Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 16 Oct 2025 · CNR DLNW030017092025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 1150/25 NIRMAL GUPTA Vs. GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI 16.10.2025 Present: Son of the plaintiff in person alongwith Ld. Counsels Mr. Shantanu Awasthi and Mr. Shikhar Mittal. Mr. Dheeraj Singh and Mr. Tarun Diwan, Ld. Counsels for the defendants no. 1 & 2 through VC. Mr. Asif Ali, Ld. Counsel for the defendant no. 3 through VC. The plaintiff has filed replication / rejoinder to the reply furnished by defendants no. 1 & 2 on LDOH alongwith several other documents sought to be relied upon. Taken on record. Copy supplied. Arguments heard from both the sides on the aspect of the suit proceedings liable to be taken forward or otherwise. In pith and substance, the plaintiff case is with regards the forceful dispossession / improper manner in which the suit property (‘Balaji Hardware’ - Plot No. 1/5, Shalimar Bagh, Singhalpur Village, Labour Chowk, Delhi) is being tried to be got vacated from the plaintiff by the defendants without following due process by issuing notice for the same in a hushed up manner. Accordingly, the present suit in that regard was filed seeking the reliefs of declaration of such notice being null and void and consequential reliefs of injunction protecting possession of the plaintiff vis a vis the suit property. On the first date of hearing itself, the Court found it proper to grant interim protection to the plaintiff from being dispossessed from the suit property and such protection has continued till date. It is to be noted that such interim measures were put in place purely on grounds of requirement of following of due CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 1/10 -- 1 of 10 -- process by State / its instrumentalities in dispossessing the plaintiff, an inherent right in favour of each citizen against every State action. Defendants entered an appearance and filed their reply. It was claimed by them essentially that the notice issued to the plaintiff was in pursuance of a road widening project being undertaken by the defendants where the suit property / shop in question was found situated within the alignment of the proposed project. Moreover, it was also contended that such portion of land was recorded a Government land, presently under the jurisdiction of PWD and as such therefore, plaintiff was liable to remove the unauthorized encroachment or else, face demolition action. Accordingly, the defendants averred that no injunction could be granted in favour of the plaintiff within the meaning of Section 20A and 41(ha) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 (‘SRA’) r/w Item A under the category ‘Transport’ at Serial No. 1 to the Schedule appended thereto. Moreover, it was also stated that the sale deed documents relied upon by the plaintiff pertain to a different Khasra No. than the one where the defendants were proposing to carry out road widening activities and on that very ground itself, the present suit proceedings must be dismissed. The site where the proposed project work is to be undertaken forms part of duly acquired land as per the defendants, with the possession thereof having been handed over as per procedure long back. All documents in that regard have been filed as well alongwith the reply furnished. In view of the same, the defendants contended that the present suit proceedings were gross abuse of the process of the Court. In the rejoinder filed, plaintiff has denied all the contentions of the defendants. It stated that though there are no CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 2/10 -- 2 of 10 -- clear guidelines / rules about competent authority / courts within the meaning of Section 20B SRA and even on the e-court portal of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, no label of infrastructure suit is present, this Court can be taken to be the designated infrastructure court within the meaning of the circular / notification issued by the Law Department, Delhi Government, whose copy stands filed on record. With regards the claim of the shop of the plaintiff lying in a different Khasra No. than the place where the road widening project is to be undertaken as well, the plaintiff has disagreed and in fact emphasized that due to competing claims in that regard, the suit proceedings must be allowed to continue, for the purpose of establishing respective rights of the parties. To that end, copy of letter addressed by defendant no. 2 to Haryana Irrigation Department has also been filed showing uncertainty over identification of land. Finally, the plaintiff has also filed copy of order dated 26.09.2025 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in writ proceedings undertaken by a similarly placed litigant against the authorities where same action was sought to be undertaken, which was stayed by the Hon’ble Court. As such therefore, the plaintiff contends that the suit proceedings must be allowed to be continued. Submissions heard. Record perused. There is no dispute with regards the intended purpose for which the suit property is stated to be required by the defendants – for road widening project. If that be so, the nature of the present suit proceedings would certainly fall in Section 20A, SRA in as much as the Schedule to such Act, while prescribing the categories of projects which constitute infrastructure projects, includes transport / roads and bridges as sectors and sub sectors. CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 3/10 -- 3 of 10 -- The present suit as a whole also, one for declaration and injunction, is therefore clearly covered by the provisions of Specific Relief Act, 1963, the relief of declaration and injunction being provided therein. The plaintiff has filed on record a copy of notification dated 17.02.2021 in the name of the Lt. Governor of NCT of Delhi, as forwarded by the Ld. Registrar General, High Court of Delhi to be circulated amongst District Courts with regards designation of Special Courts U/s 20B, SRA. The said notification states that the Court of District Judge (Commercial Court)-01 of every district, the District where only one Court of District Judge (Commercial Court) is there – such Court and the Courts of Senior Civil Judge in every district shall be the designated infrastructure courts within the meaning of Section 20B, SRA. If that be so, prima facie, the jurisdiction to try the present suit was either with the Court of District Judge (Commercial Court)-01 or Court of Senior Civil Judge only, and not strictly with this Court. Be that as it may, since the plaintiff itself has pleaded ambiguity / lack of clarity with regards designated infrastructure courts and the suit itself, is seen to be essentially one for securing protection against action sought to be taken by the defendants without due process, the Court is going to restrict its findings on the latter aspect only for now as the suit is seen to be rather premature at this stage. Superior courts have laid down from time to time that due process in State action is a sine qua non and arbitrariness is an absolute anathema thereof. The days of the Star Chamber during the Tudor times as it were are long gone and on no pretext can State action undertaken / sought to be undertaken be justified dehors following of due process and principles of fairness / natural justice ingrained in every such scenario. Just because a road CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 4/10 -- 4 of 10 -- widening project is required to be undertaken, the State / its instrumentalities cannot throw off to the winds the requirements of due process. In this regard, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Re Manoj Tibrewal Akash (Writ Petition (Civil) 1294 of 2020 (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3210) recently laid down guidelines to be followed. They are: (i) Ascertain the existing width of the road in terms of official records/maps; (ii) Carry out a survey/demarcation to ascertain whether there is any encroachment on the existing road with reference to the existing records/maps; (iii) If an encroachment is found, issue a proper, written notice to the encroachers to remove the encroachment; (iv) In the event that the noticee raises an objection with regard to the correctness or the validity of the notice, decide the objection by a speaking order in due compliance with the principles of natural justice; (v) If the objection is rejected, furnish reasonable notice to the person against whom adverse action is proposed and upon the failure of the person concerned to act, proceed in accordance with law, to remove the encroachment unless restrained by an order of the competent authority or court; and (vi) If the existing width of road including the State land adjoining the road is not sufficient to accommodate the widening of the road, steps must be taken by the State to acquire the land in accordance with law before undertaking the road widening exercise. On the same lines, in the spirit of leaving no person hapless against arbitrary State action, Hon’ble Supreme Court in Re: Directions in the matter of demolition of structures 2024 INSC 866, had passed directions for strict compliance under Article 142 of the Constitution of India as well. They may be noted as follows: 90. In order to allay the fears in the minds of the citizens with regard to arbitrary exercise of power by the officers/officials of the State, we find it necessary to issue certain directions in exercise of our power under Article 142 of the Constitution. We are also of the view that even CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 5/10 -- 5 of 10 -- after orders of demolition are passed, the affected party needs to be given some time so as to challenge the order of demolition before an appropriate forum. We are further of the view that even in cases of persons who do not wish to contest the demolition order, sufficient time needs to be given to them to vacate and arrange their affairs. It is not a happy sight to see women, children and aged persons dragged to the streets overnight. Heavens would not fall on the authorities if they hold their hands for some period. 91. At the outset, we clarify that these directions will not be applicable if there is an unauthorized structure in any public place such as road, street, footpath, abutting railway line or any river body or water bodies and also to cases where there is an order for demolition made by a Court of law. A. NOTICE i. No demolition should be carried out without a prior show cause notice returnable either in accordance with the time provided by the local municipal laws or within 15 days’ time from the date of service of such notice, whichever is later. ii. The notice shall be served upon the owner/occupier by a registered post A.D. Additionally, the notice shall also be affixed conspicuously on the outer portion of the structure in question. iii. The time of 15 days, stated herein above, shall start from the date of receipt of the said notice. iv. To prevent any allegation of backdating, we direct that as soon as the show cause notice is duly served, intimation thereof shall be sent to the office of Collector/District Magistrate of the district digitally by email and an auto generated reply acknowledging receipt of the mail should also be issued from the office of the Collector/District Magistrate. The Collector/DM shall designate a nodal officer and also assign an email address and communicate the same to all the municipal and other authorities in charge of building regulations and demolition within one month from today. v. The notice shall contain the details regarding: a. the nature of the unauthorized construction. b. the details of the specific violation and the grounds of demolition. c. a list of documents that the noticee is required to furnish along with his reply. d. The notice should also specify the date on which the personal hearing is fixed and the designated authority before whom the hearing will take place; vi. Every municipal/local authority shall assign a designated digital portal, within 3 months from today wherein details regarding service/pasting of the notice, the CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 6/10 -- 6 of 10 -- reply, the show cause notice and the order passed thereon would be available. B. PERSONAL HEARING i. The designated authority shall give an opportunity of personal hearing to the person concerned. ii. The minutes of such a hearing shall also be recorded. C. FINAL ORDER i. Upon hearing, the designated authority shall pass a final order. ii. The final order shall contain: a. the contentions of the noticee, and if the designated authority disagrees with the same, the reasons thereof; b. as to whether the unauthorized construction is compoundable, if it is not so, the reasons therefor; c. if the designated authority finds that only part of the construction is unauthorized/non-compoundable, then the details thereof. d. as to why the extreme step of demolition is the only option available and other options like compounding and demolishing only part of the property are not available. D. AN OPPORTUNITY OF APPELLATE AND JUDICIAL SCRUTINY OF THE FINAL ORDER. i. We further direct that if the statute provides for an appellate opportunity and time for filing the same, or even if it does not so, the order will not be implemented for a period of 15 days from the date of receipt thereof. The order shall also be displayed on the digital portal as stated above. ii. An opportunity should be given to the owner/occupier to remove the unauthorized construction or demolish the same within a period of 15 days. Only after the period of 15 days from the date of receipt of the notice has expired and the owner/occupier has not removed/demolished the unauthorized construction, and if the same is not stayed by any appellate authority or a court, the concerned authority shall take steps to demolish the same. It is only such construction which is found to be unauthorized and not compoundable shall be demolished. iii. Before demolition, a detailed inspection report shall be prepared by the concerned authority signed by two Panchas. E. PROCEEDINGS OF DEMOLITION i. The proceedings of demolition shall be video-graphed, and the concerned authority shall prepare a demolition report giving the list of police officials and civil personnel that participated in the demolition process. Video recording to be duly preserved. ii. The said demolition report should be forwarded to the Municipal Commissioner by email and shall also be displayed on the digital portal. CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 7/10 -- 7 of 10 -- It is to be noted that the plaintiff claim is based upon a registered sale deed, to which assumption of validity is attached. Until and unless the same is repudiated by the authority concerned during the proceeding underway, the plaintiff having furnished a reply / or by a Court of competent jurisdiction, it cannot be taken to be worthless. If that be so, the exclusion clause mentioned in the above guidelines at para no. 91 does not strictly apply to the plaintiff just because the defendants are undertaking an infrastructure project, thereby necessitating the defendants to comply with the remaining directions passed by the Hon’ble Court. Instead, seen from the above anvil, notice dated 17.09.2025 issued to the plaintiff requiring it to give reply within two days only was not prima facie proper. Moreover, in terms of the directions as above, the aforesaid notice containing no other details as well based upon which the defendants claim their rights also per se does not seem to be entirely the correct approach followed. Looking at such aspects, interim protection was granted to the plaintiff on the first date of hearing. Nevertheless, that stage is, for the time being, past us and what is required to be seen now is that proper process is followed going forward. This is so since as of now, the proceedings qua the notice dated 17.09.2025 are still inchoate as the plaintiff having furnished a reply to the defendants, the same has still not been adjudicated upon. To that extent therefore, the suit filed itself is seen to be premature. Only two possibilities can arise, i.e. either the defendants can accept the objections raised or reject them. For taking any such course however, it need not be re-emphasized that in terms of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the orders cited above, the defendants are bound to follow due process. CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 8/10 -- 8 of 10 -- Taking into consideration the totality of circumstances therefore, the forum / court before which the suit has been filed and the alternate remedy already available / being pursued by the plaintiff, this Court is of the view that the present suit may be disposed off by passing necessary directions as follows: 1. The defendants to decide the objections raised by the plaintiff in response to the notice dated 17.09.2025 issued previously by a speaking order after giving personal hearing to the plaintiff, who may appear in person or through counsel. Any documents based upon which the original notice was issued, if not previously supplied to the plaintiff, be also supplied during such personal hearing to the plaintiff and if required, based upon such documents, the plaintiff be given opportunity to respond and only after taking such response into account, the objections raised overall be disposed. 2. The order vide which the defendants ultimately dispose off the plaintiff objections be communicated by way of registered AD as well as electronically to the plaintiff. Email / Whatsapp details in this regard pertaining to the plaintiff / counsel appearing for it be exchanged appropriately during the personal hearing to be accorded. Moreover, any documents alluded to in the final order of disposal based upon which decision is taken one way or the other be also annexed with the copy to be supplied to the plaintiff. 3. If vide the final order to be passed, the objections raised by the plaintiff are held as not sustainable, a minimum of 15 working days’ time be accorded to the plaintiff to vacate the suit property or to take legal recourse, as per law and only CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 9/10 -- 9 of 10 -- after that, demolition action be undertaken, as per law. The above directions are to be construed in addition to the ones passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in both the orders alluded to above, being 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3210 and 2024 INSC 866. Since they constitute binding precedent, they be adhered to at all stages of the process with regards grant of personal hearing, disposal of objections by speaking order, grant of time to vacate / taking legal recourse and the actual demolition to be undertaken, if at all. The suit filed is disposed off in the above-mentioned terms with the liberty to the plaintiff to approach the Court of competent jurisdiction in future, if required, as per law. File be consigned to Record Room after necessary compliance. (Gaurav Sharma) JSCC-cum-ASCJ-cum-Guardian Judge North West/Rohini Courts/Delhi 16.10.2025 CS SCJ 1150/25 Nirmal Gupta Vs. Govt Of Nct Of Delhi pg. no. 10/10 -- 10 of 10 --
