Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 7

CNR DLNW01010066202513 Oct 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 7 · 13 Oct 2026 · CNR DLNW010100662025

Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS
Pdf Text: CS (COMM.)657/2025
CNR No.DLNW010100662025
Rajesh Sharma
Vs.
HDFC ERGO GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
13.10.2026
Present: Sh.Neeraj Vashisth, Sh. Mohit kumar, Sh. Rajat
Pathyan and Ms.Usha, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff.
Sh. Raghav Gupta, Ld. Counsel for defendant.
Arguments on the application under order 1 Rule 10
CPC for impleadment of Financer i.e. Yes Bank Ltd, moved on
behalf of defendant/insurance company heard. Record perused.
It is stated in the present application that the subject
matter of the present case pertains to the theft of vehicle bearing
registration No. DL-11CC-8241, make Hyundai Verna, which is
stated to be under finance with YES Bank Ltd at the time of
alleged theft. It is stated that the said vehicle is hypothecated
with the financer and that the rights and interests of the financer
may be affected by the outcome of the present proceedings,
particularly with regard to ownership, insurance claims and
recovery of outstanding dues. Accordingly, impleadment of YES
Bank Ltd. has been sought on the ground that its presence is
necessary for the proper adjudication of the matter.
On the other hand the application is strongly
opposed by Ld.counsel for plaintiff.
I have considered the averments made by Ld.counsel
for parties.
It is well settled law that the plaintiff is the master of
suit. It is for the plaintiff to determine the parties against whom
he seeks relief, subject to the settled principles governing the
impleadment of necessary and proper parties. A person cannot be
-- 1 of 3 --
2.
CS (COMM.)657/2025
impleaded merely because such person may have some financial
or commercial interest in the subject matter of the proceedings.
In the present case, the dispute primarily pertains to
the alleged theft of the vehicle in question. No cause of action
against the proposed defendant Yes Bank Ltd. has been pleaded.
The applicant has failed to satisfy this court as to how YES Bank
Ltd. is a necessary party without whose presence no effective or
executable order can be passed by this Court. Any independent
rights or claims of the financer arising out of the hypothecation
agreement may be pursued in accordance with law, as and when
required. Mere existence of a finance arrangement does not, by
itself, warrant the impleadment of the financer in the present
proceedings.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, I find no
sufficient ground to allow the present application. Accordingly,
the application under order 1 Rule 10 CPC seeking impleadment
of YES Bank Ltd. as a party to the present proceedings moved on
behalf of defendant insurance company stands dismissed. It is
clarified that the dismissal of the application shall not prejudice
any independent rights or remedies available to YES Bank Ltd. in
accordance with law.
Ld.counsel for plaintiff seeks withdrawl of the
application under order XIII A read with Section 151 CPC.
Heard.
In view of submissions, the present application
under order XIII A read with Section 151 CPC moved on behalf
of plaintiff is dismissed as withdrawn.
Pleadings in the matter are complete.
-- 2 of 3 --
3.
CS (COMM.)657/2025
From the pleadings of parties and material on record,
following issues arises and are framed as under :-
1. Whether the defendant insurance company
was justified in repudiating the claim of the
plaintiff in view of forensic report with regard
to keys of the vehicle? (OPD).
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the
recovery of the suit amount? OPP
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any
interest?, if yes, at what rate and for which
period? (OPP)
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the cost of
the suit, as prayed? OPP
5.
Relief.
No other issue arises or is pressed/claimed.
Be put up for PE on 17.11.2026. Evidence by way of
affidavit of witnesses be filed in advance.
( Devender Kumar Jangala )
District Judge (Commercial Court)-01
North-West, Rohini, Delhi.
13.10.2026
-- 3 of 3 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.