Full Order Text
Interim Order 12 · 17 Aug 2026 · CNR DLNT030014472024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 34 CS SCJ 932/24 RAM BIHARI Vs. OM PRAKASH CNR No. DLNT-03001447204 17.08.2026 Present: Ms. Renu Saini, Ld. Proxy Counsel for the plaintiff. None for the defendant. Matter is listed for orders on application of plaintiff u/o 6 rule 17 CPC r/w Section 151 CPC seeking amendment of plaint. Vide separate order of even date, the application stands allowed subject to cost of Rs. 5000/ payable by the plaintiff to the defendant. Amended plaint is taken on record. Plaintiff is directed to pay deficient court fees within 30 days from today. Defendant is at liberty to file amended WS within 30 days from the date of this order. Put up for further proceedings on 04.11.2026. (SAKSHI JAISWAL) CIVIL JUDGE (NORTH) ROHINI/DELHI/17.08.2026 -- 1 of 8 -- -1- 34 CS SCJ 932/24 RAM BIHARI Vs. OM PRAKASH CNR No. DLNT-03001447204 17.08.2026 ORDER 1. Vide this order, the court shall decide the application of plaintiff u/o 6 rule 17 CPC r/w Section 151 CPC seeking amendment of plaint. 2. Briefly stated, the case of the plaintiff as set out in the plaint, is that the plaintiff had purchased the property i.e. Plot bearing no. 5B, Area measuring 250 sq. yds out of khasra no. 16/24, situated in the area of village Swaroop Nagar,Abadi known as gali no. 14, Swaroop Nagar, Delhi-110042 (hereinafter called the suit property) from defendant no. 1 for total consideration of Rs. 1,70,000/-, which according to him, was paid in full and final settlement in the year 2001. It is pleaded that defendant no. 1 thereafter handed over peaceful possession of the suit property to the plaintiff and assured him that the necessary property documents would be executed in his favour and the previous chain of title documents would also be handed over. 3. It is further pleaded that, when the plaintiff subsequently requested defendant No. 1 to execute the documents, defendant No. 1 informed him that the property was involved in litigation and assured him that the documents would be executed after the litigation was decided in his favour. According to the plaintiff, in June 2024 defendant No. 1 informed him that he had succeeded in the said litigation. The plaintiff thereafter requested defendant No. 1 to execute the necessary documents in his favour, but -- 2 of 8 -- -2- defendant No. 1 allegedly refused to do so on the ground that the value of the property had increased. 4. The plaintiff has further pleaded that he has remained in possession of the suit property since 2001 and has been running a general store therein for about 23 years. It is also alleged that after the plaintiff issued a legal notice to defendant No. 1, defendant No. 1 threatened him with dispossession and also attempted to interfere with the electricity supply and forcibly demolished the general store. 5. The suit, as originally instituted, was for a decree of permanent and mandatory injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with the plaintiff’s peaceful possession in the suit property and from dispossessing the plaintiff except in accordance with law. 6. An application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC was earlier filed by the defendants. The said application was dismissed. However, while passing the said order, the Court observed that a question arose as to how the present suit would be maintainable without seeking the appropriate relief of specific performance and declaration of ownership. 7. The plaintiff has consequently sought amendment of the plaint so as to incorporate a prayer for specific performance, directing defendant No. 1 to execute the necessary sale documents in respect of the suit property in favour of the plaintiff, along with consequential declaratory relief. 8. The proposed amendment has been opposed by the defendants. It is contended that the plaintiff has not filed any document in support of the alleged transaction. It is further -- 3 of 8 -- -3- contended that even if the averments contained in the plaint are taken to be correct, the alleged agreement/transaction pertains to the year 2001 and the proposed relief of specific performance is hopelessly barred by limitation. It is also submitted that there is no document evidencing any agreement to sell in favour of the plaintiff. 9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 10. The scope of consideration at the stage of an application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC is limited. The Court has to examine whether the proposed amendment is necessary for determining the real controversy between the parties and whether it would result in introducing a new and inconsistent case. The Court is ordinarily not required, at this stage, to adjudicate upon the ultimate merits of the claim sought to be introduced. 11. In the present case, the proposed relief of specific performance is founded upon the very same transaction which already constitutes the basis of the plaintiff’s suit. The plaintiff has already pleaded payment of 1,70,000/- to defendant No. 1, ₹ delivery of possession, the alleged assurance regarding execution of the property documents, the pendency of litigation concerning the property, the alleged subsequent disposal of such litigation, the demand for execution of documents and the alleged refusal on the part of defendant No. 1. 12. Thus, the proposed amendment does not introduce a wholly new transaction or an unrelated cause of action. Rather, the plaintiff seeks to incorporate a consequential and substantive -- 4 of 8 -- -4- relief arising out of the transaction and facts which are already pleaded in the plaint. 13. The objection of the defendants that the plaintiff has not filed any document evidencing the alleged agreement also cannot, at this stage, be made a ground for refusing the amendment. Whether there was in fact a concluded agreement between the parties, whether the consideration was paid, whether possession was delivered pursuant to such transaction and whether defendant No. 1 agreed to execute the necessary documents are matters which may require evidence. The Court, while deciding an application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, cannot conduct a mini-trial on these disputed questions. 14. The principal objection raised by the defendants is that the proposed relief of specific performance is barred by limitation. The objection requires consideration. Article 54 of the Limitation Act, 1963 prescribes a period of three years for a suit for specific performance, commencing, where a date is fixed for performance, from such date and, where no such date is fixed, from the date when the plaintiff has notice that performance is refused. 15. In the present case, the plaintiff’s case is that defendant No. 1 had stated that the property was under litigation and that the documents would be executed after the litigation was decided. The plaintiff has further pleaded that defendant No. 1 informed him in June 2024 that he had succeeded in the litigation and that, thereafter, upon demand, defendant No. 1 refused to execute the documents. -- 5 of 8 -- -5- 16. Whether the plaintiff’s assertion regarding the absence of a fixed date for performance is correct; when the alleged litigation was finally decided; when the plaintiff acquired knowledge of the same; when the alleged refusal to perform took place; and whether the refusal pleaded by the plaintiff constitutes the refusal contemplated under Article 54 of the Limitation Act are all matters which may require adjudication on the basis of the pleadings and evidence. 17. The mere fact that the alleged transaction dates back to the year 2001 does not, by itself, conclusively establish at this stage that the proposed relief is barred by limitation, particularly when the plaintiff has pleaded a subsequent refusal to perform and the applicability of the second limb of Article 54 is thus specifically attracted for consideration. 18. The Supreme Court in Pankaja & Anr. v. Yellappa & Ors., (2004) 6 SCC 415, has held that an amendment should not necessarily be refused merely because the relief sought to be introduced may be alleged to be barred by limitation. Where the question of limitation is itself a matter requiring adjudication, the amendment can be allowed and the question of limitation left open for decision on merits. The relevant portion of the aforesaid judgment is reproduced below: “The law in this regard is also quite clear and consistent that there is no absolute rule that in every case where a relief is barred because of limitation an amendment should not be allowed. Discretion in such cases depends on the facts and circumstances of the case. The jurisdiction to allow or not allow an amendment being discretionary the same will have -- 6 of 8 -- -6- to be exercised in a judicious evaluation of the facts and circumstances in which the amendment is sought. If the granting of an amendment really subserves the ultimate cause of justice and avoids further litigation the same should be allowed. There can be no straight jacket formula for allowing or disallowing an amendment of pleadings. Each case depends on the factual background of that case”. 19. In the facts of the present case, the proposed amendment appears necessary for effectively adjudicating the controversy between the parties. In fact, the earlier order passed on the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC itself highlighted the issue regarding the absence of the relief of specific performance/declaration. The plaintiff is now seeking to incorporate such relief on the basis of the transaction already pleaded. 21. It is clarified, however, that allowing the amendment shall not amount to a finding that the plaintiff’s claim for specific performance is within limitation or that the alleged agreement has been proved. The defendants shall be at liberty to raise all pleas available to them, including limitation, absence of a concluded agreement, want of proof of consideration, readiness and willingness of the plaintiff, and all other questions of law and fact. 22. In view of foregoing discussion, the application u/o 6 rule 17 CPC of the plaintiff is allowed subject to cost of Rs. 5000/- payable by the plaintiff to the defendant. Amended plaint is -- 7 of 8 -- -7- taken on record. Plaintiff is directed to pay deficient court fees within 30 days from today. Defendant is at liberty to file amended WS within 30 days from the date of this order. Application accordingly disposed off. (SAKSHI JAISWAL) CIVIL JUDGE (NORTH) ROHINI/DELHI/17.08.2026 -- 8 of 8 --
