Full Order Text
Final Order 13 · 02 Sept 2024 · CNR DLNW010085222023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. VIRENDER KUMAR BANSAL PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE NORTH-WEST DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI CNR No. DLNW01-008522-2023 RCT ARCT 2/23 Hitesh Kumar Ghai S/o Sh. Shyam Sunder Ghai R/o A-1/247, Keshav Puram, Delhi-110035 Also at: Shop No.10, Jain Mandir Building, A-2 Block, Keshav Puram, Delhi-110035 ...Appellant Versus 1. Sushila Kumari Jain W/o Sh. Babu Ram Jain The President of Jain Trust Delhi 2. Babu Ram Jain S/o Sh. Giri Lal A Trustee & Secretary of Jain Trust Delhi 3. Moorti Jain W/o Sh. Attar Sain Jain A Trustee of Jain Trust Delhi 4. Vikas Jain S/o Sh. Babu Ram Jain A Trustee of Jain Trust Delhi 5. Vishal Jain S/o Sh. Babu Ram Jain A Trustee of Jain Trust Delhi 6. Anita Jain W/o Sh. Vikas Jain A Trustee of Jain Trust Delhi Page 1 / 11 -- 1 of 11 -- 7. Savita Jain W/o Sh. Vishal Jain A Trustee of Jain Trust Delhi All Trustees of the Trust, The Jain Trust Delhi All R/o 10944/5, Mandir Road, Doriwalan, Karol Bagh, New Delhi-110005 ...Respondents Date of institution : 15.09.2023 Date of reserving order : 24.08.2024 Date of pronouncement : 02.09.2024 Appearance: Sh. Naresh Talwar, Advocate for the appellant. Sh. R.S. Chauhan, Advocate for the respondents. JUDGMENT The present appeal has been preferred u/s.38 of Delhi Rent Control Act (in short the Act) challenging the order dated 17.08.2023 passed by the Ld. ARC vide which the eviction petition filed by Smt. Sushila Kumari Jain and others (hereinafter referred as petitioners/respondents) against the tenant Hitesh Kumar Ghai (hereinafter referred as tenant/appellant) and sub- tenant Rajeev Baweja, was allowed. 2. The brief facts giving rise to the present appeal are that Jain Trust Delhi is a registered trust having its office at A-2, Lawrence Road, Keshav Puram, Delhi and the petitioners are its trustees and the office bearers. Eviction petition was initially filed by Sh. Babu Ram Jain, who was authorized by all the members of the Managing Committee and the trustees of Jain Page 2 / 11 -- 2 of 11 -- Trust to secure and safeguard the trust properties and specifically to initiate the proceedings with respect to shop no.10, situated in Jain Mandir building A-2, Lawrence Road, Keshav Puram, Delhi (hereinafter referred as suit property). The suit property was rented out to respondent no.1/appellant on 01.12.1993 at a monthly rent of Rs.500/-, which was increased from time to time and presently the rate of rent is Rs.750/-. It is alleged that respondent no.1/appellant has sublet the premises in dispute to respondent no.2 Rajeev Baweja, who is doing the business under the name and style of Akshay Marketing for photostat, stationery items and disposable items. Respondent no.1/appellant is collecting rent @ Rs.4000/- p.m. from Rajeev Baweja. The tenancy of the respondent no.1 has been terminated by the petitioners/ respondents w.e.f. 31.12.2011 by issuing legal notice dated 14.12.2011. 3. The petitioner/respondent alleged that certain purchases were made of different items from the premises in dispute, the payment of which was made by two cheques of Rs.2530/- and Rs.2100/- which were encahsed in the account of Sh. Akshay Baweja. It is alleged that as respondent no.1 has sublet the premises to respondent no.2, hence, he is liable to be evicted u/s.14(1)(b) of the Act. 4. Notice of the petition was sent to respondent no.1/ appellant and respondent no.2. Notice sent to respondent no.2 was received back unserved. He was ordered to be served by way of affixation. Despite that, he did not appear and was proceeded ex parte. Page 3 / 11 -- 3 of 11 -- 5. Respondent no.1/appellant was served and he filed written statement taking the defence that he has not sublet, assigned or parted with possession of the tenanted premises in any manner whatsoever to respondent no.2. The premises in dispute is in possession of the answering respondent/appellant and he is running his own business from there since the inception of tenancy. It is alleged that respondent no.2 is cousin of respondent no.1/appellant. He was an employee of respondent no.1 but he has left the job now. Respondent no.2 has never worked under the name and style of Akshay Marketing from the premises in dispute. The bills, documents alleged by the petitioners are forged. However, relationship of landlord/tenant is admitted. It is alleged that Rajeev Baweja has nothing to do with the business being run by respondent no.1/appellant and has nothing to do with the premises in dispute in any manner whatsoever. 6. Petitioners/ respondents filed the replication denying the averments made in the written statement and re-asserted the facts mentioned in the petition. 7. Thereafter, the case was fixed for evidence. Sh. Babu Ram Jain himself appeared in the witness box. He tendered his affidavit Ex. PW1/1, re-affirming all the facts mentioned in the petition and proved the documents as Ex. PW1/A to PW1/X. However, out of those documents Ex. PW1/E and PW1/O were de-exhibited and were marked as Mark C & D. He was cross- examined at length by Ld. Counsel for respondent no.1/appellant. 8. Petitioners also examined Rajeev Baweja, who was Page 4 / 11 -- 4 of 11 -- arrayed as respondent no.2 in the petition but was proceeded ex parte, as PW2. He was also cross-examined by Ld. Counsel for respondent no.1. Thereafter, the petitioners closed their evidence and the case was fixed for evidence of respondent no.1/appellant. 9. Respondent no.1/appellant himself appeared in the witness box as RW1 and he tendered his affidavit as Ex. RW1/A, re-affirming the averments made in the written statement. He proved the documents as Ex. RW1/1 to RW1/9 and RW1/11 to RW1/13. He was cross-examined by the Ld. Counsel for the petitioners. 10. Sh. Sanjay Gera was examined as RW2 by respondent no.1/ appellant, who also tendered his affidavit as Ex. RW2/A. He alleged that he is the regular visitor of the shop of the respondent and has been purchasing stationery and other disposable goods for the last 20 years and that he has not seen anybody else running that shop and that he has never sublet. He also stated that Rajeev Baweja was the employee of the respondent. He was cross-examined by Ld. Counsel for the petitioners and thereafter the respondent closed his evidence. 11. The case was fixed for arguments. Ld. ARC after hearing the arguments passed the eviction order, which is under challenge in the present appeal. 12. Notice of the appeal was given to the petitioners/ respondents. They put appearance and they filed the reply to the appeal. Trial court record was requisitioned. Page 5 / 11 -- 5 of 11 -- 13. I have heard Ld. Counsel for the appellant, Ld. Counsel for the respondents and perused the record. 14. Ld. Counsel for the appellant submitted that onus was upon the petitioners/ respondents herein to prove that the appellant has parted with possession to somebody else and had divested himself not only from the physical possession but even right to possess the tenanted premises. But the petitioners/ respondents herein have not been able to prove this fact. The trial court has mis-directed itself by shifting the burden on appellant. It is well settled law that the initial burden to prove was on the landlord. If the landlord is able to discharge that initial burden only then the burden shifts on the tenant to disprove the same or to show that he has not parted with possession. 15. Ld. Counsel submitted that in this case Rajeev Baweja, who is alleged to be the sub-tenant was examined as PW2 by the petitioners themselves and he has demolished the case of the petitioners. He has specifically stated that he was only an employee of the respondent no.1/appellant herein and has now left the same. He also stated that he had not issued any bills to the petitioners for the sold goods. He has also stated that the business was being run by Hitesh Ghai. Ld. Counsel submitted that so far as the payment being made by the petitioners by way of cheque is concerned, he has stated that he received the payment of Rs.2530/- and Rs.2100/- by way of cheques drawn in favour of Akshay Baweja but the same were regarding other goods, which were purchased by him for the petitioners on the asking of petitioners and those cheques were encashed in the account of Akshay Baweja. Page 6 / 11 -- 6 of 11 -- 16. Ld. Counsel submitted that PW2 has left his job in the year 2011. The witness has also stated that Hitesh Ghai is the proprietor of Akshay Marketing and that bills PW1/1 to PW1/M are forged and that the business from the premises in dispute is being run by Hitesh Ghai and son of Hitesh Ghai is doing business from shop no. A-1/2 & 3, DDA Market, Keshav Puram, Delhi. Ld. Counsel submitted that once the witness of the petitioners himself is saying that he was not doing any exclusive business and was not doing that business to the exclusion of respondent no.1/appellant. The business was being run by respondent no.1/appellant only and he was his employee, then it is clear that respondent no.1 has not parted with possession of the premises in dispute. 17. Ld. Counsel submitted that it is not the evidence adduced by the respondent/appellant but it is the evidence adduced by the petitioners themselves and, therefore, they have themselves brought it on record that the respondent no.1 has never parted with possession of the premises in dispute but trial court has erred in reaching to the conclusion that respondent no.1 has failed to show that Rajeev Baweja was its employee or that in which capacity he was sitting on the shop and how he had received the notice. Ld. Counsel submitted that if a person i.e. the employee is sitting on a shop, he will certainly receive the notices. Even otherwise, once the witness of the petitioners is himself admitting that business was being run only by Hitesh Bhai i.e. respondent no.1/appellant herein and that Hitesh Ghai has not parted with possession, then the subletting is not proved. It is prayed that under the circumstances the judgment passed by Page 7 / 11 -- 7 of 11 -- Ld. Trial Court is not sustainable and the same be set aside. 18. Ld. Counsel for the petitioners/ respondents supported the judgment and the reasoning of the Ld. Trial Court and stated that once it is established that the bills were issued by PW2 in favour of the petitioners herein, the cheques issued were credited in the account of Akshay Baweja, who has nothing to do with the shop or with Hitesh Kumar Ghai. Respondents/appellants and even MCD has issued notice in the name of Rajeev Baweja. That is sufficient evidence to establish that Hitesh Ghai has divested himself of the premises in dispute and has handed over the possession of the premises in dispute to PW2. Ld. Counsel submitted that it is very difficult to get any direct evidence with respect to the subletting. It has to be inferred on the basis of the evidence and the circumstances appearing on the file, which clearly show that Hitesh Kumar Ghai i.e. the respondent no.1/appellant, who is now doing business from shop no. 2 & 3, Pocket A-1, DDA Market, Keshav Puram, Delhi, has now stopped business from the premises in dispute and handed over the same to respondent no.2 i.e. Rajeev Baweja. Ld. Counsel submitted that Ld. Trial Court has considered all these facts and rightly passed the judgment passing eviction order. It is prayed that there is no merits in the appeal and the same be dismissed. 19. After hearing the arguments and going through the record, in my opinion, for making out a case of subletting, the onus is upon the landlord to show that the tenant has parted with possession of the suit premises in favour of a third party without the consent of the landlord. It is not simply possession, parting with possession means that the tenant has divested himself not Page 8 / 11 -- 8 of 11 -- only of the physical possession but also the right to possess. If the tenant retains the right to possess then there is no parting with possession as required u/s. 14 (1)(b) of the Act. If this preposition is applied on the facts and circumstances of the case then it is clear that there is no parting with possession. The allegations are that respondent no.1/appellant has parted with possession in favour of respondent no.2 Rajeev Baweja, who has been examined as PW2. It is pertinent to mention here that PW2 is the witness of petitioners. PW2, as pointed out by the counsel for the respondent, has stated that the bills, on the basis of which the petitioners/respondents alleged that those were issued by respondent no.2 while doing business from the premises in dispute, were not issued by him and do not bear his signatures. 20. Petitioners/ respondents also argued that the payment against these invoices/bills were made through cheques, which were drawn in favour of Akshay Baweja and the witness stated that he received the payment of Rs.2530/- and Rs.2100/- by way of cheques drawn in favour of Akshay Baweja but the same were regarding other goods, which were purchased by him for the petitioners on his asking as the petitioners asked him to purchase those goods. Now if the testimony of the witness has to be believed then those cheques were not in respect of the goods allegedly purchased with respect to some other goods and that is why the payment was made in the account of Akshay Baweja. He also denied the suggestion that the shop no. 10 is named as Akshay Marketing on the name of his nephew Akshay Baweja. He denied the suggestion that he used to do the business of disposable items from the tenanted premises in the name of Akshay Baweja. The witness has also stated that he had left the Page 9 / 11 -- 9 of 11 -- job of Hitesh Ghai in the year 2011 and he also closed the work of Akshay Marketing in the year 2011. 21. Ld. Counsel for the petitioners/respondents has emphasised on the deposition of PW2 where he has stated that Akshay Marketing was doing the work of supply of stationery items which he used to carry out from the tenanted shop and that this work was carried out from the tenanted premises with the consent and permission of the petitioners since 2009. The Ld. Counsel submitted that as the business was being carried out without his consent and that is why it amounts to subletting. As pointed out earlier, mere presence of somebody in the shop does not amount to subletting unless it is to the exclusion of the main tenant. It is not only divesting the possession but even divesting himself of right to possess. The witness has specifically stated that proprietor of Akshay Marketing is Hitesh Ghai i.e. the appellant herein and that the business from the premises in dispute is being run by Hitesh Ghai. If this is seen coupled with his statement that he was only an employee clearly shows that it was the appellant/ respondent no.1, who was doing the business from the premises under the name and style of Akshay Marketing of which he was the proprietor i.e. the respondent no.1/appellant. It is again emphasized that this testimony is of the witness of the petitioners. 22. It is setted law that initial onus to prove that tenant has parted with possession or handed over possession to somebody else to his exclusion is on the landlord. Once the witness of the petitioners/respondents himself is admitting that the possession always remained with Hitesh Ghai i.e. respondent no.1/appellant Page 10 / 11 -- 10 of 11 -- and he was doing the business from the premises in dispute under the name and style of Akshay Marketing and that he was only an employee, in my opinion, the petitioners/respondents have not been able to show that the tenant i.e. respondent no.1/appellant herein has parted with possession or handed over the possession to his exclusion to Rajeev Baweja. 23. Keeping in view the above discussion and the evidence on record, in my opinion, the order of Ld. Trial Court is not sustainable, the same is set aside. The appeal is, accordingly, allowed. 24. Trial court record be sent back alongwith copy of the order. Appeal file be consigned to Record Room. Announced in the open Court today i.e. 2nd September, 2024 (Virender Kumar Bansal) Principal District & Sessions Judge (NW) Rohini Courts, Delhi (sb) Page 11 / 11 -- 11 of 11 --
