Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 13 Feb 2025 · CNR DLNW010108402024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA IN THE COURT OF SH. RAJINDER KUMAR : ASJ-05, NORTH WEST : ROHINI COURTS, DELHI CA No.36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta PS Rani Bagh 13.02.2025 ORDER 1. This is an appeal U/s 29 of Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (hereinafter referred as P.W.D.V. Act) for setting aside order dt. 26.09.2024 passed by Ld. MM (Mahila Court-02), N/W, Rohini, in the case titled as Suchita Gupta vs. Sagar Gupta. Vide impugned order, the Ld. MM has decided the application filed u/s.23 of P.W.D.V. Act 2005 and has directed the Appellant herein to pay Rs.8,000/- p.m. towards the maintenance of the minor son. 2. The appellant is aggrieved by the quantum of interim maintenance. The appellant is seeking setting aside of impugned order as he is finding the quantum to the exorbitant. 3. It is the contention of the appellant that the impugned order suffers from material irregularities and is contrary to the facts of the case; that the impugned order has been passed without appreciating the fact that in a petition u/s 24 of HMA Act, he offered to pay Rs.4,000/- p.m. towards the minor child; that the ld. MM has erred in ordering the maintenance without considering the fact that the age of CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.1 of 10 -- 1 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA the minor child was only 2 years at the time of the filing of the application and that no document has been placed on record to show the monthly expenses of the child to the tune of Rs.80,000/- p.m. 4. It is the contention of the respondent that the appeal is devoid of merits and has been filed just to harass the respondent and her minor son. That there is no sound ground taken by the appellant in the present appeal and the same is liable to be dismissed. 5. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in case titled as Rajnesh Vs. Neha & Anr. In Criminal Appeal NO. 730 OF 2020 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 9503 of 2018) has laid down that the test for determination of maintenance in matrimonial disputes depends on the financial status of the respondent, and the standard of living that the applicant was accustomed to in her matrimonial home. The other factors which are required to be kept in mind while deciding the interim maintenance has been mentioned in the said judgment. The relevant extract is reproduced below for ready reference:- "LAW ON THE POINT OF MAINTENANCE III Criteria for determining quantum of maintenance (1) The objective of granting interim / permanent alimony is to ensure that the dependent spouse is not reduced to destitution or vagrancy on account of the failure of the marriage, and not as a punishment to the CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.2 of 10 -- 2 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA other spouse. There is no straitjacket formula for fixing the quantum of maintenance to be awarded. The factors which would weigh with the Court inter alia are the status of the parties; reasonable needs of the wife and dependent children; whether the applicant is educated and professionally qualified; whether the applicant has any independent source of income; whether the income is sufficient to enable her to maintain the same standard of living as she was accustomed to in her matrimonial home; whether the applicant was employed prior to her marriage; whether she was working during the subsistence of the marriage; whether the wife was required to sacrifice her employment opportunities for nurturing the family, child rearing, and looking after adult members of the family; reasonable costs of litigation for a non-working wife. In Manish Jain v Akanksha Jain 34 this Court held that thefinancial position of the parents of the applicant-wife, would not be material while determining the quantum of maintenance. An order of interim maintenance is conditional on the circumstance that the wife or husband who makes a claim has no independent income, sufficient for her or his support. It is no answer to a claim of maintenance that the wife is educated and could support herself. The court must take into consideration the status of the parties and the capacity of the spouse to pay for her or his support. Maintenance is dependent upon factual situations; the Court should mould the claim for maintenance based on varlous factors brought before it. On the other hand, the financial capacity of the husband, his actual income, reasonable expenses for his own maintenance, and dependent family members whom he is obliged to maintain under the law, liabilities if any, would be required to be taken into consideration, to arrive at the appropriate quantum of maintenance to be paid. The Court must have due regard to the standard of living of the husband, as well as the spiralling inflation rates and high costs of living. The plea of the husband that he does not possess any source of income ipso facto does not CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.3 of 10 -- 3 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA absolve him of his moral duty to maintain his wife if he is able bodied and has educational qualifications. (ii) A careful and just balance must be drawn between all relevant jactors.The test for determination of maintenance in matrimonial disputes depends on the financial status of the respondent, and the standard of living that the applicant was accustomed to in her matrimonial home. The maintenance amount awarded must be reasonable and realistic, and avoid either of the two extremes i.e. maintenance awarded to the wife should neither be so extravagant which becomes oppressive and unbearable for the respondent, nor should it be so meagre that it drives the wife to penury. The sufficiency of the quantum has to be adjudged so that the wife is able to maintain herself with reasonable comfort. (iii) Section 23 of HAMA provides statutory guidance with respect to the criteria for determining the quantum of maintenance. Sub-section (2) of Section 23 of HAMA provides the following factors which may be taken into consideration: (i) position and status of the parties, ii) reasonable wants of the claimant, (iii) if the petitioner/claimant is living separately, the justification for the same, (iv) value of the claimant's property and any income derived from such property, (v) income from claimant's own earning or from any other source. (iv) Section 20(2) of the D.V. Act provides that the monetary relief granted to the aggrieved woman and / or the children must be adequate, fair, reasonable, and consistent with the standard of living to which the aggrieved woman was accustomed to in her matrimonial home. (v) The Delhi High Court in Bharat Hedge v Smt. Saroj Hegde laid down the following factors to be considered for determining maintenance : "1. Status of the parties. 2. Reasonable wants of the claimant. 3.The independent income and property of the claimant. 4. The number of persons, the non-applicant has to maintain. 5. The amount should aid the applicant to live in a CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.4 of 10 -- 4 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA similar lifestyle as he/she enjoyed in the matrimonial home. 6. Non-applicant's liabilities, if any. 7. Provisions for food, clothing, shelter, education, medical attendance and treatment etc. of the applicant. 8. Payment capacity of the non-applicant. 9. Some guess work is not ruled out while estimating the income of the non-applicant when all the sources or correct sources are not disclosed. 10. The non-applicant to defray the cost of litigation. 11. The amount awarded u/s 125 Cr.PC is adjustable against the amount awarded / 24 of the Act. 17." (vi) Apart from the aforesaid factors enumerated hereinabove, certain additional factors would also be relevant for determining the quantum of maintenance payable. (a) Age and employment of parties In a marriage of long duration, where parties have endured the relationship for several years, it would be a relevant factor to be taken into consideration. On termination of the relationship, if the wife is educated and professionally qualified, but had to give up her employment opportunities to look after the needs of the family being the primary caregiver to the minor children, and the elder members of the family, this factor would be required to be given due importance. This is of particular relevance in contemporary society, given the highly competitive industry standards, the separated wife would be required to undergo fresh training to acquire marketable skills and re-train herself to secure a job in the paid workforce to rehabilitate herself. With advancement of age, it would be difficult for a dependant wife to get an easy entry into the work- force after a break of several years. (b) Right to residence Section 17 of the D.V. Act grants an aggrieved woman the right to live in the "shared household". Section 2(s) defines "shared household" to include the household where the aggrieved woman CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.5 of 10 -- 5 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA lived at any stage of the domestic relationship; or the household owned and rented jointly or singly by both, or singly by either of the spouses; or a joint family house, of which the respondent is a member. The right of a woman to reside in a "shared household" defined under Section 2(s) entitles the aggrieved woman for right of residence in the shared household. irrespective of her having any legal interest in the same. This Court in Satish Chander A hua v Sneha Ahuja (supra) held that "shared household" referred to in Section 2(s) is the shared household of the aggrieved person where she was living at the time when the application was filed, or at any stage lived in a domestic relationship. The living of the aggrieved woman in the shared household must have a degree of permanence. A mere Neeting or casual living at different places would not constitute a "shared household". It is important to consider the intention of the parties, nature of living, and nature of the household, to determine whether the premises is a "shared household". Section 2(s) read with Sections 17 and 19 of the D.V. Act entitles a woman to the right of residence in a shared household, irrespective of her having any legal interest in the same. There is no requirement of law that the husband should be a member of the joint family, or that the household must belong to the joint family, in which he or the aggrieved woman has any right, title or interest. The shared household may not necessarily be owned or tenanted by the husband singly or jointly. Section 19 (1)() of the D.V. Act provides that the Magistrate may pass a residence order inter alia directing the respondent to secure the same level of alternate accommodation for the aggrieved woman as enjoyed by her in the shared household. While passing such an order, the Magistrate may direct the respondent to pay the rent and other payments, having regard to the financial needs and resources of the parties. (c) Where wife is earning some income The Courts have held that if the wife is earning, it cannot operate as a bar from being awarded maintenance by the husband. The Courts have CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.6 of 10 -- 6 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA provided guidance on this issue in the following judgments. In Shailja & Anr. v Khobbanna, this Court held that merely because the wife is capable of earning, it would not be a sufficient ground to reduce the maintenance awarded by the Family Court. The Court has to determine whether the income of the wife is sufficient to enable her to maintain herself, in accordance with the lifestyle of her husband in the matrimonial home. Sustenance does not mean, and cannot be allowed to mean mere survival. In Sunita Kachwaha & Ors. v Anil Kachwaha the wife had a postgraduate degree, and was employed as a teacher in Jabalpur. The husband raised a contention that since the wife had sufficient income, she would not require financial assistance from the husband. The Supreme Court repelled this contention, and held that merely because the wife was earning some income, it could not be a ground to reject her claim for maintenance. The Bombay High Court in Sanjay Damodar Kale v Kalyani Sanjay Kale while relying upon the judgment in Sunita Kachwaha (supra), held that neither the mere potential to earn, nor the actual earning of the wife, howsoever meagre, is sufficient to deny the claim of maintenance. An able-bodied husband must be presumed to be capable of earning suficient money to maintain his wife and children, and cannot contend that he is not in a position to earn sufficiently to maintain his family, as held by the Delhi High Court in Chander Prakash Bodhraj v Shila Rani Chander Prakash. The onus is on the husband to establish with necessary material that there are sufficient grounds to show that he is unable to maintain the family, and discharge his legal obligations for reasons beyond his control. If the husband does not disclose the exact amount of his income, an adverse inference may be drawn by the Court. This Court in Shamima Farooqui v Shahid Khan cited the judgment in Chander Prakash (supra) with approval, and held that the obligation of CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.7 of 10 -- 7 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA the husband to provide maintenance stands on a higher pedestal than the wife. (d) Maintenance of minor children The living expenses of the child would include expenses for food, clothing, residence, medical expenses, education of children. Extra coaching classes or any other vocational training courses to complement the basic education must be factored in, while awarding child support. Albeit, it should be a reasonable amount to be awarded for extracurricular / coaching classes, and not an overly extravagant amount which may be claimed. Education expenses of the children must be normally borne by the father. If the wife is working and earning sufficiently, the expenses may be shared proportionately between the parties. (e) Serious disability or ill health Serious disability or ill health of a spouse, child / children from the marriage / defendant relative who require constant care and recurrent expenditure, would also be a relevant consideration while quantifying maintenance..." Findings:- 6. It is well settled that there exist no straitjacket formula for fixing the quantum of maintenance to be awarded. The financial capacity of the husband, his actual income, reasonable expenses for his own maintenance, and dependent family members whom he is obliged to maintain under the law, liabilities if any, would be required to be taken into consideration, to arrive at the appropriate quantum of maintenance to be paid. The maintenance amount awarded is required to be CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.8 of 10 -- 8 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA reasonable and realistic. For the purpose of assessing the interim maintenance the Trial Court has to only form a prima facie opinion from the material available on the record. The purpose of granting the interim maintenance is to ensure that the petitioner does not suffer during the trial of the matter. 7. The appellant and the respondent are husband and wife, who are living separately. This is not in dispute between the parties that they have a minor son, who was born on 05.05.2020 and presently is studying. This is also not in dispute that the appellant herein is working and earning Rs.1.80 lac p.m. (Which admittedly is more than the income of the respondent herein). The minor son is with the Respondent herein. 8. Both the parents of the minor child are under obligation to maintain their son. While passing the impugned order, Ld. MM has assessed the monthly income of the Respondent herein to Rs.1.80 lac as was admitted by her in the affidavit, whereas the income of the Appellant was assessed to Rs.21,215/- (as per Minimum Wages Act). The Ld. MM has granted the interim maintenance @ Rs.8,000/- pm. in favour of the minor child towards his maintenance. The Ld. MM has already applied the formula laid down in the judgment of “ Annurita Vohra versus Sandeep Vohra 110(2004) 546” the Family CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.9 of 10 -- 9 of 10 -- SAGAR GUPTA Vs. SUCHITA GUPTA Resource Cake should be divided in three pieces out of which two pieces is required to be kept with the husband. This court has no hesitation to hold that Ld. Trial Court has dealt with all the contentions of the parties and the maintenance awarded is certainly reasonable and realistic. 9. In view of the discussion made herein above, I do not find any merit in the present appeal. There is nothing on record, which demand interference in the impugned order. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. Nothing stated herein above shall tantamount to expression of opinion on the merits of the case. 10. In view of the discussion made herein above, I am of the view that there is no infirmity in the impugned order. The appeal filed by the appellant does not have any merits and accordingly, the same is dismissed. 11. The appeal is accordingly disposed off. 12. TCR alongwith the copy of this order be sent to the Court concerned. Announced in the Open Court On : 13th February, 2025 (Rajinder Kumar) ASJ-05/North-West District Rohini Courts/Delhi/13.02.2025 CR No. 36/2025 Sagar Gupta vs. Suchita Gupta Page no.10 of 10 -- 10 of 10 --
