Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 23 Aug 2024 · CNR DLNW010063702024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. VIRENDER KUMAR BANSAL PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE NORTH-WEST DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI In the matter of: CNR No. DLNW01-006370-2024 CR No. 228/24 1. Ashish @ Sonu S/o Sh. Shri Bhagwan R/o J-321, Mangol Puri Delhi-110086 2. Sachin Yadav S/o late Sh. Kamal Yadav R/o H. No. 223, Mangol Puri Delhi-110086 .....Revisionists Versus State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi …..Respondent Date of institution : 11.07.2024 Date of Arguments : 02.08.2024 Date of Order : 23.08.2024 ORDER 1. The present revision has been preferred challenging the order dated 28.05.2024 whereby the court has directed the framing of charges U/s 448/380/427/34 IPC against the revisionists herein. 2. The brief facts giving rise to the present revision are that Hari Sharan Mishra made a complaint that in the year 2010, he has purchased the property No. H-223, First Floor, Mangol Puri, Delhi from Sh. Kamal Chander S/o Ram Milan and got the CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- possession of the same. He has put his articles, i.e. gas stove, one gas cylinder (big), one TV make samsung, one DVD, two tables, bed, some utensils, bedsheets, two chairs, two stools, water tank, some fitting articles, water meter and ceiling fan. He has also got installed one electricity meter in the property. It is alleged that he used to visit the property occasionally and on 15.07.2016 at about 2:30 PM when he reached there on his motorcycle and started going to the first floor, at that time Lalita, her elder son Monu and her younger son stopped him from going to the first floor and told him that he has no house here. They started manhandling him. They snatched the keys of the bike and his mobile phone. Some public persons gathered there and saved him. He made a call at 100 number, but police did not come. In the meanwhile, Lalita, Monu and younger brother of Monu called their two companions, who run NGO. One of them was Sonu, but he does not know the name of the lady. They were accompanied by 10- 15 muscle men. They started manhandling and abusing him. They threatened him that if he came again, he will be killed. 3. He made a call at 100 number. After sometime, one police official Rakesh from PS Mangol Puri came there. He told all the facts to him, but he also abused him and took him to PS, but later on, he was allowed to call his relative. They came and had shown the documents to the police. Thereafter, he was allowed to leave. He told that when he went there to bring his motorcycle, he found that those persons have removed Rs. 12,000/- from his motorcycle, alongwith the documents of the house and electricity documents. The motorcycle was also damaged. On his complaint, the FIR was registered. CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- Chargesheet was filed after completion of investigation. Ld MM after hearing the arguments passed the order on charge, which is under challenge in the present revision. 4. Notice of revision was accepted by Ld Chief Public Prosecutor for State. Trial court record was requisitioned. 5. I have heard Ld counsel for the revisionists, Ld Chief Public Prosecutor for State and perused the record. 6. Ld counsel for the revisionists submitted that in this case, the FIR was registered on the complaint of Hari Sharan, who alleged himself to be the owner and that he was given beatings, his motorcycle was damaged and his money was also taken out. Ld counsel submitted that all these facts are false and frivolous. Infact father of the revisionist No. 2 borrowed a sum of Rs. 6 lacs and in this regard, some documents were prepared, i.e. GPA, Agreement to Sell, Affidavit etc as well as mortgage deed, all dated 04.01.2010. In the agreement, it was clearly mentioned in para 6 that the possession of the property shall remain with the first party, i.e. father of revisionist No. 2. The father of revisionist No. 2 expired and Smt. Lalita, mother of revisionist No. 2 filed a suit for declaration and permanent injunction, which is still pending adjudication. Ld counsel submitted that wife of the complainant had also filed a civil suit No. 62429/2016 titled Nirupam Mishra Vs. Lalita & Ors. In that case, Smt. Nirupam Mishra appeared in the witness box as PW1. She admitted the agreement dated 04.01.2010 and the same is Ex.PW1/D. Ld counsel submitted that Nirupam Mishra did not CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- have any document to show her possession in the property in question at any point of time and she ultimately withdrew that suit on 21.02.2024. Ld counsel submitted that all these document are already on the file of trial court, but were not considered at all. Ld counsel submitted that once it is already on record that the complainant and his wife had not got the possession, therefore, the question of trespassing in the property by the owners themselves does not arise as the property always belonged to the father of revisionist No. 2 and after his demise, his mother Lalita. As they were never in possession, therefore, the complainant placing any articles in the house is only a far- fetched story. Ld counsel further submitted that though the complainant alleges that his motorcycle was damaged, but in the entire chargesheet, there is nothing on record to show that his motorcycle was found on the spot or the complainant has produced his motorcycle, which was in damaged condition. He also alleges that his mobile phone was also taken, but again he is silent about the make of that mobile phone and even the number, which was used in that mobile phone. Ld counsel submitted that he alleges that there were some documents with respect to the electricity. Nirupam Mishra when appeared in the witness box has also cleared that doubt and she stated in his cross examination in civil suit No. 62429/2016 titled Nirupam Mishra Vs. Lalita & Ors. on 07.04.2022, as under: “It is correct that till today there is no electricity meter installed in the name of my husband. I do not remember the exact date or the year on which the said disconnection of the said electricity meter. It is correct that I have not placed any document on record to show that I am in possession of the first floor of the suit property except the photographs. It is wrong to suggest that the photographs filed by me on record is not of the CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- suit property. It is correct that I have ration card, aadhar card and PAN card of the Bhajanpura address and not of the suit property.” 7. Ld counsel submitted that this statement of Nirupam Mishra falsifies the entire story concocted by her husband and that is why, Nirupam Mishra also withdrew the suit. Ld counsel submitted that it is settled law that if two views are possible, then the one favouring the accused has to be followed. Ld counsel submitted that the trial court had not considered these facts and in view of these admitted facts and the judicial record, the order passed by the trial court is not sustainable. It is prayed that the order of the trial court be set aside and the revision be allowed. 8. Ld Chief Public Prosecutor submitted that in this case, there are documents to show that the property in dispute was sold to the complainant herein by virtue of documents. The copies are on record, i.e. GPA, Agreement to Sell, Affidavit, Mortgage deed, affidavit etc, all dated 04.01.2010. These documents were executed by Kamal Chander in favour of Nirupam Mishra. The possession was also delivered to Nirupam Mishra, but later on when on 15.07.2016, Hari Sharan, husband of Nirupam Mishra, went to the property, i.e. H-223, situated on first floor, Mangol Puri, Delhi, he was not allowed to reach his property by Lalita, his son Monu and also younger son. They manhandled him and also called their other associates. They have snatched his mobile phone and the key. They extended threats and also damaged the motorcycle. Ld Chief Public Prosecutor submitted that all these facts prima facie show that all the accused persons have trespassed in the property, which was purchased by wife of CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- complainant from the father of revisionist No. 2. They have stolen the articles, which they have placed in that house and also snatched his mobile phone and took out the documents from the motorcycle, alongwith some amount. Ld Chief Public Prosecutor submitted that prima facie all the ingredients constitute the offences are made out. It is prayed that trial court has rightly framed the charges. There is no merit in the revision, the same be dismissed. 9. After hearing the arguments and going through the record, I found that in the present case, some documents were executed by Kamal Chander in favour of Nirupam Mishra with respect to the first floor of the property No. H-223, JJ Colony, Mangol Puri on 04.01.2010. The claim of the complainant is that they have purchased the property, whereas according to the revisionists herein, a loan of Rs. 6 lacs was taken and that is why those documents were executed. Nirupam Mishra had filed a civil suit and when she appeared as witness in that civil suit, she admitted her signatures on the agreement Ex.PW1/D1. This is agreement between Kamal Chander, the father of revisionist No. 2 herein, and Nirupam Mishra, wife of the complainant. The clause 5 of this agreement reads as follows: “5. That the possession of said property shall remain with the first party and the first party will not sublet/sale the said property to any person without permission of the second party.” 10. Clause 6 of the agreement reads as under: “6. That if the first party returns the loan of Rs. 6,00,000/- to the second party before the expiry period then the first party shall remain the owner of the above mentioned property.” CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- 11. From the bare reading of these clauses of the Agreement, which is admitted to have been executed between erstwhile owner Sh. Kamal Chander and the wife of the complainant herein with respect to the suit property, it is clear that possession remained with the first party, i.e. Kamal Chander and was not handed over to the second party, i.e. Nirupam Mishra. It is also specifically mentioned that infact there is a loan of Rs. 6 lacs and if the first party, i.e. Kamal Chander returns that loan amount before the expiry, then the first party shall remain the owner. 12. No doubt, there is another set of documents, which are available on the judicial file. According to these documents, the possession was delivered to Nirupam Mishra. 13. There is statement of Nirupam Mishra also and according to that statement, she has no documents of the possession of the property. 14. There is an averment in the complaint that one electricity meter was also installed in the suit property. The witness says that it has already been disconnected and there is no electricity connection in the name of her husband in the suit property. It is also important to note here that she is not having any document of the possession in the suit property. Now the allegations are that the accused persons have trespassed in the house, which was in possession of the complainant, but the record shows that the complainant was not in possession as Ex.PW1/D1. Hence, the question of trespass by the son of CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- Kamal Chander or his wife does not arise as after the death of Kamal Chander, his wife and sons become the owners. 15. So far as putting the articles in that house and the fact that these were been stolen is concerned, once it is on record that possession of property was never delivered, the question of putting articles in that property by the complainant itself does not arise. There is also averment that motorcycle was damaged, but no such evidence has been brought on record, even there is no motorcycle number, there is no mechanical inspection report on the file to show that there was any damage to the motorcycle and to which motorcycle. 16. He claims that his mobile phone was also snatched, but has not mentioned the make of the mobile phone or even the number, which he was using in that mobile phone. Infact, he himself states in his complaint that he was taken to the PS by police Ct. Rakesh and when from his mobile phone he was trying to contact his relatives, his mobile phone was snatched by the police. Hence, this averment that his mobile phone was taken by the revisionists herein itself is false. 17. It is settled law that if two views are possible, then the view favouring the accused has to be followed. Therefore, keeping in view all these facts, the admission of Nirupam Mishra, wife of the complainant, that agreement Ex.PW1/D1 was executed bears her signature, it is clear that complainant or his wife were never in possession, thereby question of putting articles in that property does not arise and his question of visiting CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- that house also does not arise. 18. The complainant has also alleged that original documents of the property were also taken out by the accused persons that is the revisionists herein. But surprisingly those documents are on the judicial file and there is no document to show that those documents were recovered from the possession of the accused persons/revisionists herein. Therefore, in my opinion this is only a false averment. Similarly, there is nothing on record about Rs. 12,000/-. What was the denomination of those currency notes and from where he got the same and where he kept those currency notes in the motorcycle. As discussed above, even the registration number or make of the motorcycle is not given by the complainant. 19. Therefore, in my opinion, the order of the trial court is not sustainable under law. Accordingly, the revision is allowed and the order of the trial court directing the framing of charges U/s 448/380/427/34 IPC against the revisionists herein is hereby set aside. 20. Trial Court Record, alongwith a copy of this order, be sent back. 21. Revision file be consigned to record room. Announced in the open court today i.e. 23rd August, 2024 (Virender Kumar Bansal) Principal District & Sessions Judge (NW) Rohini Courts, Delhi/23.08.2024 CR No. 228/24 Ashish @ Sonu & Anr. Vs. State Page 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
