Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 05 Mar 2024 · CNR DLNW010082422023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. 05.03.2024 ORDER ON APPEAL Present : Appellant with Ld. Counsel Sh. Rajpal Singh and Sh. Deepak Chand Pandey. Respondent no.1 with Ld. Counsel Sh. Geetesh Aneja. 1. Nidhi Kashyap (the appellant herein) had filed a petition under provision of Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act 2005 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) against respondent Gulshan Kumar and Saroj (hereinafter referred to as the respondents). The appellant and her counsel failed to appear before the Ld. Trial Court in the aforesaid DV Petion, therefore, Ld. Trial Court dismissed the petition in default vide order dated 29.03.2023. Subsequently, Ld. Counsel for the petitioner moved an application for restoration of the petition, but same was also dismissed vide the impugned order dated 18.07.2023. The said order has been challenged through the present appeal. 2. During course of arguments, Ld. Counsel for the appellant has submitted that matter had come up for hearing before the Ld. Trial Court on 20.08.2022, wherein the Ld. Trial Court had directed both the parties to file the income affidavits. Matter was thereafter renotified on 28.11.2022. On that day, the Ld. Presiding Officer of the Trial Court was on leave. Ld. counsel for the appellant has submitted that he could not appear on the said date as he was diagnosed with a serious heart problem and -- 1 of 8 -- CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. therefore, had to undergo surgery. After surgery, he was repeatedly visiting the hospital for follow-ups. Ld. Counsel has also produced his medical documents to show that he was admitted to hospital in November 2022 and was operated upon for implanting stents. Ld. Counsel has submitted that due to his medical condition, he could not keep the track of the case and could not intimate the appellant regarding the further progress in the case. Therefore, she also could not appear before the Ld. Trial Court. Since the appellant also could not appear before the Ld. Trial Court on two date, the case was dismissed in default. All these facts were brought to the notice of Ld. Trial Court during hearing of application for restoration but same were not considered. 3. It is also submitted that non appearance before the Ld. Trial Court was not intentional, therefore, an opportunity has been sought to contest her case on merits. 4. On the other hand, Ld. Counsel for the respondents has submitted that appellant was absent on 20.08.2022. Thereafter, none appeared on behalf of the appellant on 28.11.2022, 20.01.2023 and 29.03.2023. Ld. Trial Court, before dismissal of the petition, had served a notice upon the appellant but she failed to appear despite service of the notice. This conduct of the appellant goes contradictory to the submissions made by Ld. Counsel for the appellant that she had lost the track of the case. -- 2 of 8 -- CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. 5. Ld. Counsel has also submitted that there were names of three counsels mentioned on the vakalatnama filed on behalf of the appellant before the Trial Court. Therefore, even if the main counsel was not able to appear, the other counsels could have appeared alongwith the appellant. Ld. Counsel has also pointed out that other litigations are also pending between the parties, wherein the counsels as well as the appellant were appearing on each and every date. However, they were deliberately not appearing in the DV Petition with sole purpose of delaying the proceedings and harassing the respondents. 6. In support of his arguments, Ld. Counsel for the respondents has placed reliance upon judgment passed by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in case titled as New Bank of India Vs. MS Marbles (India) & Ors. 2001 (Delhi). The relevant observations are as under : “6. There is no absolute proposition of law that all cases of mistakes on the part of the advocate or pleader would constitute sufficient cause. What is to be seen is as to whether absence of the advocate was bonafide. This is to be examined in conjunction with the conduct of the party who had engaged advocate viz. Whether he was persuing his case diligently or the conduct and approach was so callous that it amounted to negligence. If this is so that non-appearance would -- 3 of 8 -- CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. not be bonafide and it would not constitute sufficient cause within the meaning of Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure”. Further held that : “Nodoubt the words "sufficient cause" should receive liberal construction so as to advance substantial justice. However when it is found that the applicants were mot negligent in defending the case and their non-action and want of bonafide are clearly imputable, the Court would not help such a party. After all "sufficient cause" is an elastic expression for which no hard and fast guide-lines can be given and Court has to decide on the facts of each case as to whether the defendant who has suffered ex-parte decree has been able to satisfactorily show sufficient cause for non- appearance and in examining this aspect cumulative effect of all the relevant factors is to be seen”. 7. Ld. counsel for the respondents has further relied upon judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in case titled as Indian Sewing Machine Co. Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Sansar Machines & Ors. 1994 SC, where the Hon'ble Apex has observed that “The question to be examined is whether the responsibilities of the defendants as a litigant comes to an end merely by engaging a counsel and should not a litigant show diligence on his part”. -- 4 of 8 -- CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. 8. In another case titled as Sahil Dutta Vs. TM & MC Pvt. Ltd. 1993 SC, relied upon by the respondent, the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed as under : “The advocate is the agent of the party. His acts and statements made within the limits of authority given to him, are the acts and statements of the principal, i.e., the party who engaged him. It is true that in certain situations, the Court may, in the interest of justice, set side a dismissal order or an ex-parte decree notwithstanding the Negligence and/or misdemeanour of the advocate where It finds that the client was an innocent litigant, but there is no such absolute rule that a party can disown its advocate at any time and seek relief No such absolute immunity can be recognised. Such an absolute rule would make the working of the system extremely difficult”. 9. Taking reference of the observations made in the aforesaid judgments, Ld. Counsel for the respondent has argued that even if Ld. Counsel for the appellant was not able to appear due to alleged health condition, the other counsels mentioned on the vakalatnama could have appeared on behalf of the appellant. Moreover, bad health of the counsel is not an absolute ground for the appellant to remain absent from the proceedings. The appellant herself should have been diligent enough to pursue the -- 5 of 8 -- CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. petition. However, she remained absent despite service of notice upon her. Her conduct shows that she was deliberately not appearing. Therefore, there is no justifiable ground to allow the appeal and restore her petition. 10.Rebutting the arguments made by Ld. Counsel for the respondent, Ld. Counsel for the appellant has added that although, the names of the other counsels were mentioned in the vakalatnama, but they have recently joined the practice just 3-4 years back and do not possess the required experience to contest the case at their own without guidance of the senior counsel. Ld. Counsel has also submitted that the other counsels appearing for the appellant in other litigations did not have the brief of this case. Therefore, they couldn't have appeared and assisted the appellant in the DV Petition. 11.Submissions heard. Record has been perused. 12.In view of the submissions made by Ld. Counsel for the appellant, the delay in filing of the present appeal is hereby condoned. 13.For purpose of deciding the present appeal on merits, this Court has perused all the relevant order-sheets of the Ld. Trial Court. The order-sheets would reveal that the DV Petition had come up for hearing before the Ld. Trial Court on 20.08.2022, wherein the directions were issued to both the parties to file their income -- 6 of 8 -- CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. affidavits. Thereafter, matter came up before the Ld. Trial Court on 28.11.2022, 20.01.2023 and 29.03.2023, but none appeared on behalf of the appellant despite service of notice in this regard. In order to explain his non-appearance, Ld. Counsel for the appellant has produced his medical record. The medical record would reveal that the Ld. Counsel had undergone a cardiac surgery in November 2022. Thereafter, he was repeatedly visiting hospital for the follow-ups. These medical documents are sufficient to satisfactorily explain non-appearance of Ld. Counsel for appellant before the Ld. Trial Court. Since the Ld. Counsel for the appellant was under treatment, it is possible that he could not keep the track of the proceedings and also failed to intimate the same to appellant, which led to non-appearance of the appellant also. Although, a notice was served upon the appellant, but she failed to appear on 29.03.2023, the date when the petition was ultimately dismissed. Now, even if the absence of the appellant on the said date remains unexplained, this Court does not think that it is a sufficient ground to dismiss the petition on basis of non-appearance on a single date. As far as the appearance of other counsels is concerned, Ld. Counsel for the appellant has satisfactorily explained that they are his juniors, having very limited experience and, therefore, the they could not have conducted any effective proceedings without his guidance. 14.Above all, this Court cannot loose sight of the principle that endeavour should always be to take every matter to its logical -- 7 of 8 -- CA No.186/23 Nidhi Kashyap Vs Gulshan Kumar & Ors. end on merits and a technical dismissal on threshold should always be avoided. 15.Considering the aforesaid circumstances, the present petition is allowed, subject to payment of cost of Rs.10,000/- by the appellant to the respondents. 16.The DV Petition be restored to the same stage at which it was dismissed. The appellant shall file her income affidavit on next date of hearing before the Ld. Trial Court. In case the appellant adopts further delaying tactics, Ld. Trial Court is at liberty to pass any order as per law. 17.Parties are directed to appear before the Ld. Trial Court on 12.03.2024. 18.Appeal stands disposed of. Appeal file be consigned to Record Room. Trial Court record be sent back. ( BABRU BHAN) ASJ-03 (NORTH-WEST) ROHINI COURTS DELHI/05.03.2024 -- 8 of 8 --
