Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 27 Nov 2024 · CNR DLNW010075422024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace 27.11.2024 Regular Ld. Addl. PP for the State is on leave today. Present: Sh. Vishal Tomar, Ld. Counsel for petitioner. Sh. Ashish Kajal, Ld. Subst. Addl. PP for State / R-1. Sh. Aman Kumar Pathak, Ld. Counsel for respondent / R-2. ORDER ON REVISION 1. On an application moved u/s.156(3) Cr.P.C. by the respondent no.2/ complainant Indu Wahi, Ld. CJM, North-West had directed registration of FIR against the petitioner herein vide order dated 09.08.2024. Petitioner challenged the said order via the present revision petition. This Court imposed stay on the said order on 12.08.2024. However, before the order on stay could be conveyed to the concerned PS, an FIR bearing no. 575/24 had already been registered at PS Subhash Place. 2. Petitioner approached Hon’ble Delhi High Court with a petition seeking quashing of the FIR. Admittedly, said petition has already been withdrawn on 25.11.2024. 3. Now the first question before this Court is whether this Court can pass any effective order against the impugned order which has already been executed in form of registration of an FIR. The objective of revision proceedings is to correct a patent error and illegality in a judicial order. Merely because an order Page 1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace has been executed, doesn’t mean that its illegality cannot be cured. In other words, execution of an order cannot perpetuate its illegality. So, the present revision petition can still be heard. 4. Coming to the facts of the case, shorn of unnecessary details, brief facts are that a plot bearing no. 363, Pocket-A3, Sector-34, Rohini, Delhi, was allegedly allotted to the respondent no.2 / complainant in 2014 under the Rohini Residential Scheme. Subsequently, daughter of the respondent no.2 / complainant came into contact with Sunil Gupta, who assured her to complete the documentation with DDA. 5. On 26.04.2022, daughter of the respondent no.2/ complainant alongwith petitioner petitioner and one Sunil Gupta went to DDA office for completion of documentation. Respondent / complainant further alleged that the petitioner herein and Sunil Gupta obtained all the original documents from them and refused to return the same on demand. 6. While advancing arguments, Ld. Counsel for the petitioner has narrated a different version of the story. He has stated that the petitioner had purchased the plot in question in the year 2006. Thereafter, in 2014, payment to the DDA was also made by the petitioner herein. However, the respondent / complainant refused to transfer the plot in the name of the petitioner and filed a false complaint. Ld. Counsel has further Page 2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace submitted that the petitioner has also filed a complaint in this regard at PS Subhash Place. A counter application u/s.156(3) Cr.P.C. filed by the petitioner herein is also stated to be pending before the Court. 7. The grievance of the petitioner is that he has not committed any offence but since the FIR has been registered on an application moved by respondent no.2 / complainant, the police shall not collect evidence in support of his side of story. 8. Hon’ble Jammu and Kashmir High Court has discussed scope of fair investigation and trial in case titled as Ajay Kumar Agarwal vs Union Territory Of Jk And Ors on 12 May, 2022. The relevant observations are as under : “08.From plain reading of the definition of investigation, it is evident that the primary object of the investigation under the Code is the collection of evidence in relation to the allegations under investigation. Power of the police to investigate and procedure for investigation is delineated in Chapter XII of the Code (Section 154 to Section 176). Indisputably, any investigation into the crime should be fair and impartial and in accordance with law. It is only a fair and impartial investigation that can provide foundation of a fair trial. Fair investigation and the fair trial are as much necessary for the accused as these are for the victims and the public at large. The public at large too has its stakes in the fair, impartial and unbiased investigation and trial against the offender of the crime. It is, thus, the requirement of both Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India that the investigation conducted by the police in the Page 3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace crimes is fair, impartial and unbiased leading to the conduct of a fair trial against the offender of the law. Article 21 enshrines and guarantees precious right of life and personal liberty to a person which he can only be deprived of on following the procedure established by law. The procedure established by law ought to be a just and fair procedure and which meets the requirement of rule of law implicit in Article 14 of the Constitution of India. Assurance of a fair trial to the accused is first imperative of dispensation to criminal justice. It is, thus, the primary duty of the Investigating Officer to conduct proper, fair, impartial and unbiased investigation aimed only at finding out the truth. 09. In the State of Bihar vs. P.P.Sharma reported in 1992 Supp (1) SCC 222, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in paragraph 48 held thus: 48."From this perspective, the function of the judiciary in the course of investigation by the police should be complementary and full freedom should be accorded to the investigator to collect the evidence connecting the chain of events leading to the discovery of the truth, viz., the proof of the commission of the crime. Often individual liberty of a witness or an accused person are involved and inconvenience is inescapable and unavoidable. The investigating officer would conduct in-depth investigation to discover truth while keeping in view the individual liberty with due observance of law. At the same time, he has a duty to enforce criminal law as an integral process. No criminal justice system deserves respect if its wheels are turned by ignorance. It is never his business to fabricate the evidence to connect the suspect with the commission of the crime. Trustworthiness of the police is the primary insurance. Reputation for investigative competence and individual honesty of the investigator are necessary to enthuse public confidence. Total support Page 4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace of the public also is necessary." With regard to the necessity of a fair and impartial investigation into a criminal offence, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Babubayi vs. State of Gujrat report in 2010 (12) SCC 254 in paragraph 32 held as under:- 32 "The investigation into a criminal offence must be free from objectionable features or infirmities which may legitimately lead to a grievance on the part of the accused that investigation was unfair and carried out with an ulterior motive. It is also the duty of the Investigating Officer to conduct the investigation avoiding any kind of mischief and harassment to any of the accused. The Investigating Officer should be fair and conscious so as to rule out any possibility of fabrication of evidence and his impartial conduct must dispel any suspicion as to its genuineness. The Investigating Officer "is not merely to bolster up a prosecution case with such evidence as may enable the court to record conviction but to bring out the real unvarnished truth". (Vide R.P. Kapur Vs. State of Punjab AIR 1960 SC 866; Jamuna Chaudhary & Ors. Vs. State of Bihar AIR 1974 SC 1822; and Mahmood Vs. State of U.P. AIR 1976 SC 69). No less important are the observations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Vinay Tyagi vs. Irshad Ali reported in 2013 (5) SCC 762, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in paragraph 48 of the Judgment laid down as under: - 48."What ultimately is the aim or significance of the expression "fair and proper investigation" in criminal jurisprudence? It has a twin purpose: Firstly, the investigation must be unbiased, honest, just and in accordance with law; Secondly, the entire emphasis on a fair investigation has to be to bring out the truth of the case before the court of competent jurisdiction. Once these twin paradigms of fair investigation are satisfied, there will be the least requirement for the court of law to interfere with the investigation, much less quash the same, or transfer it Page 5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace to another agency. Bringing out the truth by fair and investigative means in accordance with law would essentially repel the very basis of an unfair, tainted investigation or cases of false implication. Thus, it is inevitable for a court of law to pass a specific order as to the fate of the investigation, which in its opinion is unfair, tainted and in violation of the settled principles of investigative canons." What is held in the case of Amitbhai Anil Chandra Shah vs. CBI reported in 2013 (6) SCC 348 is equally relevant and is, therefore, reproduced here under:- 58.9"Administering criminal justice is a two-end process, where guarding the ensured rights of the accused under Constitution is as imperative as ensuring justice to the victim. It is definitely a daunting task but equally a compelling responsibility vested on the court of law to protect and shield the rights of both. Thus, a just balance between the fundamental rights of the accused guaranteed under the Constitution and the expansive power of the police to investigate a cognizable offence has to be struck by the court. Accordingly, the sweeping power of investigation does not warrant subjecting a citizen each time to fresh investigation by the police in respect of the same incident, giving rise to one or more cognizable offences. As a consequence, in our view this is a fit case for quashing the second F.I.R to meet the ends of justice." 58.10."The investigating officers are the kingpins in the criminal justice system. Their reliable investigation is the leading step towards affirming complete justice to the victims of the case. Hence, they are bestowed with dual duties i.e., to investigate the matter exhaustively and subsequently collect reliable evidences to establish the same." 10. From the conspectus of the judicial opinion, it is axiomatic that the essence of criminal justice system is to reach the truth. The underlying principle of criminal Page 6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace jurisprudence is that the accused is presumed to be innocent till proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt in a trial conducted according to the procedure prescribed by law and which procedure is just and fair and in consonance with Article 14 of the Constitution. Fair, impartial and transparent criminal investigation is sin qua non for ensuring fair trial for the accused. The Investigating Officer is a kingpin in the criminal justice system and fair, impartial and reliable investigation by him is most important step towards affirming complete justice to the victim/victims of the crime as also to assure fair trial rights of the accused. It is with this object in view the Investigating Officer is bestowed with enormous powers and equally onerous duties to dispassionately investigate the matter and reach the truth by collecting reliable evidences for and against the allegations.” 9. So, the purpose of criminal investigation is not to collect the material selectively which supports the case of the complainant only. The purpose of criminal investigation is to uncover the truth and the investigating agency must collect all the relevant evidence. This relevant evidence includes evidence that supports and contradict the allegations. So, it goes without saying that during investigation, if the allegations and the story alleged by the petitioner is found to be more truthful, it shall be investigated upon by the investigating officer. 10. So, instead of reversing the impugned order, let the investigation on the allegations and counter allegations be investigated by the police in a fair and impartial manner. Page 7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- Cr Rev 261/2024 VINOD KUMAR AGGARWAL Vs. STATE PS Subhash Palace 11. The revision petition is disposed off as dismissed without interfering with the impugned order but with a reminder to investigating agency that it shall be an impartial and fair process which shall be carried out without being affected by the fact that at whose instance the FIR has been registered. 12. It is also clarified that by dismissing the present revision petitioner, this Court has not authorised the investigating agency to arrest the accused / petitioner in any manner. Needless to say, if any such necessity to arrest the accused is felt by the IO, at any stage of investigation, he shall be guided by the law laid down by Hon’ble Apex Court of India in Arnesh Kumar and Satender Antil’s case. 13. The revision petition is hereby dismissed being devoid of any merits. 14. Revision file be consigned to record room. 15. Copy of the order be sent to the Ld. Trial Court along- with TCR , if any. ( BABRU BHAN) ASJ-03, N/W, ROHINI COURTS DELHI/27.11.2024 Page 8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
