Full Order Text
Interim Order 3 · 13 Aug 2025 · CNR DLNW020289252024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Dated: 13.08.2025 57 57 58 58 Ct. Cases 13185/2024 Ct. Cases 13185/2024 Ct. Cases / 13186/2024 Ct. Cases / 13186/2024 Renu Vs. Shalini Renu Vs. Shalini GEETA Vs. SHALINI / GEETA Vs. SHALINI / PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) 59 59 60 60 Ct. Cases / 13187/2024 Ct. Cases / 13187/2024 Ct. Cases / 13188/2024 Ct. Cases / 13188/2024 PREETI Vs. SHALINI PREETI Vs. SHALINI POOJA Vs. SHALINI POOJA Vs. SHALINI PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) 61 61 62 62 Ct. Cases / 13189/2024 Ct. Cases / 13189/2024 Ct. Cases / 13190/2024 Ct. Cases / 13190/2024 Shweta Vs. Shalini Shweta Vs. Shalini Priyanka Vs. Shalini Priyanka Vs. Shalini PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) 63 63 64 64 Ct. Cases / 13191/2024 Ct. Cases / 13191/2024 Ct. Cases / 13192/2024 Ct. Cases / 13192/2024 Rekha Vs. Shalini Rekha Vs. Shalini DEEPALI Vs. SHALINI DEEPALI Vs. SHALINI PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) 65 65 Ct. Cases / 13193/2024 Ct. Cases / 13193/2024 REKHA RANI Vs. SHALINI REKHA RANI Vs. SHALINI PS PS (Sultan Puri) (Sultan Puri) 13.08.2025 Present: Present: Complainant with Ld. Counsel Ms. Shivani Complainant with Ld. Counsel Ms. Shivani Aggarwal. Aggarwal. COMMON ORDER ON APPLICATIONS UNDER SECTION 175 (3) BNSS 1. Vide this common order, I shall dispose of applications filed under Section 175 (3) BNSS in the aforementioned matters. A common order is passed in all the matters as the main proposed accused is common in all the matters and Page No. 1 of 4 -- 1 of 4 -- Dated: 13.08.2025 the allegations of the complainants are also common. 2. In the aforesaid matters, the respective complainants have submitted that the proposed accused Shalini was residing in the same area as the complainants. It is further averred that the complainants were approached by the proposed accused and were offered lucrative job opportunities. Initially, the complainants were offered small jobs and once the faith of the complainants was gained by the proposed accused, the proposed accused persuaded the complainants to take a group loan from different banks, assuring that the loan shall be re-paid by the proposed accused and the amount shall be utilized for expanding, the business in which the complainants were working. Later, the proposed accused obtained such loans from different financial institutions in the name of the complainants but did not repay the same and also left her address after handing over the possession to some other person. Moreover, the complainants have also alleged that the staff of the concerned financial institution was also involved with the proposed accused in cheating the complainants. It is therefore prayed that directions for registration of FIR be given to the concerned SHO. 3. ATR was received in the matter under the signatures of HC Pardeep Kumar stating that no FIR in the matter has been registered so far in the matter and that the matter is of a civil nature related to financial transaction. It is further submitted in the ATR that the loan was obtained with the prior knowledge of the respective complainants. Page No. 2 of 4 -- 2 of 4 -- Dated: 13.08.2025 4. Arguments have been heard earlier. It was argued on behalf of the complainant that the FIR be lodged against the accused person under the appropriate sections of law. 5. Record has been perused. The arguments advanced are considered. 6. In the case of Subhkaran Luharuka and Another Vs. State (2010), Hon’ble High Court of Delhi laid down the guidelines for giving directions to police to register case wherein it was held that it is not necessary that in every case, where a complaint has been filed U/s. 200 CrPC, the magistrate should direct police to investigate the crime, merely because an application has also been filed U/s. 156(3) CrPC. Court has to form an opinion as to whether police investigation in collection of evidence is necessary or not. It is to be considered as to whether evidence is in the possession of complainant or can be produced by the witnesses on being summoned by the court, at the instance of complainant. Further, before passing any other on an application U/s. 156 (3) CrPC, magistrate must call for status report from the police and then form an opinion as to whether complaint discloses commission of cognizable offence or not. He should then satisfy himself about the need of investigation by the police. In addition thereto, he should also satisfy himself with regard to necessity to direct police to investigate the matter for collection of evidence, which is neither in the possession of complainant nor can be produced by the witnesses on being summoned by the court at the instance of Page No. 3 of 4 -- 3 of 4 -- Dated: 13.08.2025 complainant and the matter is such which calls for investigation by a State agency. 7. Now in the instant case the point of consideration hereunder is as to whether in the given circumstances a direction for lodging of a FIR and investigation into the matter is required or not. The case of the complainant is partly based upon the allegations and partly upon documents. The allegations raised in the matters are of serious nature and indicate towards a greater and well coordinated plan to defraud the present complainants. I am satisfied that the allegations raised by the present complaints require a wide spread, thorough and technical investigation in the absence of which relevant evidence cannot be gathered in the matter. 8. In these circumstances, prima facie, it appears that a cognizable offence has been committed. Accordingly, the SHO concerned is directed to register an FIR under appropriate Sections of law without being influenced by the Sections, if any, mentioned in the contents of the respective complaints. 9. Be listed for the compliance report on 30.08.2025. 10.Copy of the order be sent to the SHO concerned. Copy dasti. (Announced and dictated in the open Court on 13th August, 2025) (Abhinav Singh) JMFC-01/North West/Rohini Courts 13.08.2025 Page No. 4 of 4 -- 4 of 4 --
