Full Order Text
Interim Order 1 · 07 Oct 2026 · CNR DLNW010119322026
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: OMP (I) (COMM.) 632/2026 Toyota Financial Services India Ltd. Vs. Ravi Singla Fresh petition U/s 9 of Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 received by way of assignment. It be checked and registered. 07.10.2026 Present: Ms. Priya Dubey, Ld. counsel for petitioner through V.C. 1. This is a petition filed U/s 9 of Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 by the petitioner, inter alia seeking interim relief in the nature of appointment of Receiver for taking into possession the vehicle in question. 2. At this stage, the attention of learned counsel for the petitioner is drawn to the order dated 20.06.2025, passed by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in case reported as, “FAO (Comm.) No.161/2025”, titled as, “Surender Kumar V/s Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited”, whereby the Hon’ble High Court has been pleased to issue following directions: xxxxx 6. Ld. Principal District Judge shall give instructions that in cases where Receivers are being appointed for taking over of vehicles, the Bank ought to serve an advance copy of the petition, to the borrowers, so that the borrowers are not taken by surprise by any orders that may be passed by the Court. xxxxx 3. Ld. Counsel for the petitioner submits that petitioner has duly complied with the directions contained in the aforesaid FAO (Comm.) No.161/2025 in as much as the petitioner has filed “Affidavit of Service” and the same is also accompanied with the original postal receipt regarding sending of advance copy of petition to the respondent. 4. I have gone through the record and I find substance in the submissions of learned counsel for the petitioner qua service of advance copy of petition to the respondent. 5. Heard. File perused. 6. Issue notice of the petition to the respondent on filing of PF/RC, -- 1 of 7 -- through all permissible modes, returnable for the NDOH. Steps be taken within 15 days. 7. The notice be also issued through Ld. District & Sessions Judge concerned. 8. The service of notice through Speed Post/AD is also permitted, Dasti, subject to filing of original postal receipt(s), tracking report along with affidavit of service. 9. Alongwith the petition, an application U/s 151 CPC has been filed on behalf of petitioner, inter alia seeking ex-parte interim order in the nature of appointment of “Receiver” for taking into possession the vehicle in question, as per details given below:- 1. Financed Amount Rs.34,17,867/- 2. Make of vehicle FORTUNER/DUMMY ASSET 4. Registration No. DL14CK9040 5. Engine No./Chassis No. 1GDA871922 & MBJAA3GS300634602~0325 6. EMI Amount Rs.64,154/- 7. Total No. of EMIs 60 8. No. of EMIs Paid 9 9. No. of EMIs unpaid as on date 5 10 . Future EMIs 46 10. Heard. Record perused. 11. The present petition has been filed by the petitioner against respondent stating therein that respondent had approached it for grant of the aforesaid loan facility for purchase of the vehicle in question. Consequently, the loan as detailed above was granted to the respondent for purchase of the above mentioned vehicle as per loan agreement. Vide aforesaid agreement, the respondent had also agreed to hypothecate the vehicle in question with the petitioner. Copy of Loan Agreement has been placed on record. 12. The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the respondent has failed to adhere to the financial discipline and committed -- 2 of 7 -- willful default of 05 EMIs in making the payment. It is stated that the amount claimed hereinabove includes principal amount, future interest and penal interest etc. has been due and outstanding against respondent. It is submitted that vide Legal Notice dated 11.05.2026 the said loan was recalled and respondent was requested to handover the possession of the said vehicle. 13. Further it is averred that the said agreement contains an arbitration clause which is provided in Article 23 and also provides jurisdiction of Courts at New Delhi in case of any dispute arising out of the agreement. Further Clause 24 provides Governing Law which mentions that the parties expressly agree that all disputes arising out of and / or relating to this agreement shall be subject to jurisdiction of the appropriate court/ tribunal in New Delhi. Further Ld. Counsel for applicant/petitioner submitted that arbitration has not been initiated yet, however, it will be initiated soon. 14. On these facts, it is stated that petitioner has strong apprehension that the respondent may after receiving the notice of the petition may remove the vehicle from the jurisdiction of this Court or may part with possession or dispose off the vehicle and the whole purpose of filing of the petition will be defeated and petitioner shall suffer substantial loss and injury if the present application for grant of ex parte ad-interim order is not allowed. 15. I have heard Ms. Priya Dubey, Advocate, learned counsel for the applicant/petitioner. I have also gone through the record. 16. Regarding jurisdiction, it is submitted by learned counsel for petitioner that as per agreement, the seat of arbitration is New Delhi and arbitration proceedings will be initiated at the office of learned arbitrator in his office at Rohini, Delhi which falls within jurisdiction of this court and hence this court has jurisdiction to entertain the petition. 17. As per agreement, Clause 23 Arbitration provides inter alia that in the event of any dispute or differences arising out under this agreement including any dispute as to any amount outstanding, the such dispute shall be finally resolved by arbitration, which shall be conducted in accordance with provisions of Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 or any amendment -- 3 of 7 -- or re-enactment therefore by a single arbitrator to be appointed by TFSIN. The venue of arbitration shall be in New Delhi or Bangalore. Further Clause 24 provides Governing Law which mentions that the parties expressly agree that all disputes arising out of and / or relating to this agreement shall be subject to jurisdiction of the appropriate court/ tribunal in New Delhi. As per averment in the petition, it is stated that arbitration shall be conducted in Rohini, Delhi and address is given which falls within territorial jurisdiction of this court. 18. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in case titled BGS SGS SOMA JV v. NHPC, (2020) 4 SCC 234 has clearly laid down that in case seat of arbitration is not mentioned in arbitration agreement, the venue, where arbitration proceeding is conducted, shall become the seat of arbitrator. Therefore, I am of the opinion that this court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the petition. 19. Keeping in view that vehicle is hypothecated to the applicant/petitioner as per the agreement and there is default in making payments of EMIs and despite service of loan recall notice, the respondent neither pay the outstanding amount nor hand over the possession and therefore prima facie good case is made out and balance of convenience also rests in favour of the applicant/ petitioner. Further in case ex parte interim order is not passed, the applicant/ petitioner would suffer irreparable loss as it is strongly apprehended that the respondent may dispose off or part with the possession of the vehicle in question in order to defeat the claim of petitioner. 20. The Hon'ble High Court of Delhi has been pleased to lay down certain guidelines in case titled as Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. v. Kamal Chauhan & Anr. O.M.P (I) no.540/2015 & I.A. No.25026 decided on 23.12.2015 :- (i.) The receiver shall take over the possession of the vehicle from the respondent at the address (es) given in the loan application. If the vehicle is not available at the said address (es), the receiver shall be at liberty to recover the vehicle wherever found. However, the -- 4 of 7 -- receiver shall not stop a running vehicle on the road to forcibly take out the driver to take the possession of the vehicle. The receiver shall also not make any attempt to block the passage of a car to bring it to a halt to take its possession. (ii.) The receiver shall avoid taking the possession of the vehicle if the vehicle is occupied by a woman who is not accompanied by a male member or an elderly, infirm or physically/mentally challenged person. In such cases, the receiver shall take the possession of the vehicle from the borrower's residence. (iii.) The receiver shall be at liberty to take the assistance of the local police, if required, for taking over possession of the vehicle. The concerned SHO shall provide assistance to the receiver as and when requested. (iv.) The receiver shall also ensure that the repossession of the vehicle does not result in any breach of peace. In the event of any breach of peace, the receiver shall not proceed without assistance of police. (v.) At the time of taking the custody of the vehicle,the receiver shall deliver a copy of this order to the person from whom the possession is taken. (vi.) At the time of taking the custody of the vehicle, the receiver shall take the photographs of the vehicle from different angles along with the person (s) occupying the vehicle as well as the place of taking over the possession. (vii.) The receiver shall prepare an inventory of the articles/accessories found in the vehicle and shall furnish the copy of the inventory to the person from whom the possession is taken. (viii.) After taking the vehicle in possession, the receiver shall keep the vehicle in safe custody. (ix.) If the respondent makes payment of the outstanding installments as on date of possession, the receiver shall release the vehicle in question to the respondent on superdari subject to an undertaking by the respondent to the receiver for regular repayment of future monthly installments till the expiry of the tenure and a declaration not to part with the vehicle or create third party interest in the vehicle until the entire amount is paid. (x.) If the respondent is not in a position to clear the entire outstanding installments, the receiver shall give him -- 5 of 7 -- another opportunity to pay the outstanding installments within 30 days of taking over the possession of the vehicle and in case the respondent makes the payment of the outstanding installments within the said period, the receiver shall release the vehicle to the respondent subject to an undertaking as aforementioned. (xi.) If the respondent does not make the payment of the outstanding amount to the petitioner within 60 days, the receiver, with the prior permission of the arbitrator, would be authorized to sell the vehicle in question in public auction with prior written notice (to be sent by Speed Post AD) of the date of auction to the respondent at the address (es) mentioned in the loan agreement or the address from where the respondent may also be able to participate in the action to enable the appellant to fetch maximum amount from the sale of the vehicle. The receiver shall carry out video recording of the auction proceedings and shall submit the same before the arbitrator alongwith his final report. (xii.) The receiver shall submit his report before this Court within 10 days of taking the custody of the vehicle alongwith the photographs and inventory mentioned above. (xiii.) The petitioner is directed to take appropriate steps for initiation of arbitral proceedings against respondent within 90 days from today in term of Section 9(2) of the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015 failing which the above order shall stand vacated. 21. Therefore, in the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case, the application is allowed. Accordingly, I appoint employee of applicant namely Shri Vineet S as “Receiver” to take possession of the vehicle in question subject to compliance of conditions nos. (i) to (xiii) laid down by Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in case of Kotak Mahindra Prime Ltd. (supra). Further the receiver shall serve the notice of the present order to respondent at the time of taking possession of the vehicle and shall file affidavit before this court in this regard. Further it is directed that copy of this order alongwith copy of application, copy of affidavit in support, copy of document be served upon the respondent by petitioner through -- 6 of 7 -- speed post AD/e‑mail/Whatsapp. 22. As prayed, copy of this order be given to counsel for petitioner for compliance. 23. As per discussion above, ex parte prayer stands disposed of. 24. Renotify the matter for further consideration now on 18.02.2027. 25. Let a copy of said order be given dasti to the petitioner. (Manish Gupta) District Judge (Commercial Court)-02 North-West/Rohini Courts/Delhi/07.10.2026 m -- 7 of 7 --
