Full Order Text
Order 3 · 25 Apr 2023 · CNR DLSH010004682023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS (COMM) No.71/2023 Sudhir Jain Vs. Pankaj Jain 25.04.2023 Present: Ld. Counsel for plaintiff. Ld. Counsel for defendant. In this suit under Order 37 CPC defendant was served on 27.03.2023. As per report of Ahlmad appearance was entered by them on 31.03.2023. Perusal of the application shows that as mandated under Order 37 CPC Rule 3(1) CPC no address has been filed by the defendant on which the plaintiff shall serve the summons for judgment. It is submitted by Ld. Counsel for plaintiff that defendant has filed an incomplete appearance and that his client deserves a decree under Order 37 Rule 2 CPC. Ld. Counsel for defendant sought passover and in the post-lunch session has cited case titled Sri Pal Jain Vs. Mulakh Raj AIR 1987 Del 2021 wherein in a similar case the appearance was entered only by filing vakalatnama. That it is only the appearance which is mandatory and the usage of word “Shall” qua filing of the address does not form part of the mandatory instructions. The cited judgment lays that the plaintiff can be compensated by cost in close terms in cases of incomplete appearance. The address has been filed in the course of the day. On account of opposition of the same, the defendant is burdened with cost of Rs.12,000/- to be paid to plaintiff. Put up for further proceedings on 16.05.2023. (SURINDER S. RATHI) District Judge Commercial Court-03 Shahdara District, KKD Delhi/25.04.2023 -- 1 of 1 --
