Full Order Text
Order 5 · 02 Aug 2024 · CNR DLNW020255162023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Ct. Cases 13574/2023 ARUN SINGHAL Vs. Vinod Gill & ors. (Shalimar Bagh) 02.08.2024 ORDER ON APPLICATION U/SECTION 156(3) Of Cr.P.C. 1. Vide this order I shall dispose off the present application under section 156 (3) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, filed by the complainant Arun Singhal against Vinod Gill(alleged no. 1), Krishan Saini(alleged no. 2), Deepak Pawar(alleged no. 3), Pankaj Saini (alleged no. 4), Commissioner of Police (alleged no. 5) and SHO PS Shalimar Bagh(alleged no. 6). 2. It has been stated that the complainant had purchased ground floor of the property bearing no B-246, Gali no. 3, Shalimar Bagh Village measuring 50 sq. yards vide a registered sale deed on 11.10.2022 from one Satish Kumar. It is stated that on 07.12.2021 the said Satish Kumar had purchased the same ground floor from Smt. Santosh who originally purchased the entire property from late Sh. Rattan Lal on 11.06.1986. It is further stated that the alleged no. 1, 2 and 3 are the family members residing at the first floor of the same property. It is stated that the alleged persons without complainant’s permission are using the toilet situated on the ground floor of the property which is in possession of complainant and owned by the complainant. It is further stated that on 15.12.2022, the alleged persons abused and threatened the complainant. It is further stated that a PCR call was made at 112 and both the parties were -- 1 of 5 -- taken to the police station. It is stated that no action was taken by the police against the alleged persons and eventually he filed a suit for permanent injunction bearing no. 1712/22 before the Court of Ld. ACJ cum ARC North-West, Rohini Courts, Delhi. It is further stated that the alleged persons had filed forged documents bearing forged signatures of Chunni Lal, Ashok and Rakesh. It is stated that at the time of execution of agreement to sell dated 07.12.2021 between Santosh and Satish, the alleged Deepak Saini has signed as the attesting witness and in the said agreement there was a specific stipulation with respect to conveyance of entire ground floor of the property in question. It has also been stated that in another suit bearing 469/12 titled as Santosh Saini Vs. Krishan Saini, the alleged no. 1 had only produced the registered GPA and Will dated 03.1.2000 and whereas in the new suit filed by the complainant, he had produced additional documents. It has been alleged that the signatures of additional documents are forged. It is further stated that the proposed accused Vinod Gill had produced the fake and forged documents before the Ld. Appellate Court Ms. Deepika Singh in MCA no. 02/2023 and that such documents were never executed by Smt. Santosh at any point of time. It is alleged that the accused persons have entered into criminal conspiracy which is evident from the incident of 14.02.2023(wherein the alleged persons have broken one of the two CCTV cameras and the entire incident was captured in the second CCTV camera). It is stated the complainant is in possession of Police Clearance Certificate, Adhaar Card, Water Meter and Electricity connection issued at the address (mentioned above). It has been -- 2 of 5 -- stated that complainant has given his complaint mentioning various incidents including the facts of the present case in form of another complaint dated 29.04.2023 but no action has been taken against him. As such, it is stated prayed that FIR be registered against the alleged persons U/s 420/468/471/506/34 IPC. 3. ATR has been filed by SI Vipin Rathi. It has been stated in the report that the civil suit No. 1712/2022 was decided against the complainant and the appeal against the said order is pending before the Court of Ms. Deepika Singh, Ld. Senior Civil Judge- cum-Rent Controller, North-West Rohini Courts, Delhi. It has been stated that matter is sub-judiced before the said Court. It is further stated that complainant had not provided any footage regarding breaking of the CCTV camera and FIR No. 309/23 U/s 379 has already been registerd at PS Shalimar Bagh regarding water meter theft. EO concluded that no cognizable offence is made out. 4. I have gone through the record carefully and have given my thoughtful considerations to the arguments advanced. 5. The court is not inclined to allow the present application for the following reasons: a. The identity of proposed accused persons is ascertained. No allegations have been made against alleged no. 5 and 6. -- 3 of 5 -- b. Admittedly, a civil dispute regarding the property in question is pending between the parties. c. Custodial interrogation of alleged persons is not necessary as whether the document allegedly forged are indeed forged or not can be established by the complainant by summoning the witnesses who stood as attesting witnesses to the documents referred to by the complainant in the Tabular Chart. d. All the facts are within the knowledge of complainant. As per the record, the complainant has filed the copy of all the alleged forged documents. Same according to him were filed by the alleged persons before the concerned Civil Judge. Apart from oral testimony, at this stage, only evidence in nature of documents may be required(which are already either in possession or within reach of the complainant). e. The facts of the case are not such that would warrant detailed and complex investigation to be carried out by the State Agency. f. As far as other allegations are concerned with respect to theft of water meter, an FIR has already been registered at PS Shalimar Bagh bearing no. 309/23. 6. In view of the reasons mentioned above, the present application u/section 156(3) is disposed of as dismissed. Reliance is placed upon Skipper Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. State, 2001 IV AD Delhi -- 4 of 5 -- 625 and Subhkaran Luharuka v. State, 2010 SCC OnLine Del 2324.1 Having said so, the court can take always assistance of investigating agency under section 202 of Cr.P.C., if need is felt in future. 7. Complainant is at liberty to lead PSE and to file list of witnesses. 8. Order be given dasti to the complainant. (Ritika Kansal) JMIC-7(NW)/RC/Delhi 02.08.2024 1“52… (iv) Of course, it is open to the Magistrate to proceed under Chapter XII of the Code when an application under Section 156(3) of the Code is also filed along with a Complaint under Section 200 of the Code if the Magistrate decides not to take cognizance of the Complaint. However, in that case, the Magistrate, before passing any order to proceed under Chapter XII, should not only satisfy himself about the pre-requisites as aforesaid, but additionally, he should also be satisfied that it is necessary to direct Police investigation in the matter for collection of evidence which is neither in the possession of the complainant nor can be produced by the witnesses on being summoned by the Court at the instance of complainant, and the matter is such which calls for investigation by a State agency. The Magistrate must pass an order giving cogent reasons as to why he intends to proceed under Chapter XII instead of Chapter XV of the Code.” -- 5 of 5 --
