Full Order Text
Interim Order 11 · 13 Feb 2025 · CNR DLNT030016512023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 32 CS SCJ840/23 RASHIDA BEGUM Vs. ATIF KHAN ` 13.02.2025 Present: None. Matter is at the stage of orders on application under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC. It was submitted on behalf of the applicant / Defendant that there is delay in filing the written statement as the previous counsel of the Defendant assured the Defendant that he would file the WS within stipulated time. However, the same was not filed. It was further submitted that the same is reflected from order dated 23.11.2023 wherein time was sought to file WS on the ground that file was sent to Tis Hazari Court. Thereafter, when Defendant confronted the previous counsel, he misbehaved with the Defendant. Consequently, previous counsel was changed. Further, delay is not intentional and great prejudice will be caused to the Defendant if the present application is not allowed. Per contra, in reply to the present application, it is submitted on behalf of the Plaintiff that there is a delay of 400 days in filing the WS and the present application has been filed mainly to harass plaintiff. Plaintiff has further relied upon Judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court namely Col Ashish Khanna SM Retd. Vs Delhi Gymkhana Club and Ors. CS (OS) 171/2022 and submits that in view of the Judgment, delay cannot be condoned where the WS is filed beyond 120 days. Arguments heard. Record perused. Perusal of record shows that Defendant was served on 11.08.2023 and appearance was made by the Defendant on 05.09.2023. On 23.11.2023, it was submitted by Ld. Counsel for defendant that he had inadvertently sent the file to Tis Hazari Courts and would file the WS during the course of the day. On 08.02.2024, right to file WS was closed since no WS was filed. Thereafter, matter was fixed for PE, however, no PE was led on 22.04.2024 and 15.07.2024. On 03.10.2024, the present application was filed by the Defendant. It is a settled law that matter shall be decided on merits and not on technicalities. Further, Defendant shall not suffer due to negligence by the previous counsel. The abovesaid Judgment relied upon by the Plaintiff on the point that delay cannot be condoned beyond 120 days is distinguishable from the present facts as the Judgment -- 1 of 2 -- -2- CS SCJ840/23 RASHIDA BEGUM Vs. ATIF KHAN pertains to the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 2018, which are applicable to the original side of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court. The same is clear from Rule 4 (e), Chapter I of the said rules which provides that “‘The Court’ or ‘This Court’ means the Delhi High Court.” In the present case, grave prejudice will be caused to the Defendant if the delay is not condoned. Otherwise also, for complete and effective adjudication of the case, defence becomes necessary. The same is in consonance with the Judgment of Honble Supreme Court namely Kailash Vs. Nanhku & Ors. AIR 2005 SUPREME COURT 2441, wherein it was held as under: “Considering the object and purpose behind enacting Rule 1 of Order VIII in the present form and the context in which the provision is placed, we are of the opinion that the provision has to be construed as directory and not mandatory. In exceptional situations, the court may extend the time for filing the written statement though the period of 30 days and 90 days, referred to in the provision, has expired.” Further, it is a settled law that where delay could be compensated in costs, the same shall be done. Therefore, in the present case, though there is an inordinate delay of almost 1 year, however, the defendant shall not be prejudiced due to the fault of the previous counsel. Further, the matter is at the initial stage, where no evidence has been led till date. Thus, in view of the above discussion and citations, the present application is allowed, subject to cost of Rs. 6000/- payable to the Plaintiff. Be taken up for further proceedings on 07.05.2025. (ANKITA BHATIA) CIVIL JUDGE (NORTH) ROHINI/DELHI/13.02.2025 -- 2 of 2 --
