Full Order Text
Final Order 11 · 01 May 2025 · CNR DLNT030014312023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian Vs Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. Page No. 1 of 7 IN THE COURT OF JSCC/ASCJ/GUDN. JUDGE NORTH, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI Presided by: Nitish Kumar Sharma. SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian ……..Plaintiff VERSUS Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. ......Defendants SUIT FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION ORDER 1. Vide this Order I shall dispose off an application of defendant no.1 U/o VII Rule 11 CPC for rejection of plaint. Brief facts of the present case as per plaint are - (a) That the Plaintiff is a senior citizen and a Flat No.97 in Canara Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. was allotted to him in the year 1989. It is stated that the defendant no.1 is the Cooperative Group Housing Society and is governed by DCS Act 2003. It is stated that the defendant no.2 is the president and the defendant No.3 is the secretary of defendant no.1. (b) It is averred that the defendant no.1 had made illegal demand vide demand notice dated 01.11.2018 and the plaintiff has -- 1 of 7 -- SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian Vs Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. Page No. 2 of 7 written to the defendant no.1 to withdraw the said demands. It is stated that the defendant no.1 has allowed unauthorised construction in the society and complaints were made to MCD, DDA and Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs. (c) It is averred that on 30.10.2020, defendant no.1 has again raised frivolous demands by stating extension of project. On 08.02.2021, the plaintiff obtained information through RTI that MCD has granted sanction to defendant no.1 on the basis of frivolous undertaking of defendant no.1. It is stated that a writ petition was also filed by the plaintiff which was withdrawn. (d) It is stated that there has been illegal construction and encroachment within the society and due to such construction, haphazard situation had arisen in the society. On 02.07.2023, the defendant no.2 and 3 gathered building material and started raising illegal and unauthorised construction in Block of Flat No.136-147. Hence this suit. 2. By way of present application U/o 7 Rule 11 CPC defendant no.1 has stated that the plaintiff has no cause of action against the defendants and the suit of the plaintiff is barred by Delhi Cooperative Societies Act. It is further stated that the suit has been filed to harass the defendants and the plaintiff has approached the court with unclean hands. It is stated that as regards the averments pertaining to demand raised by defendant no.1, the appropriate authority is Registrar as per Sec.70 of Delhi Cooperative Society Act. -- 2 of 7 -- SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian Vs Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. Page No. 3 of 7 It is stated that no notice as per Sec.129 of Delhi Cooperative Societies Act was issued and accordingly, the suit is not maintainable. It is further stated that the plaintiff has no locus to file present suit. 3. It is prayed that the present application may kindly be allowed and reject the plaint of the plaintiff under the provisions of the order 7 Rule 11 of CPC. 4. Per contra, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff submits that the present application filed by the Defendants No.1 is nothing but an abuse of process of law and the same is not tenable and is liable to be dismissed. It is stated that the present application filed by the Defendants No.1 does not fulfill the ingredients of Order 7 Rule 11 CPC and has been filed by defendants only to harass the Plaintiffs and to delay the proceedings and hence, is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed. 5. I have heard the arguments advanced by Ld. counsels for parties and perused the record. 6. As far as provisions U/o VII rule 11 CPC are concerned, the law is well settled that only the contentions as raised in the plaint are to be seen and the defence of defendants, if any, cannot be considered at that stage. Reliance could also be placed on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in case titled as Saleem Bhai and Others Vs. State of Maharashtra and others, (2003) SCC 557, in which the Hon'ble Court has held that :- -- 3 of 7 -- SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian Vs Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. Page No. 4 of 7 “A perusal of Order 7 Rule 11 CPC makes it clear that the relevant facts which need to be looked into for deciding an application thereunder are the averments in the plaint. The trial court can exercise the power under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC at any stage of the suit – before registering the plaint or after issuing summons to the defendant at any time before the conclusion of the trial. For the purposes of deciding an application under clauses (a) and (d) of Rule 11 of Order 7 CPC, the averments in the plaint are germane; the pleas taken by the defendant in the written statement would be wholly irrelevant at that stage ..............” In Bhau Ram vs. Janak Singh & Ors. 2012(6) SCALE 530, the Hon'ble Supreme Court re-affirmed the above proposition of law in following words :- “The law has been settled by this Court in various decisions that while considering an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court has to examine the averments in the plaint and the pleas taken by the defendants in its written statements would be irrelevant.” 7. I have considered the grounds taken by both the parties and perused the record. 8. At the outset, it is to be noted that vide present suit, the plaintiffs have sought following relief(s):- a. Mandatory injunction: to direct the defendant no.4 and 5 not to allow any encroachment and illegal or unauthorised construction in the premises of defendant no.1. -- 4 of 7 -- SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian Vs Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. Page No. 5 of 7 b. Permanent injunction thereby restraining the defendants from carrying out illegal and unauthorised construction and from encroaching the common areas. 9. Now, it is evident from the plaint itself that MCD has granted a sanction on 08.02.2021 to defendant no.1 and the plaintiff has not challenged the same. It is further evident that the plaintiff has stated himself to be resident of Flat No.97, Canara Apartment Sec.13, Rohini, Delhi and as per para No.16 of the plaint, the plaintiff has alleged illegal and unauthorised construction within the society premises in Flat No.136-147. The occupants of Flat No.136-147 have not been made a party to the suit and it is alleged that the construction is being raised by defendant no.2 and 3. 10. At this stage, it is beneficial to refer to judgment of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi passed in Rajender Motwani & Ors. Vs MCD & Ors. RSA No.243/2017 wherein it was observed: “An illegal construction in itself does not give any legal right to a neighbour. An illegal construction always no doubt gives locus-standi to local municipal authorities to seek removal of the illegal construction, but, a right of a neighbor only arises if the legal rights of light and air or any other legal right is affected by virtue of the illegal construction of the neighbor”. 11. In the instant suit, though it is alleged by the plaintiff that illegal construction has been raised by defendant no.1, it has not been spelt out as to how the said illegal construction had encroached upon the rights of the plaintiff. It has not been shown as to what right of the -- 5 of 7 -- SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian Vs Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. Page No. 6 of 7 plaintiff has been impeached. No site plan has been annexed showing the extent of unauthorised construction so as to reflect that the same is violated any right of the plaintiff. Though, it has been baldly stated that rights of fresh air and sunlight are breached, but bare perusal of photographs show that property of plaintiff is in no way near to Flat No.136-141. Further, the basis of dispute is the issuance of demand notice issued by defendant o.1. It is rightly argued that said dispute pertains to DCS Act and perhaps, for the same reason, no relief regarding the said demand has been claimed in the present suit. 12. It is also argued during the hearing on the application that the writ petition filed by the plaintiff was not withdrawn but dismissed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi by holding the same to be not maintainable and it has come in the said order that the plaintiff has a alternate remedy U/s 31 of Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. Perusal of order dated 23.03.2021 passed by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) 3829/2021 reveals that the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi had observed that the entire work in the society is being done as per the sanction plan issued by NDMC and there is no violation of any law. It was further observed that the petitioner was the exception of the entire block and in the event of any complaint, he could approach the adjudicating authority U/s 31 of Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. Now as per Sec.79 of Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016, the Civil Court has no jurisdiction to entertain any suit in respect of any matter which the adjudicating officer is empowered to determine under the Act. Thus, as per observations made by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, the plaintiff could have approached the adjudicating officer under Real Estate -- 6 of 7 -- SCJ No.733/23 Pratap Singh Benian Vs Canara Cooperative Group Housing Ltd & Ors. Page No. 7 of 7 (Regulation and Development) Act 2016 and as per Sec.79 of Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016, the jurisdiction of Civil Court is barred. 13. In view of the aforesaid discussions, the court is of the view that the plaintiff has failed to show existence of any cause of action in his favour as per the dictum of Rajender Motwani (Supra) and further the plaint is barred by Law as per Sec.79 of Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. Accordingly, the plaint of the plaintiff is liable to be rejected U/o 7 rule 11 (a) r.w. (d) of CPC. The plaint stands rejected accordingly. 14. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 15. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. Announced in the open court on 01.05.2025. (Nitish Kumar Sharma) JSCC/ASCJ/GUDN. JUDGE North Rohini, Courts,Delhi/01.05.2025 -- 7 of 7 --
