Full Order Text
Interim Order 10 · 21 Aug 2023 · CNR DLNW030000072023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: CS SCJ No. 25/23 SHEELA DEVI Vs. MANOJ KUMAR JAIN 21.08.2023 Present : Sh. K. Murli Kumar Reddy, Ld. Counsels for plaintiff. Ms. Honey Garg, Ld. Proxy counsel for defendant no. 3/MCD. 1. Vide this order I shall decide following applications moved by the plaintiff: a) Application under section 80(2) read with section 151 of CPC and under section 478(3) of Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred as DMC Act). b) Application under Order 2 Rule 2 & 3 read with section 151 of CPC seeking leave to file fresh suit for recovery of damages at a later stage against the defendants. c) Application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 of CPC read with section 151 of CPC for restraining the defendant no. 1 from raising construction at the suit property till the pendency of the suit. 2. Before adverting to the applications, the court deems it fit to discuss relevant facts of the present case. The plaintiff has filed a suit permanent and mandatory injunction concerning suit property i.e. bearing House No. A-157, Ashok Vihar, Phase-I, Delhi as well as for declaration of sanction plan of the suit property as null and void. 3. It is averred that the plaintiff is the sole and absolute owner -- 1 of 12 -- -: 2 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 of the property bearing House No. A-158, Ashok Vihar, Phase-I, Delhi which consists of four floors and plaintiff has been residing there since long. On 04.09.2022, the defendant no. 1 and 2 started construction in the suit property which is adjacent to the residence of the plaintiff. The defendant no. 1 and 2 started excavation work with heavy machines and other digging equipment like JCB and trenchers etc. The digging work was done towards the side of the plaintiff’s property without taking adequate safety measures and also to the extent of 10 feet deep, 45 feet long and 8 feet wide. The plaintiff and her family members were out of town when the digging work started and when the plaintiff returned, she found that significant damage has been done to her property including tilting towards the suit property. To stabilize the affected area, iron pillars were erected between the plaintiff's property and the construction site. The situation led to severe deterioration, with cracks of over 3 to 4 inches appearing in the walls, grounds, and pillars of the plaintiff's property. As a result of these structural issues, the plaintiff and her family were forced to relocate to a rented residence. 4. Upon reporting the matter to the concerned authority i.e. defendant no. 3/MCD, an inspection was conducted. Despite initial intervention, the construction work was later allowed to resume, leading to further damage. -- 2 of 12 -- -: 3 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 5. The plaintiff availed the service of Surrender Dutt, Structural Engineer who visited the plaintiff’s property on 19.11.2022 for inspection and confirmed the unsound condition of the plaintiff's property due to extensive excavation work. The defendant no. 1 and 2 are still doing the construction at the suit property which is causing more damage to the whole building of the plaintiff. It is also averred that the defendant no. 1 and 2 obtained sanction plan of the suit property through fraudulent means and collusion. 6. In this background, the plaintiff has filed the present suit and above stated applications. 7. The defendants were summoned and they filed written statement along with reply to the applications. Status report was also called from the defendant no. 3/MCD with respect to alleged unauthorized construction. 8. I have given due consideration to the submissions made by the Ld. Counsels of the parties and perused the record. I. Application under section 80(2) read with section 151 of CPC and under section 478(3) of DMC Act. 9. By virtue of the above-mentioned application, the plaintiff seeks exemption from the requirement to serve a statutory notice -- 3 of 12 -- -: 4 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 to defendant no. 3, i.e., the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD). The plaintiff argues that due to the precarious condition of her property, which is on the brink of collapse, there is an urgent need for relief. Therefore, she requests the court to exempt her from serving the mandatory notices under Section 478 of the DMC Act and Section 80 of the CPC. 10. In response to this application, defendants 1 and 2 have filed a reply stating that the plaintiff has taken contradictory stand in her plaint. On one hand, she claims that the building has already suffered damage, while on the other hand, she seeks an injunction to halt the construction of the suit property to protect her own. The defendants also point out that the cause of action allegedly arose on September 4, 2022, whereas the plaintiff filed the present suit on January 4, 2023. They argue that despite having sufficient time, the plaintiff did not adhere to the notice requirements mandated by Section 80 of the CPC and Section 478(3) of the DMC Act. As a result, they contend that the suit is not maintainable. 11. Section 478 of the DMC Act stipulates that no suit can be filed against the Municipal Corporation or Municipal Authorities until at least two months have passed after serving a written notice. Sub-section 3 of this section states that this requirement does not apply to suits seeking only an injunction, where the -- 4 of 12 -- -: 5 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 purpose of the injunction would be defeated by giving notice or postponing the institution of the suit. 12. In the present case, the plaintiff has sought injunction as well as declaration. As far as prayer for declaration of sanction plan as null and void is concerned, the same cannot be granted by this court as it falls within the scope of section 347B(1)(f)1 and 347E (1)2 of DMC Act and thus, appropriate remedy lies with the Ld. Appellate Tribunal MCD. However, regarding the relief of injunction, sub-section 3 of Section 478 serves as an exception to sub-section 1 of the said section, and the plaintiff's case falls squarely under sub-section 3, warranting an exemption from the need to issue a statutory notice to defendant no. 3 prior to filing the suit. Thus, plaintiff is exempted from service of notice as mandated under the above said section. 13. However, even if it is assumed for sake of arguments that the suit for the declaration of the sanction plan is maintainable before this court and the present suit is not solely for an injunction (for the applicability of Section 478(3) of the DMC 1 347B. Appeals against certain orders or notices issued under the Act(1) Any person aggrieved by any of the following orders made or notices issued under this Act, may prefer an appeal against such order or notice to the Appellate Tribunal, namely :— (f) an order sanctioning or refusing to sanction the erection of any building or the execution of any work under section 336; 2. 347E. Bar of jurisdiction of courts(1) After the commencement of section 7 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation (Amendment) Act, 1984, no court shall entertain any suit, application or other proceedings in respect of any order or notice appealable under section 343 or section 347B and no such order or notice shall be called in question otherwise than by preferring an appeal under those sections. -- 5 of 12 -- -: 6 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 Act), nonetheless, the record contains material which prima facie shows compliance of section 478(1) of the said Act. The plaintiff had lodged a complaint with the MCD, which led to the issuance of a notice to defendant no. 1 and 2 on October 11, 2022, thereby instructing them to stop construction. Thus, prima facie, it appears that defendant no. 3 was aware of the grievances of the plaintiff and nature of relief sought. 14. In light of the circumstances and my foregoing discussion, the application is disposed of by the court. II. Application under Order 2 Rule 2 & 3 read with section 151 of CPC. 15. By virtue of the said application, the plaintiff is seeking leave to file fresh suit for recovery of damages against the defendants at a later stage. It is averred that the plaintiff has got assessed the cost of damage which has been caused to her property due to illegal construction done by defendant no. 1 and 2, however, she has yet to finally determine the extent to which defendant no. 3/MCD and defendant no. 4/Architect are liable for the losses suffered by the plaintiff’s property. As a result, the plaintiff is not claiming damages from the defendants in the present suit and seeks the court's permission to bring a subsequent suit exclusively for the damages she suffered. -- 6 of 12 -- -: 7 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 16. Defendant no. 1 and 2, in response to this application, contend that there is no provision in the CPC to allow such an application. They drew attention to paragraph 6 of the plaint, where the plaintiff herself acknowledges that she has assessed the damage/estimate cost for compensation due to the construction carried out by the defendant no. 1 and 2. They argued that despite this, the plaintiff is deliberately relinquishing her claim and simultaneously seeking permission to initiate a new suit for damages. The defendants asserts that the plaintiff has deliberately abstained from claiming damages, a consequential relief, to avoid paying appropriate court fees. It is thus argued that she should not be entitled to seek the court's permission in this regard. 17. The provision of Order 2 Rule 2 of CPC indicates that if the plaintiff is entitled to several relief(s) against the defendants, in support of the same cause of action, he cannot split up the claim, so as to omit one part of the claim and sue the other. This rule is based on the cardinal principle that the defendant should not be vexed twice in the same case. Moreover, it aims to achieve finality in disputes and to prevent further litigation. 18. Further, Order 2 Rule 2(3) of the CPC outlines an exception to this general principle. It grants courts the discretionary power to permit the splitting of claims in certain circumstances. However, this discretion is to be exercised -- 7 of 12 -- -: 8 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 cautiously and with circumspection. 19. Upon careful consideration, it is evident that the present application lacks merit. The plaintiff herself acknowledges in the application as well in the plaint and supporting document that she has evaluated the damage/estimate cost of compensation through an expert. Despite being aware of the extent of the damages, she has deliberately chosen not to claim these damages in the present suit. The plaintiff has filed the inspection report of Structural Engineer along with the letter which shows that Structural Engineer has also provided estimate cost of compensation. Notably, she has not filed this report along with the present suit, and no cogent reason has been provided for this omission. 20. Furthermore, as per the plaint, the cause of action for the present case originated in September 2022, and the inspection report was filed in November 2022. The present case was filed on January 4, 2023. It is striking that no plausible explanation has been offered by the plaintiff as to why the final assessment of damages has not been conducted prior to the initiation of the suit or even subsequently. 21. Considering the same, the Court finds merit in the argument raised by the Ld. Counsel for defendants. The plaintiff's deliberate omission in claiming damages, despite having the necessary evidence and assessment, suggests a strategic attempt -- 8 of 12 -- -: 9 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 to evade payment of court fees that is associated with the relief of damages. The plaintiff's conduct is inconsistent with the principles of transparent and equitable litigation, and her actions reflect an attempt to manipulate the legal process to her advantage. This application is thus bereft of merit and is dismissed accordingly. III. Application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 of CPC read with section 151 of CPC. 22. The said application has been filed for restraining the defendant no. 1 and 2 from raising construction at the suit property till the pendency of the suit. In the application, it is averred that the plaintiff has a prima facie case in her favour and balance of convenience also lies in her favour. Further, if the interim relief is not granted, the plaintiff will suffer irreparable loss and injury. 23. Reply to the said application was filed by defendant no. 1 and 2 stating that they are the owners of the suit property and they are carrying out the construction in accordance with the authorized sanction plan and have received prior approvals from the MCD. The defendants drew attention to an apparent contradiction in the plaintiff's stance. While the plaintiff alleges that the sanction plan was obtained through misrepresentation, her plaint conspicuously lacks any explicit mention of the nature -- 9 of 12 -- -: 10 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 of the misrepresentation or forgery committed by the defendant no. 1 and 2. The defendants also highlight that the plaintiff has not identified the alleged defects in the sanctioned plan or what should constitute the correct sanctioned plan. 24. Further, the plaintiff has herself placed on record the order dated 23.11.2022 of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi which shows that the MCD inspected the suit property and found that the alleged construction was carried out in accordance with the sanction plan. Additionally, the defendants argue that the plaintiff has consistently claimed that her property sustained damage due to excavation work. However, at present, the defendant no. 1 and 2 have already completed construction up to the ground, first, and second floor without any further complaints of loss or damage. It is, therefore, prayed that the present application be dismissed as it has become infructuous. 25. In the WS filed by defendant no. 3/MCD, it is stated that sanction building plan in respect of suit property was granted u/s 336 of DMC Act vide ID No. 10104657 dated 01.07.2022. It is stated that as on date the property consists of stilt floor, ground floor, first floor, second floor and third floor and there is no non- compoundable deviation in the suit property. 26. The grant of an interlocutory injunction during the pendency of legal proceedings is a matter requiring the exercise -- 10 of 12 -- -: 11 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 of discretion of the court. While exercising the discretion the court applies the following tests: 1. Whether the plaintiff has a prima facie case; 2. Whether the balance of convenience is in favour of the plaintiff; and 3. Whether the plaintiff would suffer an irreparable injury if his prayer for interlocutory injunction is disallowed. 27. The object of the interlocutory injunction is to protect the plaintiff against injury by violation of his right for which he could not be adequately compensated in damages recoverable in the action. Satisfaction that there is a prima facie case by itself is not sufficient to grant injunction. The Court further has to satisfy that non-interference by the Court would result in irreparable injury to the party seeking relief and that there is no other remedy available to the party except one to grant injunction and he needs protection from the consequences. Irreparable injury, however, does not mean that there must be no physical possibility of repairing the injury, but means only that the injury must be a material one, namely one that cannot be adequately compensated by way of damages. 28. In the present case, it is worth noting that by the time the plaintiff initiated the proceedings before this court, alleged damage had already been inflicted due to excavation work -- 11 of 12 -- -: 12 :- CS SCJ No. 25/23 conducted by the defendant no. 1 and 2. The pleadings as well as photographs filed alongwith the report are primarily centered around the initial damage. However, it is pertinent to mention that subsequent to the excavation work, defendant no. 1 and 2 have proceeded with construction activities. Notably, there is nothing on record indicating that the ongoing construction or any subsequent construction has intensified or exacerbated the initially claimed damage. In addition, the plaintiff's contention regarding misrepresentation in obtaining the sanction plan is not substantiated, as her own plaint fails to provide the necessary details in this regard. 29. In such circumstances, it becomes evident that the fundamental principle underlying an interlocutory injunction, which is to prevent immediate and irreparable loss, does not seem to be applicable in the present case. The application is also dismissed. 30. Put up for arguments on the application under order 7 Rule 11 of CPC on 11.12.2023. (Priyanka Rajpoot) JSCC/ASCJ/GJ (North-West) Rohini Courts, Delhi/21.08.2023 -- 12 of 12 --
