Full Order Text
Interim Order 3 · 19 Jul 2025 · CNR DLNT030011632025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 5 CS SCJ 737/25 Abhishek Dahiya Vs. Mamta Jain -1/4- 19.07.2025 Present: Sh. Ankit Yadav, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff. Sh. Amit Bhatia and Ms. Garima Goel, Ld. Counsels for the defendants. Reply to application u/o XXXIX rule 1 & 2 CPC filed by the defendants. Arguments heard. To come up for orders at 3 pm. (Ajay Singh Parihar) ACJ-cum-ARC/North Rohini Court/19.07.2025 At 3 pm. Both the ld. Counsels have argued the application u/o XXXIX rule 1 & 2 CPC. It is submitted by ld. Counsel for plaintiff that plaintiff and defendants executed Lease Deed in respect of Shop No. 411, First Floor, City centre Mall, Sector-10, Rohihi, Delhi (herein referred to as ‘suit property’) wherein it was agreed that plaintiff shall pay security deposit of Rs 5,30,000/- and a monthly rent of Rs 1,50,000/-. It is submitted that defendants concealed the existence of prior Lease Deed dated 26.10.2020 in favour of Sh. Lokesh Jain. It is submitted that plaintiff came to know about the earlier Lease Deed during the course of obtaining statutory approval and license from the concerned authorities. It is submitted that when plaintiff informed the defendants -- 1 of 4 -- 5 CS SCJ 737/25 Abhishek Dahiya Vs. Mamta Jain -2/4- about the earlier Lease Deed, the defendants instead of acknowledging their wrong doing issued notice of termination dated 10.05.2025. It is submitted that on 26.06.2025, without any notice to the plaintiff, the defendants put their lock on the suit property. It is also submitted that plaintiff has invested substantial amount on the fixtures and fittings in the suit property. It is submitted that plaintiff shall suffer irreparable loss, if temporary injunction is not granted. Per contra, ld. Counsel for defendants has submitted that the plaintiff only paid half of the rent of the month of January 2025 and thereafter no rent was paid till date. It is submitted that the plaintiff committed breach of clause (I) of Lease Deed pursuant to which a notice was issued by the defendants on 10.05.2025 calling upon the plaintiff to pay arrears of rent, which was duly received and replied by the plaintiff. It is submitted that second notice for termination was issued on 12.06.2025 and thereafter, the plaintiff gave written acknowlegment for handing over the possession vide possession letter dated 20.06.2025. It is submitted that after receiving the possession letter from the plaintiff, the defendants put their lock on suit property. It is also submitted that the earlier lease in the name of Sh. Lokesh Jain was terminated on 10.10.2024. Ld. Counsel has submitted that the present suit is not maintainable in the present form as plaintiff should have filed suit u/s 6 Specific Relief Act. Ld. Counsel has submitted that plaintiff has not established essential ingredients of temporary injunction hence, the application may be dismissed. Upon inquiry, ld. Counsel for plaintiff has submitted that plaintiff has not paid rent since March 2025. -- 2 of 4 -- 5 CS SCJ 737/25 Abhishek Dahiya Vs. Mamta Jain -3/4- Essentials of temporary injunction 7. In the case of Gujrat Bottling Co. Ltd. v. Coca Cola Co. reported in 1995 5 SCC 545, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while discussing the factors to be considered by the Courts in exercise of the discretion under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC, has enunciated following test :- (i) There is a prima facie case in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. (ii) That irreparable injury is likely to be caused to the plaintiff which cannot be compensated for in terms of money. (iii) That the balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. In the present case, parties executed lease deed dated 10.10.2024 wherein it was agreed that the lessee shall pay monthly rent on or before 7th of every month, however, admittedly, the lessee/ plaintiff has not paid rent since March 2025. It is also admitted that defendants sent notice for payment of rent dated 10.05.2025 which was also replied by the plaintiff. It is clear that the lessee / plaintiff did breach of the lease deed. The defendants have argued that termination notice was issued to plaintiff on 12.06.2025 pursuant to which the plaintiff handed over possession of the suit property vide possession letter dated 20.06.2025. Plaintiff has submitted that this document is forged and does not bear his signatures. The authenticity of the document shall be adjudicated during the trial, however, at this stage, the plaintiff has to show a prima facie case. The plaintiff has not paid rent since March 2025 hence he is in breach of Lease Deed and since the plaintiff is claiming his right in the suit property from Lease Deed, he -- 3 of 4 -- 5 CS SCJ 737/25 Abhishek Dahiya Vs. Mamta Jain -4/4- cannot take benefit of his own wrong. The plaintiff has failed to establish a prima facie case. Since the plaintiff has not shown prima facie case, other essentials of temporary injunction need not be gone into. In view of the observations, application u/o XXXIX rule 1 & 2 CPC stands dismissed. To come up for further proceedings on 28.10.2025. Nothing expressed in this order shall tantamount to or be construed as an expression upon the merits of the case. (Ajay Singh Parihar) ACJ-cum-ARC/North Rohini Court/19.07.2025 -- 4 of 4 --
