Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 11

CNR DLNW03002133202324 Nov 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 11 · 24 Nov 2025 · CNR DLNW030021332023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 1 of 12
IN THE COURT OF SHRI MAYANK MITTAL,
LD. SCJ-CUM-RC, NORTH -WEST DISTRICT,
ROHINI COURTS, DELHI
Suit No. 1020/23
CNR No. DLNW03-002133-2023
In the matter of :-
Shri Lalit Kumar
R/o D-6, Aman Vihar,
Kirari Suleman Nagar,
Delhi – 110086. ........Plaintiff
V E R S U S
Shri Sachin Khandelwal
R/o O-277, O-Block,
Mangol Puri, Delhi-110083.
.....Defendant
Date of institution : 04.08.2023
Reserved for Judgment : 15.11.2025
Date of decision : 24.11.2025
Suit for Recovery and Damages
J U D G M E N T
1. This is a suit for recovery of Rs. 62,400/- (Rupees Sixty Two
Thousand and Four Hundred Only) alongwith pendent lite and future
interest @ 18 % p.a. from the date of filing of suit till realization with cost
of the suit.
-- 1 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 2 of 12
Plaintiff’s Case
2. The case of the plaintiff as averred in the plaint is that the plaintiff
wanted to start his work of Pizza Restaurant and for that purpose the
plaintiff was looking for a shop to start his business in the area of Mangol
Puri, Delhi. While searching for the shop for his business the plaintiff got
to know that a shop situated at Mangol Puri, Delhi which belongs to the
defendant has been offered to let out on rent by the defendant. As the
defendant is the owner of the aforesaid shop, hence the plaintiff in order to
finalize the deal had approached the defendant to take the aforesaid shop on
rent from the defendant and after discussion the defendant asked for
monthly rent of Rs. 30,000/- for the aforesaid shop but the plaintiff
requested the defendant to let out the said shop @ Rs.25,000/- per month
but the defendant refused to agree over said rent.
Thereafter, the defendant asked the plaintiff to come on dt.
01/03/2023 to take the keys of the aforesaid shop and as such on
dt.01/03/2023 the plaintiff reached at the shop and called the defendant and
when the defendant came at the shop then the plaintiff gave a sum of
Rs.5,000/- through paytm 01/03/2023 and the remaining amount of Rs.
25,000/- by way of cash on dt. 02/03/2023, hence in this manner the
plaintiff paid advance monthly rent of Rs.30,000/- and the defendant
promised the plaintiff to hand over the keys of the aforesaid shop on dt.
03/02/2023. After getting assurance from the defendant the plaintiff also
placed order for printing of banner, pamphlets and wall paper etc and also
purchase a pizza making machine. On 03/02/2023, the plaintiff approached
the defendant and demanded keys of the shop but the defendant avoided the
-- 2 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 3 of 12
same either on one pretext or the other. Inspite of receiving the monthly
rent of Rs. 30,000/- the defendant did not hand over the keys of the shop to
the plaintiff despite regular visits by the plaintiff as such having no option
the plaintiff asked defendant to refund the entire above but the defendant
flatly refused to refund the aforesaid amount.
The plaintiff not even for a single day got a chance to use the said
shop because the defendant did not hand over the keys to the plaintiff
despite receiving the monthly rent but upon much persuasion of the
plaintiff the defendant refunded a sum of Rs. 18,000/- out of total amount
of Rs. 30,000/-, to the plaintiff and when the plaintiff asked the defendant
as why he has deducted Rs.12,000/-from the total monthly rent then the
defendant falsely alleged the plaintiff that the plaintiff has used the shop for
about eight days and amount for eight days has been deducted from the
monthly rent of Rs.30,000/-but such version of the defendant was totally
wrong and false because the plaintiff not even for a single day used the
shop as the defendant did not hand over the keys of the shop to the plaintiff
rather the plaintiff has invested substantial amount in renovation of the
shop.
In this manner, the defendant has played fraud with the plaintiff by
illegally holding the legitimate outstanding of Rs. 62,400/- of the plaintiff
which includes damages for 50,400/- i.e Rs. 8,400/- approx spent over
printing of Menu card /pamphlets/banner, Rs.12,000/- over wallpapers for
renovation of restaurant, Rs.30,000/- over purchase of counter form olx,
and further outstanding of Rs. 12,000/- as the remaining rental amount
hence, in this manner the plaintiff has invested a sum of Rs.62,400/- in the
said shop which includes damages and advance rent and due to acts and
-- 3 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 4 of 12
deeds of the defendant the plaintiff has been made to suffer loss of around
Rs.62,400/- and for which the defendant is solely responsible, hence the
defendant is legally bound to pay the losses as suffered by his client.
The plaintiff on several occasions asked the defendant to clear the
legitimate dues of Rs.62,400/- but the defendant has totally failed to clear
the aforesaid dues to the plaintiff rather defendant not only hurled abusive
filthy language and passed castist remarks and he has also extended threats
to the plaintiff to forget about the aforesaid amount. Hence, the present suit.
Defendant’s Case
3. Written statement has been filed on behalf of defendant contended
that the plaintiff has not approached this Hon’ble Court with clean hands
and suppressed material facts. It is stated that the present suit is without
cause of action and liable to be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. The
present suit is not maintainable as the same is based on forged and
fabricated documents. Documents filed by the plaintiff are totally forged,
manipulated and fabricated documents as apparent on its face, therefore,
legal action under Section 340 CrPC for committing forgery is liable to be
initiated against the plaintiff. It is stated that the defendant never agreed to
let out his shop to the plaintiff, therefore, question of taking advance
monthly rent from the defendant in respect of the shop in question does not
arise at all. The entire claim of the plaintiff is bogus and imaginary,
therefore, the present suit is liable to be dismissed out rightly. It is
submitted that the plaintiff was asked to pay at least three months rent in
advance of the shop and to execute and register a lease/rent deed before the
-- 4 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 5 of 12
sub registrar in respect of the shop but the plaintiff has failed to pay the
remaining Rs. 85,000/- to the defendant due to the said failure, the shop of
the defendant remained vacant and the defendant suffered loss of monthly
rent of the shop. It is submitted that without paying rent in advance for
three months, question of handing over the keys of the shop does not arise
at all. The plaintiff failed to pay at least one month rent of the shop to the
defendant Rs. 30,000/- in total, therefore, question of avoiding the plaintiff
on the part of defendant and handing over the keys of the shop does not
arise at all. The plaintiff failed to pay 3 month rent in advance to the
defendant, therefore, the question of refund of Rs. 5000/- does not arise at
all as the defendant has suffered a loss at least for one month rent due to
vacation of his shop, hence, the above said amount of Rs. 5,000/- has been
forfeited by the defendant and the plaintiff is not entitled for the same.
4. Replication not filed.
5. Issues
After completion of pleadings, vide order dated 22.01.2024, the
following issues were framed by my learned Predecessor for trial :
(i) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of recovery of an amount
of Rs. 62,400/- along with interest @ 18 per annum as prayed for ?
OPP
(ii) Relief
6. Plaintiff’s Evidence
6.1 Sh. Lalit Kumar was examined as PW-1, who tendered his affidavit
-- 5 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 6 of 12
in evidence Ex. PW1/A has stated and deposed on lines of plaint in his
affidavit of examination in chief. He has relied upon the documents the
following documents:
(a) Copy of police complaint dated 15.03.2023 is Ex.PW1/1 (OSR).
(b) Copy of screen shots of online payment made by the plaintiff to the
defendant is Ex.PW1/2 (objected to on the ground of admissibility by
Ld. Counsel for defendant).
(c) Original Bill of Printing Press is Ex.PW1/3.
(d) Copy of address from where the plaintiff purchased counter for the shop
is Ex.PW1/4 (objected to on the ground of mode of proof by Ld.
Counsel for defendant).
(e) Copy of screenshot of chats between the plaintiff and person from
whom the plaintiff purchased counter is Ex.PW1/5 (objected to on the
ground of admissibility by Ld. Counsel for defendant).
6.1.1 During his cross examination he deposed that he has not taken any
receipt for the payment of Rs. 25,000/- from the defendant. He denied the
suggestion that he does not have any receipt since he did not pay Rs.
25,000/- to the defendant and also that he was not given a shop situated at
Mangopuri, Delhi on rent by the defendant since he did not agree to pay
three months rent in advance. It is correct that keys of the said shop were
not given to him by the defendant. He denied the suggestion that the
defendant had not refunded Rs. 18,000/- to him. No legal proceedings were
conducted on the complaint Ex.PW1/1 by the police officials. He denied
the suggestion that since Ex.PW1/1 is a false complaint, therefore, no
proceedings were conducted by the police official. He volunteered that he
-- 6 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 7 of 12
has video recording of Rs. 18,000/- paid by the defendant to him. It is
correct that no date is mentioned in Ex.PW1/4. He does not have any
receipt to show that he had purchased Pizza Counter from OLX. Vol., no
receipts are issued for sale & purchase of second hand items from OLX. He
denied the suggestion that he had purchased Pizza Counter from OLX after
March, 2023 and not at the relevant time and that the defendant had
incurred a loss of Rs. 25,000/-since the shop remained vacant for a month
on account of non payment of advance rent by him and also that Ex.PW1/3
is a forged and fabricated document. It is correct that Ex.PW1/3 does not
bear signatures of the seller and no GST has been charged. He denied the
suggestion that he has filed a false case since the defendant did not return
Rs. 5000/- paid by him as a token money for taking his shop on rent.
7. Plaintiff's evidence was closed on 21.01.2025 and the matter was
adjourned for defendant's evidence.
8. Defendant's Evidence
8.1 Sh. Sachin Khandelwal was examined as DW1, who tendered his
affidavit in evidence Ex. DW1/A and reiterated on oath the contents of his
affidavit.
8.2 During his cross examination by ld. Counsel for plaintiff he stated
that he does not know the plaintiff Sh. Lalit Kumar. (Vol. he came to him
but he does not remember the date, month and year.) It is correct that the
plaintiff agreed to take his shop on rent for a monthly rent of Rs. 30,000/-
per month. He does not remember the plaintiff has paid Rs. 5,000/- as
advance rent. It is correct that when he approached he told him to reduce
-- 7 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 8 of 12
the monthly rent from Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 25,000/- per month. Ld. Counsel
for plaintiff asked whenever the defendant let out his shop whether he
demanded 3 months advance rent. Defendant answered it no. It is correct
that beside the rent over Rs. 30,000/- the plaintiff was agreed to pay
electricity and water charges and no further charges was to be demanded
from the plaintiff. It is correct that the plaintiff had demanded the key of
shop after paying Rs. 5,000/- for renovation. It is correct that when he has
demanded id of the plaintiff he has sent him a copy of his aadhar card but
same was not clear. He does not remember the month in which the key was
demanded. He did not demand 3 months rent in advance from the plaintiff.
He has not let out the said shop to any tenant and his brother occupy the
same. He has received the legal notice sent by plaintiff. He denied the
suggestion that after paying Rs. 5,000/-, the plaintiff also paid Rs. 25,000/-
in cash to him and that he has returned Rs. 18,000/- to the plaintiff after
taking Rs. 30,000/- from him. He does not remember any police complaint
was made by the plaintiff. He denied the suggestion that he is liable to pay
the suit amount and that he is deposing falsely.
9. Thereafter, the defendant's evidence was closed on 11.11.2025 and
matter was listed for final arguments.
10. Final arguments have been heard. I have gone through the judicial
record.
11. Now I shall give my issue-wise findings.
-- 8 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 9 of 12
(i) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a decree of recovery of an amount
of Rs.62,400/- alongwith interest @ 18 % p.a. as prayed for? OPP
11.1 The burden of proving this issues was upon the plaintiff. To
discharge the burden of this issue, the plaintiff has examined himself as
PW1. PW1 has deposed on the line of plaint in his affidavit of examination
in chief. PW1 was cross-examined at length. His cross-examination has
been discussed above. In order to discharge the onus, shifted to defendant,
on leading of evidence by plaintiff, the defendant has examined himself as
DW1. DW1 has deposed on the line of WS in his affidavit of examination
in chief. DW1 was cross-examined at length. His cross-examination has
been discussed above.
11.2 Before giving findings on the evidence led by plaintiff and
submissions advanced on behalf of plaintiff and defendant, it is important
to note that in civil litigation, it is sufficient for litigants to prove its case by
preponderance of probabilities. In Adiveppa V. Bhimappa (2017) 9 SCC
586. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Adiveppa (supra) has observed
that:
“It is a settled principle of law that the initial burden is always on the
plaintiff to prove his case by proper pleadings and adequate evidence (oral
and documentary) in support thereof.”
Thus, the burden to prove its case and that the burden to prove the
case as per law entirely is upon the plaintiff, by way of documentary and
oral evidence.
11.3 The plaintiff has filed the present suit for recovery of sum of
-- 9 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 10 of 12
Rs. 62,400/- as defendant has not returned the Rs.12,000/- out of alleged
advance of Rs. 30,000/- given by plaintiff to the defendant and also for
recovering damages for the money spent by plaintiff for printing of menu
card/pamphlets/banners and for affixation of wallpaper for renovation of
restaurant as well as for purchase of counter from OLX. It is pertinent to
mention that the case of plaintiff is that defendant has returned Rs. 18,000/-
in cash out of the advance of Rs.30,000/- (Rs. 5,000/- through UPI and Rs.
25,000/- in cash) given by plaintiff to defendant.
11.4 In order to prove its case, the plaintiff has examined himself as
PW1. Apart from the oral averments and depositions of plaintiff, the
plaintiff has not led any evidence to prove either the payment of Rs.
25,000/- in cash to the defendant. Neither any witness has been examined
to depose before the Court about the fact of his seeing or hearing himself
about the advancing Rs. 25,000/- by plaintiff to defendant, nor any source
has been stated and proved, from which the plaintiff has brought the said
amount of Rs. 25,000/-. Further though plaintiff has averred the fact of
getting the bill books printed, renovation of the said shop and purchase of
counter and other material, however, plaintiff has not examined any
witness, who could have depose before the Court the fact of printing bill
books for plaintiff and receiving money for that, renovating the said room
at the instructions of plaintiff and receiving the consideration for that,
selling counter and other stuff to the plaintiff and sum of money for which
such counter and other stuff was sold to the plaintiff. In fact, the plaintiff
has admitted during his cross-examination that he had not received the keys
of room from the defendant. It is difficult to understand as to how, the
plaintiff can allege renovation in the room, when the said room was not
-- 10 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 11 of 12
handed over by defendant to the plaintiff. The mere filing and exhibiting
the compliant allegedly filed by the plaintiff to the concerned police
station, the bill of printing and photograph of alleged counter, does not
prove the contents of the complaint or the fact of filing of such complaint,
the fact that bill books were printed for plaintiff and the counter was
purchased by plaintiff and the consequential expenditure incurred by the
plaintiff. The plaintiff could only prove the fact of advancing Rs. 5,000/- to
the defendant through UPI, which in fact has been admitted by defendant as
well.
11.5 During its cross examination, the defendant/DW1 has stated
that he had not demanded the rent of three months in advance, however, in
the WS filed by defendant, the defendant had defended the suit on the
ground that defendant has not handed over the possession of the suit
property to the plaintiff as plaintiff could not arrange the three months’
advance rent agreed between plaintiff and defendant. On the basis of WS,
defence evidence and arguments advanced on behalf of defendant,
defendant could not justify the non-returning of Rs. 5,000/- advanced by
plaintiff to the defendant, as proved by plaintiff during PE.
11.6 In view of abovesaid fact, as plaintiff could be proved the fact
of advancing only Rs. 5,000/- to the defendant and could not prove the
other advance to the defendant or any other expenditure incurred by him or
the fact that the said expenditure was incurred at the instance of the
defendant, the plaintiff is entitled for the recovery of Rs. 5,000/- only.
Plaintiff is also entitled to the interest @ 9 % p.a. from the date of decree
till actual realization.
Relief
-- 11 of 12 --
CS No. 1020/2023 Lalit Kumar Vs. Sachin Khandelwal Page no. 12 of 12
12. In view of my observations made while deciding issue no. (I), the
suit of the plaintiff is decreed and followings reliefs are granted in favour
of the plaintiff and against the defendant:-
i. Decree for a sum of Rs.5,000/- ( Rupees Five Thousand).
ii. Interest at the rate of Rs.9% per annum is also awarded in favour of
the plaintiff from the date of decree till the realization of the amount.
iii. Cost of the suit
13. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to Record
Room after due compliance.
Announced in the Open Court
on 24.11.2025
(Mayank Mittal)
Senior Civil Judge-cum-Rent Controller,
North West District : Rohini Courts : Delhi
-- 12 of 12 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.