Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 12

CNR DLNW01003455202314 Jan 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 12 · 14 Jan 2025 · CNR DLNW010034552023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL,
NORTH WEST, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI
PRESIDED BY SH. SHIVAJI ANAND,
==============================================
UID No. / CNR No. DLNW01-003455-2023
MACT CASE No.380/2023
FIR No.1022/22, PS Mangolpuri
In the matter of :
1.
Ms. Sahana
W/o Sh. Gulzar Ali
R/o I-1080, Mangolpuri,
Rohini, Delhi.
…..Petitioner
Vs.
1.
Sh. Gautam
S/o Sh. Duli Chand
R/o B-345, Gali No.10,
Balbir Vihar, Delhi.
….Driver/R1
2.
Ms. Sushila Devi
W/o Sh. Hari Chand
R/o E-141, Mangolpuri, Delhi.
....Owner/R2
3.
HDFC ERGO General Insurance Company Ltd.
O/o 2/2A, Universal Insurance Building,
Asaf Ali Road, New Delhi.
....Insurer/R3
Date of institution of the DAR
: 13.04.2023
Date of final Arguments
: 11.11.2024
Date of Decision
: 14.01.2025
Appearance (s) : Sh. S N Thakur, Ld. Counsel for the petitioner.
None for R1 & R2.
Sh. S K Tyagi, Ld. counsel for R3.
J U D G M E N T / A W A R D
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 1 of 18
-- 1 of 18 --
1. Vide this judgment/award, I shall dispose off the Detailed
Accidental Report (
in short, the DAR) filed by the IO SI Bhagirath
Dabla in FIR No.1022/22, PS Mangolpuri, Delhi pertaining to the injury
of Sahana
(in short, the injured) in road accident.
FACTULAL POSITION AND PLEADINGS
2. The brief facts relevant for disposal of the present DAR petition
are that on 02.09.2022, at about 10:30 pm, the petitioner was crossing the
road near I block, Mother dairy booth, Mangolpuri road then suddenly
one offending motorcycle bearing registration no. DL-6SAR-1621 (in
short, the said vehicle) pulsor colour being driven by the respondent
no.1/driver in rash and negligent manner hit the petitioner. Due to the
accident, the petitioner suffered multiple injuries. Thereafter, she was
admitted by some public persons to Sanjay Gandhi Hospital, Manolpuri
where she was medically examined vide MLC No. 22918/2022 on
02.09.2022 and the doctor opined that petitioner sustained facture on left
foot and multiple injuries in her entire body.
3. The petitioner was then diagnosed in Sanjay Gandhi Hospital,
Avantika Multi Specialty Hospital, Rohi where doctor diagnosed
‘amputation below knee’ and multiple injuries in whole body. The
petitioner is attending to the doctors continuously and approximately
incurred expense on her medical treatment a sum of Rs.1,54,290/- during
the period between 03.09.2022 to 01.08.2023.
4. It is stated that IO was lodged an FIR bearing No.1022/2022, PS
Mangolpuri under Section 279/338 IPC was registered.
5. Written statement has been filed on behalf of R2 wherein it is
inter alia submitted that the present DAR is liable to be dismissed as the
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 2 of 18
-- 2 of 18 --
claim of the petitioner is not maintainable in the present form being
barred by law of limiation as the incident took place on 02.09.2022 and
claim petition /DAR was filed before the court on 13.04.2023 as per the
amended. Therefore, the present petition is not sustainable in the eyes of
law as barred by law of limitation, law of equity and justice.
6. It is further submitted that policy no.2320101175485000000
provided by the police is valid for the period 01.03.2022 to 28.02.2023
was issued in the name of Sh. Hashim for the offending vehicle wereas its
registration stands in the name of the petitioner.
7. The driver who was driving the offending vehicle was found
without holding driving license at the time of accident. The police filed
chargesheet under Section 279/338 IPC r/w Section 3/180 and 5/180
M.V.Act against respondent no.1 driver. The insured and driver both have
acted against the rules of M.V. Act as well as violated the policy terms
and conditions and therefore, the insured committed the breach and
hence, the respondent no.2 insurance company is not liable to indemnify
the insured and to pay any compensation.
8. It is further submitted that the accident took place was due to
negligence on part of the petitioner since she was crossing the road
negligently without taking necessary precautions and therefore, R-3
insurance company is not liable for any compensation. respondent no. 2 is
a house wife and studied till 7th standard only and she is the owner of the
offending vehicle. It is further submitted that on 27.04.2017 in the
afternoon, the respondent no.1 went to HDFC Bank situated at Ayodhya
Chowk, Sector-3, Rohini, Delhi for having some clerical work by using
the aforesaid offending vehicle and the respondents are the permanent
resident of back side street of the abovesaid bank and the said bank is
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 3 of 18
-- 3 of 18 --
situated almost at the corner of the main road in a congested area. It is
further submitted that on the day of accident, the respondent no.1 duly
parked the vehicle in front of bank and done his work within 5-10
minutes as he has to take some stamps on the NEFT and after getting free
from the bank, he came back to his duly parked car and sit inside the car.
All of a sudden, the petitioner hit his scooty from behind in the right side
mirror of the car and felt down alongwith his scooty.
9. It is further submitted that the vehicle of the respondent no.1 and 2
was duly insured with the respondent no.3 i.e. Royal Sunderam General
Insurance Company Ltd vide comprehensive insurance policy bearing
no.VPC0799587000100 having validity from 16.01.2017 to 15.01.2018.
10. No reply or Written Statements has been filed on behalf of the R-1
and R-2 nor they appeared. Accordingly, vide order dated 08.06.2023, R1
and order dated 24.07.2023, R-2 were proceeded ex-parte.
ISSUES:
11. After completion of pleadings, following issues were framed
by this Tribunal on 24.07.2023: -
1. Whether the petitioner Sahana W/o gulzar Ali
suffered injuries in road traffic accident on
02.09.2022 at about 10:30 PM, in front of Mother
Dairy, I Block, Mangolpuri, Delhi due to rash and
negligent driving of offending vehicle bearing no.
DL-6SAR-1621 which was being driven by its
driver Gautam @ Goldy S/o Sh. Duli Chand on the
said date, time and place? OPP.
2. Whether the petitioner/injured is entitled for
compensation, if so, to what amount and from
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 4 of 18
-- 4 of 18 --
whom? OPP.
3. Relief.
PETITIONER'S EVIDENCE
12. Thereafter, matter was listed for recording of petitioner's evidence
before Local Commissioner. In order to prove its case, petitioner no.1
Ms. Sahana has been examined as PW1 and tendered her evidence by
way of affidavit which is Ex.PW-1/1 bearing her signature at point A and
B and relied upon the following documents which are as follows:
1. Ex.PW-1/1 (OSR): Copy of Aadhar card petitioner.
2. Mark A PW-1/B Photocopy of Aadhaar Card of husband of
petitioner being photocopyt is exhibited and marked as Mark-A
(Objections raised by Ld. Counsel of Insurance company on Mark A: As
photocopy exhibited herewith not related to present case)
3. Ex.PW-1/2 (OSR): Copy of PAN Card of petitioner.
4. Ex.PW-1/3: Photocopy of M.L.C. of deponent
5. Ex.PW-1/4 (Colly.): Copy of Discharge/OPD card issued by
the hospital.
6. Ex.PW-1/5 (Colly.): Original copy of Medical Bills of
deponent.
7. Ex.PW-1/6 (In DAR) (Colly.): Photocopy of Charge sheet
13. In cross-examination by Ld. Counsel for R3, PW1 testified
that she is doing the work of stiching/switching. She is not an income tax
assessee. She further deposed that she incurred expenditure of Rs.
10,000/- in IPD account vide receipt no. 10687 dated 05.09.2022. She
denied the suggestion that she did not suffer injuries in the accident. She
further deposed that her statement was not recorded by the police official.
She admitted that the place of accident was a two-way road with divider
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 5 of 18
-- 5 of 18 --
without zebra crossing. She denied that she was crossing the road
negligently and the accident had taken place in the middle of the road.
She further denied the suggestion that the respondent no.1 driver was
driving the offending vehicle at normal speed and correct side of the road.
She deposed that her son admitted her in hospital.
14. Thereafter, petitioner's evidence was closed and matter was
listed for respondent's evidence.
RESPONDENT'S EVIDENCE:
15. Ms. Simarpreet Kaur, has come in witness box and has been
examined as R3W1 and tendered his evidence by way of affidavit
Ex.R1W1/A bearing his signature at point A and B and relied upon the
following documents which are as follows:
1. Copy of insurance policy is Ex.R3W1/1 (Colly.).
2. Notice under Order XII Rule 8 CPC is Ex.R3/W1/2
3. Postal receipts are Ex.R3W1/3 and Ex.R3W1/4.
4. Return envelops are Ex.R3W1/5 and Ex.R3W1/6.
FINDINGS:
16. I have heard ld. Counsel for the petitioner and have gone
through the testimony of P W 1 including the pleadings and the
documents. My issue wise findings in the case are as under :-
ISSUE NO.1
17. It is well settled that the procedure followed for proceedings
conducted by an accident tribunal is similar to that followed by a civil
court and in civil matters the facts are required to be established by
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 6 of 18
-- 6 of 18 --
preponderance of probabilities only and not by strict rules of evidence or
beyond reasonable doubts as are required in a criminal prosecution. The
burden of proof in a civil case is never as heavy as that is required in a
criminal case, but in a claim petition under the Motor Vehicles Act, this
burden is infact even lesser than that in a civil case. Reference in this
regard can be made to the propositions of law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Bimla Devi and others Vs. Himachal Road
Transport Corporation and others, reported in (2009) 13 SC 530, which
were reiterated in the subsequent judgment in the case of Parmeshwari
Vs. Amir Chand and others 2011 (1) SCR 1096 (Civil Appeal No.1082 of
2011) and also recently in another case Mangla Ram Vs. Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors., 2018 Law Suit (SC) 303.
18. In order to prove this issue, the petitioner has examined herself
as PW-1 to prove her case. Also, the Insurance Company has examined
one witness I.e R3W1 Ms. Simpranpreet Kaur, Deputy Manager, Legal
with HDFC Ergo General Insurance Co. Ltd. to prove their case. They
have taken the defence that the driver of the offending vehicle was not
holding valid Driving License. However, it still establishes that the
incident had occurred due to negligence of respondents. Therefore, the
case does not warrant any other best evidence. Keeping in view the facts
& evidence produced by the petitioner, it has proved on record that the
said accident has taken place due to the rash and negligent driving of the
offending vehicle being driven by respondent no.1, as a result of which,
the petitioner sustained injuries.
19. The FIR has been lodged against the respondent no.1 & 2 and
they have faced criminal charges of causing injuries by rash and negligent
driving in the said accident.
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 7 of 18
-- 7 of 18 --
20. In view of the aforesaid discussion and the evidence which has
come on record, it is held that the rashness and negligence on the part of
driver of the offending vehicle, which is clearly visible and as such, was
responsible not only for this accident, but also for everything that
followed thereafter. However, as the defence of No DL was taken by the
Insurance Company and on going through the evidence and douments
placed on record, it is hereby ordered that Insurance Company is liable to
the awarded amount. However, they are given recovery rights i.e to pay
the awarded amount and later on get it recovered from the respondents.
Accordingly issue no.1 is decided in favour of the petitioner and against
the respondents.
ISSUE NO. 2
21. As the issue no.1 has been proved in affirmative and in favour
of the petitioner, the petitioner has become entitled to be compensated for
the injuries suffered in the above accident, but the computation of
compensation and liability to pay the same are required to be decided.
22. In terms of provisions contained in Section 168 of the MV
Act the compensation which is to be awarded by this tribunal is required
to be 'just'. In the injury cases a claimant is entitled to two different kinds
of compensations i.e. pecuniary as well as non-pecuniary damages. The
pecuniary damages or special damages are those damages which are
awarded and designed to make good the losses which are capable of
being calculated in terms of money and the object of awarding these
damages is to indemnify the claimant for the expenses which he had
already incurred or is likely to incur in respect of the injuries suffered by
him in the accident. The non-pecuniary or general damages are those
damages which are incapable of being assessed by arithmetical
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 8 of 18
-- 8 of 18 --
calculations. The pecuniary or special damages generally include the
expenses incurred by the claimant towards his treatment, special diet,
conveyance, cost of nursing/ attendant, loss of income/earning capacity
etc. and the non-pecuniary damages generally include the compensation
for the mental or physical shock, pain and sufferings, loss of amenities of
life, marriage prospects and disfiguration etc. The above categories
falling under both the heads of compensation are not exhaustive in nature
but only illustrative. It is also necessary to state here that no amount of
money or compensation can put the injured/claimant exactly in the same
position or place where he was before the accident and an effort is to be
made only to reasonably compensate her or to put her almost in the same
place or position where she could have been if the alleged accident had
not taken place and this compensation is to be assessed in a fair,
reasonable and equitable manner. The object of compensating her is also
not to reward her or to make her rich in an unjust manner. It is also well
settled that the 'just' compensation to be awarded to the claimant has to be
calculated objectively and it may involve some guess work in calculating
the different amounts which the claimant may be entitled under the
different heads of compensation. Reference in this regard can be made on
some of important judgments on the subject like the judgment in the case
of R.D. Hattangadi Vs. Pest Control (India) Pvt. Ltd., AIR 1995 SC 755,
Arvind Kumar Mishra Vs. New India Assurance Company Limited,
(2010) 10 SCC 254 and Raj Kumar Vs. Ajay Kumar & Anr., (2011) 1
SCC 343.
23. In light of the above legal prepositions, the amount of
compensation which could be considered to be 'just' in the opinion of this
tribunal shall be as under:-
Medical or Treatment Expenses:
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 9 of 18
-- 9 of 18 --
24. Petitioner has deposed after the accident, she was taken to
Sanjay Gandhi Hospital Manolpuri, Delhi where no MLC was prepared.
Thereafter, MLC was prepared by the said Hospital where at the time of
medical examination. I have gone through the Ex.PW-1/5 and the
medical bills of deponent amounting to Rs. 1,54,290/- have been
furnished. Keeping in view of this bill, the petitioner is granted a sum of
Rs. 1,54,290/- under this head.
(ii) Pain and Suffering
25. PW-1 has examined herself in evidence. He was given
treatment in Sanjay Gandhi Hospital. Petitioner was having 5 %
Permanent Disability in relation to her left lower limb. It is not possible
to quantify the compensation admissible to injured for the shock, pain and
sufferings etc. which she actually suffered because of the above injuries,
but as stated above, an effort has to be made to compensate her for the
same in a just and reasonable manner. Hence, keeping in view the extent
and nature of the injuries suffered by injured and duration of the
treatment taken by her etc., an amount of Rs. 50,000/- is being awarded to
her towards pain and sufferings during the said period of her treatment
and immobility. Thus, she is awarded a total amount of Rs. 50,000/-
under this head.
26. Loss of Actual Earnings
In her affidavit Ex. PW-1/A, the petitioner has deposed that at the
relevant time, she was working as a tailor/stiching work and was earning
Rs. 15,000/- per month. Ld. Counsel for injured argued that the income of
injured as mentioned in her affidavit be considered in order to calculate
the compensation under the head of loss of income. However, she has not
placed any document to prove the same. Hence, As such, it would be
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 10 of 18
-- 10 of 18 --
appropriate that the monthly income of petitioner be assessed as per the
minimum wages payable to an skilled person in Delhi at the relevant
time. As per relevant notification, the minimum wages admissible to an
skilled person as on the date of accident i.e 02.09.2022 in the Delhi were
Rs. 20,019/- per month. Keeping in view the nature of injuries sustained
by the petitioner as well as her prolonged medical treatment, it could be
safely assumed that the petitioner would not have been able to resume her
work/ vocation for a period of 03 months at least. As such, the petitioner
is held entitled to a sum of Rs. 60,057/-
(Rs. 20,019- X 3). The said sum
is awarded to the petitioner under this head.
(iii) Conveyance, attendant charges and Special Diet
Petitioner has suffered loss of income and incurred money on injury,
medical treatment and special diet. However, he failed to place on record
any corroborative material in this regard. However, as per the bills
furnished by her, shows that he took treatment from 03.09.2022 to
01.08.2023 i.e for a period of 11 months. In view of the nature of injuries
sustained by her, she has visited hospital multiple times during the 11
months visit to hospital. Also petitioner has placed on record all the bills
and treatment details of injured which shows that due to disability of 5 %,
he must have kept attendant for a period of about 1 month atleast. Hence,
reasonably a sum of Rs. 20,000/- as attendant charges and Rs. 20,000/- is
awarded as conveyance charges and special diet. Hence, a sum of Rs.
40,000/- is awarded to the petitioner cumulatively under these heads.
27 Loss of future earnings due to disability
Petitioner claims in her affidavit Ex. PW1/A that he had become
permanently disabled from performing her most essential functions.
After amputation of her one left leg, she sustained 5 % of loss of his
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 11 of 18
-- 11 of 18 --
earning capacity.
28. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has laid down the law with regard to
assessment of future loss of earnings due to permanent disability in the
case of
Sidram Vs. The Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. 2022 (16) SCALE as follows:
“13. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent
disability on the actual earning capacity involves
three steps. The Tribunal has to first ascertain what
activities the claimant could carry on in spite of the
permanent disability and what he could not do as a
result of the permanent disability (this is also
relevant for awarding compensation under the head
of loss of amenities of life). The second step is to
ascertain his avocation, profession and nature of
work before the accident, as also his age. The third
step is to find out whether (i) the claimant is totally
disabled from earning any kind of livelihood, or (ii)
whether in spite of the permanent disability, the
claimant could still effectively carry on the activities
and functions, which he was earlier carrying on, or
(iii) whether he was prevented or restricted from
discharging his previous activities and functions, but
could carry on some other or lesser scale of activities
and functions so that he continues to earn or can
continue to earn his livelihood.
29. For example, if the left hand of a claimant is amputated, the
permanent physical or functional disablement may be assessed around 5
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 12 of 18
-- 12 of 18 --
% itself. If the claimant was a tailor, the actual loss of earning capacity
may virtually be 5 %, if she is not able to do tailoring work.
30. In view of the observation made by the Hon'ble Apex Court of
India in case titled
Sidram Vs. Divisional Manager, United India
Insurance Company (supra) the effect of permanent disability of the
injured has to be assessed in order to quantify the future loss of earnings
due to disability. Admittedly, petitioner has suffered 05% Permanent
Physical Impairment in relation to her left lower limb. The petitioner was
earning his livelihood by working as a tailor. Now, due to disability, she
would not be able to do the work of tailor very well, though she can still
do other sitting work of skilled labor itself. In the absence of any material
to the contrary, it would be appropriate to hold that the functional
disability of petitioner be assessed at 5 %. This Tribunal has already held
that petitioner is entitled for minimum wages as of skilled labour
amounting to Rs. 20,019/- per month at the relevant time. As far as the
age of petitioner at the time of accident is concerned, The Aadhar Card
reflects age of petitioner is 01.01.1962 was 60 years 8 months
(approximately). Therefore, in view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in case of
Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation & Anr.,(2009) 6 SCC 121, which has also been upheld by the
Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a recent judgment
dated 31.10.2017 given in the case of
National Insurance Company Ltd.
vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. SLP (Civil) No. 25590 of 2014, the multiplier of
'9' is held applicable for calculating the loss of future earnings of
petitioner arising out of his above disability. The petitioner is also entitled
to future prospects as per the observations made by a Three Judge Bench
of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Erudhaya Priya Vs. State Express Transport
Corporation Ltd., MANU/SC/0545/2020 [please see para 7 (b)].
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 13 of 18
-- 13 of 18 --
31. Thus, the loss of future earnings of petitioner due to her above injury and
permanent disability comes to is calculated as follows:
S.
No.
Head Amount (Rs.) Remarks
1 Monthly Income of injured
(A)
Rs. 20,019/-
2 Monthly loss of earning (B) 1000.95/- 5 % of (A)
3 Annual Loss of earning (C) 12,011.4/- (B) x 12 =
(C)
4 Multiplier @ 5
5 Total Loss of earnings (D) 60,057/- (C) x
5(multiplier)
= (D)
6 Add: Future prospects 10 % 6005.7/-
Total : 66,062.7/-
32. (v) Loss of General Amenities and Enjoyment of Life
As already mentioned above, there is sufficient evidence on record i.e.
disability certificate to establish that the petitioner is suffering from 5 %
Loco Motor Disability with regard to her lower limb. Considering the
aforesaid, it is quite apparent that petitioner would not be able to enjoy
general amenities of life after the said accident, during rest of her life and
her quality of life has been definitely affected. Hence, considering the
nature of injuries suffered by the petitioner, the yearly loss of general
amenities and enjoyment of life is considered to be for Rs. 20,000/- per
year and the same is multiplied with the multiplier of 5. Hence, she is
entitled to a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- towards loss of general amenities and
enjoyment of life to the petitioner.
33. Thus, the total compensation is assessed as under : -
S. No. Head Amount
1 Medical Expenses 1,54,290/-
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 14 of 18
-- 14 of 18 --
2 Pain and Suffering 50,000/-
3 Loss of actual earning 60,057/-
4 Loss of future earning due to disability 66,062.7
5 Conveyance/ Attendant charges and special diet 40,000/-
6 Loss of Amenities and Enjoyment of Life 1,00,000/-
Total 4,70,410/-
Issue No.3/Relief
34. The petitioner is thus entitled to a sum of Rs. 4,70,410/-(Rs.
Four Lacs Seventy Thousand Four Hundred Ten Only) along with
interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the DAR i.e.
13.04.2023 till actual payment. However, it is directed that the amount of
interim award and interest for the suspended period, if any, during the
course of this inquiry, shall be liable to be excluded from the above
amount and calculations of compensation.
LIABILITY
35. As already stated above, R-1 being the driver and R-2 being
owner of the offending vehicle, and also being vicariously liable for the
acts of R-1, are jointly and severally liable to pay the awarded amount of
compensation to petitioner. As the defence of ‘No DL’ was taken by the
Insurance Company and on going through the evidence and douments
placed on record, it is hereby ordered that Insurance Company is liable to
the awarded amount. However, they are given recovery rights i.e to pay
the awarded amount and later on get it recovered from the respondents.
However, since the offending vehicle was insured with R-3 at the time of
accident, therefore, R-3 is liable to indemnify R-1 and R-2 in respect of
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 15 of 18
-- 15 of 18 --
above liability. As such R-3 is directed to deposit the above award
amount within 30 days from the date of this Award by way of NEFT or
RTGS mode in the account of this Tribunal maintained with SBI, Rohini
Courts, Delhi under intimation to the petitioner/ injured and this Tribunal
in terms of the format for remittance of compensation as provided in
Divisional Manager Vs. Rajesh, 2016 SCC Online Mad. 1913 (and
reiterated by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the orders dated 16.03.2021 and
16.11.2021 titled as Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Pvt. Ltd. Vs.
Union of India & Ors) along with interest @ 9% per annum.
ISSUE No.3/ RELIEF:
36. Thus, in view of the aforesaid discussion, this tribunal awards
compensation of Rs. 4,70,410/-(Rs. Four Lacs Seventy Thousand Four
Hundred Ten Only) alongwith interest @ 9% per annum w.e.f the date of
filing of the DAR, i.e. 13.04.2023 till the date of actual payment to the
petitioner. Keeping in view the expenses incurred on the medical
treatment of the petitioner and the facts and circumstances, it is directed
that the entire amount of compensation be released to the petitioner.
Conditions :
- The payment will be made by the respondent/Insurance
Company by draft or cross cheques or through ECS in the name of the
petitioner in SBI, Rohini Courts Complex, Delhi as per the directions in
the award within 30 days of passing of the award failing which it will be
liable to 12 % interest from the date of this court.
- Concerned Manager, SBI, Rohini Courts is directed to
transfer the aforesaid amount in the MACT Account of the petitioner
only, on completing necessary formalities as per rules. It is further
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 16 of 18
-- 16 of 18 --
directed to keep the said amount in fixed deposit in the name of bank for
accrual fo interest thereupon, till the claimant approaches the bank for
disbursement as may be directed by the concerned court.
37. Concerned Manager, SBI, Rohini Court Branch is directed to
transfer the disbursed amount immediately to the petitioners in his
MACT saving bank accounts, on completing necessary formalities as per
rules.
38. Copy of this Award alongwith one photograph each, specimen
signatures, copy of bank passbook and copy of residence proof of the
petitioner, be sent to Nodal Officer of SBI, Rohini Court, Branch, Delhi
for information and necessary compliance.
39. The Bank(s) shall not permit any joint name(s) to be added in
the savings bank account or fixed deposit accounts of the petitioner(s) i.e.
the savings bank account(s) of the petitioner(s) shall be an individual
savings bank account(s) and not a joint account(s). The original fixed
deposit shall be retained by the SBI, Branch Rohini Courts, Delhi in safe
custody. However, the statement containing FDR number, FDR amount,
date of maturity and maturity amount shall be furnished by the bank to
the petitioner(s). The maturity amounts of the FDR(s) be credit by
Electronic Clearing System (ECS) in the savings bank account of the
petitioner(s) near the place of their residence. No loan, advance,
withdrawal or pre-mature discharge be allowed on the fixed deposits
without permission of this Tribunal.
40. Parties are directed to download digital copy of this award
from the website. Ahlmad is directed to send a copy of the award to
Ld. Metropolitan Magistrate concerned and Delhi Legal Services
Authority in view of Central Motor Vehicles (fifth Amendment) Rules,
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 17 of 18
-- 17 of 18 --
2022 [(Directions at serial nos. 39, 40 of Procedure for Investigation of
Motor Vehicle Accidents (under Rule 150A)]. Further Nazir is directed to
maintain the record in Form XVIII in view of Central Motor Vehicles
(fifth Amendment) Rules, 2022 [(Directions at serial no. 41 of Procedure
for Investigation of Motor Vehicle Accidents (under Rule 150A).
41. Ahlmad is also directed to e-mail an authenticated copy of the
award to the insurer as directed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in
WP (Civil) No. 534/2020 titled as Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co.
Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India & Ors. on 16.03.2021. Ahlmad shall also e-
mail an authenticated copy of the award to Branch Manager, SBI, Rohini
Courts for information.
42. Ahlmad is further directed to comply with the directions
passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in MAC APP No. 10/2021
titled as New India Assurance Company Ltd. Vs. Sangeeta Vaid & Ors.,
date of decision : 06.01.2021 regarding digitisation of the records.
43. Form V and IVB in terms of MCTAP are annexed herewith as
Annexure-A.
44. A separate file be prepared for compliance report by the Nazir
and put up the same on 07.10.2024.
45. File be consigned to record room after due compliance.
ANNOUNCED IN THE OPEN COURT
ON 14th Day Of January, 2025
(SHIVAJI ANAND)
ADJ-1+MACT, NORTH WEST,
ROHINI COURTS, DELHI
MACT Case No.380/2023 (FIR no.1022/2025)
Sahana Vs. Gautam & ors.
Page no. 18 of 18
-- 18 of 18 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.