Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 11

CNR DLNW01001856202314 Aug 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 11 · 14 Aug 2025 · CNR DLNW010018562023

Order Details: COPY OF ORDER
Pdf Text: 12
CS DJ 154/23
DEEPTI ASHWANI GUPTA Vs. SHOPAT RAI GUPTA
14.08.2025
Present: Sh. Naveen Parkash, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff with
plaintiff.
Sh. Abhimany Sharma, Ld. Counsel for defendant
no. 1 to 3.
Affidavit of witnesses of plaintiff are still not
reflecting on CIS, however reply to the application under Order
18 Rule 17 CPC is reflecting on CIS.
Submissions on the application of defendant under
Order 18 Rule 17 CPC are heard.
On 30.01.2025, matter was listed for evidence of the
plaintiff and on that day, none appeared for the defendant and
they were awaited till 12:35 pm and thereafter by proceeding
further under Order 17 CPC, plaintiff was discharged.
By way of the application, it is contended by
defendant no. 1 to 3 that their counsel could not appear because
he was suffering from fever and cough, as such, he requested to
his colleague, who appeared through videoconferencing before
this Court but due to the technical issue with the
videoconferencing of this court, the appearance put by him in the
chat box could not be recorded. It is submitted that copy of
medical prescription dated 30.01.2025 and screen shot of the
appearance has been filed with the application.
Ld. Counsel for plaintiff has opposed the application
stating that Sh. Abhimanyu Singh, Ld. Counsel for defendant had
appeared through videoconferencing in another matter in the
-- 1 of 3 --
..2..
Court of Ld. ASJ-03, North-West on the same very day i.e.
30.01.2025 and there was intentional non appearance of the
defendants to delay the matter. It is stated that copy of digitally
signed order mentioning the attendance of counsel in the
ordersheet has been filed with the reply.
The issues were settled in the matter on 02.02.2024
and plaintiff was asked to lead her evidence and on 29.05.2024,
she filed her affidavit and was present for her examination but
adjournment was prayed by Ld. Proxy Counsel appearing for
defendant stating that main counsel, Sh. Abhimanyu Sharma was
present in the court room but he had left the court room as was
having loose motions.
If the counsel for defendants was unable to attend the
court on 30.01.2025 for the cross examination of plaintiff then
appropriate application mentioning the grounds was to be filed
and any of the defendants by appearing in the court or the
associate could have filed the same. The defendants did not
adopt the requisite process and in the facts of the case non
appearance on behalf of defendants on 30.01.2025 as contended
by counsel for plaintiff may be intentional, however recognizing
the right of defendants to cross examine the plaintiffs for putting
their defence, a lenient view is taken so that matter may be
decided on merits especially where matter is still at the stage of
plaintiff evidence and plaintiff may be compensated for the delay
occurred in her case, the application is allowed and defendants
are granted one opportunity to cross examine the plaintiff subject
to compensation to the tune of Rs. 25000/- to the plaintiff by
them.
Ld. Counsel for defendants seeks time to pay the
-- 2 of 3 --
..3..
compensation so that witness may be cross examined as the
defendants have not come today.
As prayed, put up on [date withheld] for payment of
compensation and cross examination of PW-1 and remaining PE.
(SUNIL CHAUDHARY)
DJ-04/North-West
RHC/Delhi 14.08.2025
-- 3 of 3 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.