Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 15 Mar 2024 · CNR DLSH010006792024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Ram Babu vs. Ved Prakash MISC DJ 127/2024 15.03.2024 Present : Sh.Mridul Jindal, ld. Counsel for applicant/ JD. Ms.Pinki Talukdar, ld. Counsel for non-applicant/ DH. This is an application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, seeking setting aside of judgment/award dated 09.12.2023. Before I go into the grounds taken in the application, it is appropriate to precisely refer the factual background of the matter. Proceedings in the present case arose in filing of a DAR in FIR No.529/2019 of PS Nand Nagri regarding an accident dated 23.08.2019 wherein the petitioner Ram Babu suffered injuries. At the time of filing of DAR respondents (driver and owner) were very much present and the offending vehicle was without insurance. Time was given for filing the WS/reply to the DAR, however despite repeated opportunities reply was not filed and therefore an opportunity for the same was closed by the ld. Predecessor of this Tribunal on 22.11.2021 as by then respondents stopped appearing in the proceedings. During the course of proceedings petitioner Ram Babu appeared as witness (PW1). Later when matter was listed for final arguments, ld. Predecessor of this Tribunal vide order dated 14.08.2023 tried to enforce the presence of respondents because the vehicle was not insured. Counsel for the respondents put appearance on 14.08.2023 and sought time for filing application/ permission for filing the WS/reply. Matter was also kept for possible settlement. Thereafter efforts for settlement were made, -- 1 of 4 -- when matter was not settled this Tribunal decided the matter on merits as case pertains to year 2020 and the petitioner was senior citizen. By award dated 09.12.2023 a compensation for sum of Rs.1,63,936/- with interest @ 8%, was passed. It is in this context the present application has been moved on the ground that respondent no.1 engaged the counsel. That counsel was pro bono appearing for respondent and was given instructions to keep on appearing on behalf of respondents and to apprise them about the progress of the case. It is stated that in the meantime respondent no.1 diagnosed with coronary artery disease in March 2020 and later there was Covid situation prevailing in 2020 and 2021. It is stated that counsel for the respondents did not diligently pursue the matter and due to his non-action, adverse order was passed on 22.11.2021. It is further mentioned that in February 2023 respondent was diagnosed with heart blockage. After issuance of bailable warrants, counsel for the respondent appeared and apprised the Tribunal regarding the medical condition of the respondent. However the adverse order was passed and non-appearance of the counsel could not be attributed to the respondents. I have heard the counsel for applicant/JD and ld. Counsel for the DH. It is argued by ld. Counsel for the applicant that court should show some indulgence as respondent was an old age person and suffering from medical issues. Moreover it was the negligence on the part of the previous counsel who did not pursue the matter properly and diligently and therefore for the fault of the lawyer, respondent may not be made to suffer. -- 2 of 4 -- On the other hand Ms.Pinki Talukdar, ld. Counsel for the petitioner/DH submitted that provisions of Order 9 Rule 13 CPC are not applicable as respondents were duly aware about the proceedings and still did not move an application under Order 9 Rule 7 CPC during the pendency of the proceedings. It is submitted that counsel for the respondent participated in the process of efforts for settlement and by then they were aware that the case was at the final stage. In the present case it is not the plea of the applicant that he was not served with the notice, rather the day DAR was filed respondents duly appeared and were duly apprised of their responsibility to file reply to the DAR. Opportunity for filing the reply was given even beyond the period of 30 days at first instance. But not only reply was not filed rather respondents failed to appear for no possible explanation. If at all there was any lapse on the part of the previous lawyer of the respondents, such aspect could have been duly appreciated but no explanation has been given as to why any legal action has not been taken against the previous counsel if he was not diligently pursuing the case of respondents. Court’s indulgence cannot be sought when what was required on the part of respondents, has not been done. More particularly in the facts of the present case because even during the pendency of the proceedings, respondents put appearance and on two dates of hearing an opportunity was given for filing the reply as well as for possible settlement. Therefore no case is made out for any of the ground within the meaning of Order 9 Rule 13 CPC. As such application stands dismissed being meritless. -- 3 of 4 -- File be consigned to record room. ( Shailender Malik ) PO MACT-02/SHD/KKD/15.03.2024 -- 4 of 4 --
