Full Order Text
Order 16 · 02 Sept 2026 · CNR DLNW030017662023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 3 CS SCJ 865/23 MAHAVIR SENIOR MODEL SCHOOL Vs. MONIKA ARORA 02.09.2026 Present: Ld. Counsel for plaintiff (through VC). Sh. Pranav Sharma, Ld. Counsel for defendant. 1. It is the argument of the defendant that as per the plaintiff, the cause of action arose at the plaintiff school which is situated at Sangam Park Extension, Rana Pratap Bagh, GT Karnal Road, Delhi and the same falls within Central District, hence it is argued that this Court does not have territorial jurisdiction to try this suit as the cause of action arose outside the territorial jurisdiction of North West District. Also, it is argued that, in another suit filed by the plaintiff against someone else, the SDM had filed a report in the Court whereby it was mentioned that the plaintiff school is within jurisdiction of Central District. Further, it is stated that the suit of plaintiff is not maintainable as the plaintiff has not produced relevant documents in support of his claim. 2. Per contra, ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has argued that the subsequently, the District Magistrate had filed a report clarifying that the plaintiff suit is within jurisdiction of North West District. It is argued that this Court has territorial jurisdiction to try the suit. Further, it is argued that the relevant records shall be produced during the trial and hence is prayed that the application be dismissed. 3. Arguments heard. Record perused. 4. Both the parties are relying upon the reports of revenue authorities/ administration mentioning the jurisdiction of the plaintiff. This Court is cognizant of the fact that the area demarcation for the purpose of territorial jurisdiction of Revenue authorities and Police authorities is different than for Judicial District. The subject matter and pecuniary jurisdiction of this Court is not being denied/ -- 1 of 2 -- challenged and the only dispute is regarding the territorial jurisdiction. On enquiry from the Court staff of filing centre and Nazarat Branch, it has been apprised that the concerned area of Sangam Park Extension, Rana Pratap Bagh is within the jurisdiction of North West District. In view of this Court, this dispute regarding territorial jurisdiction be decided at the tile of trial. Even otherwise, a defect regarding territorial jurisdiction is a procedural irregularity and not an illegality. In view of the arguments of both the parties, it appears that the dispute regarding territorial jurisdiction of this Court is a mixed question of fact and law. Accordingly, the following additional issue is being framed: “3. Whether this Court does not have territorial jurisdiction to try this Suit? (OPD)”. 5. Further, the matter was at the stage of PE when this contention was raised and the parties still have opportunity to lead best evidence available with them. 6. Accordingly, be put up for PE for 07.12.2026. (Vaibhav Kumar) Civil Judge/N-W District 02.09.2026 -- 2 of 2 --
