Full Order Text
Final Order 10 · 04 Jun 2026 · CNR DLNW030011462025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. GAURAV SHARMA JSCC-CUM-ASCJ-CUM-GUARDIAN JUDGE NORTH WEST, ROHINI COURTS/DELHI CNR No. DLNW030011462025 MCA SCJ 6/2025 Sh. Laxman Dass S/o Sh. Devi Prasad, R/o: C-198, Second Floor and Third Floor, Shakurpur, Anandvas Colony, Delhi-110034 Also At: Plot No. 3, L-2 Block, Mohan Garden, Uttam Nagar, Delhi-110059 ......Appellant Versus 1. Smt. Basanti W/o Late Sh. Shiv Charan, 2. Sh. Rajesh S/o Late Sh. Shiv Charan, 3. Sh. Kishan S/o Late Sh. Shiv Charan, All R/o: C-198, Ground Floor and First Floor, Shakurpur, Anandvas Colony, Delhi-110034 ......Respondents MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 1/8 -- 1 of 8 -- ORDER 04.06.2026 1. Appeal Dismissed. 2. The present appeal is directed against the order dated 11.06.2025 in CS SCJ 1621/24 whereby the Ld. Trial Court dismissed the application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC filed by the appellant / plaintiff seeking interim injunction. 3. As for the facts of the case, for convenience sake, parties shall be referred to by their status of plaintiff / defendant as in the original suit proceedings. 4. Pithily put, the case of the plaintiff before the Ld. Trial Court is that he is the owner and in possession of suit property (C-198, Second Floor (with roof right), Shakurpur, Anandvas Colony, Delhi-110034), having purchased it from his father Devi Prasad vide customary documents GPA / ATS / Possession Letter / Receipt / Registered Will, all dated 26.10.2020. It is claimed that the plaintiff and his family have been residing therein and have also constructed the Third Floor using own funds. In support of claim of possession, such documents have been filed on record together with copies of Voter ID Card, electricity bill and water bill. Defendant no. 1 is the sister in law of the plaintiff (wife of his deceased brother) with defendants no. 2 & 3 being his nephews residing on MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 2/8 -- 2 of 8 -- Ground and First Floor. The defendants, as per the plaintiff have not had cordial relations with him and want to dispossess him from the suit property. Due to such conduct, it is also averred that the plaintiff and his family had temporarily shifted to Mohan Garden, Uttam Nagar by locking his portion, leaving goods etc. behind, residing alternatively at both places. Visits of the plaintiff on 08.11.2024 and 10.11.2024 have been described when the defendants blocked the plaintiff access to his portion, while also threatening of creating third party interest. In view of the same, the necessity to file the civil suit arose seeking the sole relief of permanent injunction for protection against forcible dispossession from the suit property or warding off any interference in the peaceful use thereof. 5. The defendants in their WS denied all the plaintiff claims and stated that the father in law of defendant no. 1 / father of the plaintiff was the owner of the overall property of which the suit property also formed one part and has been in possession of the same as well. The plaintiff and his son Amit are stated to have surreptitiously taken away documents of the property as well as that of defendant no. 1 property, including other important retirement papers of the father in law and has misused them to portray himself to be the owner of the suit property. As for themselves, defendants have claimed that the plaintiff has been hellbent upon getting them evicted after the demise of his brother, the husband of defendant no. 1. In fact, in this MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 3/8 -- 3 of 8 -- regard, it is stated that a false suit was got filed by the plaintiff in the name of his father against the defendants to dispossess them and later when the father in law got to know about the same, the matter was disposed off as settled and withdrawn. Having been harassed, the defendant no. 1 is also stated to have filed a DV complaint case which was however later settled as well and withdrawn given the false case foisted by the plaintiff having also been withdrawn. Not only that, it is also stated that the father in law of defendant no. 1 / father of the plaintiff, extremely troubled by the plaintiff conduct, has filed a complaint against him as well which is currently pending. Acts of unnecessarily troubling the defendants have also been alluded to in the WS to claim that the plaintiff case was liable to be dismissed. 6. Pleadings being as such, upon consideration of the application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC, Ld. Trial Court dismissed the same primarily on the ground that the appellant was unable to establish his settled possession qua the suit property with his documents for the same not being in sync with one another. 7. In the appeal filed, it has been urged that Ld. Trial Court did not take into consideration the documents relied upon by the appellant and erroneously dismissed the application. Conversely, Ld. Counsel for the respondents have argued that the appeal is devoid of merits with the appellant having no case. MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 4/8 -- 4 of 8 -- 8. Submissions heard. TCR perused. 9. First of all, it is seen that the only relief sought by the appellant in the original suit proceedings is the same relief he seeks to canvass through the application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC. Final relief cannot be granted at the interim stage unless exceptional circumstances are shown. In the present matter, no such state of affairs was established by the appellant and as such therefore, the application could have been repelled on that count itself. 10.As for the documents relied upon by the appellant for showing settled possession qua the suit property, Ld. Trial Court has correctly held that they simply do not add up with there being a gap of about four years between the customary documents on one hand and the electricity / water bills on the other. Not only that, Ld. Trial Court has also rightly held that by merely filing a copy of one electricity and water bill, it was not sufficient for the appellant to establish his settled possession. Moreover, the Ld. Trial Court also treaded on the right path by noting that when an objection was specifically raised by the respondents that the father in law was in possession of the suit property, he should have been impleaded in the proceedings, even if not as a necessary party, but a proper party at least. This was important moreso since the respondents have categorically taken a submission that the appellant had falsely filed a suit previously on behalf of his father for evicting the respondents, of which nothing came MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 5/8 -- 5 of 8 -- off ultimately. Not only that, a complaint is also stated to have been made against the appellant by his father, which does indeed raise suspicion as to how and under what circumstances the suit property was sold off by him to the appellant. During the course of appeal proceedings, it was informed that the father had moved an application seeking impleadment before the Ld. Trial Court already and if that be so, without the same having been considered and decided, on balance, given the defence raised by the respondents qua appellant having purchased the suit property by stealth, its case indeed came under doubt with regards the factum of purchase of the suit property from his father and ultimately residing therein continuously and regularly. The customary documents – GPA / Agreement to Sell / Receipt / Possession Letter / Registered Will do not unto themselves show settled possession and are therefore of no use to the appellant case any which way. The electricity and water bill documents, one each, as noted above, are not credible to establish settled possession either given the defence raised in the WS. The other proof of identity documents – Aadhar Card / Voter I Card also reflect the address to be of the overall property and not specifically the Second and Third Floors thereof, with regards which the suit in question has been filed by the appellant. Finally, it is also noted that the appellant himself has pleaded that he has a place of living at Uttam Nagar as well and he lives there some time and at the suit property, on other occasions. This in itself reflects that the settled possession of the appellant qua the suit property cannot be MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 6/8 -- 6 of 8 -- readily inferred. In fact, the nature of stay of the appellant at the suit property is described by himself in the appeal documents at paragraph no. (I) of the grounds of appeal as ‘occasional stay’, which per se shows that the appellant clearly acknowledges the nature of his possession of the suit property, if at all, as something other than settled possession. 11.Considering the overall circumstances as above, this Court is of the view that the Ld. Trial Court came to the right conclusion that the appellant was unable to make out a prima facie case, with too many uncertainties having been pointed out by the respondents. 12.Even on the balance of convenience aspect, it is noted that the comparative harm that will be caused to the respondents shall be far greater if injunction is granted in favour of the appellant by recognizing his settled possession, particularly given the contrary assertions made – such as that of prior suit proceedings having been filed, complaints made by the father and his impleadment application to be considered. 13.Likewise, if injunction is allowed and ultimately the suit fails, irreparable loss caused to the respondents shall outweigh the hindrance caused to the appellant if injunction were not to be granted as by his own admission he is having another place of residence at Uttam Nagar. MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 7/8 -- 7 of 8 -- ORDER 1. For the reasons as aforesaid, the appeal is Dismissed and the order passed by the Ld. Trial Court on 11.06.2025 is upheld. 2. Having said so, the appellant is granted opportunity to canvass his application afresh before the Ld. Trial Court, if so required, after the impleadment application of the father in law of respondent no. 1 is considered and decided and he becomes a party to the suit proceedings. Parties to bear their own costs. Appeal file be consigned to Record Room after necessary compliance. Copy of the order be sent to the Ld. Trial Court. Trial Court record be sent back forthwith. Announced in the open Court on 04.06.2026 (Gaurav Sharma) JSCC-cum-ASCJ-cum-Guardian Judge North West/Rohini Courts/Delhi 04.06.2026 MCA SCJ 6/2025 Laxman Dass Vs. Basanti pg. no. 8/8 -- 8 of 8 --
