Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 13 Feb 2024 · CNR DLNW030014682023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 705/23 AZAD SINGH Vs. PINKI GUPTA 13.02.2024 ORDER ON MAINTAINABILITY OF THE PRESENT SUIT (1) Briefly stated, it is the case of the plaintiff that the plaintiff and the defendant were residing together in a live-in relationship since the year 2015 on the basis of a MOU. It is further stated that the defendant is a widow and having three children from her last marriage. It is stated that the plaintiff severed all his relationship from his first wife and started living with the defendant. It is further stated that one girl was born on 06.06.20178 from their live-in relationship. It is further stated that the plaintiff and the defendant started living in a rented accommodation and the plaintiff also opened one kirana shop for the defendant in her house for her and children’s livelihood from which she is earning Rs. 60,000/- as on date. It is further submitted that all the expenses of the minor daughter are being looked after by the plaintiff. It is further stated that after some time, the defendant started harassing the plaintiff and started quarreling with him. The defendant also insulted the plaintiff in the public place. It is stated that on 25-26/09/2022 the plaintiff was beaten by the defendant in public. The plaintiff called at 100 number, however, the matter later got settled and the defendant gave written apology to the officials of PS Mangol Puri. It is further submitted that the parties are now living separately since 19.09.2022 due to the ill behavior of the defendant. In view of the above facts, the plaintiff has filed the present suit against the Page no. 1 of 5 -- 1 of 5 -- defendant seeking the following reliefs: a) seeking decree of permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant thereby restraining the defendant including her heirs, agents, servants, associates, relatives and supporters etc from entering in the resident house of the plaintiff i.e. property bearing no. K- 536,Mangolpuri, Delhi. b) seeking decree of permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant thereby restraining the defendant including her heirs, agents, servants, associates, relatives and supporters etc from creating any scene, nuisance and spreading any slander/defaming the plaintiff in the society and in the general public. c) seeking decree of separation whereby declaring the relationship between the plaintiff and defendant as null and void from the due separation. (2) While no formal application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC was filed, ld counsel for defendant argued that the suit is not maintainable since no cause of action is made out in favour of the plaintiff. Accordingly, arguments on maintainability of the suit were heard on behalf of both parties. (3) I have perused the plaint in light of the arguments advanced. (4) It is a settled law that in order to determine if a suit is liable to be Page no. 2 of 5 -- 2 of 5 -- rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC or not, the court needs to be guided by the averments made in the plaint only and the contentions made by the defendant in WS or otherwise cannot be taken into consideration. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled P.V. Guru Raj Reddy vs. P. Neeradha Reddy (2015) 8 SCC 331 held as follows: “Rejection of the plaint under Order VII rule 11 of the CPC is a drastic power conferred in the court to terminate a civil action at the threshold. The conditions precedent to the exercise of power under Order VII rule 11, therefore, are stringent and have been consistently held to be so by the Court. It is the averments in the plaint that has to be read as a whole to find out whether it discloses a cause of action or whether the suit is barred under any law. At the stage of exercise of power under Order VII rule 11, the stand of the defendants in the written statement or in the application for rejection of the plaint is wholly immaterial. It is only if the averments in the plaint ex facie do not disclose a cause of action or on a reading thereof the suit appears to be barred under any law the plaint can be rejected. In all other situations, the claims will have to be adjudicated in the course of the trial.” (5) In the instant case, the plaintiff has submitted that the parties were living together voluntarily and the relationship between them was not that of a marriage as recognized by Hindu Marriage Act etc. Therefore, a decree of separation or a declaration in this effect, cannot be passed by this court, since there is no civil right operating in favour of the plaintiff or any entitlement to any legal character of the plaintiff which is being Page no. 3 of 5 -- 3 of 5 -- infringed or denied by the defendant, to allow this court to grant such relief. (6) Further, while the plaintiff has prayed for injunction against the defendant from entering property bearing no. K-536, Mangolpuri, Delhi, there is not even a single submission in the plaint that the said property belongs to the plaintiff and that the defendant has no right upon the same and despite the same she is attempting to enter the said property unlawfully. Thus in absence of the pleadings to the effect, no cause of action for seeking injunction as prayed for in clause (a) is made out in favour of the plaintiff. (7) Again, there is no submission in the plaint that the plaintiff created any scene/nuisance or is spreading misinformation leading to slander/defamation of the plaintiff in the entire plaint. The plaintiff has only made generic submissions that the defendant is harassing him and has threatened him to implicate him in false and frivolous cases. However, there are no specific pleadings to this effect. There is no mention of any specific incident or the dates when the same happened. There is also no submission in regards to the contents of the alleged defamatory statement or how the same were published or circulated to some third party. Thus in absence of any specific pleadings, no cause of action is made for seeking injunction as prayed for in clause (b) as well. (8) In absence of any cause of action, the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable. Plaint is accordingly rejected under Order 7 rule 11(a) Page no. 4 of 5 -- 4 of 5 -- CPC. (9) Since nothing else survives, file be consigned to record room after due compliance. (Amardeep Kaur) ACJ/ARC (North-West) Rohini Courts, Delhi/13.02.2024 Page no. 5 of 5 -- 5 of 5 --
