Full Order Text
Interim Order 6 · 19 Mar 2025 · CNR DLNW010087592023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: MACT No. 838/23 Kumari Rajni Rajbhar vs. Santosh Kumar & Ors M A C T No. 838/23 In the matter of : Kumari Rajni Rajbhar & Ors. ……….Petitioners Versus Santosh Kumar & Ors. ………..Respondents 19.03.2025 ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall decide the application under Order 7 Rule 10 CPC r/w section 151 CPC, filed by the insurance company/respondent no.3, seeking return of claim petition, on the ground of territorial jurisdiction, averring that as per the claim of the petitioners, neither the petitioners nor respondents are living/residing within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal, the accident has taken place beyond the jurisdiction of this Tribunal and policy issuing office of Insurance company is also situated outside Delhi. Thus, it is stated that this Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to entertain the present claim petition, as no part of cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal. 2. Reply to the present application has been filed by the petitioners wherein it is stated that R3 is having its Branch Office at Unit-23, 24, 26, 1st Floor, Pearl Omaxe Mall, Netaji Subhash Place, Pitampura, New Delhi-110034 from where they are Page 1 of 5 -- 1 of 5 -- MACT No. 838/23 Kumari Rajni Rajbhar vs. Santosh Kumar & Ors running their business, which is situated within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal. It is stated that the present application is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed. 3. In support of its contention, Ld. Counsel for petitioners has placed reliance upon the following judgments:- 1) Mantoo Sarkar vs. Oriental Insurance co. Ltd (2009 ACJ 564); 2) Malti Sardar vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd of Hon’ble Apex Court, decided on 05.01.2016 in Civil Appeal No. 10/2016 arising out of SLP (civil) No. 27243 of 2015. 3) Pramod Sinha vs. Suresh Singh Chauhan & Ors T.P. (Civil) No. 1792/2023 dated 31.07.2023. 4. In support of his contentions, Ld. Counsel for Insurance company/R3 has placed reliance upon judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court “South East Asia Shipping Co. Vs. M/s Nav Bharat Enterprises Ltd. 1996 SCC (3) 443 decided on 13.03.1996. But, the reliance on the said judgment has been misplaced, as the same does not pertain to decision as to territorial jurisdiction, with regard to MACT cases and the court decided lack of jurisdiction observing that no plaint can be presented in a Court, when no part of cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of concerned court. 5. Ld. counsel for insurance company has further placed reliance upon the judgment of Apex Court titled as Sonic Surgical vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd., Civil Appeal no. 1560 of 2004 DOD 20.10.2009, UOI of Adani Exports Ltd., AIR 2002 Page 2 of 5 -- 2 of 5 -- MACT No. 838/23 Kumari Rajni Rajbhar vs. Santosh Kumar & Ors SC 126 and of Hon’ble High Court of Jammu & Kashmir M/s Ladakh Road Lines vs. Union Territory of J & K and Ors A.A. No. 14/2020 CM No. 6914/2020 & 6915/2020 and Patel Roadways Ltd. Bombay vs. Prasad Trading Company and Ors. Appeal no. 3050 and 3051 of 1991, wherein it was observed that where a Corporation has more than one Branch office, then the jurisdiction will be determined, only if the corporation has branch office at that place coupled with the fact that part of cause of action arose in that place. 6. Ld. Counsel for Insurance company has further placed reliance upon decision of Hon’ble Kolkata High Court in Nirmala Debi vs. M/s ICICI Lombard GIC 2015 (1) ACJ 639 Cal, 2010 (1) TAC 405 Cal. (DB), Subhadra vs. Pankaj MFA 31609/2011 DOD 07.08.2012, and New India Assurance Co. Ltd. vs. Kurti Swar Pramanik of Kolkatta High Court civil order no. 2225 of 2006 DOD 15.12.2009, wherein while dealing with issue of territorial jurisdiction under the provisions of MV Act, it was observed that the claim petition can be entertained, where part of cause of action arose i.e. where accident occurred, victim and owner of offending vehicle resides or defendant resides but, does not confer jurisdiction to the claim Tribunal, within whose local jurisdiction defendant carries on business. Thus, in order to confer jurisdiction, either the Insurance company’s Head office or policy issuing office should be within the jurisdiction of Claim Tribunal. 7. Ld. counsel for Insurance company has also placed Page 3 of 5 -- 3 of 5 -- MACT No. 838/23 Kumari Rajni Rajbhar vs. Santosh Kumar & Ors reliance on case titled as Smt Kamla Chopra vs. LIC, AIR 1975 Delhi-15, wherein also, it was observed that where no part of cause of action has arisen at a place, where branch office is situated, that Court has no jurisdiction to entertain a suit. 8. However, the decisions relied by Ld. Counsel for Insurance Company are either not pertaining to Motor Vehicle Cases or of Hon’ble Courts of other States but, Ld. Counsel for petitioner has placed reliance on decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in Mantoo Sarkar vs. Oriental Insurance Co Ltd & Ors Civil Appeal No. 7318 of 2007 arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 8201 of 2007, in which while entertaining application u/s 166 (2) of MV Act 1988, with regard to territorial jurisdiction, the court had set aside the order of Hon’ble High Court of Uttrakhand, wherein Hon’ble High Court of Uttrakhand at Nainital took the view that Nainital Tribunal had no jurisdiction to entertain petition under section 166 MV Act. It was observed that since the insurance company, which was main contesting respondent, has its business at Nainital therefore, unless there is failure of justice, Hon’ble High Court was not justified in setting aside the award of Tribunal, on the plea of lack of territorial jurisdiction. 9. Similar view was taken by Hon’ble Apex Court in Malati Sardar vs. National Insurance co. Ltd. 2016 (3) SCC 43, wherein it was observed as under:- “The provision in question, in the present case, is a benevolent provision for the victims of accidents of negligent driving. The provision for territorial jurisdiction has to be interpreted consistent with the Page 4 of 5 -- 4 of 5 -- MACT No. 838/23 Kumari Rajni Rajbhar vs. Santosh Kumar & Ors object of facilitating remedies for the victims of accidents. Hyper technical approach in such matters can hardly be appreciated. There is no bar to a claim petition being filed at a place where the insurance company, which is the main contesting parties in such cases, has its business. In such cases, there is no prejudice to any party. There is no failure of justice. Moreover, in view of categorical decision of this Court in Mantoo Sarkar (supra), contrary view taken by the High Court cannot be sustained. The High Court failed to notice the provision of Section 21 CPC”. 10. In view of the said decisions of Hon’ble Apex Court, petitioner has filed the present claim petition contending that one of the branch office of the Insurance Company is within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal, and in the entire application, there is no contention of the Insurance Company that prejudice was caused to any of the parties. Therefore, the said objection cannot be taken into consideration and since the provisions of M.V. Act is a benevolent provision, for the purpose of disbursement of compensation to the victim of accident of negligent driving and no prejudice will be caused to the Insurance Company, whose branch office is within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal. Therefore, this Tribunal has jurisdiction over the subject matter of the claim. Therefore, the application of the Insurance Company under Order 7 Rule 10 CPC R/w Section 151 CPC stands dismissed. Announced in the open (Shama Gupta) Court on 19.03.2025 PO MACT/North West District Rohini Courts, Delhi. Page 5 of 5 -- 5 of 5 --
