Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 8

CNR DLNW03002082202508 Oct 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 8 · 08 Oct 2026 · CNR DLNW030020822025

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: CS No. 1374/2025 Satto Devi Vs. Ravi Kumar 1 of page no. 7
IN THE COURT OF SH. VAIBHAV KUMAR: CIVIL JUDGE
NORTH WEST: ROHINI COURTS: DELHI
CNR No. 1374/2025
CNR no. DLNW030020822025
SMT SATTO DEVI
LATE OF VIJAY KUMAR
R/O. A-1/22, BUDH VIHAR
PHASE-I, NORTH WEST
DELHI-110086 ...PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
RAVI KUMAR
S/O. SH LATE VIJAY KUMAR
R/O A-1/22 BUDH VIHAR PH-1
NORTH WEST DELHI-,
110086 DELHI …...DEFENDANT
Date of institution : 24.11.2025
Date of decision : 08.10.2026
Argued by : Sh. Parmod Panwar, Ld. Counsel
for plaintiff.
-- 1 of 7 --
CS No. 1374/2025 Satto Devi Vs. Ravi Kumar 2 of page no. 7
SUIT FOR PERMANENT AND MANDATORY INJUNCTION
JUDGMENT
1. Brief facts of the case as per the plaint are that the
defendant is son of the plaintiff. The plaintiff claims
herself to be the owner of the property situated at A-1/22
land measuring area 33 sq. yards, out of Khasra no. 62/25,
Village Pooth Kalan, Delhi, in the colony known as Budh
Vihar, Phase-1, Delhi (hereinafter referred as “
Suit
Property”). It is stated that the defendant was allowed to
reside at the suit property as a licensee however, his
behavior towards the plaintiff has drastically changed,
hence, the plaintiff had revoked her permission/licence and
asked the defendant to vacate the suit property. It is stated
that the plaintiff had de-barred the defendant from her
movable and immovable properties and had also given Rs.
1 Lakh to the defendant, however, he has not vacated the
suit property, hence, the present suit has been filed seeking
directions to the defendant to vacate the suit property and
to remove his belongings from the suit property. Also,
directions are sought to the defendant to hand over the
peaceful and vacant possession of the suit property to the
plaintiff and further to restrain the defendant from creating
any obstruction in the peaceful possession of the plaintiff
qua the suit property.
2. Summons of the suit were served upon the defendant
-- 2 of 7 --
CS No. 1374/2025 Satto Devi Vs. Ravi Kumar 3 of page no. 7
however none appeared for the defendant. Hence, the right
to file written statement of defendant was closed and the
defendant was proceeded ex-parte on 10.04.2026 by this
Court.
PLAINTIFF’S EVIDENCE
3. In evidence, the plaintiff examined herself as PW-1. PW-1
tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex. PW1/A and
relied upon following documents:
(1) Ex.PW1/1(OSR)- Copy of the Adhar Card.
(2) Ex.PW1/2(OSR) (Colly)- Copy of property documents.
(3) Ex.PW1/3- photocopy of News paper dated 02.02.2012
(now de-exhibited and marked as Mark A)
(4) Ex.PW1/4(OSR)- Copy of complaint dated 06.02.2012.
(5) Ex.PW1/5(OSR)- Copy of complaint against defendant
dated 03.12.2013 DD no.3913.
(6) Ex.PW1/6(OSR)- Copy of complaint against defendant
dated 26.12.2024 DD no. 61A.
(7) Ex.PW1/7(OSR)- Copy of complaint against defendant
dated 13.03.2023 DD no. 82A.
(8) Ex. PW 1/8 - Copy of oath letter of defendant dated
22.03.2014. (now De-exhibited and Marked as Mark B)
(9) Ex. PW1/9-Copy of newspaper "Virat Vaibhav" dated
22.01.2025.
4. The plaintiff was not cross examined, as the defendants
were ex parte and they did not even join the proceedings
-- 3 of 7 --
CS No. 1374/2025 Satto Devi Vs. Ravi Kumar 4 of page no. 7
afterwards.
5. Thereafter, PE was closed on 08.08.2026.
FINAL ARGUMENTS
6. Thereafter, final arguments were advanced by the plaintiffs.
7. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff had argued that the defendant
was allowed to reside at the suit property however, his behavior
towards the plaintiff has drastically changed, hence, the plaintiff
had revoked her permission/licence and asked the defendant to
vacate the suit property. It is stated that the plaintiff had de-
barred the defendant from her movable and immovable property
and had also given Rs. 1 Lakh to the defendant, however, he has
not vacated the suit property. Hence, it is prayed that the suit be
decreed.
8. Arguments were heard. Record was perused.
9. Before embarking to decide the present case, it would be
appropriate to reiterate the burden of proof required to be
discharged in civil proceedings. As laid down in Postgraduate
Institute of Medical Education and Research v. Jaspal Singh,
(2009) 7 SCC 330, the burden which ought to be discharged in
civil proceedings in not as strict as in criminal cases and in
order for any party to succeed, he/it is required to prove his/its
case on the preponderance of probabilities. The relevant portion
of the aforesaid pronouncement is hereby produced here for the
-- 4 of 7 --
CS No. 1374/2025 Satto Devi Vs. Ravi Kumar 5 of page no. 7
sake of brevity:
“It has been held that there is a marked
difference as to the effect of evidence, namely,
the proof, in civil and criminal proceedings. In
civil proceedings, a mere preponderance of
probability is sufficient, and the defendant is not
necessarily entitled to the benefit of every
reasonable doubt; but in criminal proceedings,
the persuasion of guilt must amount to such a
moral certainty as convinces the mind of the
court, as a reasonable man, beyond all
reasonable doubt.”
10. Further, Section 101 of the Evidence Act, 1872 defines
"burden of proof" and lays down that the burden of proving a
fact always lies upon the person who asserts the facts. Until such
burden is discharged, the other party is not required to be called
upon to prove his case. The court has to examine as to whether
the person upon whom the burden lies has been able to discharge
his burden. A party cannot proceed on the basis of weakness of
other party. In view of Section 103 of Evidence Act, the burden
of proof as to any particular fact lies on that person who wishes
the Court to believe in its existence, unless it is provided by any
law that the proof of that fact shall lied on any particular person.
Further, Section 58 of the Indian Evidence Act contains that no
fact needs to be proved in any proceedings which parties thereto
or their agents agree to admit at the hearing, or which, before the
hearing, they agree to admit by any writing under their hands or
which by any rule of pleadings enforce at the time they are
deemed to have admitted by their pleadings.
-- 5 of 7 --
CS No. 1374/2025 Satto Devi Vs. Ravi Kumar 6 of page no. 7
11. Having determined the burden of proof required to be
discharged in civil cases, this court will now proceed to give its
findings. The plaintiff has produced document i.e. Ex. PW-1/1 to
Ex. PW1/9 and has categorically stated that the defendant was
allowed to stay at the suit property and the said permission has
been revoked now. It is stated that the suit property is the self-
acquired property pf the plaintiff and she is the absolute owner,
hence has an excusive right in the suit property. There is nothing
to disbelieve the version of the plaintiff and the defendant never
appeared to raise any dispute to the averments of the plaintiff
meaning thereby he has no defence to offer.
RELIEF:-
12. For the reasons assigned herein above, plaintiff has been
able to successfully prove her case. Accordingly, the suit of the
plaintiff is hereby decreed. The following reliefs are granted to
the plaintiff, as prayed for:
I. The defendant is directed to vacate the suit premises and
remove his belongings from the suit premises and to hand over
the peaceful and vacant possession of the suit premises to the
plaintiff.
II. Further, the defendant is restrained from creating any
obstruction in the peaceful possession of the plaintiff qua the suit
property.
-- 6 of 7 --
CS No. 1374/2025 Satto Devi Vs. Ravi Kumar 7 of page no. 7
13. No order as to cost.
14. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly.
15. File be consigned to record room after due compliance.
IT IS CERTIFIED THAT JUDGMENT RUNS INTO
SEVEN PAGES.
Announced in the open Court today.
(VAIBHAV KUMAR)
Civil Judge-N/W District
Rohini Courts/08.10.2026
-- 7 of 7 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.