Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 23 Mar 2024 · CNR DLNT030027792023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. 23.03.2024 ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall decide the application u/o 7 rule 11 r/w section 151 CPC moved on behalf of the defendants no.2. Argument was already heard. BRIEF FACTS OF THE PRESENT CASE AS PER PLAINT 2. Brief facts of the present case are that, plaintiffs are member of Revanta CGHS Ltd. now known as Aman Apartment, Sector-13, Rohini, Delhi (hereinafter referred as Said Society). It is further averred that the defendant no.1 & 2 are permanent resident of Aman Apartment, Sector-13, Rohini, Delhi and Defendant no.3 is the president of Aman CGHS Ltd. and is permanently resided at the respective address mentioned in the memo of party. It is averrred that defendant no. 4, being a civic agency, Defendant No. 5 is responsible for maintaining, and supply of electricity. It is further averred that since the ownership & possession of the Said Flat, plaintiffs has fundamental rights to enjoy the easementary rights viz Right of Air, Right of Water, Right of Sunlight, Right of common area etc. associated with the said Flat in terms of sanctioned plan of said society passed by DDA and duly cared by defendant no. 4 on regular basis. It is further averred that unaware of criminal conspiracy hatched by the defendant No.1 & 2 in collusion with defendant No.3 with a sole intention to deceive and usurp the plaintiff's rights associated with the said flats, had malafidely, dishonestly, fraudulently prepared a false document i.e. undated, unstamped CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 1 of 11 -- 1 of 11 -- NOC in favour of defendant no.4 for installation of elevator and by falsely showing the alleged NOC issued with the consent of the residents of Aman CGHS Ltd. It is further averred that plaintiff no.1 by smelling the cunningness of the defendant No.1, 2 & 3 have served the legal notice dt. 07.11.2023 on defendants through counsels Sh. Anand Parkash Jain & Sh. Punit Jain via speed post by requesting them to remove an illegal construction, electricity connection etc. for installation of said elevator along with damages and cost towards sending of legal notice, within a period of 15 days of receipt of this notice. It is further averred that defendants, after receiving the abovesaid legal notice, have replied in an affirmative way and further assured the plaintiffs that neither they have raised any illegal construction for installation of elevation near the said flats nor they got the electricity connection. It is further averred that surprisingly on 20.12.2023, defendant no. 1 to 3 along with the labours came with some heavy construction equipment like hammer/ heavy machinery, laborer etc. for demolishing the old structure and to raise an unauthorized- construction for elevator which severely damaged the plaintiff’s property, drainage system, IGL pipe line as well as obstruct the easementary rights attached with the said flats and further caused threat to the life and liberty of plaintiffs family members which goes to such an extent that any untoward incident may occurred. It is further averred that plaintiffs immediately approached the SHO, PS KN Katju Marg and further called the PCR by dialing 112 number at 11.21 am & 11:37 am on 20.12.2023 but neither the PS KN Katju Marg nor PCR did take any action against the wrongdoer, on the contrary, defendant no.1 to 3 was directed to commence an unauthorized construction on 23.12.2023. Moreover, plaintiffs also approached the MCD regarding an CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 2 of 11 -- 2 of 11 -- unauthorized construction but they also did nothing. It is further averred that defendant no.1 & 2, being resident of Flat No A-20, TF & Flat No. A 24, TF of said society, malafidely in collusion with defendant no.3 resident of Flat No. A-36, TF of said society, have deliberately created nuisance by raising an illegal construction and further obtaining the illegal electricity connection from defendant no. 5 for installing a lift without having sanctioned plan from defendant no. 4 as well as non obtaining the consent from the neighbouring residents which severely violated the easementary rights of the residents as well as defacing the said society. It is further averred that the Plaintiffs along with other residents of the said society contacted and had word with the defendants many times but the defendant no.1 to 3 deliberately avoided the plaintiffs and tried to linger on the issue on one pretext or the others. It is further averred that defendants have no locus standi to indulge in such an illegal activity for causing a wrongful gain to defendants and further cause a wrongful loss to plaintiffs. The abovesaid acts amounts to a criminal breach of trust for which defendants shall be held responsible to make good the loss suffered to plaintiffs. It is further averred that the plaintiff’s has requested the defendants many a times not to indulge in such type of practice but the defendants has finally refused to do so hence the present suit. 3. On the basis of averment mentioned in the plaint, Plaintiff claimed following reliefs:- A). to pass a decree of mandatory injunction by directing the defendant no. 1 to 3 for immediately stopping the demolition of old structure near the said flats and to restore the damaged portion to its original shape as shown in the photograph near the said flats of the society, be passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 3 of 11 -- 3 of 11 -- b) to pass a decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendants, his agents, servants, family members etc. from raising an unauthorized construction for installing an elevator without having sanctioned plan from defendant no. 4 and further interfering into peaceful and vacant possession near the said flats; forcibly, illegally and with the help of his agents, servants and family members etc. in any manner whatsoever, be passed in favour of plaintiffs and against the defendant with costs, in the interest of justice; c) to pass a decree of mandatory injunction by directing the defendant no.5 not to install an electric connection without having sanctioned plan from defendant no. 4/ NOC from the neighbouring residents of the said society, be passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. D) to pass a decree of mandatory injunction by directing the defendant no.1, 2& no.3 to remove an illegal construction for installing a lift without sanctioned plan from defendant no. 4 / NOC from the neighbouring residents, be passed in favour of the plaintiffs and against the defendants. E) to award the cost of litigation in favour of the plaintiff against the defendants. f) any other relief which this Hon'ble court deems fit and proper may kindly be granted in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. BRIEF FACTS OF THE APPLICATION FILED U/o 7 Rule 11 CPC BY THE DEFENDANT NO. 2 4. The brief facts of the present application is that the suit filed by the plaintiff is based upon conjectures and surmises and the plaintiffs have deliberately and intentionally suppressed the material facts from the Hon'ble court in order to procure a favorable order in their favor. CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 4 of 11 -- 4 of 11 -- It is averred that the plaintiff has mislead the Hon'ble court by stating that the defendant no.1 and 2 conspired with the defendant no.3 and prepared a forged and fabricated document i.e. the NOC in favour of the defendant no.4. Moreover, the defendant no.3 i.e. the President of the RWA has already filed his WS in the court where in he has specifically stated that the defendant no.3 in the capacity of the President of the society has issued the NOC for the installation of the lift after carefully considering the grievance and the hardships of the residents of the society (Aman Apartments). This clearly shows that the plaintiffs are misleading the Hon'ble court. It is further averred that the plaintiffs have mislead the Hon'ble court by stating in para no. 9 of their plaint, that the defendant no. 1 & 2 in collusion with the defendant no.3 have raised an illegal construction and had also obtained the illegal electricity connection from the defendant no.5 and had further alleged that the applicant does not even have the sanctioned plan from the defendant no.4 (MCD). On the contrary the applicants have not raised any illegal construction (same is evident from the photographs of the site Annexed along with the WS) nor they have obtained any illegal electricity connection from the defendant no.5 as alleged by the plaintiffs. Further, the defendant no. 4 in their Status report has clearly stated that they have issued the NOC to the Defenant no. 1 and 3 for the installation of lifts. And as such from these facts it is very much evident that the plaintiffs are misleading the Hon'ble court by presenting false, frivolous and baseless pleadings which should not be entertain by the Hon'ble court. It is further averred that it is significant to mention here that the Hon'ble court in order to ascertain the true facts of the case had directed the MCD vide its order dated 18/01/2024 to file the status report in order to CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 5 of 11 -- 5 of 11 -- ascertain "whether MCD has granted sanction for installation of lift in the suit property". And in the status report so filed by the MCD on 1/02/2024 they have clearly stated that "The permission for installation of lift sought by the owners of flat No. A-19, A 20 & A 24 of the Aman Apartment was granted by the MCD after following the due process of law and as per policy for the installation of the lift". And thus negates the frivolous contentions of the plaintiff's that the applicants are constructing the lift without having the sanction plan/NOC. It is further averred that from the contentions so raised above it is very much evident that the plaintiffs have not approached the Hon'ble court with clean hands as they have deliberately and intentionally suppressed the material facts from the Hon'ble their favor. Hence, this application. It is prayed that the court may kindly be pleased to dismiss the suit so filed by the plaintiff as per the provision of Order VII Rule XI CPC, as they have not approached the Hon'ble court with clean hands. REPLY ON BEHALF OF NON-APPLICANT/PLAINTIFF TO THE APPLICATION U/O 7 R 11 CPC 5. It is submitted that all the Facts, averments, contentions, allegations, statements and submissions made by the Applicant/Defendants in the aforesaid application are specifically denied at the very outset unless admitted herein under. It is submitted that applicant puts to strict proof how the plaintiff procured a favourable order from the Hon'ble Court by suppressing the material facts. Moreover, perusal of entire application fails to disclose the maintainability of present application and is beyond the scope of order 7 Rule 11 CPC. Therefore, the present application deserves to be CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 6 of 11 -- 6 of 11 -- dismissed with heavy costs. It is further submitted that applicant puts to strict proof regarding the alleged averment. Moreover, registered RWA of Aman Appartment, Sector-13, Rohini, Delhi, vide Letter dt. 21.12.2023, have specifically mentioned that they have not issued any NOC in favour defendant no. 4 MCD for installation of lift for the simple reason is that structure stability of the society is weak and it may cause heavy damage to the society. Therefore, the present application deserves to be dismissed with heavy costs. Copy of registered RWA Letter dt. 21.12.2023 of Aman Appartment, Sector-13, Rohini, Delhi is already attached. It is further submitted that applicant keeps on changing his stance on one hand applicant alleges there was no construction and no electricity connection etc. on the other hand applicant demolishes the old structure by digging the common area as shown in the photographs filed with plaint, applied for the electricity connection as mentioned in WS filed by TPDDL meter, obtained NOC from MCD without site verification as well as structure stability certificate on the basis of forged and fabricated NOC issued by self declared president of the society i.e. defendant no.3 herein. Therefore, the present application deserves to be dismissed with heavy costs. 3 D animation for installation of lift is already attached. It is submitted that applicant keeps on changing his stance on one hand applicant alleges due process of law has been complied while granting conditional permission by MCD on the other hand applicant fails to bring on record the requisite permissions, certificate, coment viz structure stability certificate, fire safety norms. consent from the residents of the society, non hindrance of easementry rights, sanctioned plan from DDA, how far the lift from blind wall, site verification report, inspection report, NOC from registered welfare society ete.. In Catena of Judgments Hon'ble CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 7 of 11 -- 7 of 11 -- Supreme Court held that The who approaches the court must come with clean hand". It is worth to mention here that applicants admittedly have different versions and keep on changing his stance. Therefore, the present application deserves to be dismissed with heavy costs. It is submitted that the present application U/O 7 Rule 11 CPC deserve to be dismissed with exemplary cost. It is prayed that this Hon'ble Court may graciously be dismiss the present application U/O 7 Rule 11 CPC with exemplary cost, in the interest of justice and to pass any other or further orders as this Hon'ble Courts deems fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case, in favour of Plaintiff and against the defendant. ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS 6. In the case in hand essence of plaintiffs case is that defendant No.1 and 2 in collusion with defendant No.3 with intention to deceive and usurp the plaintiffs right i.e. right of Air, Right of Water, Right of Sun Light right of common area had malafidely, dishonestly, fraudulently prepared a false document i.e. undated, unstamped NOC in favour of defendant no.4 for installation of elevator and by falsely showing the alleged NOC issued with the consent of the residents of Aman CGHS Ltd. It is further case of plaintiff that defendant No.1 and 2 is doing unauthorised construction of elevator without any sanctioned plan obtained from defendant No.4. It is further case of plaintiff that defendant No.1 and 2 has been installing elevator without taking consent of neigbouring residents which severely violated the easementary right of resident as well as defacing the above society. It is further case of the plaintiff that due to the illegal construction being done by defendants wrongful loss was caused to plaintiff. It is further case of the CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 8 of 11 -- 8 of 11 -- plaintiff that due unauthorised construction of elevator plaintiffs property was damaged. 7. It is relevant to note that in the case in hand status report was filed by defendant No.4 /MCD. As per status report permission for installation of elevator was granted by the MCD after following due process of law and as per policy for installation of lift. In the case in hand plaintiffs have alleged that defendant No.1 and 2 in collusion and conspiracy with defendant No.3 have malafidely, dishonestly and fraudulently prepared a false NOC in favour of defendant No.4 for installation of elevator. However, plaintiffs have not filed any material particulars in the plaint regarding collusion and conspiracy between plaintiff and defendant. It is settled law that allegation of collusion and conspiracy must be supported by necessary particulars and vague and general averment to the effect that there was conspiracy or collusion is not suffice to show cause of action in favour of plaintiffs regarding any collusion or conspiracy. It is settled law that in the case of collusion or conspiracy the parties pleading it must set forth full material particulars and vague and general allegation regarding conspiracy and collusion is not suffice. As discussed above said in the case in hand defendant No.4/MCD had filed status report stating that permission for construction of elevator was granted. There is in fact a presumption that public authority has acted bonafide and in good faith. The above presumption can no doubt be rebutted by the person making the charge but only on cogent and satisfactory material. However, in the case in hand plaintiff has made general and vague allegation regarding conspiracy and CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 9 of 11 -- 9 of 11 -- collusion which in the view of Court does not give rise of cause of action in favour of plaintiffs and against the defendants. 8. It is also relevant to note that plaintiff has alleged the violation of fundamental right of enjoyment of easementary right i.e. right of air, right of water, right of sun light, right of common area as MCD has granted NOC/permission for installation of lift. However, in the view of court above allegations mentioned in the plaint is highly vague in nature as plaintiff has not mentioned material particulars as to how and to what extent easementary right is violated due to installation of lift. 9. Moreover, as discussed above said no material particular is pleaded in the plaint to show conspiracy or collusion or malafide or fraudulent intention of defendants regarding obtaining NOC/permission from MCD for installing elevator in the suit property. In the view of the vague and general allegation is not enough to show cause of action in favour of plaintiff. There is nothing material on record or any material particulars mentioned in the plaint to show that NOC/permission was obtained from MCD fraudulently. There is no material particulars to show that above permission/NOC was a false document. There is also no material particulars mentioned in the plaint to show that defendants have violated any condition of the policy notified by MCD/DDA regarding installation of lift in above apartment. 10. Considering the above facts and circumstances, court is of the view that no cause of action is made out in favour of plaintiff as no individual right of plaintiffs have infringed because of installation of lift in the suit property particularly keeping in view the fact that MCD has granted CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 10 of 11 -- 10 of 11 -- the sanction/permission for installation of lift to defendants in the suit premises. 11. In view of above discussion the present suit / plaint is rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. File after due compliance be consigned to Record Room. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. Announced in the open court on 23.03.2024. (Rakesh KumarII) JSCC/ASCJ/Gudn. Judge North, Rohini Courts, Delhi/23.03.2024 CS SCJ 1441/23 Atul Garg Vs. Preeti Grewal & Ors. Page No. 11 of 11 -- 11 of 11 --
