Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 15 May 2025 · CNR DLNW010043522025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. PRASHANT KUMAR, ASJ (ELECTRICITY) NORTH WEST DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI BAIL REGISTRATION NO : 854/2025 FIR No : 16/2025 US : 498A/406/34 IPC PS : Maurya Enclave STATE Vs. VAIBHAV JAIN 15.05.2025 Present : Sh. Gyanendra Mishra, Ld. Substitute PP for the state. Sh. Deepika Jain, Ld. Counsel for complainant. Sh. D. K. Singh and Virender Rajput, Ld. Counsel for accused. IO SI Meena in person. Arguments heard at length. As per record, the fact of the case are that marriage of complainant was solemnized with Divyanshu Jain on 19.03.2023, according to Hindu rites, however, after few days of the marriage dispute arose and complainant lodged a complaint with the police station that she had been subjected to cruelty and there has been demand of dowry from her husband and other relatives i.e., mother-in-law, father-in-law, sister- in-law and jethani. FIR has been registered on 15.01.2025. ARGUMENTS OF APPLICANT/ACCUSED Ld. Counsel for accused/applicant submits that that two cars have been given in the marriage, however, loan have been taken against these cars by father-in-law Rajesh Jain and mother-in-law Alka Jain of the complainant. EMIs of the car have been paid by father-in-law and mother-in-law, respectively. It is stated that allegations of demand of Page No. 1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- dowry is false and frivolous. There has been no demand and whatever jewelry was given to complainant at the time of marriage, has been taken by her or returned. IO has obtained search warrants of the houses of accused persons and have also searched the lockers but no such jewelry as alleged has been found. It is submitted on behalf of the accused that, as per their assessment the value of the jewelry, other articles and expenses of marriage incurred by the father of complainant are not more than Rs.20 to Rs.25 Lakhs and accused and his/her family members are ready and willing to return the said amount i.e., Rs.25 Lakhs to the complainant in lieu thereof. During arguments, IO has placed on record one assessment sheet of the alleged articles/jewelries given at the time of marriage, which is approximately for Rs.55 Lakhs and as per fresh report of IO, it is alleged that bills of jewelry of worth approximately Rs.16 Lakhs and miscellaneous item bills of Rs.10 Lakhs have also been verified. Photograph and videograph of the marriage have not been provided by the accused, as per the report of the IO. It is stated that the assessment sheet showing articles of approximately Rs.55 Lakhs are false and fabricated as no basis of assessment, date of obtaining the old jewelry, rate and date of assessment of such rate has not been mentioned. It is further stated that, it is the complainant whose behavior is erratic and aggressive. Due to her behavior, she herself has left the family of accused and has sent a number of vulgar messages to accused Page No. 2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- persons which speaks for itself. All the jewelries which was given by the complainant, at the time of marriage, has been taken by her. Ld. Counsel for accused has relied upon two judgments, which are as under : 1. Varun Sharma Vs. State of Punjab, 2024 SCC OnlineP& H455, Order Dated 12.02.2024. 2. Apruva Kirti Mehta Vs. The State of Maharashtra, arising out of SLP (crl.) No. 15402-15403/2024. ARGUMENTS OF PROSECUTION AND COMPLAINANT On the contrary, prosecution has opposed the anticipatory bail application alleging that accused themselves have stated that jewelry worth Rs.20 Lakhs were given at the time of marriage however,the value of the jewelry is much more than that. Accused persons have placed all the jewelry articles at some other place and hiding the same. Complainant has provided all the bills of jewelry and miscellaneous expenses which have been verified by the IO. Complainant has been subjected to severe mental cruelty due to which she was forced to leave the house of her in-laws just after few days of marriage. All the accused persons are yet to be arrested, therefore, anticipatory bail application should be dismissed. Arguments have been heard at length. Before proceeding further, judgments relied upon by accused are perused thoroughly. In case Varun Sharma (Supra), court has laid down following principals, “ The Court laid the following principles: Page No. 3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- (a) Non-recovery of dowry articles/stridhan cannot ordinarily be a ground for declining a plea for anticipatory bail to the husband or his relatives; (b) The accused’s conduct is a relevant factor for considering such a plea. Such conduct would also include cooperation extended by the accused for recovery of dowry articles/stridhan, as ascertainable from the facts and circumstances of a given case; (c) In exceptional cases, if the peculiar and/or accentuating facts/circumstances of the case so warrant, a Court would be well within its discretion to pass a direction to the petitioner/accused to deposit in Court or remit to the complainant-wife an appropriate amount towards the Istri-dhan/dowry articles. It is neither possible nor desirable to enumerate a set of guidelines in this regard and a Court would have to exercise its judicial discretion based on facts and circumstances of the case.…” In another case Apruva Kirti Mehta (Supra), it has been held that, “That apart, the direction for payment was in the teeth of a plethora of decisions of this Court. We can profitably refer to a few of them, viz. Ramesh Kumar vs. State (NCT of Delhi); St. George Dsouza vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and Dilip Singh vs. State of M.P. & Anr.. Having regard to the principles of law laid down in the said decisions, inter alia, to the effect that the courts, exercising jurisdiction to grant bail/pre-arrest bail, are not expected to act as recovery agents for realization of dues of the complainant from the accused, the High Court should have independently applied its mind and arrived at a conclusion as to whether a case for grant of bail, on settled parameters, had been made out or not irrespective of whatever statement was made on behalf of the appellant before the Sessions Judge.” Page No. 4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- It is needless to say that, in the cases of cruelty and demand of dowry as well as not returning the dowry articles, the court has to look into the allegations in brief before proceeding further. It has been laid down in many cases as well as judgments mentioned above i.e., Apruva Kirti Mehta (Supra) and Varun Sharma (Supra) that it is the facts and circumstances of the case which determine the fate of the bail application and the discretion is always with the court to consider all the relevant aspects as well as conduct of the parties. Another factor should also be kept in mind, as to whether accused is ready and willing to return the dowry articles and stridhan or not. In the present case, there is a dispute with regard to the valuation of dowry articles and other miscellaneous articles. Accused has stated that, it is not more than Rs. 20 Lakhs however, complainant and her family has stated that the value of jewelry articles and other expenses are much more than that as they have spent more than Rs. 1 Crore on the marriage. However, they have allegedly given the list of articles worth approximately Rs, 80 lakhs. If the report given by the IO regarding verification of old jewelry is perused then, it is suffering from various lack of information like when such old jewelries were purchased, whether the valuation has been done according to the current prevailing rate or the rate prevailing at that time and what weightage has been given to the duration of time. None of the articles reflects their proposed or approximate date of purchase. Even the valuation of diamond is not mentioned in carats as well as prevailing rate of carat either current or the rate at the time of Page No. 5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- their purchase. Thus, the report furnished by IO cannot be said to be free from doubts, however, in my considered opinion, this is not the stage to comment upon the authenticity of the list provided by the IO which though is suffering from some defects. Such assessment and observation should be given by the concerned court where trial has to begun or who is dealing with the matter. The undertaking given by accused cannot be ignored that they are ready and willing to deposit a sum of Rs.25 Lakhs with the court. Whatsapp messages, which have been filed along with the application, have not been denied specifically though not admitted by the complainant. It is has been stated by the IO that accused have been interrogated and they have given certain reply as well. Thus, it is reflected that as and when accused was asked to join the investigation, they have joined. It has been laid down in the judgments relied upon by the accused i.e., Apruva Kirti Mehta (Supra) and Varun Sharma (Supra) that non-recovery of dowry articles/ stridhan cannot ordinarily be a ground for declining the plea for anticipatory bail to the husband of his relatives. Efforts for settlement/mediation in between the parties have also been initiated between the parties, however, of no result. None of the accused persons is stated to be having previous criminal antecedents they are stated to be having their permanent addresses/place of work/business which has been verified by the IO as correct. Considering the circumstances, therefore, I deem it appropriate that anticipatory bail application of the accused/applicant Page No. 6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- should be allowed. Accordingly, in the event of arrest applicant/accused Vaibhav Jain shall be released on bail on furnishing a personal bond in the sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- with one surety in the like amount to the satisfaction of arresting officer, subject to the following conditions :- (a) applicant shall join the investigation as and when required by the IO and shall cooperate in the investigation. (b)applicant shall not flee from the justice; (c) applicant shall not tamper with the evidence; (d) applicant shall not threaten or contact in any manner to the prosecution witnesses, (e) applicant shall not leave country without permission; (f) applicant shall convey any change of address immediately to the IO and the court; (g) applicant shall also provide his mobile number to the IO; It is clarified that nothing mentioned herein shall tantamount to expression of opinion on the merits of the case. With these observations, anticipatory bail application stands disposed of. Copy of this order be given dasti to the Ld. Counsel for applicant/accused. (PRASHANT KUMAR) ASJ (Electricity)/(N-W) Rohini Courts, Delhi 15.05.2025 Page No. 7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
