Full Order Text
Interim Order 6 · 15 Nov 2025 · CNR DLNW030033622023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 2/24 RAVINDER KUMAR Vs. JATINDER MALIK 15.11.2025 Present: None for the plaintiff. Mr. Vivekanand Jha, Ld. Counsel for the defendants through VC. On perusal of the case file, it is observed that the matter is at the stage of orders on the application under O 12 R 6 CPC. Kept awaited at 04:00 PM. (Gaurav Sharma) JSCC-cum-ASCJ-cum-Guardian Judge North West/Rohini Courts/Delhi 15.11.2025 AT 04:00 PM Present: None. The plaintiff, being a senior citizen and 60% disabled, has claimed that he is the absolute and lawful owner of the suit property (WZ-2337-B, First Floor, Raja Park, Shakurbasti, Delhi-110034), having been acquired vide relinquishment deed bearing registration no. 7400 in Book No. 1, Volume No. 9862 dated 28.06.2021, currently in possession of two bedrooms, one kitchen and a common washroom (as shown in green colour in site plan). It is further averred that the plaintiff regularly visits Delhi for his treatment and stays in such portion under his possession. Defendant no. 1 & 2 are stated to be the son and daughter in law respectively of the plaintiff residing in the suit property as licensees since 06.10.2011 with permissive possession of two bedrooms, one kitchen set, one Indian style toilet and a common washroom pg. no. 1/7 -- 1 of 7 -- (shown in blue in site plan). The plaintiff initially executed a registered Will on 22.03.2022 bequeathing the suit property to his son / defendant no. 1. However later as per the plaintiff, conduct of the defendants became troublesome under the misconception that defendant no. 1 had become the owner of the suit property by virtue of the Will as aforesaid. Police complaint was also made but despite apologizing, things did not improve. In view of such behaviour of the defendants, the plaintiff executed registered cancellation of previous Will dated 12.10.2023, informing the defendants as well about the same, which perturbed them even more that on 05.11.2023, the defendants did not even allow the plaintiff to get groceries delivered to cook food for himself. The defendants are also stated to have threatened the plaintiff to file false cases through defendant no. 2 / daughter in law levelling false allegations against him. The defendants, as per the plaintiff, have also barred Smt. Neeru, daughter of the plaintiff from helping her father, while extending open threats of dire consequences all this time and that of taking over possession of the portion of the plaintiff. Things being as such, the plaintiff canceled the license of the defendants to stay in the suit property vide legal notice dated 17.11.2023, but things did not change, necessitating the filing of the present suit for recovery of possession and use and occupation charges. The defendants have denied all the allegations of the plaintiff by claiming that he is no longer the owner of the suit property, with the defendants residing at the First Floor therein since 2005 as legal owners. It is claimed that the suit property has been partitioned alongwith other properties among the plaintiff and his two sons – the defendant no. 1 and Parveen Malik, in pursuance of which the First Floor thereof has fallen in the share of defendant pg. no. 2/7 -- 2 of 7 -- no. 1, with Ground Floor going to the other brother. It is further contended that the suit property was purchased out of the sale proceeds of the house property situated at Chattarpur, Delhi belonging to the grandfather of defendant no. 1, who expired in the year 1997 leaving behind a Will in favour of the plaintiff qua the said property. In pursuance of such Will, the defendants claim that the plaintiff had executed a sale deed in favour of their mother, who by virtue of the same, became the owner of the Chattarpur property. Such property was later sold by the mother of defendant no. 1 and out of pressure of the plaintiff, two properties were purchased – one being the suit property in the name of mother of defendant no. 1 and the other one at Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh in the name of the plaintiff. The mother of defendant no. 1 expired on 18.04.2021. During her lifetime, the plaintiff is stated to have ill treated her and so also, his sons and their families, including defendant no. 1. Complaints against improper behaviour on part of the plaintiff are also stated to have been made with the police by defendant no. 2 / wife of defendant no. 1. After the death of the mother of defendant no. 1, plaintiff in collusion with his daughter Neeru and her husband started creating problems further, pressurizing the defendants to transfer the suit property in the name of the plaintiff. To avoid bitterness in relations, it is stated that defendant no. 1 alongwith his younger brother Sh. Parveen and their sister Ms. Neeru executed a relinquishment deed in favour of the plaintiff qua their share in respect of the suit property, though even that did not change the plaintiff ways and he still wanted to sell off another property belonging to the mother of the defendant as well (WZ-116, Shri Nagar, Shakurbasti, New Delhi-110034). To resolve the family disputes, a family settlement was arrived at whereunder such other property of the mother of the defendant no. pg. no. 3/7 -- 3 of 7 -- 1 was jointly sold by the plaintiff at Rs. 70 Lakhs together with his two sons and a daughter and out of which, the amount reflected on the sale / transfer document as per circle rate was equally shared by all four with the cash component being retained by the plaintiff, in lieu of which the plaintiff had given the property to his sons - the First Floor to defendant no. 1 by way of registered Will dated 22.03.2022. Since the brother of defendant no. 1 had been residing with the plaintiff at Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh, his portion of the Ground Floor was rented out, with rent being realized by the plaintiff himself. In view of such arrangement between the parties, the defendants have contended that the First Floor of the suit property had fallen in the share of defendant no. 1 as per family settlement, making defendant no. 1 the legal / lawful owner thereof, unaffected by the revocation / cancellation of the Will in favour of defendant no. 1. It is further stated that defendant no. 1 has also filed a suit for partition and permanent injunction against the plaintiff before the Court concerned at Himachal Pradesh and a stay was secured therein qua all the ancestral property of defendant no. 1 at Himachal Pradesh. As such therefore, the defendants have claimed that the present suit deserves to be dismissed. In view of the WS as aforesaid, replication and an application under O 12 R 6 CPC came to be filed by the plaintiff. It has been argued by the plaintiff that the defendants have admitted to the relinquishment deed executed by them in favour of the plaintiff qua the suit property making him the absolute owner thereof. Further, it is also averred that they have also admitted that the First Floor portion was willed in favour of defendant no. 1 on 22.03.2022. However, since subsequently, cancellation of such Will was executed on 12.10.2023 by a registered instrument, the defendant no. 1 was left with no share in the suit property. pg. no. 4/7 -- 4 of 7 -- Moreover, with the relinquishment having been admitted and the Will only liable to come into the picture, if at all, after the death of the plaintiff, there is nothing left to be adjudicated and the suit must be partly decreed in favour of the plaintiff, having terminated the license of the defendants by virtue of him being the absolute owner thereof. In the reply to the application under O 12 R 6 CPC, defendants have claimed that they have nowhere admitted the plaintiff being the owner of the suit property and the relinquishment deed which was executed in his favour, was based upon a family settlement, in view of which Will dated 22.03.2022 was executed, conditional upon such settlement. The import of O 12 R 6 CPC has been reiterated by superior courts from time to time. As per the same, the Court can, either on its own or on application pass judgment in view of admissions of facts made by the parties in their pleadings or otherwise, orally or in writing at any stage of the suit. In fact, such admissions may not be categorical and even constructive admissions which can be inferred from the facts and circumstances of the case can form the basis of passing of orders under O 12 R 6 CPC. The underlying theme of such a provision is to curtail litigation on agreed aspects of the suit and narrow it down to points of contention only upon which there are differing stands of the parties. The Court must not allow unnecessary litigation to continue on factual aspects which are admitted by the parties and orders for relief can be passed in that regard without further ado. (Anar Devi Vs. Nathu Ram (1984) 4 SCC 250) In the present matter, the relinquishment deed dated 28.06.2021 executed by defendant no. 1, his brother Parveen and sister Neeru in favour of the plaintiff qua the suit property has been pg. no. 5/7 -- 5 of 7 -- admitted and not disputed by the defendants. If that be so, the plaintiff is indeed seen to have been admitted to become the owner of the suit property in pursuance of execution of the said document. A Will, by definition, comes into effect, only upon the death of its maker. As such therefore, both the Will documents dated 22.03.2022 and 12.10.2023, one creating interest qua the suit property in favour of defendant no. 1 and the other taking it back, do not have any legal validity as on date since their maker / executor, the plaintiff, is still alive. Based upon such Will documents therefore, no interest can be seen to devolve upon defendant no. 1 qua the suit property. Irrespective as well, the Will document dated 22.03.2022 independently as well does not anywhere allude to any family arrangement between the parties, as per the defendants’ assertion, in pursuance of which the defendant no. 1 was ultimately liable to obtain any interest in the suit property later. As such therefore, looked at from whichever angle, the relinquishment deed document stands and the same having been admitted, the plaintiff is indeed the owner of the suit property as on date. The defendant no. 1 is seen to have filed a partition suit before the Court concerned at Himachal Pradesh qua his ancestral property at Himachal Pradesh only. In Delhi, qua the present suit property, the defendants have not instituted any suit claiming partition based upon their averment that the suit property was willed in favour of defendant no. 1 based upon a family arrangement / partition. That remedy is for the defendants to pursue, if required. The undisputed position as on date, admitted by the defendants remains that in view of the relinquishment deed alluded to as aforesaid, the sons and daughter of the plaintiff, including defendant no. 1, had given up their share in the suit property in favour of the plaintiff. If that be so, the possession of pg. no. 6/7 -- 6 of 7 -- the suit property by defendants remains to be permissive only. Such possession as licensees has already been objected to by the plaintiff, with their license having been terminated vide legal notice issued in that behalf. Considering the same, this Court is of the view that the application under O 12 R 6 CPC qua the relief of possession by way of mandatory injunction and restraining the defendants from creating third party interest in the suit property by way of permanent injunction is liable to be allowed. Accordingly, application under O 12 R 6 CPC is Allowed and the suit is partly decreed in the following terms: 1. A decree of permanent injunction is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants thereby restraining them from creating third party interest in the suit property (WZ-2337-B, First Floor, Raja Park, Shakurbasti, Delhi-110034, as shown in the site plan). 2. A decree of mandatory injunction is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants thereby directing them to remove themselves from the suit property alongwith their belongings and handover vacant peaceful possession of the same to the plaintiff. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. The suit proceedings to continue with regards the aspect of use and occupation charges. Re-list for framing of issues on 27.01.2026 (Gaurav Sharma) JSCC-cum-ASCJ-cum-Guardian Judge North West/Rohini Courts/Delhi 15.11.2025 pg. no. 7/7 -- 7 of 7 --
