Full Order Text
Order 12 · 08 Jul 2026 · CNR DLNT030014202024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 35 CS SCJ 916/24 BRIJ MOHAN KHANNA Vs. RAJ KUMAR KHANNA 08.07.2026 Present: Shri V. K Aggarwal, Ld. Counsel for both the plaintiffs (Through VC) None for the defendant. None for proposed defendant. Matter is listed for orders on application u/o 1 rule 10 CPC. Vide separate order, an application u/o 1 rule 10 CPC stands dismissed. Perusal of file shows that issues are yet to be framed in the present case. Both the parties are at liberty file to affidavit of admission / denial of documents, if any, by NDOH. Put up for admission / denial of documents and for framing of issues on 10.09.2026. (SAKSHI JAISWAL) CIVIL JUDGE (NORTH) ROHINI/DELHI/08.07.2026 -- 1 of 6 -- -1- 35 CS SCJ 916/24 BRIJ MOHAN KHANNA Vs. RAJ KUMAR KHANNA ORDER 08.07.2026 1. Vide present order, the court shall decide the application u/o 1 rule 10 CPC r/w Section 151 CPC filed on behalf of applicant Vijay Kumar Khanna for impleading him as defendant in the present suit. 2. Before deciding the application it is necessary to state the facts of the case in brief. The present suit has been filed for declaration thereby declaring that the oral partition and subsequent family Settlement Deeds dt. 21.02.2012 and 15.07.2018 are legally binding on the parties thereto and legally valid, and for permanent injunction in favour of plaintiffs thereby restraining the defendants from interfering in the ownership and peaceful possession of the plaintiffs over the properties falling in plaintiff’s share in the aforesaid family settlement deeds. Both the plaintiffs and the defendant in the present case are brothers and it is the case of the plaintiff that three brothers (i.e. plaintiff no. 1, plaintiff no.2 and defendant) were doing joint family business and from the proceeds of the said joint business, they had acquired certain properties which were jointly owned by the parties to the present suit. It is further averred by the plaintiff that in February 2007 oral partition took place between the parties to the present suit with regard to various properties and business assets acquired by joint / common funds and the said oral partition was reduced into writing vide deed of family -- 2 of 6 -- -2- settlement dt. 21.02.2012 and memorandum of settlement dt. 15.07.2018 which was signed and executed among the three brothers i.e. parties to the present suit. It is in respect of these settlements, that the present suit has been filed. 3. The present application u/o 1 rule 10 CPC is filed by Shri Vijay Kumar Khanna, who is fourth brother of the parties to the present suit. It is submitted by the Ld. counsel for applicant / proposed defendant that the declaration sought by the plaintiffs with regard to alleged settlement are in respect of properties which pertains to father of plaintiffs, defendant and the present applicant and their family business, therefore, applicant being one of the legal heir has equal right, title and interest in respect of properties as mentioned in the alleged settlement, which were left behind by father of the parties. It is argued by Ld. counsel for applicant / proposed defendant that he is required to be impleaded as party for just adjudication of the case and that without impleading him as a party, the suit cannot be decided properly as applicant has equal interest in the properties. 4. Same is opposed to by Ld. Counsel for plaintiffs on the ground that the proposed defendant is not a necessary or proper party in the present suit as he is not the party of the aforesaid settlement deed dt. 21.02.2012 and 15.07.2018. It is further argued by Ld. counsel for plaintiffs that the property mentioned in the aforesaid deeds were acquired by joint funds from the joint business between the parties to the suit and the proposed defendant does not have any right, title and interest in the said property. 5. Submissions heard. Record perused. -- 3 of 6 -- -3- 6. Order I R 10 CPC gives the court ample powers to induct any person as a party to the suit whose presence is necessary in order to enable the Court to effectually and completely adjudicate and settle the questions involved in the suit, out of its own violation or on an application filed by either such party, and mandates the joining of necessary party. The term necessary party, as defined by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Mumbai International Airport Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Regency Convention Centre and Hotels Pvt. Ltd and Ors., (2010) 7 SCC 417 is a person who ought to have been joined as a party and in whose absence, no effective decree can be passed. 7. Further, O I R 3 CPC lays down the requirements to be satisfied in order for persons to be joined as Defendants in the suit. It mandates that only such persons can be joined as Defendants when the right to relief against such persons arises out of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions, either jointly, severally or in the alternative, and if separate suits were to be brought against such persons, common questions of law or fact would arise. 8. A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provision makes it clear that in order to be joined as a Defendant in a suit, the person to be so arrayed as a Defendant must be either a necessary or proper party and it would also be incumbent to show that any relief arises against such person out of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions, either jointly, severally or in the alternative, and if separate suits were to be brought against such persons, common questions of law or fact would arise. -- 4 of 6 -- -4- 9. In the present case, the dispute is confined to the validity and binding nature of the settlement between its parties and whether the plaintiffs are entitled to decree of permanent injunction against the defendant. The proposed defendant is not a party to the settlement nor he is claiming under the said settlements. Instead the proposed defendant asserts an independent right, interest and share in the properties which are part of the settlement deeds. Moreover, the relief of permanent injunction is granted in personam and the said relief has not been sought against the proposed defendant. Thus, even if the proposed defendant is not impleaded, the court can still decide whether the family settlement between the plaintiffs and the defendant is valid and binding inter se. The decree will bind only parties to the suit and if the proposed defendant has an independent right in the properties, his right are not extinguished merely because he is not a party to the present suit. Therefore, no effective adjudication of the present controversy is prevented by his absence. The proposed defendant is free to institute an independent suit for declaration, partition or other appropriate relief. 10. Moreover, the claim of proposed defendant requires adjudication of an independent title inconsistent with the plaintiff’s case which would convert the present suit for declaration simplicitor into comprehensive title suit which cannot be allowed. A person claiming independent title is ordinarily neither a necessary nor a proper party if his presence changes the nature of the suit. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the judgment Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Kasturi Vs. Uyyamperumal and ors, decided on 25.04.2005 in Appeal (Civil) 2831 of 2005. -- 5 of 6 -- -5- 11. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this court is of the opinion that proposed defendant is neither a necessary nor a proper party to the present suit as the right asserted by him is independent of the controversy involved in the present suit and therefore, his presence is not necessary to enable the court to effectually and completely adjudicate upon on all the questions involved in the suit. Accordingly, the application of proposed defendant u/o 1 rule 10 CPC stands dismissed. Copy order be given dasti, as prayed for. (SAKSHI JAISWAL) CIVIL JUDGE (NORTH) ROHINI/DELHI/08.07.2026 -- 6 of 6 --
