Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 23 Apr 2024 · CNR DLNW030008622024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS NO. 859/2024 SMT. CHANDANI KUMAR MEHTO & ORS. VS. SANJAY KUMAR MEHTO 23.04.2024 Fresh suit for permanent and mandatory injunction received by way of assignment. It be checked and registered. Present: Ms. Aarti Sharma, Ld. LAC for plaintiff with plaintiff. Arguments on maintainability heard. Put up for orders at 02.00 pm. At 02.00 pm Present: Ms. Aarti Sharma, Ld. LAC for plaintiff with plaintiff. 1. Vide this order I shall decide the maintainability of the present suit. 2. It is pertinent to note at the outset the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme court in Patil Automation Private Limited vs Rakheja Engineers Private Limited whereby it was observed that a Court has power to reject a plaint suo motu invoking its powers under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The Court has to hear the plaintiff before it invokes its power besides giving reasons under Order VII Rule 11. -- 1 of 5 -- 2.1 In the present case, Opportunity was given to plaintiff to advance arguments on the maintainability of the present suit and the arguments so made were heard. 3. Upon a perusal of the pleadings, It is observed that the reliefs sought by the plaintiff are of permanent and mandatory injunction. 3.1 It is pertinent to note Section 7 & 8 of the Family Court Act, 1984 which is being reproduced as hereunder:- “Section 7. Jurisdiction— (1) Subject to the other provisions of this Act, a Family Court shall— (a) have and exercise all the jurisdiction exercisable by any District Court or any subordinate Civil Court under any law for the time being in force in respect of suits and proceedings of the nature referred to in the explanation; and (b) be deemed, for the purposes of exercising such jurisdiction under such law, to be a District Court or, as the case may be, such subordinate Civil Court for the area to which the jurisdiction of the Family Court extends. Explanation: The suits and proceedings referred to in this sub- section are suits and proceedings of the following nature, namely— (a) a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage for a decree of nullity of marriage (declaring the marriage to be null and void or, as the case may be, annulling the marriage) or restitution of conjugal rights or judicial separation or dissolution of marriage; (b) a suit or proceeding for a declaration as to the validity of a marriage or as to the matrimonial status of any person; (c) a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties or of either of them; (d) a suit or proceeding for an order or injunction in circumstances arising out of a marital relationship; a suit or proceeding for a declaration as to the legitimacy of any person; (f) a suit or proceeding for maintenance; (g) a suit or proceeding in relation to the guardianship of the person or the custody of, or access to, any minor. (2) Subject to the other provisions of this Act, a Family Court shall also have and exercise: -- 2 of 5 -- (a) the jurisdiction exercisable by a Magistrate of the First Class under Chapter IX (relating to order for maintenance of wife, children and parents) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974); and (b) such other jurisdiction as may be conferred on it by any other enactment. Section 8. Exclusion of jurisdiction and pending proceedings.— Where a Family Court has been established for any area,— (a) no district court or any subordinate civil court referred to in sub- section (1) of Section 7 shall, in relation to such area, have or exercise any jurisdiction in respect of any suit or proceeding of the nature referred to in the Explanation to that sub-section; (b) no magistrate shall, in relation to such area, have or exercise any jurisdiction or powers under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974); (c) every suit or proceeding of the nature referred to in the Explanation to sub-section (1) of Section 7 and every proceeding under Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974),— (i) which is pending immediately before the establishment of such Family Court before any district court or subordinate court referred to in that sub- section or, as the case may be, before any magistrate under the said Code; and (ii) which would have been required to be instituted or taken before or by such Family Court if, before the date on which such suit or proceeding was instituted or taken, this Act had come into force and such Family Court had been established,shall stand transferred to such Family Court on the date on which it is established.” 3.2 It is also pertinent to note the judgment of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in Geeta Anand Vs. Tanya Arjun CS(OS) 601/2022 & I.A. Nos. 15957/2022 (O. 39 R. 1&2), 20302/2022. Relevant para are being reproduced as hereunder:- “34. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we unhesitatingly hold that the term 'marital relationship' has to be interpreted de hors the meaning and import of the term 'family'. The expression 'marital relationship' when bifurcated brings out that the word 'marital' has been defined as 'of or relating to marriage or relations between husband and wife' while 'marriage' has been defined as a 'formal union of a man and a woman, typically as recognised by law, by which they become husband and wife'. 35. A fortiori every suit or legal proceeding when brought before the Court must invariably explain the 'cause of action', which is the fundamental requirement of law in any given case, and it must invariably include the -- 3 of 5 -- narration of the 'circumstances' that arise out of marital relationship in order to confer jurisdiction upon the Family Court. There is no gainsaying that the expression 'cause of action' is not defined under any statute and the Supreme Court in the case of Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India held that it was to mean “every fact which would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed in order to support his right of judgment i.e., the essential facts that must be proven by a party to obtain a decree, which are material to the case”. 36. The interplay as between the expressions 'cause of action' and the term 'circumstances' in the context of the subject provision must be deciphered in the follow manner; firstly, the averments in the plaint must explain the 'cause of action' for instituting a suit or legal proceedings for injunction; and secondly that this 'cause of action' is one which falls within the jurisdiction of the Family Courts. The cause of action, in order to bring the case under the subject provision and so as to confer jurisdiction upon the Family Court must encapsulate a tangible averment that the dispute is one which has an intrinsic nexus with the martial relationship. The circumstances should be of such a nature that it is demonstrable that the dispute is closely emanating from and surrounded by such matters which are integral to the marital relationship. Mere existence of a marital relationship between the litigating parties howsoever tangential cannot be the basis or the foundation for the proceedings being brought before a Family Court. We hasten to add that if we allow the interpretation that has been placed to the subject provision in the case of AvneetKaur, it is likely to open a pandora's box, which would risk inclusion of all disputes as between the parents and their married children and even siblings within its ambit. 37. We are in agreement with the submission of learned Amicus that while the subject provision may encompass a range of 'circumstances', including those preceding, surrounding, influencing, and emanating from a marital relationship, the emphasis is on a direct connection between the 'cause of action' and the 'marital relationship'. He has rightly urged that prioritising the cause of action in determining the correct jurisdictional forum also ensures that family courts can maintain their specialized focus on matrimonial matters, avoiding a situation of becoming overburdened with cases unrelated to marital relationships, which could inter alia lead to overreach of jurisdiction and a potential straining of resources.” 4. In light of the abovesaid law and principles, in the facts & circumstances of the present case, it is observed that the present case is squarely covered under explanation (c) & explanation (d) of Section 7 (1) of the Family Court Act. Plaintiff no. 1 and defendant are husband and wife. Also, a perusal of the pleadings shows that there is a direct connection between the cause of action and the -- 4 of 5 -- matrimonial relationship between the parties. Accordingly, it is observed that the jurisdiction of this court is barred in the present matter by virtue of Section 8 of the Family Courts Act and the present suit is barred by law to be tried in this Court and thus the plaint is rejected u/o VII Rule 11(d) CPC. File be consigned to record room. Copy of the order be given dasti, as prayed for. (Shaina Goyal) Civil Judge-N/W District Rohini Courts-23.04.2024 -- 5 of 5 --
