Full Order Text
Interim Order 3 · 26 May 2026 · CNR DLNW030009852026
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 1 CS SCJ 590/2026 SANJEEV KUMAR DUBEY Vs. PANKAJ SHUKLA 26.05.2026 ORDER 1. Vide this order I shall dispose off the application u/O 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC. 2. Brief facts of the case as per the plaint are that the plaintiff claims himself to be the elected president of Residence Welfare Association namely Kanhiya Nagar RWA of Tri Nagar. It is stated that the defendant no. 1 is the General Secretary of the said RWA and he is not working as per the bye-laws of the society. Hence, the plaintiff made several requests to the defendant no. 1 to not to indulge in illegal acts, however, the defendant no. 1 alongwith defendant no. 2 to defendant no. 4, threatened the plaintiff to falsely implicate him in false cases. It is the case of plaintiff that the defendants are trying to take over the operation and management of the said RWA with magnified intentions and for the same reason, the defendants have spread false messages on WhatsApp groups of the RWA, whereby it is stated that the plaintiff is a tenant and not a land owner, hence, from now onwards, the plaintiff shall not be considered as the president of the said RWA. Hence the present suit has been filed seeking declaration and injunction thereby declaring the plaintiff as duly elected and continuing president of the RWA and declaring the acts, resolutions etc. passed by the defendants to -- 1 of 4 -- 2 remove the plaintiff from office, as void. Also injunctions have been sought against the defendants. By way of present application, the plaintiff has stated that the plaintiff shall suffer irreparable loss and injury if the defendants are not restrained from maligning the name and reputation of the plaintiff. It is stated that the defendants have pasted posters with above said messages which are defamatory to the plaintiff. 3. Notice of this application was given to the defendants which was duly served, however, no appearance has been entered into on behalf of the defendants and no reply has been filed. 4. Arguments heard on behalf of plaintiff. Record Perused. 5. It is a well settled law that for proving himself to be entitled to a temporary injunction, the plaintiff has to prove three things:- (i) That a prima facie case is made out in his favour. (ii) That the balance of convenience lies in his favour. (iii) That the refusal of injunction will cause irreparable injury to him. 6. As has been repeatedly held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, prima facie case means that there is a serious disputed question to be tried in the suit, and on facts before the Court, there is probability of applicant to be entitled to the relief asked for. -- 2 of 4 -- 3 7. Prima facie case does not mean a case proved to the hilt. It is no part of the Court's function at this stage, to sift and weigh, the evidentiary material filed alongwith pleadings to assess their probative value. The only requirement is that whether the view taken as per the plaint and documents filed by the plaintiff is a possible view or not. [M. Gurudas V/s Rasranjan (2006) 8 SCC 367]. 8. As far as the point of irreparable injury is concerned, it is a settled law that no injury is irreparable which can be adequately compensated by way of damages and when there are other efficacious remedies available to the applicant. [Kuldip Singh V/s Subhash Chandra Jain (AIR 2000 SC 1410), Maharawal Khewaji Trust V/s Baldev Dass (2004) 8 SCC 488]. 9. Balance of convenience connotes comparative hardship or mischief likely to be caused to either party in case of grant or refusal of the injunction. [Dalpat Kumar V/s Prahlad Singh (AIR 1993 SC 276)]. 10. Apart from the above stated legal position, it is noteworthy that the interim relief sought by the plaintiff is the same as one of the final reliefs and the law is well established that in order to obtain the final relief at an interim stage, the plaintiff has to show a very strong prima facie case in his favor (Deoraj vs State of Maharashtra AIR 2004 SC 1975). 11. In light of the above said principles, the plaintiff has to -- 3 of 4 -- 4 show a very strong prima facie case in his favour. Coming back to the facts of the present case, the plaintiff claims himself to be the elected president of the said RWA, however, no document has been annexed with the plaint to show the said election of the plaintiff. The plaintiff relies upon certain photocopies of letterheads of the said RWA where name of the plaintiff has been mentioned as president, however, in view of this Court, the same is not sufficient to show a strong prima facie case in favor of the plaintiff. Also in absence of any prima facie proof of being the elected president, the balance of convenience also does not lie in the favor of the plaintiff. Further, by reading the contents of the said poster, it appears that the defendants have raised their objection to the plaintiff’s claim of being president of the said RWA with a note given that the plaintiff can give clarifications in the working committee. As such none of the essential ingredient is satisfied. 12. Accordingly, the application u/O 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC is dismissed. 13. Nothing mentioned above would tantamount to expression of any opinion on the merits of the suit. 14. Application stands disposed of. Be tagged with the main file. (Vaibhav Kumar) Civil Judge/N-W District 26.05.2026 -- 4 of 4 --
