Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 10

CNR DLNW01000854202402 Sept 2024
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 10 · 02 Sept 2024 · CNR DLNW010008542024

Order Details: COPY OF ORDER
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. VIRENDER KUMAR BANSAL
PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE
NORTH WEST DISTRICT: ROHINI COURTS: DELHI
CNR No. DLNW01-000854-2024
RP No. 02/24
Renu Bala & Ors. v. BSES Yamuna Power Ltd.
02.09.2024
Present: None for the applicant.
Sh. Amit Gupta, Advocate for BSES/non-applicant,
through VC.
ORDER
The present Review Petition u/o. XLVII Rule 1 r/w
Section 114 & 151 of CPC has been preferred by the
appellant/applicant with respect to the judgment dated
21.12.2023 passed by my Ld. Predecessor, vide which the appeal
bearing PPA No. 01/2021 was decided, on the ground that the
court while deciding the said appeal under Public Premises Act
held in para 21 as follows:
“21. In view of these facts, the impugned order qua ‘Public
Premises’ which no longer remains a public premises after
the respondent took over the responsibility from erstwhile
DVB, cannot be sustained. Moreover, the respondent itself
is creating confusion by resorting to proceedings under the
Company’s Act by initiating proceedings before Ld.
ACMM, in addition to invoking jurisdiction of different
SDM’s qua the same property/premises, as was pointed out
by the appellants and no cogent answer/denial came from
respondents.”
2. Ld. Counsel for the appellant/applicant submitted that
while holding that the property in dispute no longer remains a
public premises after the respondent i.e. BSES took over the
Page 1 of 6
-- 1 of 6 --
responsibility from the erstwhile DVB. Hence, the impugned
order cannot be sustained. However, after reaching to this
conclusion that the respondent nowhere qualifies to fall into the
definition, which may lead to a conclusion that the said premises
in question is a public premises on the ground that respondent is
a company in which government does not have more than 50%
share and the respondent is a private company, cannot be equated
or treated to be a government company and, hence, the premises
is a public premises, but the court dismissed the appeal.
3. Ld. Counsel submitted that there is error apparent as
the court has already reached to the conclusion that the premises
in dispute is no longer a public premises, the appeal should have
been allowed. Ld. Counsel submitted that the order be reviewed
and instead of dismissing the appeal, the appeal be allowed and
the review petition be accordingly disposed of.
4. Ld. Counsel for the respondent/non-applicant BSES
submitted that Ld. Trial Court has rightly dismissed the appeal as
the Ld. Trial Court has observed that they are in unauthorized
possession, even otherwise, it is a public premises.
5. Ld. Counsel for the non-applicant submitted that the
premises in dispute falls within the definition of public premises
as defined u/s.2(3) of the Act. The flats were handed over to the
non-applicant herein with the right to use basis and the
ownership was never transferred to the non-applicant. The non-
applicant is merely a licensee of the Govt. of NCT of Delhi with
respect to the said flats in accordance with Delhi Electricity
Page 2 of 6
-- 2 of 6 --
Reforms Act, 2000 and Delhi Electricity (Transfer Scheme)
Rules, 2001. Ld. Counsel submitted that the Govt. of NCT of
Delhi, being the owner, has also appointed the SDMs of all Sub-
Divisions as Estate Officer u/s.3 of the Public Premises Act in
respect of the property in dispute. Ld. Counsel submitted that as
the flat in dispute is still on and under the control of the Govt. of
NCT of Delhi and the non-applicant is only a licensee, therefore,
the premises still falls within the ambit of public premises. It is
submitted that keeping in view all these facts, the court has
rightly dismissed the appeal. There is no merit in the review, the
same be dismissed.
6. After hearing the arguments and going through the
record, I find that my Ld. Predecessor vide order dated
21.12.2023 dismissed the appeal of the applicant herein. The
brief arguments that in para 21 of the judgment, the court has
specifically observed that premises in question is no longer a
public premises after the BSES i.e. the non-applicant took over
the responsibility of the premises in dispute from the erstwhile
DVB. And, thereafter, dismissed the appeal.
7. Order XLVII Rule 1 of CPC reads as under:
“1. Application for review of judgment.
(1) Any person considering himself aggrieved-
(a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed,
but from which no appeal has been preferred,
(b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed,
or
(c) by a decision on a reference from a Court of Small
Causes,
and who, from the discovery of new and important
matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due
Page 3 of 6
-- 3 of 6 --
diligence was not within his knowledge or could not be
produced by him at the time when the decree was passed
or order made, or on account of some mistake or error
apparent on the face of the record of for any other
sufficient reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree
passed or order made against him, may apply for a
review of judgment to the Court which passed the decree
or made the order.”
8. From the bare perused of the same, it is clear that if the
error is apparent on the face of record, then the review is
maintainable but if one has to go into detail for finding out the
error that it is not permissible u/o. XLVII Rule 1 of CPC.
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India discussed the law on review in
the case of
Kamlesh Verma v. Mayawati, (2013) 8 SCC 320, and
summarize the same as follows:
“16. Thus, in view of the above, the following grounds of
review are maintainable as stipulated by the statute:
(A) When the review will be maintainable: -
(i) Discovery of new and important matter or evidence
which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within
knowledge of the petitioner or could not be produced by
him;
(ii) Mistake or error apparent on the face of the record;
(iii) Any other sufficient reason.
The words "any other sufficient reason" has been
interpreted in Chhajju Ram v. Neki, AIR 1922 Privy
Council 112 and approved by this Court in Moran Mar
Basselios Catholicos v. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius
& Ors., (1955)1 SCR 520, to mean "a reason sufficient on
grounds at least analogous to those specified in the rule".
The same principles have been reiterated in Union of India
v. Sandur Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. & Ors., 2013(3)
Recent Apex Judgments (R.A.J.) 436 : JT 2013(8) SC 275.
(B) When the review will not be maintainable :-
(i) A repetition of old and overruled argument is not
enough to reopen concluded adjudications.
(ii) Minor mistakes of inconsequential import.
(iii) Review proceedings cannot be equated with the
original hearing of the case.
(iv) Review is not maintainable unless the material error,
manifest on the face of the order, undermines its soundness
Page 4 of 6
-- 4 of 6 --
or results in miscarriage of justice.
(v) A review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby
an erroneous decision is re-heard and corrected but lies
only for patent error.
(vi) The mere possibility of two views on the subject
cannot be a ground for review.
(vii) The error apparent on the face of the record should
not be an error which has to be fished out and searched.
(viii) The appreciation of evidence on record is fully within
the domain of the appellate court, it cannot be permitted to
be advanced in the review petition.
(ix) Review is not maintainable when the same relief
sought at the time of arguing the main matter had been
negatived.”
9. In view of the above judgment, it is clear that if any
mistake or error is apparent on the face of the record, then review
is maintainable. In the present case, as pointed out and as
reflected from the order, the court in para 21 of the judgment has
observed as follows:
“21. In view of these facts, the impugned order qua ‘Public
Premises’ which no longer remains a public premises after
the respondent took over the responsibility from erstwhile
DVB, cannot be sustained. Moreover, the respondent itself
is creating confusion by resorting to proceedings under the
Company’s Act by initiating proceedings before Ld.
ACMM, in addition to invoking jurisdiction of different
SDM’s qua the same property/premises, as was pointed out
by the appellants and no cogent answer/denial came from
respondents.”
10. From this paragraph, it is clear that the court has
reached to the conclusion that the premises in dispute is no
longer a public premises as defined under the Act. Once it is
held that premises in dispute is not a public premises and does
not fall within the ambit of the public premises as defined under
the Act, the proceedings under the Act cannot continue and the
Estate Officer also does not get any jurisdiction under the Act to
decide with respect to the premises in dispute. Therefore, in the
Page 5 of 6
-- 5 of 6 --
last paragraph, instead of dismissing the appeal, the appeal
should have been allowed. It is the error apparent on the face of
the record. The review is, therefore, allowed and the paragraph
22 of the order dated 21.12.2023 is modified. It be read as
follows:
“22. In view of above discussion and considering the
entire gamut of facts and circumstances, the appeal is
hereby allowed.”
11. The review application is, accordingly, disposed of.
File be consigned to Record Room.
Announced in the open Court
today i.e. 2nd September, 2024
(Virender Kumar Bansal)
Principal District & Sessions Judge (NW)
Rohini Courts, Delhi (sb)
Page 6 of 6
-- 6 of 6 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.