Full Order Text
Final Order 14 · 07 May 2025 · CNR DLSH010006982024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. DEEPANKER MOHAN DISTRICT JUDGE-04, SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI RCA DJ 16/2024 In re: SMT. SUNITA W/O LATE NAVAL SINGH, R/O H.NO.651, GALI NO.24, VILLAGE SABOLI, DELHI-110093. …….. Appellant Versus 1. SH. DHANI RAM S/O SH. ATAR SINGH R/O H.NO.650, GALI NO.24, NEAR ANGAN WARI, VILLAGE SABOLI, DELHI-110093. 2. SH. VIKAS S/O SH. ARVIND R/O GALI NO.9, NEAR PRIYA ADARSH PUBLIC SCHOOL, DELHI-110093. 3. SHO, PS HARSH VIHAR, DELHI-110093. 4. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER CIVIC CENTRE, MINTO ROAD, DELHI. ……. Respondents 1. RCA DJ : 16/2024 2. Under Section : Appeal U/s 96. 3. Date of institution : 30/01/2024 (e-filed) 4. Date of registration : 01/02/2024 5. Reserved for judgment : 11/02/2025 6. Date of Judgment : 07/05/2025 RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- JUDGMENT By way of this judgment, this Court shall dispose of the present appeal filed by the appellant against respondents on 30.01.2024. 1. That the present appeal is being filed by the appellant/defendant against the judgment and decree dated 27.01.2024 passed by the Court of Sh. Mayank Goel, the then Ld. ASCJ, Shahdara District, KKD Courts, Delhi in CS No.40/2024 vide which the suit of plaintiff/appellant was rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. 2. The parties are being referred to their original ranks given/mentioned in the main suit, in the present judgment. Brief facts mentioned in the plaint:- 3. The plaintiff has filed the suit for permanent and mandatory injunction against defendants before Ld. ASCJ on 05.01.2024 praying the following reliefs : “ i. To pass a decree of permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants thereby restraining the defendants, their agents, servants, officials, associates, etc. etc. from raising any kind of illegal construction over the suit plot ad-measuring 70 sq. yards, out of Khasra No.434, Gali No.9, Near Priya Adarsh Public School, Mata Wali Gali, Village Saboli, Delhi-110093, RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- specifically shown in the red colour in the site plan without following due process of law. ii. To pass a decree of mandatory injunction in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants thereby directing the defendants, their agents, servants, officials, associates, etc. etc. to remove the entire illegal construction over the suit plot ad- measuring 70 sq. yards, out of Khasra No.434, Gali No.9, Near Priya Adarsh Public School, Mata Wali Gali, Village Saboli, Delhi-110093, specifically shown in red colour in the site plan annexed herewith, without following the process of law. Pass any such other order(s)/relief(s)/ direction(s) which this Hon’ble court may deem fit and proper also be passed in favour of the plaintiff under the facts and circumstances of the case, in the interest of justice.” 4. As per the case of plaintiff, she is the lawful owner of the plot ad-measuring 70 sq. yards, out of Khasra No.434, Gali No.9, Near Priya Adarsh Public School, Mata Wali Gali, Village Saboli, Delhi-110093. The said plot had come to the share of plaintiff and her children through her deceased husband in an oral family arrangement. It is pleaded that initially Khasra No.434, ad- measuring 900 sq. yards was owned by father-in-law of plaintiff namely Atar Singh, who was survived by four sons namely, Bhanwar Singh, Karan Singh, Dhani Ram and Naval Singh (now deceased-husband of the plaintiff). RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- 5. The deceased husband of plaintiff was the real brother of defendant No.1 Sh. Dhani Ram. Defendant No.1 is the brother- in-law of plaintiff. On 02.01.2024, defendant No.1 and 2 brought the building material and in collusion with defendant No.3 and 4, they have started raising illegal construction over the plot in question with the sole intention to grab the same. The defendants in collusion with each other have started raising illegal construction over the property in question without any right, title or interest and without prior consent/sanction from competent authority i.e. MCD. The plaintiff has also reported about the illegal construction over the plot in question to defendant No.3 and 4 but despite making complaint, no action has been taken by defendant No.3 and 4 against defendant No.1 and 2 for stopping the illegal construction. The defendant No.1 and 2 have now speed up the illegal construction over the plot in question and the construction is being raised round the clock. 6. The Ld. Trial Court has rejected the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC on the ground that the simpliciter suit for injunction is not maintainable as the plaintiff is not in possession of the suit property and also there is a cloud on the title of the suit property. 7. The plaintiff aggrieved from the judgment dated 27.01.2024 passed by the Court of the then Ld. JSCC-cum- ASCJ-cum-GJ, Shahdara, KKD Courts, Delhi on the following grounds: i. The Ld. Trial Court has failed to appreciate that after demise of Atar Singh, plaintiff being the wife of Sh. Naval Singh, has succeeded the inheritance rights in the property in question. The Ld. Trial Court has not appreciated that no written statement RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- has been filed on behalf of defendants and therefore, question of raising any cloud upon the title of plaintiff would not arise at all. ii. Ld. Trial Court has failed to appreciate that the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Anathulla Sudhakar Vs. P Buchi Reddy, AIR 2008 Supreme Court 2033 has no application to the present case because none of the parties have raised any cloud over the title of the plaintiff. iii. Ld. Trial Court has not appreciated the fact that the property in question is a vacant plot and recently defendant No.1 and 2 have started raising illegal construction over the property in question in order to grab the same. The observation of Ld. Trial Court that plaintiff is not in possession of the suit property, is contrary to record. The illegal construction over the property in question by defendant No.1 and 2 would not tantamount to ouster of possession of the plaintiff from the property in question. SERVICE OF SUMMONS OF PRESENT APPEAL: 8. The notice of the appeal has been duly served upon respondents. Defendant No.4/MCD filed the status report. As per the status report, the property in question has been booked and show cause notice under Section 343 and 344 (I) of DMC Act, 1957 have been issued on 13.03.2024 to the owner/occupier. The defendant No.4 had also filed another status report on 24.07.2024 in which it has been stated that demolition action has already been taken against the property in question on 19.07.2024. It is also mentioned that the roof of the first floor of the property in question has been punctured by defendant No.4. Photographs have also been filed by MCD. RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- 9. No replies to the appeal on behalf of defendant No.1 and 2 have been filed, however, Ld. Counsel for defendant No.1 and 2 on 25.04.2024 submitted that he will address the arguments straightaway. Enquiry report has been filed on behalf of defendant No.3 on 25.04.2024. 10. Final arguments were heard on 11.02.2025. 11. File as well as trial court record perused. 12. The plaintiff in her plaint has specifically pleaded that defendant No.1 and 2 have started raising construction over the property in question without sanctioning the site plan from MCD. The photographs filed along with the plaint show that the boundary walls have been constructed, however, no date has been mentioned as to when the said photographs were taken. Admittedly, defendant No.1 had raised the construction over the property in question which cannot be done without entering into the property in question. The site plan filed by the plaintiff also mentions about the construction over the property in question. Moreover, the photographs filed by MCD along with its status report filed on 24.07.2024 shows that the roof of the first floor property in question has been punctured. The defendant no.4 has only punctured the roof of the first floor, however, the ground floor is being used and under the possession of defendant no.1. 13. The property in question had been constructed by defendant No.1 which clearly means that plaintiff is not in possession of the suit property. It is not the case of the plaintiff RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- that she had the access to the property in question on the date of institution of the suit. 14. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, material came on record and above observations, this Court concludes that plaintiff was not in possession of the property in question on the date of institution of the suit and therefore, the simpliciter suit for injunction is not maintainable in view of the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Anathula Sudharkar Vs. P. Buchi Reddy (Dead) by LRs and Ors., AIR 2008, Supreme Court 2033. The plaintiff ought to have claimed possession of the property in question and in the absence of such claim in the plaint, the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable. The Ld. Trial Court has rightly rejected the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC on this account. 15. The finding of Ld. Trial Court that there is a cloud on the title of the suit property in favour of plaintiff, is not correct because as per plaint, Khasra No.434, ad-measuring 900 sq. yards was owned and occupied by Sh. Atar Singh and after his death the same was inherited by his four sons namely Sh. Bhanwar Singh, Sh. Karan Singh, Sh. Dhani Ram and Sh. Naval Singh and the property in question ad-measuring 70 sq. yards which is part of the Khasra No.434 came in the share of plaintiff and her children through deceased Sh. Naval Singh in an oral family arrangement. Plaintiff had filed Khatoni of Village Saboli, Delhi for the year 1986-1987 which shows the name of Sh. Atar Singh as bhumidhar/khatedar. Plaintiff, being one of the LR of Sh. Atar Singh, was entitled for the estate left by late Sh. Atar Singh with respect to ownership rights as well as possessory RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- rights. On the basis of possessory rights, an injunction can be asked/claimed. However, plaintiff claims that the property in question came into her share and admittedly, she was not in possession of the property in question and the date of institution of the suit, therefore, the suit of permanent and mandatroy injunction without seeking possession is not maintainable. 16. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, material came on record and above discussions, the appeal stands dismissed. 17. Appeal is accordingly disposed of. 18. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 19. Trial Court record be sent back to the Ld. Trial Court along with the copy of this judgment and decree sheet. 20. File be consigned to the Record Room, after due compliance. Announced in the open Court on 07th May, 2025 (DEEPANKER MOHAN) DISTRICT JUDGE-04, SHAHDARA DISTRICT KKD Courts, Delhi. RCA DJ 16/2024 Page No.8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
