Full Order Text
Final Order 6 · 30 May 2024 · CNR DLSH010006612024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. RAMESH KUMAR-II, DISTRICT JUDGE-01, SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI CNR No.DLSH01-000661-2024 RCA DJ No. 15/24 In the matter of:- Sh. Hazari Lal S/o Late Badri Prashad R/o H. No.6/156, Nand Nagari, Delhi-110093. .........Appellant Versus Sh. H.S. Bansal @ Hari Shankar Bansal R/o 2362, Hudson Lane, Mall Road, Delhi. ..…....Respondent Date of Institution : 31.01.2024 Judgment passed on : 30.05.2024 Decision : Dismissed. JUDGMENT 1. Vide this judgment, I shall dispose of the present appeal filed on behalf of the appellant under Order 41 Rule 1 & 2 read with Section 96 CPC for setting aside the impugned judgment and decree dated 16.08.2022 passed by the court of Ld. Civil Judge- 01, Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in suit no.1213/2019 titled as H.S. Bansal @ Hari Shankar Bansal Vs. Hazari Lal, whereby the suit of the plaintiff/respondent herein was decreed in favour of the plaintiff and against the RCA DJ 15/24 1 -- 1 of 12 -- defendant/appellant herein. 2. Before proceedings further, it is important to mention here that the appellant has also filed an application alongwith the present appeal under Section 5 of the Limitation Act read section 151 CPC for condonation of delay in filing the present appeal. Reply to this application has been filed on behalf of the respondent with a prayer to dismiss the application mainly on the ground that there is no specific number of days delay mentioned in application. 3. I have heard the arguments on application for condonation of delay. 4. Ld. Counsel for appellant argued and submitted that the appeal is time barred and Section 5 of Limitation Act deals with sufficient cause which is not defined in the Act and it is subject to court’s discretion and the only explanation the appellant has that it was a bona-fide mistake on the part of JD/appellant herein for not pursuing statutory relief simultaneously because the appellant had faith in Ld. Trial Court under review to acknowledge the new evidence which came to light after the decree was passed. She further submitted that the new evidence even with their best efforts could not be produced before Ld. Trial Court and there was no negligence on the part of JD/appellant, nor an intention to delay but only request to grant condonation of delay to the appellant so that it could prevent unjust enrichment. She further submitted that the procedural law i.e. Limitation Act 1968 is the handmaiden of substantive justice and it is bond to fulfill the purpose of justice. She further submitted that Ld. Trial Court passed a decree against the appellant on 16.08.2022, thereafter the appellant has received the notice from Ld. Trial Court in the RCA DJ 15/24 2 -- 2 of 12 -- month of January 2023 and then the appellant approached the court and filed objection of execution petition alongwith an application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC and also filed application under Order 21 Rule 26 CPC and also filed review petition but Ld. Trial Court did not consider the said facts and issued the attachment of movable properties vide order dated 20.01.2024. Ld. Counsel for appellant further submitted that thereafter the appellant had applied for certified copies of decree and judgment and the appellant is filing the online copy of the order dated 16.08.2022 and order dated 20.01.2024 and due to above-said reasons the delay was caused which is neither intentionally nor deliberate and as such ld. Counsel for appellant requested to condone the delay. 5. Per contra, ld. Counsel for respondent submitted that the appellant has admitted that there is delay in filing appeal due to filing objections, application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC and application under Order 21 Rule 26 PC and review application which all had been out rightly rejected by Ld. Trial court. He further submitted that there is no specific number of days mentioned in the application under Section 5 of Limitation Act and even no specific maintainable reason has been mentioned. Therefore, ld. Counsel for respondent requested to dismiss the application under Section 5 of Limitation Act with cost. 6. I have considered the submissions made before the court on application under Section 5 of Limitation Act. 7. To obtain an extension of time by invoking the provisions of Section 5 of Limitation Act Act, the party seeking extension must satisfy the court that he had sufficient cause for not filing the suit, appeal, revision or objections within the prescribed RCA DJ 15/24 3 -- 3 of 12 -- period. 8. A perusal of record reveals that Ld. Trial Court passed the judgment and decree on 16.08.2022, whereas the appeal alongwith present application for condonation of delay in filing the appeal was filed on 31.01.2024. Limitation is of 30 days will be reckoned from 16.08.2022. There is a delay of 488 days in filing the appeal. 9. It is settled law that generally the case is not to be rejected on the technical ground of limitation but it has been held in numerous judgments that certainly, if the filing of appeal suffers from inordinate delay, then it is the duty of the court to consider the application to condone the delay before entering into the merit of the case. 10. The present application is too vague to be considered on the ground that the delay of 488 days, which has been caused, has not been explained day by day. The appellant took a stand in condonation application that Ld. Trial Court passed the decree against the appellant on 16.08.2022 and thereafter the appellant had received the notice from Ld. Trial Court in the month of January, 2023 and then the appellant approached Ld. Trial Court and filed objection of execution petition alongwith an application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC and also filed application under Order 21 Rule 26 CPC and also filed review petition but Ld. Trial Court did not consider the said facts and issued the attachment of movable properties vide order dated 20.01.2024 and there is delay from January, 2023 from the date of knowledge in filling of the appeal due to forgoing reason. 11. Since the appellant was duly served with the summons of suit, it cannot be presumed that the appellant would have no RCA DJ 15/24 4 -- 4 of 12 -- knowledge of pendency of suit before Ld. Trial Court. The pendency of suit before Ld. Trial Court was well within the knowledge of the appellant but he did not contest the suit despite having been duly served. There is no sufficient cause to condone the delay in filing the appeal. The present application is devoid of merit and deserves dismissal. However, in order to decide the present appeal on merits, the condonation application is allowed and the delay of 488 days is hereby condoned subject to cost of Rs.5,000/- upon the appellant to be deposited with Shahdara Bar Association, Karkardooma Courts Complex, Delhi for the welfare of Advocates. Judgment in case titled as State (NCT) Vs. Ahmed Jaan as cited by the appellant is not applicable to the facts of the present case, since the appellant has failed to show any sufficient cause for condoning the delay in filing the appeal. 12. Coming now to the present appeal. Brief facts relevant for disposal of present appeal are that the plaintiff/respondent herein filed a suit for recovery of Rs.2 lacs against the defendant/appellant herein and stated in the plaint that the appellant had approached the respondent as he required funds on urgent basis and wrote him letter dated 12.03.2018 and under the instigation/deceive of the appellant the respondent had given friendly loan of Rs.2 lacs to the appellant through NEFT on 19.03.2018. The appellant has also executed a pronote cum receipt dated 19.03.2018 in favour of the respondent. However, the appellant did not repay the friendly loan to the respondent and as such the respondent served a legal notice dated 30.11.2018 upon the appellant. Thereafter, the appellant issued a cheque bearing no.129031 dated 20.12.2018 for a sum of Rs.2 las in favour of the respondent which was got dishonored upon its RCA DJ 15/24 5 -- 5 of 12 -- presentation. The respondent again issued a legal notice dated 01.01.2019 to the appellant but of no avail. 13. Summons of suit were issued by Ld. Trial Court to the defendant/appellant which were duly served upon the defendant/appellant through his daughter-in-law on 14.11.2019 but the defendant did not appear and ultimately, the defendant/appellant was proceeded ex-parte by Ld. Trial Court vide order dated 03.02.2020. Thereafter, the plaintiff adduced ex- parte evidence. 14. It is worthwhile to mention that after considering the arguments of ld. Counsel for plaintiff as well as material available on record, the Ld. Trial Court passed the impugned judgment and decree dated 16.08.2022. 15. Aggrieved by the said order dated 16.08.2022, the appellant/defendant preferred the present appeal mainly on the grounds that:- 1. That the impugned order is based on conjecture and surmises and this court failed to consider the facts of the case. 2. That the ld. Court did not consider the facts that the counsel for the appellant stated before this court that the appellant had given some amount through cheques in the principle amount of the respondent, but the said facts was concealed by the respondent in his averments made in the petition, but the appellant could not mention the said facts before this court in writing as the bank of appellant recently another bank, but at merged in this stage, the appellant are available all the details mentioned in RCA DJ 15/24 6 -- 6 of 12 -- his account, the details of the cheques payment are under:- (i). That as per version of respondent, the alleged loan of Rs.2 lacs was given to the appellant through bank transferred on 19/03/2018, before disbursed the loan amount to the appellant, the appellant had handed over six post dated signed cheques to the respondent after bears his signature on the pretext of installments of loan amount. (ii). That the appellant had repaid the amount of Rs.90,000/-, out of Rs. 2,00,000/- in the year 2018 through six cheques i.e. cheque bearing no. 129030 for Rs. 50,000/- dated 20/3/2018 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Branch Nand Nagari, Delhi; cheque bearing no.129038 for Rs. 8,000/- dated 03/05/2018 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Branch Nand Nagari, Delhi; cheque bearing no.129032 for Rs.8,000/- dated 24/05/2018 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Branch Nand Nagari, Delhi; cheque bearing no.129033 for Rs. 8,000/- dated 22/06/2018 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Branch Nand Nagari, Delhi; cheque bearing no.129034 for Rs. 8,000/- dated 24/7/2018 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Branch Nand Nagari, Delhi; & cheque bearing no.129037 for Rs.8,000/- dated 09/11/2018 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Branch Nand Nagari, Delhi; Total amounting to Rs. 90,000/-. 3. The appellant further alleged that after settlement in the court, as per compliance of order of RCA DJ 15/24 7 -- 7 of 12 -- court, the appellant had transferred Rs.65,000/- in the account of the respondent dated 11/08/2023 and Rs.5,000/- was already transferred in the account of respondent's attorney on the 11.08.2023, and 05.08.2023 before the court and that he has already paid Rs.1,60,000/- out of principle amount of Rs.2,00,000/- to the respondent and there was only Rs. 40,000/- dues was against the appellant, but the true facts was concealed the respondent since filing the present suit. 4. Because the ld. Trial court failed to consider the evidence as to certified the copy statement of appellant. 5. Because the Ld. Trial court did not consider the act of the appellant as a due diligence to take the evidence on record as the defense and Ld. Trial court did not consider the real situation of the case and without opportunity to giving proper the appellant whereas it is well settled law that the every case should be decided on merits. The principle of unjust enrichment requires first, that the defendants has been enriched by the receipt of the benefits, secondly that this enrichment is expense of at the the appellant and thirdly that the retention of the enrichment be unjust. 6. Because the Ld. trial court has not considered plaintiff the fact that the /respondent wants to extort money from the appellant by misleading this trial court and has concealed the true and material facts in the suit as well affidavit, which were differ RCA DJ 15/24 8 -- 8 of 12 -- /contradictory beyond the pleading of alleged suit and also not considered that the suit of the plaintiff is filed without proper cause accordingly passed the of action the Hon'ble any and court impugned judgment /decree against the appellant which is liable to be set aside. 7. Because the Ld. trial court has not considered the facts and circumstances of the case and the evidence available on the file and passed the impugned order/ judgment against the law, hence the impugned order/judgment is liable to be set aside. 8. Because the Ld trial court did not apply the judicial mind and passed the impugned order / judgment in arbitrary manner, hence the same is liable to be set aside. 9. Because the judgment of the trial court is based on surmises and conjectures, hence the same is liable to be set aside. 16. Notice of this appeal was sent to respondent/defendant. 17. Trial Court record was also requisitioned. 18. Respondent has duly appeared through his counsel and filed reply to the appeal of the appellant denying all the assertions made therein and has prayed for dismissal of the appeal on the ground that the present appeal is liable to be dismissed as the same is nothing but only the tactics on behalf of the appellant for delaying the execution proceedings. 19. Ld. Counsel for appellant argued that the appellant could not have the evidence as the bank were merged at that time which was not deliberate and intentional. She further submitted that as per the provision of order 41 rule 27 CPC relates to taking of RCA DJ 15/24 9 -- 9 of 12 -- additional evidence in the appellant court and the object was to provide that additional evidence may be allowed by the appellate court, if the evidence could not be produced in the lower court because it was not within the knowledge, etc. of the party seeking to produce it now. 20. After making above-said submissions, ld. Counsel for appellant request to consider the additional evidence as per Order 41 Rule 27 CPC. 21. In support of her submissions, ld. Counsel for appellant has placed reliance on the following judgments: a) Sirajudheen Vs. Zeenath & Ors. (AIR 2023) b) G. Kamogowda Vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer, AIR 1988 SC 897. c) State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Ahmed Jaan, Crl. Appeal (Hon’ble Supreme Court). 22. Per contra, ld. Counsel for respondent submitted that although the appeal filed by appellant after dismissal of objections and dismissal of application under Order IX Rule 13 and then dismissal of review application and then non- compliance of settlement despite being admitting it before Court and then appeal on false frivolous grounds/gross delay / stating that assumption that inferior court would have taken itself shows malafide intentions of appellant. He further submitted that even in ground of appeal also appellant is taking the defence of merger of bank which happened in April 2020 and appellant was unable to take the bank statement till year 2023-24 is also false and frivolous. He further submitted that even the major fact of payment which is still hidden by the appellant is by hiding the fact of taking first loan of Rs 1,00,000/-and paying it back in two installments of Rs 50,000/- each. He further submitted that even RCA DJ 15/24 10 -- 10 of 12 -- the false story is being concocted of 5 Cheques totaling Rs 40,000/- as in reality cheques given to Ms Anu Bansal (Respondent's wife) as rent and sufficient to show that it was not part payment of loan taken. He further submitted that a false and frivolous case are filed by appellant just to mislead the Hon'ble Court and in expectation of some non-eligible advantages. 23. I have perused the record of appeal as well as trial court record including judgments relied upon by the appellant and considered the rival submissions made before the court. 24. The entire arguments of the appellant for setting aside the impugned judgment dated 16.08.2022 is based on the additional evidence which the appellant wants to introduce under Rule 27 of Order XLI CPC. In case this additional evidence is not allowed to be introduced, there is nothing for the appellant to argue. Order XLI Rule 27 CPC is not meant for those who deliberately do not appear before the Ld. Trial Court. The appellant had knowledge of the proceedings as he was duly served with summons of the suit. The appellant was also served through RC and he could have appeared and answered the claim of the plaintiff, but he did not contest the suit. I, therefore, consider that the request made by the appellant to consider the additional evidence as per Order XLI Rule 27 CPC is not appreciable and is declined accordingly. 25. A perusal of record it is revealed that the appellant had also filed objections before Ld. Trial Court which were dimissed by Ld. Trial Court vide its order dated 06.05.2023. Thereafter, the appellant had filed an application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC which was also dismissed by Ld. Trial Court vide its order dated 05.08.2023. Thereafter, the appellant had moved an application for review of judgment which was also dismissed by Ld. Trial RCA DJ 15/24 11 -- 11 of 12 -- Court vide its order dated 20.01.2024. It is quite surprising that none of the abovesaid orders have ever been challenged by the appellant and the appellant has only challenge the judgment and decree dated 16.08.2022. 26. In view of the abovesaid discussion, I do not find any merit in the appeal as there is no illegality or irregularity in the impugned judgment and decree dated 16.08.2022. The appeal is therefore dismissed. Stay order, if any, stands vacated. Pending application(s) is also dismissed being infructuous. No order as to costs. 27. Judgments in case titled as Sirajudheen Vs. Zeenath & Ors. and G. Kamogowda Vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer as cited by the appellant are also not applicable to the facts of the present case. 28. A copy of this judgment alongwith the trial court record be sent back to the Ld. Trial Court for information. 29. Appeal file be consigned to Record Room as per rules. (Typed to the dictation directly, corrected and pronounced in open court on 30.05.2024). (RAMESH KUMAR-II) DISTRICT JUDGE-01 SHAHDARA DISTRICT KARKARDOOMA COURTS DELHI RCA DJ 15/24 12 -- 12 of 12 --
