Full Order Text
Interim Order 3 · 26 Apr 2024 · CNR DLNW010003582024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 23 CS DJ 51/24 ANAND PADIA Vs. SUSHILA JIAN 26.04.2024 Present: Sh. Shrey Gupta, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff. Sh. Shubham Singh, Ld. Proxy Counsel for defendants. The defendants were granted time to file written statement within one week vide order dated 23.02.2024. The defendants have not filed the written statement till date. The written statement is filed by the counsel appearing for defendants today along with one application for condonation of delay in its filing. Copy is supplied to counsel for plaintiff. Ld. Counsel for plaintiff stated that he is ready to argue the application today itself. Submissions are heard. The reason mentioned in the application due to which the written statement could not be filed within time granted is that time was sought on 23.02.2024 to file the written statement as defendants were traveling at that point of time and thereafter there was some seepage problem at the office of the counsel for defendants due to which few case files were damaged and the computer/desktop wherein the written statement was drafted was damaged too and hence the defendants could not file the same. It is averred that defendants also recently shifted to a new place in DecemberJanuary 2024 due to which whole house was not properly set and the spare set of the file could not be located due to which they also took time in finding the set of the -- 1 of 3 -- ..2.. suit and the written statement could not be prepared again and filed on time. Ld. Counsel for plaintiff opposed the application stating that no documents have been filed with the application and had he been contacted by opposite counsel to supply the set of documents again if defendants were unable to find the same, he could have supply the set of documents to enable the defendants to file the written statement well within time. It is further submitted that defendants have not approached the court for extension of time if they were unable to file written statement within time granted by the court. The averment about shifting of the address by the defendants in DecemberJanuary 2024 is immaterial as the summons were served upon them on 25.01.2024 and one week time was granted to them to file written statement on 23.02.2024. If the written statement was prepared on the computer / desktop by Ld. Counsel for defendants to whom the plaint with documents was supplied, then there is no occasion that the set of documents was to be located at the addresses of the defendants. Ld. Counsel for defendants have not filed affidavit or any document to show that his computer / desktop was damaged, thus, the reasons mentioned in the application do not inspire trust, however considering the facts of the case, a liberal approach is taken so that matter may be decided on merits especially where the plaintiff may be compensated monetarily for the delay in his case, the delay in filing the written statement is condoned subject to payment of compensation of Rs. 25,000/ to the plaintiff. Put up on 09.08.2024 for payment of compensation, -- 2 of 3 -- ..3.. filing of replication if any, completion of pleadings, filing of documents in original if any, admission/denial of documents and settlement of issues. (SUNIL CHAUDHARY) DJ04/NorthWest RHC/Delhi 26.04.2024 -- 3 of 3 --
