Full Order Text
Order 7 · 31 Jul 2024 · CNR DLNW030008002024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. NEHA MITTAL, ASCJ-JSCC-GJ, NORTH-WEST : ROHINI COURTS, DELHI CS SCJ No.513/2024 SWATI ......Plaintiff Versus THE COMMISSIONER & ANR. .....Defendants ORDER 1. Vide this order, this Court shall dispose off, application filed by Plaintiff under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC seeking interim directions to permit the plaintiff to carry out its business from Teh Bazari site no.2954 measuring 6’x4’ situated at footpath, near Netaji Subhash Place, Opp. BTW, Near Bus Stand, Pitampura, Delhi, which is specifically shown in the site plan. 2. The brief facts of the case of plaintiff as stated in the plaint are that the plaintiff is the owner and in possession of the above said Teh Bazari site which was allotted by defendant no.1 in her name vide Allotment Letter No.3362/AC/NDMC/CLZ/ 2017 dated 01.03.2017 for which, the mutation fees of Rs.65,000/- was paid by the plaintiff vide Receipt no.81624 dated 08.03.2017. It is stated that the plaintiff has deposited the Teh Bazari fees regularly and the same is now paid upto 31.03.2024 and that further fees could not be paid due to unavailability of online services on account of unification process. It is further submitted that on 04.04.2024, the officials of defendant no.1 and 2 illegally took the kiosk of the plaintiff without any notice and have further failed to assign any reason for the same despite her CS SCJ No.513/2024 Swati Vs. The Commissioner & Anr. Page 1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- complaint dated 08.04.2024. Hence, the present suit has been filed. 3. Defendant no.1 has filed the written statement stating that during inspection on 01.04.2024, a locked structure of 6’x4’ was found erected at footpath near NSP, Pitampura, Delhi and the same was removed by the concerned officials of MCD. It is further stated that as no one was present at this locked structure, the fact of the allotment and genuineness of this Teh Bazari site could not be determined. It is further stated that no erection of such structure is allowed in 6’x4’ Teh Bazari and that no application for releasing of the structure has been received in their office. With these submissions, it is prayed that the suit of the plaintiff be dismissed. No separate reply to application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC has been filed on behalf of defendant no.1. However, status report was filed by defendant no.1 on 29.07.2024 stating that the plaintiff has encroached the site in question over the Government land and has violated the terms and conditions of the Teh Bazari site due to which, it was removed. 4. Arguments have already heard. Record perused. I have considered the submissions and gone through the record carefully. 5. In the present case, the relief sought by the plaintiff is in the nature of mandatory injunction. The Apex Court in judgment Dorab Cawasji Warden Vs. Coomi Sorab Warden & Ors. 1990 AIR 867 observed that the relief of interlocutory mandatory injunction is generally granted to preserve or restore the status-quo of the last non-contested status which preceded the pending controversy until the final hearing when full relief may CS SCJ No.513/2024 Swati Vs. The Commissioner & Anr. Page 2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- be granted or to compel the undoing of those acts that have been illegally done or the restoration of that which was wrongfully taken from the party complaining. The following paras from the said judgment would further amplify the legal position :- "15. In one of the earliest cases in Rasul Karim A Anr. v. Pirubhai AMrbhm, ILR 1914 38 Bom. 381, Beaman, J. was of the view that the court's in India have no power to issue a temporary injunction in a mandatory form but Shah, J. who constituted a Bench in that case did not agree with Beaman, J. in this view. However, in a later Division Bench judgment in Champsey Bhimji & Co. v. The Jamna Flour Mills Co. Ltd., two learned Judges of the Bombay High Court took a different view from Beaman, J. and this view is now the prevailing view in the Bombay High Court. In M. Kandaswami Chetty v. F. Subramania Chetty , a Division Bench of the Madras High Court held that court's in India have the power by virtue of Order 39 Rule 2 of the CPC to issue temporary injunction in a mandatory form and differed from Beaman's view accepting the view in Champsey Bhimji & Co. v. Jamna Flour Mills Co. (supra). In Israil v. Shamser Rahman, it was held that the High Court was competent to issue an interim injunction in a mandatory form. It was further held in this case that in granting an interim injunction what the Court had to determine was whether there was a fair and substantial question to be decided as to what the rights of the parties were and whether the nature and difficulty of the questions was such that it was proper that the injunction should be granted until the time for deciding them should arrive. It was further held that the Court should consider as to where the balance of convenience lie and whether it is desirable that the status quo should be maintained. While accepting that it is not possible to say that in no circumstances will the Courts in India have any jurisdiction to issue an ad interim injunction of a mandatory character, in Nandan Pictures Ltd. v. Art. Pictures Ltd. and Ors., AIR 1956 Cal 428, a Division Bench was of the view that if the mandatory injunction is granted at all on an interlocutory application it is granted only to restore the status quo and not granted to establish a new state of things differing from the state which existed at the date when the suit was instituted. 16. The relief of interlocutory mandatory injunctions CS SCJ No.513/2024 Swati Vs. The Commissioner & Anr. Page 3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- are thus granted generally to preserve or restore the status quo of the last non-contested status which preceded the pending controversy until the final hearing when full relief may be granted or to compel the undoing of those acts that have been illegally done or the restoration of that which was wrongfully taken from the party complaining. But since the granting of such an injunction to a party who fails or would fail to establish his right at the trial may cause great injustice or irreparable harm to the party against whom it was granted or alternatively not granting of it to a party who succeeds or would succeed may equally cause great injustice or irreparable harm, courts have evolved certain guidelines. Generally stated these guidelines are: (1) The plaintiff has a strong case for trail. That is, it shall be of a higher standard than a prima facie case that is normally required for a prohibitory injunction. (2) It is necessary to prevent irreparable or serious injury which normally cannot be compensated in terms of money. (3) The balance of convenience is in favour of the one seeking such relief. 17. Being essentially an equitable relief the grant or refusal of an interlocutory mandatory injunction shall ultimately rest in the sound judicial discretion of the Court to be exercised in the light of the facts and circumstances in each case. Though the above guidelines are neither exhaustive or complete or absolute rules, and there may be exceptional circumstances needing action, applying them as prerequisite for the grant or refusal of such injunctions would be a sound exercise of a judicial discretion." 6. It would be seen from the aforesaid observation of the Apex Court in the said case that the relief of interlocutory mandatory injunction is granted generally to preserve or restore the status quo of the last contested status. The expression 'generally' in the above observation gives a clear indication that the grant of interim mandatory injunction does not only confine to restore the status quo of the last contested status. The Apex CS SCJ No.513/2024 Swati Vs. The Commissioner & Anr. Page 4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- Court in the said judgment further observed that being essentially an equitable relief the grant or refusal of an interlocutory mandatory injunction shall ultimately rest on the sound judicial discretion of the Court to be exercised in the light of the facts and circumstances of each case. The Court also observed that there may exist exceptional circumstances for the grant or refusal of such injunction and it would ultimately depend on the facts of each case for the Court to exercise the equitable jurisdiction in favour of one party in preference to the other party. 7. In the present case, defendant does not dispute the fact that the Teh Bazari site in question has been allotted to the plaintiff. The counsel for defendant had produced the office file of Teh Bazari site in question during the course of arguments having the photographs of the Teh Bazari site to show that the same was found located on the road/Government land during inspection and not on the footpath where it is supposed to be and hence, it was removed. It is further stated that the plaintiff is entitled to get her kiosk released by paying the fixed composition fees and removal fees apart from the storage charges per day calculated on the basis of the weight of the structure. 8. Record shows that the submissions made on behalf of defendant are contrary to the submissions made in the written statement. In para 3 of the preliminary objections of the written statement, it is stated that during inspection, the structure was found erected at the footpath which is admittedly the appropriate place where the structure is supposed to be. It is also admitted on behalf of defendant that no written intimation / communication was made to the plaintiff regarding the reason for the removal of the kiosk despite having received her complaint vide diary CS SCJ No.513/2024 Swati Vs. The Commissioner & Anr. Page 5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- no.257 dated 08.04.2024. Separate statement of the Licensing Inspector, Keshav Puram Zone, MCD is on record to this effect. The above facts clearly show the contradiction in the stand of the defendant regarding the location of the Teh Bazari site during inspection. Hence, the plaintiff has been able to show prima- facie case in her favour. Further, in the opinion of the court, balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff as the refusal of the relief would amount to denial of livelihood to her whereas no inconvenience shall be caused to the defendant who is otherwise is ready to release the structure of the plaintiff subject to the payment of penalty charges. 9. The next question is whether the plaintiff is required to pay the penalty charges at this stage. Even if it is assumed, for the sake of arguments, that the kiosk of the plaintiff was located on the Government land, then also, the defendant has failed to show as to why the plaintiff should be held liable for paying the storage charges on per day basis when it is the defendant who failed to intimate her regarding the removal of the structure despite being approached by the plaintiff by way of the aforesaid complaint dated 08.04.2024 and subsequently, by way of filing of present suit. It is pertinent to mention that the present suit was filed on 15.04.2024 and appearance was entered on behalf of defendant no.1 on 01.05.2024. Despite this, it is only on 29.07.2024 that the defendant no.1 has been able to give a plausible explanation for the removal of the structure of the plaintiff. Thus, in the opinion of the court, the defendant no.1 shall release the structure of the plaintiff without insisting her for the payment of the penalty charges. However, as the plaintiff has admittedly paid the license fees upto 31.03.2024 only, the CS SCJ No.513/2024 Swati Vs. The Commissioner & Anr. Page 6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- structure be released to her only upon payment of further license fee as per law. 10. Accordingly, the application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC filed by the plaintiff is hereby allowed. It is needless to mention that nothing stated herein above shall tantamount to the expression of opinion on the merits of the case. (Announced in the open Court) (NEHA MITTAL) on 31st day of July, 2024 JSCC/ASCJ/GJ (NORTH-WEST) ROHINI COURTS/DELHI CS SCJ No.513/2024 Swati Vs. The Commissioner & Anr. Page 7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
