Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 01 Feb 2025 · CNR DLNW010114502023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: CS (Comm) 895/2023 M/s Mudit Impex Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Panna Lal Sodhi IN THE COURT OF VINOD YADAV: DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT)-02: NORTH-WEST DISTRICT: ROHINI COURTS: NEW DELHI CNR No.DLNW010114502023 Civil Suit (Comm.) 895/2023 In the matter of: M/s Mudit Impex Pvt. Ltd., B-17, Group Indl. Area, Wazirpur, Delhi-110052 Through its Dir Sh. Sanjay Jain. .....Plaintiff (Through Sh. R.K. Singhla, Advocate) Versus Sh. Panna Lal Sodhi, Sole Prop. – M/s. Prem Metal Company, 10578/34, Shankar Gali No.2, Motia Khan, Delhi-110055. .....Defendant (Defendant already ex parte vide order dt. 03.09.2024) Date of Institution of Suit : 15.12.2023 Date of hearing final arguments : 21.01.2025 Date of judgment : 01.02.2025 Suit for recovery of Rs.11,31,766/- (Rupees eleven lacs thirty one thousand seven hundred sixty six only) Page 1 of 5 -- 1 of 5 -- CS (Comm) 895/2023 M/s Mudit Impex Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Panna Lal Sodhi EX-PARTE JUDGMENT: 1. This is a suit for recovery filed on behalf of plaintiff against the defendants, thereby seeking a decree in the sum of Rs.11,31,766/- (Rupees eleven lacs thirty one thousand seven hundred sixty six only) . 2. The facts of the case in brief, as borne out from the record are that plaintiff is a company duly incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 having its work place and registered office B-17, Group Indl. Area, Wazirpur, Delhi-110052 and is engaged in the business of manufacturing and trading of SS coil and circles etc. and other ancillary items. The defendant is the sole proprietor of M/s. Prem Metal Company. 3. The defendant approached plaintiff and placed order for supply of stainless steel sheets which were accordingly supplied by plaintiff vide invoice No.2106, dated 05.01.2021 for an amount of Rs.7,42,522/-. Despite repeated requests, the defendant did not pay the said amount due to which plaintiff sent legal notice dated 30.05.2022 to the defendant. Thereafter, to discharge his aforesaid liability, the defendant issued a post dated cheque bearing No.002138, dated 25.08.2022, for a sum of Rs.7,42,522, drawn on Bank of Baroda. On 24.08.2022, defendant requested the plaintiff not to present the said cheque for encashment and further requested the plaintiff to present the same after one month so that he could arrange sufficient funds in the account. Accordingly, on 15.10.2022, plaintiff presented the aforesaid cheque but the same got dishonoured with the endorsement ‘exceeds arrangements’ vide memo Page 2 of 5 -- 2 of 5 -- CS (Comm) 895/2023 M/s Mudit Impex Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Panna Lal Sodhi dated 15.10.2022. This was intimated by plaintiff to the defendant on which he sought one week’s time for making the payment but even after about one year, he did not paid the said outstanding amount. As per statement of account maintained by plaintiff, a total sum of Rs.7,42,522/- was shown as due against the defendant. Despite repeated requests/reminders from the plaintiff, the defendant did not pay the outstanding amount. 4. Accordingly, the plaintiff has filed the instant suit, thereby invoking the provisions of Section 2(1)(c) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. 5. After filing of the suit, summons for settlement of issues were issued against the defendant vide order dated 15.12.2023. The defendant was served and despite repeated calls, none appeared on behalf of the defendant. Accordingly, defendant was proceeded “ ex-parte” on 03.09.2024 and the matter was notified for ex-parte PE. 6. The plaintiff during the course of ex-parte evidence examined Sh.Sanjay Jain, AR of plaintiff as PW1 in the matter. PW1 in his evidence by way of affidavit Ex.PW-1/A has reiterated the averments made in the plaint and has proved on record the following documents :- Sl. No. Document(s) Ex. 1. Copy of certificate of Incorporation of plaintiff Mark-A 2. Board Resolution in favour of Sh. Sanjay Jain Ex.PW1/1 3. Invoice and e-way bill Ex.PW1/2 Page 3 of 5 -- 3 of 5 -- CS (Comm) 895/2023 M/s Mudit Impex Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Panna Lal Sodhi 4. Copy of legal notice dt. 30.05.2022 Ex.PW1/3 5. Speed post receipt Ex.PW1/4 6. Tracking report Ex.PW1/5 7. Original cheque No.002138 dt. 25.08.2022 for Rs.7,42,522/- Ex.PW1/6 8. Return memo of cheque dt. 15.10.2022 Ex.PW1/7 9. Statement of Account Ex.PW1/8 10. Interest calculation sheet Ex.PW1/9 11. Certificate u/s 65B IE Act Ex.PW1/10 12. Non-Starter Report dt. 23.11.2023 Ex.PW1/11 7. Thereafter, ex parte PE in the matter was closed on 25.11.2024.### 8. I have heard Sh. R.K. Singhla, learned Counsel for the plaintiff and perused the entire material on record. 9. From the perusal of record, it is clearly evident that defendant had approached the plaintiff for business purpose. The execution of necessary/requisite documents between the parties in this regard has been duly proved on record by plaintiff. 10. The plaintiff has further proved on record the Statement of account (Ex.PW1/8) . 11. The defendant being ex-parte, the testimonies of the plaintiff's witnesses have remained unchallenged and unrebutted. There is nothing on Page 4 of 5 -- 4 of 5 -- CS (Comm) 895/2023 M/s Mudit Impex Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Panna Lal Sodhi record to disbelieve the unrebutted testimonies of the plaintiff's witnesses or to doubt the authenticity and veracity of the documents exhibited and proved on record. 12. From the unrebutted testimony of PW-1 in the matter and the documents proved by them on record, I am satisfied that the plaintiff has been able to make out a good case for passing of decree in its favour. As regards the quantum of interest, the transaction between the parties being commercial in nature, I am of the considered opinion that interest @ 12% per annum would meet the ends of justice. 13. (i) In view of the above, a decree in the sum of Rs.7,42,522/- (Rupees seven lacs forty two thousand five hundred twenty two only) along with interest @ 12% per annum from 05.01.2021 till recovery is passed in favour of plaintiff and against the defendant. (ii) Plaintiff is also entitled to costs as well as counsel’s fee which is quantified as Rs.22,000/-. 14. Decree Sheet be drawn accordingly, subject to payment of requisite court fees, if any. 15. File be consigned to Record Room after completion of necessary formalities. Dictated & Announced in the (Vinod Yadav) open Court on 01.02.2025 District Judge (Commercial Court)-02 North-West/Rohini Courts Page 5 of 5 -- 5 of 5 --
