere with decision in exercise of their revisional jurisdiction.” 14. In the above case also conviction of the accused was recorded, the High Court set aside the order of conviction by substituting its own view. This Court set aside the High Court’s order holding that the High Court exceeded its jurisdiction in substituting its views and that too without any legal basis.” 12. Similarly, Hon'ble Apex Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Kumar Pandey, 2019 SCC Online SC 1786, made the follwing observations : "8. The scope of the revisional jurisdiction of the High Court (or Sessions Court) under Section 397 Cr.P.C, is limited to the extent of satisfying itself as to the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order passed by an inferior Court. The revisional Court Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- is entitled to look into the regularity of any proceeding before an inferior Court. As reiterated by this Court in a number of cases, the purpose of this revisionsal power is to set right a patent defect or an error of jurisdiction or law." 13. Learned Trial Court has already given an opportunity to complainant/revisionist to lead his evidence u/s 200 Cr.P.C. Further, Learned Trial Court may also exercise its discretion u/s 202 Cr.P.C. at the appropriate stage, in case the same is warranted in facts and circumstances of the case. 14. In the opinion of this Court, order of registration of FIR cannot be made merely to pressurize the opposite party to come to terms. Further, the facts and circumstances of the present matter, as discussed above, do not call for any interference with the order dated 17.11.2023 of learned Magistrate in exercise of revisional jurisdiction by this Court, as there is no patent error in the impugned order. 15. In view of the discussion in preceding paragraphs, this Court does not find any incorrectness, illegality or impropriety in the order of learned Trial Court dated 17.11.2023. The same appears to have been passed after due consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case. Accordingly, the present revision petition is dismissed. Revision file be consigned to Record Room. Copy of this order be sent to Learned Trial Court for necessary intimation. Dictated and Announced in open Court today i.e. on 27.07.2024 (Arvind Bansal) Addl. Sessions Judge-05 Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts,Delhi. Crl. Revision No. 32/2024 Nisha Gupta vs. Amir & Ors Police Station: Nand Nagri Page 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
