Full Order Text
Order 2 · 14 Sept 2023 · CNR DLNW020309122023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CC No. 15833/23 PS : Kanjhawala Prabhu Ram Vs. Shri Bhagwan 14.09.2023 Fresh case received by way of assignment. It be checked and registered. Present: Sh. Ashish Dabas, Ld. Counsel for complainant. Heard on the application u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C. I have perused the file. SHO, PS- Kanjhwala is directed to file an action taken report stating the following:- 1. Whether any complaint has been made/received by the complainant in the police station. 2. If yes, whether any action has been taken on the complaint. 3. Whether as a result of investigation/inquiry, any cognizable offence has been made out against the accused person and whether any action has been taken by the police. 4. If yes, whether any FIR has been registered & status of investigation. 5. If no cognizable offence has been made out, whether the complainant has been informed accordingly. Copy of the complainant alongwith the annexures be supplied to the concerned Naib Court for compliance. ATR be called from the SHO concerned returnable for 06.10.2023. At this stage, an application u/s 91 Cr.PC has also been filed for preservation of CCTV footage of incident dated 02/03.09.2023 on behalf of the complainant. Ld. Counsel for complainant has submitted that the incident in question took place at 22/Rasoolpur, North West Delhi and the footage of the CCTV cameras installed in the vicinity be preserved for purposes of evidence. He has also submitted a site plan and site view of the CCTV Camera installed at the spot. He has further submitted that non preservation/deletion of the same may -- 1 of 2 -- seriously prejudice his case. Heard. In Special Police Establishment vs Umesh Tiwari and Anr., M.CR.C No.60404/21 decided on 21.01.2022, the Hon’ble Division Bench of M.P. High Court, has noted down “The court can invoke section 91 either suo moto or on behest of some stake holder in the process of investigation, enquiry, trial and other proceedings. The cause for invoking section 91 can arise from any source, be it victim, accused (except during pendency of investigation) and police. Denying any of the stake holder, the right to invoke section 91 may defeat the ultimate objective behind section 91 which is to ensure discovery of truth, rendering of justice and preventing failure of justice. However, any such invocation by any stake holder at any point of time would be subject to satisfaction of necessity and desirability of that document to the process of investigation, enquiry, trial or other proceedings”. In view of the above discussion, what comes out loud and clear is that the preservation of CCTV footage appears to be necessary and desirable as non preservation of the same may prejudice the case of the complainant as an essential piece of evidence may be lost. Hence, concerned SHO is directed to preserve the CCTV footage of the cameras installed at the spot before its deletion and file the compliance report along with status report on the date already fixed i.e., 06.10.2023. (AYUSH SHARMA) MM-02, NORTH WEST DISTRICT ROHINI COURTS DELHI/14.09.2023 -- 2 of 2 --
