Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 29 Jan 2024 · CNR DLSH010002942024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: T. P. Crl. No.1/2024 Suhail Vs. State 29.01.2024 ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall decide an application under Section 408 Cr.PC moved on behalf of applicant/accused Suhail, seeking transfer of criminal case bearing FIR No.306/2022, U/s 394/397/411/34 IPC, PS Nand Nagri, titled as 'State Vs. Suhail', from the court of Ms. Surabhi Sharma Vats, Ld. ASJ-04, Shahdara District, KKD Courts, Delhi, to some other court. 2. It is stated in the application that on 17.10.2023 the complainant was called for PE who did not identify the accused. Ld. Judge Ms. Surabhi Sharma Vats then herself asked the complainant/PW-2 to identify the accused Suhail, but the complainant/PW-2 again could not identify the accused and stated that this boy is not one who committed the offence with him. Ld. Judge Ms. Surabhi Sharma Vats then shouted on the complainant/PW-2 and said, ' Kya Tamasa Laga Rakha Hai Kyo Nahi Pahchan Raha', but thereafter also complainant/PW-2 again and again said that he is not that boy who committed offence with him, but the Ld. Judge got herself written 'identified by the complainant'. 3. It is further stated that at that time of examination of complainant/PW-2 there was no presence of main counsel of the accused and there was one proxy counsel namely Saloni who again and again requested the Ld. Judge Ms. Surabhi Sharma Vats for conducting cross-examination in the presence -- 1 of 3 -- of main counsel but no hear was given to the proxy counsel and cross-examination of complainant/PW-2 was got conducted by the proxy counsel. It is stated that the applicant/accused has no hope/chance to get proper justice from the court of Ld. Judge Ms. Surabhi Sharma Vats and therefore the present case be transferred from the said court to any other court. 4. Notice of this transfer application was issued to the non applicant/State and TCR was also called. Ld. Chief PP for the State did not file reply to the application and submitted that he will argue straightway. 5. Ld. Chief PP for the State has raised objection for transfer of the matter and argued that there is nothing on record which could suggest that the Ld. Trial Court is biased towards the accused in any manner. 6. I have heard the submissions of counsel for the applicant/accused as well as Ld. Chief PP for the State and have also perused the trial court record. 7. There is nothing on the record to raise an inference of biasness of Trial Court from the court record that the Ld. Trial Court got herself written 'identified by complainant' in the testimony of PW-2. However, it is reflected from the court record that cross-examination of PW-2 was allowed to be conducted by the proxy counsel instead of main counsel. It is the settled principle that justice should not only be done, but should also seem to be done. 8. Accordingly, the criminal case bearing FIR No.306/2022, -- 2 of 3 -- U/s 394/397/411/34 IPC, PS Nand Nagri, titled as 'State Vs. Suhail' is withdrawn from the court of Ms. Surabhi Sharma Vats, Ld. ASJ-04, Shahdara District, KKD Courts, Delhi and is transferred to the court of Sh. Dheeraj Mor, Ld. ASJ-01 (POCSO), Shahdara District, KKD Courts, Delhi, to be tried as per law. Parties are directed to appear before the Ld. Transferee Court on date already fixed in matter i.e. 26.03.2024. Copy of this order be sent to both the courts for compliance. 9. Transfer application stands disposed of as allowed. Transfer application file be consigned to record room. TCR be returned to the court concerned. (RENU BHATNAGAR) Principal District & Sessions Judge Shahdara, KKD Delhi/29.01.2024 -- 3 of 3 --
