Full Order Text
Final Order 11 · 03 Aug 2026 · CNR DLNW030006842024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: CS SCJ/ 435/24 Page no. 1 of 5 THE COURT OF CIVIL JUDGE: NORTH WEST DISTRICT: ROHINI COURT: NEW DELHI Unique case ID No: 435/2024 CNR NO. DLNW030006842024 IN THE MATTER OF : Rajan @ Rajan Narayan S/o Ram Narayan r/o J-304, Anand Vas, Shakurpur, Safal Dairy, I Block Market New Delhi ……….Plaintiff Versus 1. Sam Hatchery Agro Private Limited Through its Directors/AR office at: Workshala, D-9, Vyapar Marg Block D, Sector 3, Noida, U.P 2. Priyanka Maseh Director/owner of Sam Hatchery Agro Private Limited r/o A-122, 1st Floor, Flat no.3, Nehru Nagar-2 Ghaziabad, U.P 201001 3. Arvind Pathak Director of Sam Hatchery Agro Private Limited R/o Flat no.01,02 Upper Ground Floor Plot no. 122, Radha Krishan Enclave, Inder Garhi Govindpuram, Ghaziabad, U.P 4. Samvil Maseh Signing authority/ AR of Sam Hatchery Agro Private Limited R/o A-122, 1st Floor, Flat no.3, Nehru Nagar-2 Ghaziabad, U.P 201001 ........... Defendant Date of filing : 30.03.2024 Date of Institution : 02.04.2026 Date of pronouncing judgment : 03.08.2026 Argued by: Mr. Sanjay Mandawat , Ld. Counsel for plaintiff Defendant is ex-parte -- 1 of 5 -- CS SCJ/ 435/24 Page no. 2 of 5 SUIT FOR RECOVERY OF MONEY 1. Present matter is instituted for recovery of money of Rs.2,16,000/- along with pendente-lite and future interest, costs and other charges from the defendant. The present suit has been instituted by the plaintiff. 2. In brief, it is the case of the plaintiff that the defendants approached the plaintiff for membership of poultry scheme for which they demanded a sum of Rs.1Lakh and assured to return 12% per month to the plaintiff. It is stated that such return was assured to be paid after 45 days and thereafter, on or before 15th day of every succeeding month till the party informs in writing about discontinuation of the scheme. It is stated that upon the said assurance, the plaintiff made a payment of Rs.1Lakh to the defendants and agreement dt. 26.03.2023 was executed between the parties whereby, it was agreed that the defendant shall make monthly payment of Rs.12000/- to the plaintiff for 18 months i.e. a total of Rs.2,16,000/-. It is stated that defendant failed to pay a single penny. Hence, a legal notice was served upon the defendant however, no payment is made. As such, the present suit has been filed seeking the relief of recovery of money of Rs.2,16,000/- along with pendente-lite and future interest @ 18% per annum against the defendant; and costs of the suit. 3. Summons of the suit were served upon the defendant however none appeared for the defendant. Hence, the right to file written statement of defendant was closed and the defendants were proceeded -- 2 of 5 -- CS SCJ/ 435/24 Page no. 3 of 5 ex-parte on 09.06.2025 by the Ld. Predecessor of this Court. 4. The plaintiff only examined one witness on his behalf i.e., himself. In his testimony, PW1 tendered his evidence by way of affidavit being Ex.PW1/A and he reiterated the contents of the plaint and also relied upon the following documents: 1) Copy of Board Resolution Ex.PW1/1. 2) Copy of PAN card Ex. PW1/2(OSR). 3) Bank Statement Ex. PW1/3. 4) Agreement Sam Hatchery Agro Pvt ltd Ex. PW1/4(Colly) 5) Copy of aadhar card of defendant Ex. PW1/5(OSR) 6) Copy of legal notice and postal receipts Ex. PW1/6 5. No Cross examination was done as the defendant had already been proceeded ex-parte by the Ld. Predecessor. PE was closed on 06.04.2026 and ex-parte final arguments were heard. 6. During the Ex-parte arguments, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff adverted to agreement which was signed on behalf of defendant no.1 containing the terms & conditions of the said scheme. He has also relied upon the legal notice sent to the defendant and has argued that the defendants have deliberately defaulted the said repayment with mala fide intention which is also visible from the fact that they did not appear before this Court to face the proceedings choosing not to defend the suit. 7. Ld. Counsel for plaintiff argued that the suit of the plaintiff should be decreed as the testimony of PW1 remains uncontroverted along with the corroborative evidence on the record. -- 3 of 5 -- CS SCJ/ 435/24 Page no. 4 of 5 8. Heard. Perused. Considered. 9. The plaintiff has sufficiently discharged the burden of proof placed upon him by virtue of Section 104 of Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (earlier Section 101 Indian Evidence Act, 1872). The PW1 has testified in the affidavit of evidence that the defendants had obtained money from the plaintiff on the pretext of returning 12% i.e. Rs.12000/- per month for 18 months however, the same has not been done. It is also stated that the defendants failed to adhere with the terms and conditions of scheme agreement. The oral testimony is supported by corroborative documentary evidence. PW1 has also duly proved the acknowledgment of its liability on part of the defendants, by relying upon Ex. PW 1/1 to Ex PW1/6. 10. The testimony of PW1 has remained uncontroverted. Reference can be placed upon the Judgement of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in M/s. Eco Lab I.MC.N vs. Eco Labs Ltd., 2011(185) DLT 664, wherein it was held that if the defendants have failed to cross- examine the plaintiff, the evidence of plaintiff is to be presumed to be correct. In view of the fact that the testimony of PW1 has remained unrebutted, his testimony on oath is accepted as correct. There is no reason to disbelieve the same. 11. Further, the defendant has not replied to the legal notice being exhibited as Ex. PW1/5. PW1 deposed that the legal notice was duly served upon the defendant. The contents of the legal notice can be deemed to be admitted by the defendant. Reliance in this regard can be placed upon judgement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India titled Abdul Gaffar v DDA, 2001 RLR 249. 12. In any case, since the defendant has not appeared despite -- 4 of 5 -- CS SCJ/ 435/24 Page no. 5 of 5 service and also chose not to file WS, it can be safely presumed that he has no defence to offer. The suit of the plaintiff is well within the limitation. 13. However, the agreement was executed by plaintiff with defendant no.1 i.e. Sam Hatchery Agro Pvt Ltd which is a company and a separate legal entity. There is no averment regarding any personal liability of defendant no.2, 3 & 4 and they have been sued in the capacity of Director/Authorized Signatory of defendant no.1. hence, no liability is made out against defendant no. 2, 3 & 4. 14. The present suit is therefore decreed in favour of the plaintiff entity and against the defendant no.1. The Defendant no.1 is liable to pay Rs. 2,16,000/- to the plaintiff with the interest @ 12 % p.a. from the date of filing of the suit till the date of actual realization of the decretal amount. 15. Costs of the suit are also awarded in favour of the plaintiff. 16. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 17. File be consigned to Record Room after compliance with due formalities. ANNOUNCED IN THE OPEN COURT ON 03.08.2026 IT IS CERTIFIED THAT JUDGMENT RUNS INTO FIVE PAGES. (VAIBHAV KUMAR) CIVIL JUDGE-(NORTH-WEST)/ ROHINI COURTS/NEW DELHI -- 5 of 5 --
