Full Order Text
Order 2 · 10 Jul 2025 · CNR DLNW030009162025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 10 CS SCJ 618/25 GHANSHYAM SINGH Vs. LOHIA KIA 10.07.2025 Present : Sh. Gagandeep Singh, Ld. counsel for the plaintiff with plaintiff. Sh. Ritesh Kumar, Ld. counsel for the defendants. All the defendant were served on 03.06.2025. However, Ld. counsel for the defendants submits that legible copies of page no. 51 to 54 have not been supplied to him. Plaintiff is directed to supply the same within one week from today. Written Statement be filed within 30 days from supply of the documents with advance copy to the opposite side. Replication, if any, be also filed by the plaintiff with advance copy to the opposite side. Arguments heard on the application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC. Be put up for orders on the application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC today itself at 02:00 pm. (Mansi Malik) ACJ/ARC (North-West) Rohini Courts, Delhi/10.07.2025 At 02:00 pm Present : None. Vide this order, I shall dispose off the application filed by the plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC. The brief facts of the case are that the plaintiff is a Chartered Account and had joined defendant no. 1 as Vice President, Pg. No. 1 of 4 -- 1 of 4 -- Finance and Accounts on 03.07.2022 but since last year, the defendants pressured the plaintiff to engage in illegal and unethical activities, which he refused to do. In order to harass the plaintiff, the defendants installed CCTV cameras with audio recording in his cabin. On 22.04.2025, the plaintiff intimated to defendant no. 3 that he will be on leave and would not be able to come to office due to personal urgent work and requested him to implement HR policy as per Industry Norms and Labour Laws and requested him to remove CCTV cameras from his cabin. It is the case of the plaintiff that he never intimated the defendants that he wants to resign from the company but that on 02.05.2025, the defendants issued a letter calling upon the plaintiff to provide clearance of no dues for full and final settlement and to handover the company data/belongings as the plaintiff is not interested in working in the Organization. It is contended by counsel for the plaintiff that the said letter constitutes constructive dismissal/termination and it is prayed that the operation of the said letter/notice dated 02.05.2025 be stayed till the disposal of the present case. It is also prayed that the defendants be restrained from creating any hurdle/hindrance in the entry/exit of the plaintiff in the office of defendant no. 1 and to permit the plaintiff to work peacefully in defendant no. 1 company. Per contra, Ld. counsel for the defendants submits that whether the letter/notice dated 02.05.2025 was issued in compliance of labour laws or as per the rules and regulations of the company is a matter of trial and cannot be determined at this stage. It is further stated that no ground exists to stay the operation of the letter/notice dated 02.05.2025 and that the interim application filed by the plaintiff be dismissed. Pg. No. 2 of 4 -- 2 of 4 -- Arguments heard. Record perused. I have considered the submissions and gone through the record carefully. The Plaintiff is required to prove the following three ingredients under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC:- i) to make out a prima facie case in his favour; ii) the balance of convenience also lies in favour of Plaintiff and iii) irreparable loss and injury in case the injunction is not granted. In the present matter, it is the case of the plaintiff that the letter/notice dated 02.05.2025 constitutes constructive dismissal/termination of the plaintiff and that the operation of the said letter be stayed till disposal of the matter. A perusal of the appointment letter placed on record by the plaintiff shows that para no.19 is the termination clause. The said clause states that termination of services may be effective by either side by tendering one months notice or payment of one months basic salary in lieu of notice. It is further stated that in case of unauthorized absence or overstay of leave for continuous period of more than eight days, it shall be presumed that employee is no longer interested in continuing the employment with the company and has appended the job of his own accord and his name shall be struck off from the company’s role as having resigned without any notice or intimation. In view of the said clause, it is clear that in case of unauthorized absence or overstay of leave, the name of the employee shall be struck off from the company’s rolls as having resigned without any notice or intimation. Although the plaintiff states that the leave he had taken was authorized by the defendant but the same is not admitted by the defendant. Therefore, it is a matter of trial, as to whether, the Pg. No. 3 of 4 -- 3 of 4 -- leave of the plaintiff was authorized or not as evidence has to be led on the said issue by both the parties. As a consequence of the same, it is not possible to determine at this stage whether the letter/notice dated 02.05.2025 was issued in compliance of the terms agreed upon between the parties. The Court is then not inclined to stay the operation of the said letter/notice. Accordingly, this court is of the opinion that plaintiff has failed to establish prima facie case in his favour. In view of the above discussion, neither balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff nor can it be said that irreparable loss will be caused to the plaintiff if the present application is not allowed. Accordingly, the application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC filed by the Plaintiff is hereby dismissed. It is needless to mention that nothing stated herein above shall tantamount to the expression of opinion on the merits of the case. Be put for completion of pleadings, admission/denial of documents and framing of issues on 18.09.2025. (Mansi Malik) ACJ/ARC (North-West) Rohini Courts, Delhi/10.07.2025 Pg. No. 4 of 4 -- 4 of 4 --
