Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 12

CNR DLNW03000319202428 Mar 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 12 · 28 Mar 2026 · CNR DLNW030003192024

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SHRI MAYANK MITTAL
SCJ-CUM-RC, NORTH -WEST DISTRICT,
ROHINI COURTS, DELHI
Suit No. 232/2024
CNR No. DLNW03-000319-2024
In the matter of :
STATE BANK OF INDIA
constituted under State Bank of India Act,1955,
Having its corporate centre office at:
State Bank Bhawan, Madam Cama Road,
Mumbai-440024
One of its Local Head Office at :
11, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-01
Having one of its Branch at:
Kanjhawala, Delhi and RACPC at
A-5, Pearl Best Height-I, Netaji Subhash Palace,
New Delhi
......Plaintiff
Versus
1. Sh. Kamal
S/o Sh. Ram Chander
R/o H.No. 190, Village Mubarakpur Dabas,
North-West, Delhi-110081
2. Smt. Birmati
W/o Sh. Ram Chander
R/o H.No. 190, Village Mubarakpur Dabas,
North-West, Delhi-110081
....Defendants
Date of institution : 12.02.2024
Reserved for Judgment : 27.03.2026
Date of decision : 28.03.2026
SUIT FOR RECOVERY
JUDGMENT (EX-PARTE)
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 1 of 8
-- 1 of 8 --
1. This is a suit for recovery of Rs.1,37,789/- (Rupees One
Lakh Thirty Seven Thousand Seven Hundred and Eighty Nine
Only) along with pendentelite and future interest @ 10.40% per
annum from the date of filing of present suit till realization along
with cost of the suit.
2. The brief facts of the case of the plaintiff as averred in the
plaint are that the plaintiff is a corporate bank constituted under
State Bank of India Act, 1955. Sh. Virender Kumar Handa, AR of
plaintiff bank is posted as Manager in State Bank of India
RACPC situated at A-5, Pearl Best Height-I, Netaji Subhash
Place, New Delhi of the plaintiff bank. It is stated that on re-
organization of set up of the State Bank of India, RACPC has
been introduced/established by the Plaintiff Bank to deal
exclusively with the non performing assets accounts of branches
of State Bank of India situated within Delhi/New Delhi for
restructuring of the borrower and recovery of the amounts due
against the said borrowers etc., hence, the NPA Accounts of the
Branches throughout Delhi including Kanjhawala, Delhi branch
have been migrated to RACPC at A-5, Pearl Best Height-I, Netaji
Subhash Place, New Delhi for the convenience of operation &
execution which for practical purposes has become the plaintiff
bank including the account in present suit. Hence, RACPC at A-
5, Pearl Best Height-1, Netaji Subhash Place, New Delhi in place
of Kanjhawala, Delhi Branch, is filing the present suit, however,
the Plaintiff remains the State Bank of India only.
2.1. It is stated that the defendant no.1 being a student and
defendant no.2 as mother/co-borrower/guardian/guarantor of
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 2 of 8
-- 2 of 8 --
defendant no.1, had approached and requested to the plaintiff
bank at its Kanjhawala, Delhi branch for grant of financial
assistance by way of education loan for higher studies of
defendant no.1 for completion of four years course of B-Tech
(IT) from Guru Teg Bahadur Institute of Technology, New Delhi
under State Bank's education loan scheme. After considering
their proposal and economic viability, the plaintiff bank had
processed and sanctioned to the defendants named above
education loan amount to the tune of Rs.1,72,000/- on
12.02.2018 which the defendant no.1 and 2 have duly availed of
as co-borrowers. It is stated that in consideration of above loan
facility granted by the plaintiff, the defendants had executed
various loan documents voluntarily and cautiously for repayment
in favour of the plaintiff bank. It is further stated that the
defendants had agreed to pay interest on the outstanding loan
amount @ 9.95% p.a. with monthly rest subject to rise and fall
time to time as per banking guidelines. Defendants had also
undertaken to repay the loan outstanding amount in 60 EMI of
Rs.3,651/- each with interest in terms of agreement containing
schedule therein till entire loan outstanding is liquidated.
2.2. It is averred that the loan amount is repayable after
completion of course period plus one year moratorium or six
months after getting job whichever is earlier. It is submitted that
during course period defendant no.2/guardian shall continue to
pay/deposit interest as per agreement. It is further submitted that
repayment by EMI would start after completion of course period
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 3 of 8
-- 3 of 8 --
(2016 to 2019) plus one year moratorium period i.e. year 2020 or
six months after getting job.
2.3. It is stated that education loan account no.37536800471
was opened with the plaintiff bank in the name of defendants at
Kanjhawala, Delhi branch of plaintiff bank who had made
transactions in the said account. It is submitted that the
defendants have failed to pay/deposit monthly loan installments
in terms of loan agreement despite repeated demands, notices and
personal visits of field staff of the plaintiff bank, hence, the loan
account of the defendants has been classified as nonperforming
asset on 15.10.2023, therefore, the defendants are liable to pay
jointly and severally the suit amount with cost, interest and
expenses. It is averred that on persistent defaults committed by
defendants the loan was recalled by the plaintiff bank interalia by
serving legal notice on dated 30.11.2023 upon defendants sent
under Regd. A.D. cover but despite due and proper service the
defendants failed to comply with the same. It is further averred
that after giving credits for all the sums of money and paid by the
defendants including part payment if any, in his education loan
account, a sum of Rs.1,37,789/- is recoverable from the
defendants jointly and severally as on date of filing the suit.
Hence, the present suit.
3. Defendants were served with the summons of the suit on
14.12.2024. Defendants appeared but failed to file WS within
time stipulated by law, therefore, were proceeded ex-parte vide
order dated 20.09.2025 and the plaintiff was directed to bring ex-
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 4 of 8
-- 4 of 8 --
parte evidence.
4. Sh. Virender Kumar Handa, AR of the plaintiff bank
examined as PW1 who in his evidence by way of affidavit
Ex.PW1/A has reiterated and reaffirmed the averments made in
the plaint. He has relied upon the following documents :
1. True copy of gazette notification of SBI is Ex.PW1/1;
2. Photocopy of e-KYC certificate of defendant no.1 is Mark A;
3. Copy of PAN Card of defendant no.1 is Mark B;
4. Copy of Aadhar Card of defendant no.1 is Mark C;
5. Copy of college ID of defendant no.1 is Mark D;
6. Copy of e-KYC certificate of defendant no.2 is Mark E;
7. Copy of Aadhar Card of defendant no.2 is Mark F;
8. Copy of PAN Card of defendant no.2 is Mark G;
9. Certificate issued by Guru Teg Bahadur Institute of
Technology is Ex.PW1/2;
10. SBI Education Loan Application Form is Ex.PW1/3;
11. Arrangement letter dated 12.02.2018 is Ex.PW1/4;
12. Agreement for term loan under education loan scheme dated
12.02.2018 is Ex.PW1/5;
13. Annexure-1 (undertaking) dated 12.02.2018 is Ex.PW1/6;
14. Standing Instructions dated 12.02.2018 is Ex. PW1/7;
15. Office copy of legal notice is Ex.PW1/8;
16. Postal receipts are Ex.PW1/9 (colly);
17. Statement of account is Ex.PW1/10 (colly);
18. Certificate of accrued interest is Ex.PW1/11;
19. Certificate under Section 65B of Indian Evidence Act is
Ex.PW1/12.
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 5 of 8
-- 5 of 8 --
5. I have heard the plaintiff and perused the material available
on record carefully.
6. Before giving findings on the evidence led by plaintiff and
submissions advanced on behalf of plaintiff, it is important to
note that in the present case, the defendants appeared but failed
to file WS within stipulated time by law and were proceeded ex-
parte vide order dated 20.09.2025. It is further noted that the
Court is mindful of the fact that in cases where the defendants are
ex-parte, the Court needs to be extra cautious, as it would not
have the advantage of defence and before passing the judgment,
the pleadings and evidence of the plaintiff should be weighed
carefully before arriving at the finding as to whether the plaintiff
has made out a case for a decree. The onus to prove the
averments of the plaintiff rests entirely upon the plaintiff who has
to discharge the burden of proof to establish its case, as per law.
In civil litigation, it is sufficient for the plaintiff to prove its case
by preponderance of probabilities. In Adiveppa V. Bhimappa
(2017) 9 SCC 586, Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has
observed that:
“It is a settled principle of law that the initial burden is
always on the plaintiff to prove his case by proper pleadings
and adequate evidence (oral and documentary) in support
thereof.”
Thus, the burden to prove the case as per law entirely is
upon the plaintiff, by way of documentary and oral evidence.
7. PW-1 has proved on oath the allegations against the
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 6 of 8
-- 6 of 8 --
defendant and the evidence produced by the plaintiff goes on
unchallenged and un-rebutted. True copy of gazette notification
of SBI is Ex.PW1/1; Photocopy of e-KYC certificate of
defendant no.1 is Mark A; Copy of PAN Card of defendant no.1
is Mark B; Copy of Aadhar Card of defendant no.1 is Mark C;
Copy of college ID of defendant no.1 is Mark D; Copy of e-
KYC certificate of defendant no.2 is Mark E; Copy of Aadhar
Card of defendant no.2 is Mark F; Copy of PAN Card of
defendant no.2 is Mark G; Certificate issued by Guru Teg
Bahadur Institute of Technology is Ex.PW1/2; SBI Education
Loan Application Form is Ex.PW1/3; Arrangement letter dated
12.02.2018 is Ex.PW1/4; Agreement for term loan under
education loan scheme dated 12.02.2018 is Ex.PW1/5;
Annexure-1 (undertaking) dated 12.02.2018 is Ex.PW1/6;
Standing Instructions dated 12.02.2018 is Ex. PW1/7; Office
copy of legal notice is Ex.PW1/8; Postal receipts are Ex.PW1/9
(colly); Statement of account is Ex.PW1/10 (colly); Certificate
of accrued interest is Ex.PW1/11; Certificate under Section 65B
of Indian Evidence Act is Ex.PW1/12.
8. The present suit is filed within the prescribed period of
limitation as per provisions of Limitation Act and the present suit
has been instituted on 12.02.2024, hence the present suit is
within limitation. As defendants have not filed WS within time
stipulated by law and accordingly were proceeded ex-parte, the
averments made in the plaint and the testimony of the plaintiff
during PE remained unrebutted. There is no reason to disbelief
the unrebutted testimony of PW1 and the documents relied upon
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 7 of 8
-- 7 of 8 --
him. These documents coupled with testimony of the plaintiff
prove the case of the plaintiff.
Relief
9. In view of the reasons given above and uncontroverted
evidence brought on record, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed
and followings reliefs are granted in his favour and against the
defendants:-
i. Decree for a sum of Rs.1,37,789/- (Rupees One Lakh
Thirty Seven Thousand Seven Hundred and Eighty Nine Only).
ii. Seeing the prevalent market conditions, pendente lite and
future interest at the rate of Rs.9% per annum is also awarded in
favour of the plaintiff from the date of filing of present suit till
the realization of the amount.
iii. Cost of the suit.
10. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to
Record Room after due compliance.
Announced in the Open Court
on 28.03.2026
(Mayank Mittal)
Senior Civil Judge-cum-Rent Controller,
North West District : Rohini Courts : Delhi
CS SCJ No. 232/2024 State Bank of India v. Kamal 8 of 8
-- 8 of 8 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.