Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 07 Mar 2024 · CNR DLSH010004182024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Criminal Appeal No. 11/2024 Radhey Shyam vs. Seema 07.03.2024 Present: Sh. Deepak Sharma Counsel for the appellant. Respondent along with LAC Sh. Ravi Dhankar. Written arguments filed by the appellant along with some documents and another application for medical examination of the respondent. ORDER: 1. Vide this order, I shall decide the present appeal filed by the appellant under Section 29 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (in short “the DV Act”) against order dated 18.12.2023 passed by Ld. MM (Mahila Court03), Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in Complaint Case No. 1701/2020 tittled as “Seema Vs Radhey Shyam” filed by the respondent under Section 12 of the DV Act by which the appellant (husband) was directed to pay interim maintenance to the respondent (wife) to the tune of Rs.5,000/ per month from date of filing of the said petition till its disposal. 2. Aggrieved by order dated 18.12.2023, the appellant has preferred the present appeal on the following grounds: (a) That the order of Trial Court is contrary to law and based on harsh observations Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 1 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 1 of 9 -- (b) That the Trial Court has failed to see that the respondent is not the wife of the appellant because appellant has never married with the respondent. (c) That the respondent was tenant of appellant’s son and by filing the present petition she wants to create pressure to grab the property. (d) That the respondent during course of tenancy got to know the name of the appellant’s wife Seema and being of same name the respondent wants to take advantage by illegally declaring herself the wife of the appellant. The real name of the respondent is Indresh and she is mentally ill and taking treatment for last many years. (e) That the respondent has filed the false affidavit of assets and liability. She has not filed the bank statement. She is earning well and doing the job. (f) That there is no documentary evidence which can prove any marriage of the respondent with the appellant. The respondent has prepared the photographs by trick photography. (g) That the Trial Court did not appreciate that the appellant has no source of income and he is taking the medical treatment. 3. On these grounds, the appellant has contended that the impugned order is bad in law and also in facts and has prayed for setting aside the impugned order. Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 2 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 2 of 9 -- 4. The respondent has not filed reply to the present appeal. 5. I have heard the Ld. Counsel for both the parties and perused the records carefully. 6. I have also gone through the written arguments filed by the appellant. 7. The Ld. Counsel for the appellant has argued that the respondent is not the wife of the appellant nor there was any livein relationship between them. He submitted that in fact the respondent is the tenant of the son of the appellant and in order to grab the property she is falsely claiming to be the wife of the appellant. He further submitted that the name of the deceased wife of the appellant was Seema and the said fact was known by the respondent which she manipulated in the documents to claim the wife of the appellant. He further submitted that the appellant is not liable to pay the maintenance when there is no relationship with the respondent by way of marriage or livein. 8. The Counsel for the respondent has vehemently opposed the submissions. He submitted that it was the second marriage of both the appellant and the respondent which took place in the year 2005 and since then the respondent was living with the appellant as her legally wedded wife which is apparent from the Aadhar card and photographs of the marriage function of the son of the appellant. He further submitted that the appellant has Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 3 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 3 of 9 -- thrown away the respondent from the matrimonial home in the year 2020 and since then she has been staying with her brother’s house. He further submitted that the respondent has no source of income as she is illiterate and not employed anywhere. He further submitted that the appellant has agricultural land and having other source of income and in these circumstances the impugned order granting maintenance of Rs.5000/ per month to the respondent is not on the higher side and calls for no interference. He has prayed for dismissal of the appeal. 9. Perusal of the trial court record reveals that the respondent (wife) has filed a petition under Section 12 of the DV Act, 2005 against the appellant (husband). During pendency of the petition, the Ld. Trial Court vide impugned order dated 18.12.2023 passed the order for interim maintenance @ Rs. 5,000/ per month after considering the contents of affidavit of assets and liabilities of both the parties and their contentions. 10. The appellant has impugned the order of the Ld. MM granting interim maintenance of Rs.5,000/ per month to the respondent and has sought to set aside the order granting interim maintenance by way of present appeal. 11. The foremost contention of the appellant by way of this appeal is that the respondent is not the wife of the appellant nor there was any livein relationship between them. The appellant has also contended that in fact respondent is the tenant of the appellant’s son and she Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 4 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 4 of 9 -- wants to grab the property. While as per the case of the respondent, she was previously married and from the said marriage there is one son and appellant was also previously married and his wife had expired and, thereafter, the respondent and the appellant solemnized the marriage on 30.06.2005 and since then the respondent was residing with the appellant as her legally wedded wife. She was thrown away from the matrimonial home on 08.07.2020. 12. In support of her contentions, the respondent has placed on record copy of her Aadhar card in which name of her husband is shown of Radhey Shyam with the same address which belongs to the appellant. The respondent has also placed the photographs in which the appellant and respondent can be seen blessing the son of the appellant at the time of his marriage. 13. It is also important to note that in reply to the DV petition, the factum of the respondent residing with the appellant since 2005 till 2020 at the matrimonial address is not disputed. Only a vague plea has been taken by the appellant that the respondent is not legally wedded wife of the appellant and she was tenant of his son and wants to grab the property. The appellant has not disclosed any details of the said tenancy viz. in which premises the respondent was inducted as a tenant by the son of the appellant, what was the rate of rent, any tenancy agreement by which the respondent was inducted as a Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 5 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 5 of 9 -- tenant and when the respondent evicted the said premises. Only a vague and bald plea has been taken that the respondent was the tenant of appellant’s son and she wants to create pressure on the appellant to grab the property. 14. Further, one fails to understand that if the respondent was tenant in the property of the appellant, then how she can grab the property when she is not occupying the same. It is not the case of the appellant that the said tenancy is still continuing. It is not in dispute that the respondent has not been residing in matrimonial home since 2020. 15. In view of the documents i.e Aadhar card and photographs, the Ld. Trial Court has rightly observed that the dispute qua the marriage between the respondent and the appellant is a triable issue. So far as the contention that the name of the wife of the appellant was also Seema and being of the same name the respondent is taking advantage and claiming to be wife of the appellant are concerned, the same is again a matter of trial. 16. The appellant has also filed an application for medical examination of the respondent from IHBAS Hospital along with the written arguments. It is stated in the application that the respondent is of abnormal behaviour and taking sleeping pills due to depression, therefore she may be directed to be examined from IHBAS hospital. There is no merit in this application and on the above ground no such direction can be passed by this Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 6 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 6 of 9 -- Court. The appellant has also filed a list of articles which were taken by the respondent on 27.08.2020 as an AnnexureA along with written arguments and it is claimed that in the said paper the respondent has admitted herself to be tenant. 17. The respondent along with her counsel has strongly denied of execution of the said document AnnexureA. It is submitted that she had only taken her wearing clothes and the articles mentioned in the said letter were not given to her nor she had written herself as tenant and the same has been manipulated by the appellant. 18. In view of the above document AnnexureA, it cannot be concluded that the respondent was / is tenant of the appellant’s son when the said document is alleged to be forged and created by the appellant and the said fact is again a matter of trial. 19. The next contention of the appellant is that he is on medical treatment and has no source of income and further that the respondent is earning well and doing the job and therefore she is not entitled for any maintenance. 20. In the income/asset affidavit, the respondent has stated that she is illiterate and has no source of income. Nothing has been placed on record by the appellant that respondent is gainfully employed or even she has capacity to earn. So far as the contention of the appellant that he is not medically fit and is dependent on others therefore he cannot pay the maintenance, is concerned, though the Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 7 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 7 of 9 -- appellant has placed the medical documents but same are of the year 201617 and some document of the year 2018 19 and some medical prescription of the eye hospital of the year 2022 but that do not show that the appellant is bed ridden or that he cannot do any work. The Ld. Trial court has considered the said documents. Since there was no income proof of the appellant, therefore keeping in view the Minimum Wages Act, the monthly income of the appellant was assessed @ Rs.10,000/. 21. In the income/ asset affidavit, the appellant has also admitted that he has some agricultural land in Ahmadshapur Bhagpat UP and as such he must be having some source of income. As it has come on record that the appellant is residing in his own house and the respondent is not residing in the matrimonial home and as per the allegations of the respondent, she was thrown out from the matrimonial home in the year 2020 and since then she has been residing with her brother. No separate order of residence has been passed by the Ld. Magistrate and therefore considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case that the respondent has to maintain herself and may have also to find out some rented accommodation in case she is asked to vacate the house by her brother, the interim maintenance @ Rs. 5000/ per month to the respondent cannot be said to be on the higher side. 22. In view of the aforesaid discussions, I do not find any infirmity or illegality in the impugned order dt Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 8 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 8 of 9 -- 18.12.2023 granting interim maintenance to the respondent after taking into consideration the entire facts and circumstances of the case and the needs and requirements of the respondent and the same is well reasoned and does not call for any interference. The present appeal against the impugned order is devoid of any merit and the same is hereby dismissed. 23. Appeal file be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. 24. TCR be sent back to the Ld. Trial Court along with copy of this order. (Balwant Rai Bansal) Special Judge (NDPS Act), Shahdara Karkardooma Courts, Delhi 07.03.2024 Criminal Appeal No.11/2024 Page 9 of 9 Radhey Shyam vs Seema Order dt.07.03.2024 -- 9 of 9 --
