Full Order Text
Order 7 · 01 Oct 2024 · CNR DLNW010097102023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS DJ 879/23 VINOD KUMAR Vs. INDU WAHI AND ANR 01.10.2024 Present: Proxy counsel for the plaintiff (through VC). Sh. Dheeraj Kumar, proxy counsel for plaintiff in person. Sh. Nikhilesh Kumar and Sh. A. Alam, Ld. Counsels for defendant no.1. Ld. Counsel for DDA (through VC). Arguments heard. It appears that this is a suit for specific performance of an agreement to sell. Primarily, the defendant no.1 wants to contend that she never entered into any type of agreement. I consider that this will be taken into account only after recording of evidence and not at this stage. The Ld. counsel for defendant has argued that in terms of Section 17 of Specific Relief Act, this suit cannot be entertained as defendant no.1 is not the owner of the suit property. Perusal of the section shows that it is simply prohibiting specific performance in favour of a vendor. The suit however has not been filed by a vendor. In the agreement to sell, the vendor is the defendant no.1 and therefore Section 17 will not have any application. Ld. counsel for defendant no.1 then argued that since DDA has prohibited any sale or transfer while allotting the property to the defendant no.1, this suit cannot be maintained. It appears that the defendant no.1 herself has been approaching the DDA to get conveyance deed executed in her favour. She has even filed a writ petition before Hon’ble High Court which has issued directions for expeditious consideration by the DDA. Counsel for defendant no.1 submits that DDA has rejected the -- 1 of 2 -- -2- claim of defendant no.1 on account of objection raised by the plaintiff Vinod Kumar as stated in the WS. I consider that if only reason for rejection by DDA is the objection of Vinod Kumar, it would be more proper if the DDA considers the claim of defendant no.1 by ignoring the objection of Vinod Kumar since his objection can only come through the instant agreement to sell which if performed specifically will give him right to get executed sale deed from defendant no1. If defendant no.1 is able to obtain a conveyance deed only then she will be able to transfer the ownership of the property in favour of the plaintiff Vinod Kumar. The other mode may be that the suit is put up for trial and if agreement to sell is established and the plaintiff is able to get specific performance, the DDA shall execute the conveyance deed directly in favour of the plaintiff wherein an injunction can be issued against defendant no.1 to provide no objection to DDA in favour of Vinod Kumar. In either situation, if the agreement to sell is established, Vinod Kumar will be entitled to receive title of the suit property. In converse situation, the suit has to be dismissed. However, for both the situations evidence would be required to be recorded. The defendant no.1 cannot avoid a trial simply on the claim that presently she does not have any ownership right and is only a lessee of paramount lessor i.e. DDA. I am of the view that the application filed by the defendant no.1 under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC is meritless and is therefore dismissed. List for framing of issues and for further proceedings on 18.02.2025. (Rakesh Kumar Singh) DJ-02/(N-W), Rohini Courts Delhi/01.10.2024 -- 2 of 2 --
