Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 26 Aug 2025 · CNR DLNW010058102025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: Cr. Rev. No.175/25 PS Shalimar Bagh Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg 26.08.2025 ORDER ON REVISION 1. Present revision petition is preferred by petitioner Sh. Sushant Gupta aggrieved by the order dated 22.05.2025 passed by Ms. Aishwarya Sharma, Ld. JMFC (Mahila Court), North West District, Rohini Courts in contempt petition filed by R-1 Poonam Garg in complaint case no. 7001/2021 titled as Poonam Garg Vs. Praveen Garg & Ors. 2. Ld. Counsel for petitioner has submitted that vide impugned order dt. 22.05.2025, Ld. JMFC has issued notice upon all the respondents of said contempt petition i.e. R-1 Sh. Praveen Garg, R-2 Sh. Prahlad Garg, R-3 Smt. Sunita Garg, R-4 Sh. Sushant Gupta (the Petitioner herein) and R-5 SHO PS Shalimar Bagh. 3. It is stated that neither the Petitioner is family member of husband of the Respondent no.1 nor he is related to husband of the Respondent or his family members in any manner. Moreover, the Petitioner is not a party to the complaint case. 4. It is further stated that the Petitioner is legal owner of the Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 1 of 10 -- 1 of 10 -- property bearing no. AH-44, Second Floor, Shalimar Bagh, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as “said property”) and he is in constant legal possession of said property since 01.05.2023. 5. It is further stated that it is clear that said contempt petition has been filed by R-1 for alleged violation of order dated 29.03.2022 passed by Ld. JMFC in complaint case. Pertinently, vide order 29.03.2022, Ld. JMFC directed R-1 to R-4 of the complaint case to restrain from dispossessing the aggrieved person/petitioner (R-1 herein) from the said property. Further, Ld. JMFC also gave the liberty to aggrieved person (R-1 herein) to approach the concerned SHO PS Shalimar Bagh in this regard. It is stated that the said complaint case/application has been filed on behalf of aggrieved person (R-1 herein) u/S 23 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (43 of 2005) (DV Act) requesting interim relief u/S 12/18/19/20/21/22 of DV Act. Therefore, it is clear that the said complaint case has not been filed by R-1 against the petitioner herein and same has been filed against the husband and his family members. Similarly, the order dt. 29.03.2022 was passed against the respondents of the complaint case and not against the Petitioner herein. Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 2 of 10 -- 2 of 10 -- 6. It is further stated that the Ld. JMFC has issued notice of contempt petition upon the Petitioner vide order dt. 22.05.2025 without application of judicial mind and without considering the fact that Petitioner herein could not have committed contempt of Court without there being any direction against the Petitioner vide order dt. 29.03.2022. Therefore, the impugned order dt. 22.05.2025 is bad in law and shall be set-aside while recording malafide conduct of R-1. 7. It is further stated that the R-1, with intention to mislead Ld. JMFC, has falsely stated in the contempt petition that she has been residing at said property from 18.01.2019 till date of impugned order dt. 22.05.2025. It is further stated that the Petitioner has legally purchased the said property from its erstwhile owner after paying its due consideration and took its possession on 01.05.2023 and is in constant possession of said property till date. It is stated that as a matter of fact, the lawful title of said property was transferred in favor of Petitioner vide registered sale deed dated 08.05.2023. It is further stated that in order to determine actual whereabout of R-1, it is important to preserve the CDR of R-1 from 01.08.2022 to 22.05.2025. 8. It is further stated that the bundle of lies was forced out of Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 3 of 10 -- 3 of 10 -- R-1 by virtue of registration of FIR bearing no. 267/2025 dated 06.05.2025 and the said FIR was registered in terms of order dt. 05.05.2025 passed by Sh. Gaurav Kataria, Ld. JMFC, N-W District in CC No. 5826/2025. 9. It is further stated that the impugned order has been passed by Ld. Trial Court while acting, without application of mind, in a manner that is unreasonable, arbitrary, capricious and also contrary to the settled prepositions of law and without appreciating the material on record. It is stated that the Ld. JMFC has errored in fact and in law while issuing notice to the Petitioner of the Contempt Petition, filed by R-1 alleging violation of order dt. 29.03.2022, vide impugned order dt 22.05.2025, as no directions were passed in said order to or against the petitioner. 10.It is stated that Ld. JMFC has errored in law while passing impugned order, without appreciating the fact that no relief as prayed in Contempt Petition against the Petitioner can be granted / awarded by Ld. JMFC since no direction was passed against the Petitioner in said complaint case. Ld. JMFC has passed the impugned order in utmost mechanical manner without going through the contents of the Contempt Petition and the Complaint Case. Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 4 of 10 -- 4 of 10 -- 11.Ld. Counsel has submitted that the impugned order passed by JMFC is bad in law as Petitioner cannot commit contempt of order dt. 29.03.2022 as no direction, whatsoever, was passed by Ld. JMFC vide order dt. 29.03.2022 against the Petitioner. Therefore, impugned order is liable to be set aside. 12. Submissions heard from both the sides. Record perused. 13.In the instant Revision Petition, Petitioner has challenged the impugned order mainly on the ground that the Ld. JMFC has issued the contempt notice against the Petitioner without considering the fact that Petitioner was not a party to the case wherein the protection order was passed in favour of the Aggrieved Person (Respondent No.1 herein). It is contended on behalf of the Petitioner that the impugned order dated 22.05.2025 is bad in law as Petitioner cannot commit contempt of order dated 29.03.2022 as no directions were passed against the Petitioner herein by Ld. JMFC vide order dated 29.03.2022. It is submitted that the Petitioner has legally purchased the said property from its erstwhile owner after paying due consideration and took its possession on 01.05.2023 and he is in constant possession of said property till date. It is contended that a third party cannot Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 5 of 10 -- 5 of 10 -- be held liable for contempt. Per contra, Ld. Counsel for Respondent No.1 has submitted that Respondent No.1 was in possession of the said property in from 18.01.2019 to 22.05.2025. It is submitted that M/s Rolexco Buildtech (OPC) Pvt. Ltd. or Petitioner Sushant Gupta is not the bonafide purchaser of the shared household of the Respondent herein. It is submitted that the Petitioner was having the notice of the order dated 29.03.2022 passed by the Ld. JMFC and also have the notice that Respondent No. 1 has been in possession of the shared household. It is submitted that Petitioner in collusion with other respondents (respondents in complaint case) dispossessed the aggrieved person from shared household and all of them including Petitioner herein had committed contempt of the court order. It is submitted that respondents of complaint case never disclosed about the alleged sale deed before the Ld. JMFC which is sufficient to prove that the alleged sale deed is an act of fraud by the Respondents of the complaint case and Sushant Gupta and M/s Rolexco Buildtech(OPC)Pvt. Ltd. It is contended that though Petitioner is not a party to the complaint case but he is liable for contempt of court as he assisted in breach of the court order. 14. It is a well settled law that a third party can be held liable Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 6 of 10 -- 6 of 10 -- for contempt of breach of a court order if he is having sufficient notice of a court order and knowingly obstruct the implementation of the Court order. In case titled as Ramakrishna Township And Projects Private Limited Vs. Authorized Officer, State Bank of India, WP 5058/2019 decided on 29.10.2019, Hon’ble Telangana High Court has held that : “31. No doubt, the bank was not a party to the suit, but even a third party can be held liable for contempt if it assists in the breach of a Court order after knowing about it and thus facilitates obstruction of course of justice. 32. The Supreme Court considered the question about liability of a third party who assists a party to a litigation to violate a Court order in Sita Ram v. Balbir Alias Bali. (2017) 2 SCC 456 and followed the principle in Seaward v. Paterson (1859-99) All ER 1127. It held: "In Seaward v. Paterson the landlord of the concerned premises had obtained an injunction against Paterson i.e. his tenant restraining him from doing or allowing to be done anything on the premises which would be a nuisance to the landlord and from using the premises otherwise than for the purposes of a private club. Alleging that the tenant had committed contempt of the court by allowing the premises to be used for boxing matches, the landlord applied for committal of two other persons, namely, Sheppard and Murray on the ground that they had aided and assisted the tenant in his disobedience to the injunction. The following passages from the Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 7 of 10 -- 7 of 10 -- judgment of Lindley LJ. are quite instructive: (All ER pp. 1130 F-G & 1131 B-D) Now, Let us consider what jurisdiction the court has to make an order against Murray. There is no injunction against him - He is no more bound by the injunction granted against Paterson than any other member of the public. He is bound. like other members of the public, not to interfere with, and not to obstruct, the course of justice; and the case, if any, made against him must be this - not that he has technically infringed the injunction, which was not granted against him in any sense of the word, but that he has been aiding and abetting others in setting the court at defiance, and deliberately treating the order of the court as unworthy of notice. If he has so conducted himself, it is perfectly idle to say that there is no jurisdiction to commit him for contempt as distinguished from a breach of the injunction, which has a technical meaning.” “A motion to commit a man for breach of an injunction, which is technically wrong unless he is bound by the injunction, is one thing: and a motion to commit a man for contempt of court, not because he is bound by the injunction by being party to the cause, but because he is conducting himself so as to obstruct the course of justice, is another and a totally different thing The difference is very marked. In the one case the party who is bound by the injunction is proceeded against for the purpose of enforcing the order of the court for the benefit of the person who got it. In the other case, the court will not allow its process to be set at naught and treated with contempt." Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 8 of 10 -- 8 of 10 -- 15.In the instant case, it is the claim of the Respondent no.1 that the petitioner alongwith respondents of the complaint case with malafide intention committed breach of the Court order. The Ld. JMFC has restrained R-1 to R-4 of the complaint case from dispossessing the aggrieved person (R-1 herein) from second floor of AH-44, Shalimar Delhi, without due process of law till disposal of the case or until further orders vide order dated 29.03.2022. There is nothing to suggest that R-1 to R-4 of the complaint case obtained the vacant peaceful possession of the “said property” from the aggrieved person (Respondent No. 1 herein) after following due process of law and thereafter, sold the property to Petitioner vide sale deed dated 08.05.2023 or that the restrained order dated 29.03.2022 was vacated by the Court. It is a question of fact as to whether the Petitioner is a bonafide purchaser of the said property in question and received peaceful vacant possession of the said property on 01.05.2023 and he has not assisted in breach of the Court order. These questions can be decided after adducing evidence by the parties before the Ld. Trial Court. Therefore, at this stage, notice issued by the Ld. Trial Court to Petitioner in contempt petition cannot be set aside. This court does not find infirmity or illegality in the order dated 22.05.2025. Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 9 of 10 -- 9 of 10 -- 16. Revision is without any merit. Same is dismissed. 17.Pending application, if any, shall be treated as dismissed being devoid of merit. 18.TCR, if any, be sent back to the concerned Trial court alongwith copy of order. 19.File be consigned to Record Room after necessary compliance. ( MUNEESH GARG) ASJ-03, N/W, ROHINI COURTS DELHI/26.08.2025 Cr. Rev. No.175/25 Sushant Gupta Vs. Poonam Garg Page 10 of 10 -- 10 of 10 --
