Full Order Text
Interim Order 9 · 18 May 2026 · CNR DLNW020154502025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 1 of 8 CT CASE NO. 959 /2025 VIVEK BHARDWAJ VS. VIKAS BANSAL PS SUBHASH PLACE 18.05.2026 Present: None for the complainant. ORDER ON APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 175(3) BNSS 1. An application under Section 175(3) BNSS was filed by the complainant for issuance of directions to SHO for registration of FIR. 2. It is the case of the complainant that the complainant is one of the Directors of M/s MISEMIND TECHNOLOGIES PVT. LTD which is engaged in the business of IT consulting and staffing having his mother-in-law, Ms. Mithlesh i.e. accused no.3 holding equal shares in the company. Accused no. 3 introduced complainant to Vikas Bansal i.e. accused no.1 in the month of September 2020 under the pretext of involving him in the company's affairs to handle software application development work, which was essential to the business operations. He further stated that in the first meeting, accused no.1 represented himself as a freelancer with vast experience in IT solutions and is working on two projects along with Mr. Mayank Garg & Mr. Vineet & further assured the complainant that his involvement would significantly contribute to the growth of the company. He further stated that the accused no.1 also said that he is working on different applications/projects related with event industry & project management & these -- 1 of 8 -- Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 2 of 8 applications have good future in the present global digital market. He further stated that he further engaged Vikas Bansal i.e. accused no.1 to work for the company providing him with office space, about 10 employees, and other resources for executing IT-related tasks. He further stated that thereafter accused no.1 introduced accused no.2 i.e. Deepak Bansal and both of accused told that accused no.2 doing the business the sale & purchase of used cars & need a website for his business. That thereafter accused no.2 also started to visit the office. However, instead of fulfilling his responsibilities for the company, Vikas Bansal, along with his brother Deepak Bansal, began to use the office premises and company employees for their personal business interests without knowledge & consent of the complainant. In the month of January 2022, complainant came to know that accused no.1 Vikas Bansal was also associated with other companies and are in "contract to hire" and doing multiple jobs with number of companies namely Aethon Technologies Pvt. Ltd.", "Bartleby Technologies Private Limited" and many more. He further stated that he inquired from accused Vikas Bansal about the completion of a project which is related to the event industry and another one is related with project management, accused no.1 assured that currently the accused is working with other companies and will complete the project by the end of this year and complainant further come to know that accused is using complainant Ompany employees & sources to complete his other projects. During the year 2022 in the month of September/October, accused no.1 Vikas Bansal stating that he requires more systems laptop/desktop and 3 to 4 more employees for the completion of the projects and also need big office space and therefore after discussing with accused no.3 company has been -- 2 of 8 -- Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 3 of 8 shifted to present address in. 1105-A Pearls Best Heights-2 Netaji Subhash Place. Delhi-110034. He further alleged that he purchased two apple desktops amounting each Rs.1,44,210-00 in the month of January 2023. During the month of October 2022 accused no.1 Vikas Bansal approached the complainant for financial assistance/ friendly loan of Rs 1,00,000/- for some personal use and assured the complainant that accused will return the amount in short period and same assurance has been also given by accused no.3 on the assurance & promise to payment the complainant provides the amount for short term. Thereafter, accused no.1 & 3 also asked for mobile device for application testing and for further development therefore under the influence of both accused and assurance Rs 1,00,000/- transferred in the account of Vikas Bansal from company's account & payment of Rs1,45,546.06 was made. Further accused no.1 & 2 started to use the office for their personal use & stopped to transfer the work in company names & continue using the On premises and the employees and assets of the company for their own persona profit. Thereafter, in the month of December 2022, complainant asked from accused no.1 for the return of the amount as promised by him, then Vikas Bansal replied that he needs time as he bought a home so he has taken some loan from bank and from relatives once he is free from them then he will return the whole amount and the same assurance was also given by accused no.3. In the month of January 2023, Vikas Bansal demands for additional setups and therefore complainant purchased desktop through his credit card. In the month of August 2023 accused no.1 again demanded for additional items i.e printer, mouse, headphones & SD card etc. for trial of apps on different devices. In December accused demands for more laptops and 2 more employees for the -- 3 of 8 -- Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 4 of 8 completion of the projects. That thereafter complainant again purchased 2 apple laptops amounting to Rs. 453600 in the month of December 2023 and installed the same in the office premises. He further alleged that he had also purchased an I-phone 15 pro max to check the feasibility of the project on the app store and the same was still in possession of the accused. In the month of April/May 2024 Dr. Sonia Gandhi scientist at INMAS. DRDO Timarpur Delhi along with the Director visited the company office for discussion of the computer programme/ application related with the project management. In the month of June 2024 accused Vikas Bansal along with Mayank Gar (employee of M/S Misemind Technologies Pvt. Ltd.) visited the DRDO office for understanding the project requirement and for the information that all teams require in the application program, as both are the technical personnel and with good knowledge, so the requirement gathering can be done accurately. He further alleged that to his utter shock in the month of august 2024, he came to know that accused no.1 had represented himself to be the owner of the company i.e "M/S Misemind Technologies Pvt. Ltd.", in front of the director of INMAS, DRDO, Delhi and got the server of DRDO installed at the office premises of our company in conspiracy with other accused. He stated that accused persons with mala fide intention procured the jobs of DRDO in their personal name and have misappropriated the funds and assets of the company by misrepresenting himself before DRDO without any authority, concern and right on behalf of the company as such had cheated, embezzled the funds and assets of the company. He further alleged that when he demanded from accused no.1 to return all amount as complainant has to pay bills and office rent and expenses as well, he failed to payback & started -- 4 of 8 -- Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 5 of 8 to pressurize complainant for resign from the company to make his brother accused no.2 as director of the company. Accused no.3 also demanded his resignation and to handover the company to all accused persons then only accused person will return loan advance by him to them & investment in the company. When the complainant denied the same, all accused persons threatened to kill the complainant & stopped the complainant entry in the office in order to grab the company and transfer all the company related assets to his brother's name. When on 29th December, he reached at office to talk with accused, then came to know that all accused persons has taken away all company assets including laptop/desktop, letterhead, company documents, stamps, Audi car from office premises and surrender the keys to owner and apart from that, accused persons had also withdrawn a huge amount of cash from bank accounts with cards. He further stated that accused no.1 was a habitual cheater an FIR NO. 20/19 P.S Subhash Palace U/S 420 IPC with similar kinds of facts was already registered. The complainant made a complaint against the alleged Vikas Bansal on 05.12.2024 to SHO Subhash Place. However no action has been taken by the police. 3. In the present case, the status report was called, which was duly filed. The said report is considered. In the report, it is mentioned that that the dispute appears to be purely civil in nature and falls within the domain of civil remedies as the complainant and the proposed accused are related both professionally and allegations were related to the internal management and functioning of a private limited company, wherein financial transactions, decision-making powers, and asset usage were all part of a business -- 5 of 8 -- Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 6 of 8 relationship built on mutual trust. There were no specific allegations of false inducement, dishonest misrepresentation, or fraudulent intent at the inception of the relationship or the transactions. The complainant has specifically averred that a sum of Rs. 1,00,000 was advanced to accused No.1 as a friendly loan for personal use. There is no written agreement, no formal lending terms, nor any proof of inducement by fraud or coercion. The non-repayment of this personal loan, although a civil wrong, does not attract any cognizable offence under criminal law. The appropriate remedy, if any, lies in civil recovery proceedings. The allegations relating to unauthorized withdrawals, misuse of laptops, office space, and misrepresentation in dealings with third parties (such as DRDO) are inherently governed by the Companies Act and related civil/commercial frameworks. It was finally concluded that matter is civil in nature and no cognizable offence was made out in the jurisdiction of PS Subhash Place. 4. Arguments were heard. Record perused and considered. 5. In the case Subhkaran Luharuka and Another Vs. State (2010), Hon’ble High Court of Delhi laid down the guidelines for giving directions to police to register case wherein it was held that it is not necessary that in every case, where a complaint has been filed U/s. 200 CrPC, the magistrate should direct police to investigate the crime, merely because an application has also been filed U/s. 156(3) CrPC. Court has to form an opinion as to whether police investigation in collection of evidence is necessary or not. It is to be considered as to whether evidence is in the possession of -- 6 of 8 -- Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 7 of 8 complainant or can be produced by the witnesses on being summoned by the court, at the instance of complainant. Further, before passing any other on an application U/s. 156 (3) CrPC, magistrate must call for status report from the police and then form an opinion as to whether complaint discloses commission of cognizable offence or not. He should then satisfy himself about the need of investigation by the police. In addition thereto, he should also satisfy himself with regard to necessity to direct police to investigate the matter for collection of evidence, which is neither in the possession of complainant nor can be produced by the witnesses on being summoned by the court at the instance of complainant and the matter is such which calls for investigation by a State agency. 6. It is well settled that the Magistrate is not bound to direct registration of FIR in every case. The power is discretionary and is to be exercised where: cognizable offence is clearly disclosed, and police investigation is necessary for collection of evidence beyond the reach of the complainant. 7. In this case, complainant has not stated as to what evidence is needed through investigation. Further, the identity of accused is also known to the complainant. Accordingly, no assistance of investigating agency is required and the facts and circumstances of the case as well as identity of the accused is within the knowledge of the complainant. -- 7 of 8 -- Vivek Bhardwaj Vs. Vikas Bansal Page No. 8 of 8 8. Keeping in mind the aforesaid facts and circumstances; it does not appear that investigation by police is necessary as the complainant is in possession of necessary material/evidence. Accordingly, application U/s. 175 (3) BNSS filed by the complainant is dismissed. However, complainant is at liberty to lead PSE in support of his complaint under Section 223 BNSS. If court is of the opinion that any inquiry or investigation is necessary, then it can postpone the issue of process against the accused and inquire itself or direct an investigation to be made by police officer or appropriate person U/s. 225 BNSS. 9. The matter be now listed for PSE on 07.09.2026. Complainant is directed to furnish list of witnesses within 7 days from now and to file PF for summoning them as per rules. (UPASANA SATIJA) CJM (North-West) Rohini Courts, Delhi 18.05.2026 -- 8 of 8 --
