Full Order Text
Final Order 9 · 31 Oct 2025 · CNR DLNW030016962024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. ARJUN KIRAR: CIVIL JUDGE NORTH WEST: ROHINI COURTS: DELHI CS No. 1114/24 CNR No. DLNW03-001696-2024 SMT. PUSHPA AGGARWAL W/o Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ ML Agarwal SH. SACHIN AGGARWAL S/o Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ ML Agarwal SH. VIKAS AGARWAL W/o Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ ML Agarwal All 1 to 3 R/o C-71, Rohit Kunj Pitampura, Delhi - 110034 Email: currentad@gmail.com Mobile: 98110 13049 4. SMT. SUMITA GUPTA D/o Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ M.L. Agarwal W/o Sh. Sanjay Gupta R/o B-7, Extn. 80, Safdarjung Enclave New Delhi - 110029 5. SMT. POONAM GUPTA D/o Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ M.L. Agarwal W/o Sh. Sanjay Gupta R/o A-213, Knights Bridge Apartment ITPL Main Road, AECS Layout Kundalahalli, Bangalore Karnataka - 560037 CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- 6. SMT. SEEMA AGARWAL D/o Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ M.L. Agarwal W/o Sh. Sandeep Goel R/o 113, Lok Nayak Apartments Sector - 9, Rohini Delhi - 110085 …...PLAINTIFFS VERSUS 1. THE SDM DC Office Complex, Kanjhawala Delhi - 110081 Email: dcnw@nic.in 2. THE REGISTRAR / DEPUTY HEALTH OFFICER Keshav Puram, MCD Zone A-1, Keshav Puram MCD Zonal Office Delhi - 110035 Email: keshavpuramdho@gmail.com 3. THE SHO P.S. Subhash Place New Building Police Station Shakurpur Delhi – 110034 Proprietor of Sagar Enterprises Address: H No. 4180, First Floor, Gali No. 65, Regarpura, Karol Bagh, New Delhi-110005 .....DEFENDANTS CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- Suit for Declaration and Mandatory injunction Date of institution : 20.08.2024 Date of decision : 31.10.2025 Final order : Decreed JUDGMENT BRIEF FACTS 1. Brief facts of the case as per the plaintiffs are that the plaintiff no.1 is the wife, plaintiff no.2 and 3 are the sons and Plaintiff no. 4 to 6 are the daughters of Sh. mukut Singh @ M.L Aggarwal. Sh. mukut Singh @ M.L Aggarwal (Date of birth - 1st July, 1945) had gone missing on 09-08-2017 and till date no person has heard of him or got any information with regard to him being alive. The plaintiffs had lodged a complaint dated vide DD (GD) No. 18A dated 09-08-2017 with local PS Subhash Place, North- West District, Delhi. The plaintiffs also got published the public notice in respect of Sh. mukut Lal Aggarwal under the heading “Search for missing” in various leading newspapers. The defendant no. 1 is the SDM, Kanjhawala. Defendant no. 2 is the concerned authority for issuing death Certificate. No relief has been claimed against defendant no. 3, however defendant no.3 is a necessary and proper party. The plaintiffs on 07-06-2024, obtained a certificate from the local Police station i.e. PS. Subhash Place regarding the status of Sh. Mukut Lal Aggarwal @ M.L Aggarwal as untraceable. Sh. Mukut Lal Aggarwal has neither been seen nor heard either by the plaintiffs or their relatives for the last more than 7 years since 09-08-2017 till date and thus, needs to be declared as presumed dead. Hence, the present suit. CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- 2. On being served, the Defendant no. 2 marked appearance before the court and filed written statement wherein it stated that as per Rules laid down by the GOI, the death certificate can only be issued after the declaration of the missing person by the competent Court of law in accordance with section 107 & 108 of the Evidence Act 1872. 3. Defendant no. 1 and 3 were proceeded exparte vide order dated 19-11-2024. ISSUES 4. Vide order dated 24-12-2024 the following issues were framed in the matter: 1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of declaration declaring Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal s/o Late Sh. Munsi Ram Agarwal as dead ? (OPP) 2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of mandatory injunction, directing the defendant no. 2/ MCD to issue death Certificate of Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal ? (OPP) 3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of mandatory injunction, directing the defendant no. 1 / SDM, Kanjhawla to issue surviving member Certificate to plaintiff ? (OPP) 4) Relief. TRIAL:- 5. Plaintiffs led their evidence and examined plaintiff no. 2 Sh. Sachin Aggarwal as PW-1 vide affidavit Ex.PW1/A wherein he reiterated the contents of the plaint and proved the following documents:- CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- (i) Ex.PW1/1 - Passport of Plaintiff no. 1 (OSR) (ii) Ex.PW1/2 - Voter Card of Plaintiff no. 1 (OSR) (iii) Ex.PW1/3 - Aadhar Card of Plaintiff no. 2 (OSR) (iv) Ex.PW1/4 - Aadhar Card of Plaintiff no. 3 (OSR) (v) Ex.PW1/5 - Aadhar Card of Plaintiff no. 4 (OSR) (vi) Ex.PW1/6 - Aadhar Card of Plaintiff no. 5 (OSR) (vii) Ex.PW1/7 - Aadhar Card of Plaintiff no. 6 (OSR) (viii) Ex.PW1/8 - Original DD no. 18A dated 09-08-2018. (ix) Ex.PW1/9 - Print out of missing report status (x) Ex.PW1/10 - Original Untrace report (xi) Ex.PW1/11 - Aadhar Card of Mukut Lal Aggarwal (OSR) (xii) Ex.PW1/12 - PAN Card of Mukut Lal Aggarwal (OSR) (xiii) Ex.PW1/13 - Times of India dated 10-08-2017 (xiv) Ex.PW1/14 - Nav Bharat Times dated 10-08-2017 (xv) Ex.PW1/15 - Hindustan Times dated 10-08-2017 (xvi) Ex.PW1/16 - Hindustan dated 10-08-2017 (xvii) Ex.PW1/17 - Dainik Jagran dated 10-08-2017 (xviii) Ex.PW1/18 - Punjab Kesari dated 10-08-2017 (Hindi Edition) (xix) Ex.PW1/19 - Dainik Jagran (Meerut Edition) dated 11-08- 2017 (xx) Ex.PW1/20 - Amar Ujala (Uttrakhand Edition) Dainik Jagran (Hindi Edition) dated 11-08-2017 (xxi) Ex.PW1/21 - Amar Ujala (Meerut Edition) dated 12-08- 2017 (xxii) Ex.PW1/22 - Amar Ujala (Uttarakhand Edition) dated 12-08-2017. (xxiii) Ex.PW1/23 - Print out of chapter-3 provision 3. A-18- Registration of Deaths of missing person - Training manual for Civil Registration functionaries in India (2012) (xxiv) Ex.PW1/24 - Certificate u/s 65 of Cr.P.C. in respect of Ex CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- PW1/9 and Ex PW1/23. 5.1 The witness was duly cross examined by Ld Counsel for defendant no. 2 /MCD 5.2 Plaintiffs also examined HC Anil, PS Subhash Place as PW-2. The said witness brought an record missing report bearing DD No.018A, dated 09-08-2017 and same was Exhibited as Ex.PW2/1 (OSR). 5.3 No other witness was examined by the plaintiff and PE stood closed on 12.06.2025. 5.4 Ld. Counsel for Defendant no.2 did not lead DE and DE was closed on 06-08-2025. 5.5 Vide order dated 06-09-2025, issue no.3 was dropped on the submission of Ld. Counsel for plaintiff that he is not pressing issue no. 3 wishes to drop the same. 6. Arguments heard. Record perused. FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS:- 7. Before embarking to decide the present case, it would be appropriate to reiterate the burden of proof required to be discharged in civil proceedings. As laid down in Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research v. Jaspal Singh, (2009) 7 SCC 330, the burden which ought to be discharged in civil proceedings in not as strict as in criminal cases and in CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- order for any party to succeed, he/it is required to prove his/its case on the preponderance of probabilities. The relevant portion of the aforesaid pronouncement is hereby produced here for the sake of brevity: “It has been held that there is a marked difference as to the effect of evidence, namely, the proof, in civil and criminal proceedings. In civil proceedings, a mere preponderance of probability is sufficient, and the defendant is not necessarily entitled to the benefit of every reasonable doubt; but in criminal proceedings, the persuasion of guilt must amount to such a moral certainty as convinces the mind of the court, as a reasonable man, beyond all reasonable doubt.” 7.1 Further, Section 101 of the Evidence Act, 1872 defines "burden of proof" and lays down that the burden of proving a fact always lies upon the person who asserts the facts. Until such burden is discharged, the other party is not required to be called upon to prove his case. The court has to examine as to whether the person upon whom the burden lies has been able to discharge his burden. A party cannot proceed on the basis of weakness of other party. In view of Section 103 of Evidence Act, the burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on that person who wishes the Court to believe in its existence, unless it is provided by any law that the proof of that fact shall lied on any particular person. Further, Section 58 of the Indian Evidence Act contains that no fact need to be proved in any proceedings which parties thereto or their agents agree to admit at the hearing, or which, before the hearing, they agree to admit by any writing under their hands or which by any rule of pleadings enforce at the time they are deemed to have admitted by their pleadings. 7.2. Having determined the burden of proof required to be discharged in civil cases, this court will now proceed to give it issue wise findings as per the issues framed as follows:- CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- Issue no. (i) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of declaration declaring Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal s/o Late Sh. Munsi Ram Agarwal as dead ? (OPP) Issue no. (ii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of mandatory injunction, directing the defendant no. 2/ MCD to issue death Certificate of Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal ? (OPP) 8. These issues are being taken together as they involve a common question of law and fact. 9. The facts of the case in hand are directly related with Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act which deals with the presumption of death for a person who has not been heard of for seven years by those who would have naturally heard of him. Coming now to the facts of the case in hand, one of the plaintiffs appeared as PW-1 and stated that Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal had gone missing on 09-08-2017 and till date, no person has heard of him or got any information with regard to him being alive. The statement of the witnesses is duly corroborated by the documents placed on record like complaint to police, missing report status, various leading newspapers, etc. Further all the plaintiff in the present case are the relatives i.e, wife, sons and daughters of Sh. Mukut Agarwal and are the persons who would have naturally heard of him had he been alive. The period of seven years as required u/s 108 of the Indian Evidence Act has also expired. In view of the above discussion it can safely be said that all the requirements of section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act has been fulfilled. On the basis of the same, Sh. Mukht Lal Agarwal @ ML Agarwal, s/o Late Sh. Munshi Ram Agarwal, R/o C-71, Rohit CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- Kunj, Pitampura, Delhi - 110034 can be presumed to be dead. RELIEF:- 10. In view of the above discussion, the plaintiffs have been able to prove their case. A decree of declaration is passed, declaring Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ ML Agarwal (DOB- 1st July, 1945), s/o Late Sh. Munshi Ram Agarwal, R/o C-71, Rohit Kunj, Pitampura, Delhi- 110034 is hereby declared as dead under the provision of section-108 of the Indian Evidence Act. A decree of mandatory injunction is passed in favour of the plaintiffs, thereby, directing defendant no. 2 i.e. The Registrar/Deputy Health Officer, Keshav Puram, MCD Zone to issue death Certificate of Sh. Mukut Lal Agarwal @ ML Agarwal (DOB- 1st July, 1945), S/o Sh. Munshi Ram Agarwal, R/o C-71, Rohit Kunj, Pitampura, Delhi– 110034. No orders as to cost. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. Announced in the open Court today. (Arjun Kirar) Civil Judge-N/W District Rohini Courts/31.10.2025 CS No. 1114/24 Page No. 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
